• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
Ryan_V

What size generator do I need??

Question

Ryan_V

I'm looking to get a generator for my shack on mille lacs. all I would be running are a few light bulbs, some fans to move air and a tv/dvd player. Do I want to go with the bigger is better, or try to go as small as I can?? any brand better, or anything to stay away from??? never owned or ran a generator, so any help and advice will be heeded!!! Thanks guys.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

13 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Whoaru99

Typically, bigger will be more noisy and use more gas, but will cover you as you find more stuff to plug in.

The Honda generators are premium, but very quiet and work very well.

To figure the size, just add up all the watts of the stuff you want to run and make sure the generator has more than that.

If truly all you are going to run is as described, I'd think the Honda 1000 watt would take care of it. But, for future needs, the 2000 watt would give you some extra capacity to run a bit more diverse range of goodies.

The only thing that gets a little tricky is if you are wanting to run something with a larger motor. Once you start getting into 1/3HP motors and up, they have a pretty high initial current draw that often necessitates a larger generator than merely the sum of the watts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
GotOne

I also have been looking at a few different generators. Sportsmans Guide has some similar units (as far a noise & power) at a much lower price. If I remember right a 2000 watt was around 600.00 and a 1050 watt, 950 continuous ( 65dB) output for around 300.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
cold one sd

I have the 950 watt that wallabee mentioned. Got it on ebay for $166 new including shipping. Runs nice and is quiet. It is a 2 stroke and uses the same mix as my auger. I just checked and there is on on ebay now new for $135 including shipping.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
beer batter

I was in the same boat as you a few months ago. Did lots of research on brands and came to the same conclusion on the Honda's. Quiet, efficient, light weight, run forever, very low customer complaints.

As for the watts, a 1000 will easily power your fish house. You can run just about anything you want off 1000 watts on the ice.

Something else you should consider is if you'd use it at all off the ice. If you should have a power outage to run a freezer and sump pump in the summer time, sad to say a 1000 watt will not cut the juice. That will take around 1500 watts to run both simultaneously.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

If you value the opinion of Consumer Reports, they just tested some generators (albeit a bit larger than we are talking here).

Several common brands didn't meet their advertised spec. Honda met and or exceeded it by a small amount depending on the model and had excellent quality of power (stable voltage). Yamaha fared well too for meeting it's rating and quality of power.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
GotOne

What issue of c/r were the generators listed?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

October 06.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Ryan_V

sounds like I'd want about at least a 1500 watt unit, maybe more. I'd use it other times as well, but on the ice will be by far and away the most use. Am I also correct in assuming that the bigger the wattage/engine, the more it will cost to operate?? thanks so far, keep the advice coming!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Ryan_V

coldone/wallabee,

what is the brand of generator you were talking about on ebay??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
cold one sd

I don't remember what brand it was. I took a quick look after I read your post. I think there are several brands that are made by the same manufacturer and are made in China. Sportsmans Guide sells the same thing. The one I have starts and runs good. I bought the 2 stroke because I have mixed gas along for my auger already and I didn't want to mess around with oil changes if I'm on the ice for several days. I also didn't want to spend a lot of money as I already have a Generac 6,000 in the garage. Moost people on here will recomend Honda, but they are about $700. Too much for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
GotOne

Can't make out the name in Sportsmans Guide catalog. Go to S/G web site and you will see it. I haven't purchased one yet, but the research that I have done checking out other sites looks like these will perform just fine. Plus, you could just about buy two for the price of a Honda.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

Based on the short review in Consumer reports, if you are buying models other than Honda or Yamaha (they certainly did not review "all" models) and want a solid 1500 watts, you need to buy something that is rated on the order of 2500 watts to be safe.

I'm saying that because most of those tested fell fairly well short of their rated power output - like 1000 watts and more short which is a pretty high percentage when you are talking 3000 to 6000 watt units.

Maybe that's why Brand X 2000 watt generator is much cheaper, because it's really only a 1000 watt generator when you get down to it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
cold one sd

I have 9 twelve volt batteries im my ice house and these generators come with the cord for charging batteries. I like drip coffee in the morning when on the ice and I have a 4 cup coffee maker that takes 600 watts. I crank the generator and have hot coffee in 6 minutes. grin.gif I have never used the generator to charge my batteries on the ice because I haven't been out longer than about three days yet. Maybe this year. They have some 1,250w and 1,500w generators on ebay also that are 4 stroke and only weigh about 50 lbs. The Hondas run about $700 for a 1,000w.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • srj
      Fished a couple hours late Tues afternoon, Weds and Thurs morning. Caught supper on Tues pulling leadcore in about 31' out from Zipple. Not the huge schools like a few weeks ago but enough to fish. Weds went rock hopping and found fish on about half the humps, no biggies. Seemed to be an unusual number of very nice boats for a Weds and all pulling leadcore. Good deal for me as I was fishing spinners. Found out that night about the AIM tourney explaining the boat show with the guys prefishing. Thurs morning was out 11 miles from the washout pulling baits in the mud and the bite was pretty good. Again, not the massive numbers seen previously but a good number of biters. The charters were scattered all over the basin with some up north as well. Still a fair number of boats bait fishing out deep. Sure hate to see summer slipping away.   Good luck.
    • cookie129
      I have not been tromping though the woods but did flush a couple picking blueberrys  
    • TAJ
      I agree with Rayguy. A lot of ecological changes happening everywhere and I think we’re seeing that on the Whitefish chain. Keep looking for new spots and new structure. Fish are still there. It’ll be interesting to see how Fall fishing goes. I am planning on fishing the next couple of days. I’ll let you know how I do. 
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Ace is right, no need to run to far to find walleyes! They are all over the East end where you will be staying. The number one rule is "trust your depth finder"! I never fish a spot unless I see a few fish there! Lindy rigs, spinner rigs, slip bobber rigs, and jigs will all catch walleyes that time of the year. Cliff
    • bluewater2
      Thank you, my husband and I usually go to Kabetogama . but we are going to go later, had a chance to go here for the first time(Labor day weekend)and are excited to try it. Found a private cabin to rent very reasonable in that bay.
    • Borch
      I fished most of the lake in scout mode today.  Found walleyes early on midlake humps and bars in 18-24 fow.  Got a couple to go on jigging raps but then they shut off.  Spent the rest of the day trying to pin down a panfish pattern.  Found good numbers of sunfish in shallow cabbage beds(6-9 fow).  None were huge but good numbers of 8-8 1/2" gills.  A few crappies are mixed in with them and some are suspending off the break.  There are also good numbers of sunfish in or just outside the reeds.   Most of the sunfish ran smaller though although there were some keepers there too.  Pike and bass I did not target but saw others do so successfully.   Plenty of bass in the reeds and spinnerbaits seemed to be what most were using.   Troll over the weeds and you will be rewarded with pike.
    • Borch
      I fished most of the lake in scout mode today.  Found walleyes early on midlake humps and bars in 18-24 fow.  Got a couple to go on jigging raps but then they shut off.  Spent the rest of the day trying to pin down a panfish pattern.  Found good numbers of sunfish in shallow cabbage beds(6-9 fow).  None were huge but good numbers of 8-8 1/2" gills.  A few crappies are mixed in with them and some are suspending off the break.  There are also good numbers of sunfish in or just outside the reeds.   Most of the sunfish ran smaller though although there were some keepers there too.  Pike and bass I did not target but saw others do so successfully.   Plenty of bass in the reeds and spinnerbaits seemed to be what most were using.   Troll over the weeds and you will be rewarded with pike.
    • Borch
      I fished most of the lake in scout mode today.  Found walleyes early on midlake humps and bars in 18-24 fow.  Got a couple to go on jigging raps but then they shut off.  Spent the rest of the day trying to pin down a panfish pattern.  Found good numbers of sunfish in shallow cabbage beds(6-9 fow).  None were huge but good numbers of 8-8 1/2" gills.  A few crappies are mixed in with them and some are suspending off the break.  There are also good numbers of sunfish in or just outside the reeds.   Most of the sunfish ran smaller though although there were some keepers there too.  Pike and bass I did not target but saw others do so successfully.   Plenty of bass in the reeds and spinnerbaits seemed to be what most were using.   Troll over the weeds and you will be rewarded with pike.
    • Rick
      No brush or yard waste burning today through Sunday The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency has issued an air quality alert for today through Sunday for northern Minnesota.    As a result, the Department of Natural Resources will not issue burning permits for brush or yard waste for all areas north of Alexandria, including Mille Lacs and Pine counties. Burn restrictions may expand as smoke from the Canadian fires drifts south. For updates and the air quality forecast, check the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency website. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • guideman
      If you are looking for Walleyes stay on the east end. There is no need to go running all over the lake to catch them. Daisy bay has Walleyes available as does Big bay which in my opinion has some of the best Walleye fishing on the lake.  Trolling cranks works this time of year, as well as Lindy rigging, or pulling spinners on a bottom bouncer. You can also find some decent evening slip bobber fishing close to where you are staying.  Good luck and have fun, you won't be disappointed.     "Ace" "It's just fishing man".