Skeeter Solera 189 w/Yamaha 200 SHO vs. Ranger 1850MS Reatta w/Merc 175 Pro XS

[DanNorthWoods]

I am buying a new 2022 fish-ski.  I have narrowed it down to these two boats.  They are almost identical in every way, including price.

 

Fishing is the primary use, but slalom skiing by adults (225 lbs) is going to happen.  I prioritize hole-shot over top speed.

 

I am not interested in considering other boats at this point so please don't reply with "neither" or "my boat is better".

 

I am aware that both are great boats and I really can't go wrong so please don't reply to only tell me that.  

 

I am asking for input/advice based on first hand experience with these brands, models or engines that I don't have.  Basically, looking to break the tie.

 

Thanks in advance, your expertise is very much appreciate!

[leech~~]

Welcome to the forum Dan.

Looks like you have a pretty hard and high buck decision to make.  

You know that you can always work with "I prioritize hole-shot over top speed" with prop changes as well. 

It only takes like 5 mins to change out a prop when you want to pull someone around the lake. 

Gook luck, hope someone on here can help and let us know what you choice!