Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Threads like this need to be put to rest....It's hard to argue a fish being better than a Walleye as a sportfish (even if it is) in the state of Minnesota. Maybe if the thread was more specific (i.e. Which do you prefer on your dinner plate, best fighting fish etc.) we would have some quality debate. But this just turns into a never-ending p!ssing contest in my opinion.

Posted

I love to fish for both but if I had to choose to fish for only one it would be bass. As soon as I catch 3 lb plus walleye that jumps completely out of the water I will vote for walleye.

Not sure I buy the argument that one is easier to catch than the other. I have caught lots of each some days and been skunked by both on others.

Skilled anglers of both species are a joy to watch.

A truly skilled walleye angler can do amazing things with boat control. Precision boat control while watching a depthfinder/GPS, and paying attention to the line in the water...way harder to do than it looks.

Ever watch a pro bass fisherman with a baitcaster? It is incredible what they can do with it. Watch one pitch a bait where it seems to float and gently land on the water exactly where they want it.

I think the fact that walleyes are tasty makes them seem harder to catch because so many more are harvested every year. I would guess that 80 - 90 percent of the walleyes of harvestable size are kept while it is just the opposite for bass.

Luckily for me, my cabin is on a lake with plenty of both as well as good size panfish so I do not have to choose.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Posted

Quote:
KVD, Skeet Reese, and Alton Jones.

WHO? smile

Peter Parker would out fish all of them!!!!

Posted

walleye

Posted
Walleyes. I used to fish bass all the time when I was 10-16 years old. But since then I enjoy a challenge, so I fish walleyes way more often. Apparently the guys on here who say walleyes don't fight very hard have never caught one while casting.
Words out of my mouth brother! That, or they never caught a ten plus walleye! If its a fight you want, then go to the river and toss a night crawler off the bottom!
Posted

WALLEYE

Posted

anyone know what the 4 stars are for?

Posted

I don't care which fish I catch, as long as I'm fishing smilesmilesmilesmilesmile!!!!!

Posted

Walleye, and it's not even close for me, I'd rather catch crappies than bass!

Posted

Bass all the way..........

Posted

Definetly walleyes way better eating, but if nothing else will bite I'll still fish for the bass large or smallmouth.

Posted

Walleye. If you know the right place and time you can catch walleyes with top water tactics. I do it every year on a lake up north.

Posted

bass...or better yet, a basseye!

  • 5 years later...
Posted

Bass!

 

I once hooked a walleye on a crankbait. As I was landing it a smallmouth tried to take away the lure and my line broke. Next day I snagged something and reeled in my lost lure. Both fish were still attached. The bass was frisky but the walleye had been turned inside out from having been dragged around for 24 hours.

 

OK, so I might be exaggerating a little but I have had bass try to take away a crank from a ten pound pike. Really just testing the new site to see if I can actually post anything.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Posted

Catfish first but walleye for catching and bass (pound per pound) for fight.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Posted

Walleye!

Posted

Most of the time I prefer to fish for bass.  I like to cast and nothing beats topwater and leaping fish in my book.  But this year on Opener weekend I put 90% of my effort into eyes.  Since the night ban went into effect I'm 80% bass, dogfish, pike, 15% crappie, 5% eye.  Eating the fish I catch isn't high on the priority list.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Posted

Bass.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Most definitely walleye on a jig.  I haven't intentionally fished for bass in years.  Was on Vermilion for the opener this year and we couldn't keep the 4#-5# smallies off the line. Fun to catch but I guess I'm hooked on walleyes.

Posted

Have always been a Walleye guy my entire life, more I think because they are better eating and I find a walleye as more of a trophy fish. If I want more of a fight and just looking to catch a fish that personally I think is easier to catch than a walleye, I'll fish for bass. But, this is all my opinion.

Posted

Walleye. If you know the right place and time you can catch walleyes with top water tactics. I do it every year on a lake up north.

​Do this during the Mayfly hatch? Have never really heard anyone do this before.

Posted

Walleye. Out west. In the shallows. At darkk during post spawn. With 5" shallow running jerk baits. From shore or in waders. 5 to 8 lb walleyes fight pretty hard, actually.

Posted (edited)

1-Northern Pike

2-Catfish

3-Perch,Crappie,Sunnie.

4-Bass

.......

17.5-Walleye

Edited by PurpleFloyd
  • 'we have more fun' FishingMN Builders
Posted

caught 5 eyes and 6 smallies yesturday.  I like them both. :)

  • 'we have more fun' FishingMN Builders
Posted

5 eyes and 6 smallies yesturday.  i like both :)

Posted

 

Quote:
KVD, Skeet Reese, and Alton Jones.

 

 

WHO? smile

 

Peter Parker would out fish all of them!!!!

​Spiderman?:grin:

Posted

Real Bass. White Bass.

Posted

Can't pick between them, love to catch all of them, but for eating purposes walleye.

Tunrevir~

  • Thumbs Up 1
Posted (edited)

Smallies or buckets. Though that may be from only catching very few eyes in my life and all being accidental catches

Edited by derbier122x
spelling

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Similar Content

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • smurfy
      🤣 not fer some of us!!!!!!!!!!
    • smurfy
      i couldnt find it.....but maybe???
    • leech~~
      Looks great! Thought we started a smoker thread?  🤔
    • leech~~
      Well, that's not getting 10 years old now is it!  🥱🥱
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the South Shore...  Ice fishing remains strong across Big Traverse Bay, with resorts and outfitters still in full swing offering both day houses and sleeper fish houses. The bite in February has been excellent, with lots of fish being caught and plenty of opportunities for fresh fish fries. Some ice roads are now extending over 20 miles out, keeping anglers on productive schools of walleyes and saugers. Ice conditions continue to build, making this one of the best late-season ice years in recent memory. If you’re fishing on your own, bring an auger extension, as ice thickness is significant. Most fish houses are positioned over deep mud, while some remain on or near structure. As always, expect to sort through some smaller fish, but that’s a good sign of a healthy fishery. With fish houses allowed on the ice through March 31st and walleye and sauger seasons open through April 14th, the extended season on Lake of the Woods offers plenty of time to plan your trip. Pike fishing never closes, and with the thick ice conditions, this year is shaping up to be fantastic for targeting trophy pike. March: The Go-To Month for Trophy Pike March is prime time for big northern pike, as these aggressive predators begin staging for the upcoming spawn. Lake of the Woods is loaded with pike over 40 inches, and tip-up fishing can be lights out this time of year. Anglers targeting pike should set baits under tip-ups in shallow water (6-15 feet) near pre-spawn areas, weedy areas, river mouths, or back bays. Current Fishing Depths & Patterns: Most fish are being caught in 26-32 feet of water. Walleyes, saugers, jumbo perch, eelpout, pike, tullibees, and even some crappies are in the mix. Suspended walleyes are showing up—watch electronics closely. Plenty of limits are being caught, with many anglers taking home bonus perch this season. Best Techniques: Jigging Line: Jigging spoons with rattles tipped with a minnow head continue to be the top producer. Lipless crankbaits and jigging rap-style lures are also working well for aggressive fish. Lures with built-in lights have been very effective in the stained water (Reminder: In Minnesota, lighted lures are legal as long as the battery is mercury-free and the hook is attached directly to the lure, not on a dropper line). Deadstick: A plain hook or small jig with a live minnow, set 6 inches to a foot off the bottom, continues to catch neutral or less aggressive fish. Time of Day: Bite windows vary daily. Some days, mornings are best; other days, the afternoon bite turns on. Walleyes can move through at any time, so staying patient and watching electronics is key. On the Rainy River...  Mornings and evenings continue to be the best times for targeting walleyes. A jig and minnow or jigging spoon tipped with a minnow head remains the go-to presentation. Sturgeon fishing has been solid, with some giants being iced (Reminder: The current sturgeon season is catch-and-release). Safety Note: Ice conditions on the Rainy River are good, but they can change rapidly due to current. Always check with resorts or outfitters before heading out. Up at the NW Angle...  Ice fishing remains excellent throughout the islands region of Lake of the Woods. Resorts are moving fish houses regularly, keeping guests on active schools of walleyes. Anglers are catching a nice mix of walleyes, saugers, jumbo perch, pike, and tullibees. Big crappies continue to be caught just over the border in Canada. If you're interested in targeting crappies, check with a NW Angle resort for guide services and ice conditions. Plan Your Ice Fishing Adventure! Lake of the Woods offers an extended ice fishing season, with:  Fish houses allowed overnight through March 31st  Walleye & sauger season open through April 14th  Pike season never closes—March is prime time for trophies!  Perch and crappie seasons open year-round Whether you’re looking for a day house rental, a sleeper fish house, or comfortable lodging at a resort with or without a meal plan, there’s still time to plan your late-season ice fishing adventure.    
    • smurfy
      Off da smoker!😉
    • smurfy
      At least he's got a shirt on! 😊🤣😜
    • leech~~
      Sounds like a nice last day.  I like how you photoshop a different shirt on that same picture the last few years!  🤣
    • JerkinLips
      Beautiful day on Vermilion Sunday for the last day of walleye season.  Lots of people were fishing in portables, or out in the open.  Was entertaining watching many of the wheel and skid houses being pulled off of the lake.  Checked half a dozen spots where wheel houses were removed and didn't find any trash at all.  Sounds like people are getting the message.  I may go out on the lake when the snow is melted to do a further check and cleanup if needed.   Fishing was average for this time of the year.  Had a decent bite from 2pm to 4pm when I caught my biggest eye (pictured 22 inch).  Decent finish to a good season.  Now on to lake trout fishing.   Hope everyone had an enjoyable and successful ice fishing season.  Going to be a long time before this year's open water season.  
    • smurfy
      Thanks Kettle! I'll bring mine with but won't be until  mid march
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.