• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • WE CREATE LONG TERM, MEANINGFUL RELATIONSHIPS IN HERE ... PLEASE JOIN US.

    You know what we all love...

    RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE
    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
TylerS

What Deer Should I Shoot?

Recommended Posts

TylerS

Honest question: I have a bow tag (didn't draw rifle), so I have the choice to shoot any deer that walks by. I'm in North Dakota, and according to our G&F Dept. the deer herd is way down (thus, my missing out on a rifle tag).

Ethically, what would be the preferred deer to shoot? I mean, since the herd is down, do I pass on does? Or, since others want bigger deer, do I pass on small bucks and wait for a big buck? Or, if it's the choice between a small buck or a doe, which would be better to shoot?

I guess ideally, bagging el beastro is the given choice. But since I only have rifle opener to fill my tag, that's long odds.

It'll most likely come down to one of these: Small buck, doe, or fawn. Of those three, and considering ND's deer numbers, which should I harvest given the opportunity?

I'm in it for the meat, period. Can't afford taxidermy bills.

Honest question, as I get conflicting information depending on who I talk to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
HNTNBUX

Whichever one makes you happy when the time comes. Honest answer.

I like big bucks but.....enjoy your hunt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
icehole10

Whichever one makes you happy when the time comes. Honest answer.

I like big bucks but.....enjoy your hunt.

+1

I would be more worried about even seeing a deer, but that's just me. If your only in it to put a little meat on the table. I wouldn't let anyone tell you what you should or shouldn't shoot. If it presents a shot, its your tag to fill!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bear55

If you want meat shoot the first one that comes in range.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ClownColor

I guess you need to ask yourself "why are you hunting?" Do you enjoy the meat? do you enjoy the hunt? do you enjoy the racks? For me it simple, I enjoy the hunt first, rack second, and meat third. I've been hunting for a long time now and up until a few years I'd put meat ahead of rack...but I'd never force that upon someone else.

If you enjoy the hunt, save a doe. It appears you can't even (rifle) hunt as numbers are already to low. I'd be upset if I count huunt at all vs only shooting a buck.

If you enjoy the meat and the hunt, take a small buck. No need for others to influence your buck size restriction. Everyone is at a different point in their hunting career.

If you're after the rack...well, its a no-brainer!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bottomdweller

Good answers, I would shoot the first buck I saw. If the numbers are really low help the herd out by letting the does go. But its your tag and I hope you fill it with whatever you decide to shoot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TylerS

Good suggestions! I'm getting a solid theme. Settles my mind a bit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Archerysniper

If you shoot a buck you are only removing one deer from the heard,shoot a doe and that is 2 or 3 deer removed her and the next years fawns. 2c

That said any archery deer is a trophy and I would take any deer that gives me a slam dunk shot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nofishfisherman

For me it would be small buck first if given the option. Killing a buck reduces the herd by 1, killing a doe reduces the herd by 1 plus any future offspring it may have.

Each area is a little different in terms of herd size though even within the same zone. If you are seeing a lot of deer in your particular area then taking a doe isn't going to matter much most likely. But if numbers are WAY down and you only see one doe then obviously taking one of the few remaining deer in the area that is capable of reproducing will have a bigger impact. Its really up to you since you have a better sense of deer population in your area then we do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
InTheNorthwoods

I'd buy beef/pork/chicken. Its a sure thing, and you'll only have to drive to the grocery store. Then I'd go hunt for the same quality of animal* that you'd be looking for in any other year, and just enjoy the time in the woods.

Edit - *Whatever deer that might be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TylerS

I'd buy beef/pork/chicken. Its a sure thing, and you'll only have to drive to the grocery store. Then I'd go hunt for the same quality of animal* that you'd be looking for in any other year, and just enjoy the time in the woods.

Edit - *Whatever deer that might be.

Except, we rarely buy beef/pork/chicken. Our wild game freezer feeds us most of the year. But I appreciate your input.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DonBo

If you rely on the meat, and your time/opportunities are limited, take the first good shot you get. Don't let anyone tell you what kind of deer you can/should take. Shoot, fill the freezer, be happy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smsmith

If the question is "what is best for a herd with low numbers and the intention to grow them (either by a person or G&F)?" The answer is to pass all antlerless deer and take any buck.

If the question is "what is best for a herd with low numbers, the intention to grow them, and promote bucks to older age classes?" The answer is to pass all antlerless deer, and pass all yearling bucks...taking only a mature buck.

Only you can make the decision that is right for you. I personally follow the second strategy I mentioned. However, that doesn't lead to a freezer full of venison that frequently.

Given the fact you are in it for the meat only, and the apparent attempt to grow the herd in ND by G&F...I'd recommend taking the first buck you get a crack at.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TylerS

If the question is "what is best for a herd with low numbers and the intention to grow them (either by a person or G&F)?" The answer is to pass all antlerless deer and take any buck.

If the question is "what is best for a herd with low numbers, the intention to grow them, and promote bucks to older age classes?" The answer is to pass all antlerless deer, and pass all yearling bucks...taking only a mature buck.

Only you can make the decision that is right for you. I personally follow the second strategy I mentioned. However, that doesn't lead to a freezer full of venison that frequently.

Given the fact you are in it for the meat only, and the apparent attempt to grow the herd in ND by G&F...I'd recommend taking the first buck you get a crack at.

That makes a lot of sense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

Announcements



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Wanderer
      Fence and pressure from the neighborhood is your best best until there is a law against it. Good luck.
    • delcecchi
      My deck?
    • PRO-V
      A letter from all the neighbors or a neighborhood meeting with him sounds like a good first thing to try. Maybe he'll get the hint. Better than war.
    • james_walleye
      Got a good tree for a stand? Haha
    • CigarGuy
      Rig up a motion sensor with a horn or alarm of some kind.
    • delcecchi
      New neighbor decided he likes to feed deer in the winter, and he does so right on our side of his yard.   The food attracts many many deer, and so our yard now has a big mudhole as well as bushels of deer pellets.    (free for the raking).    Nobody on the road is very happy about him feeding the deer since they tramp around the area and stand on the road and so on.    He didn't sound like "oops won't do that anymore" but more like "no big deal, it will wash away and the grass will grow back"    Anybody got any suggestions?   CO says "nothing that he can do", Town board isn't happy either but isn't convinced they can do anything.   I'm thinking that if they pass a rule, then I can take him to small claims court every spring until he stops wrecking our lawn.   Molotov cocktails are a last resort.   I am thinking of a fence that I put up in the fall to funnel the deer away from my yard.   Snowfence is too short but might help discourage them....   I really don't want war with the neighbor but this can't go on.    I'll talk to him again and see what he is thinking....   Maybe a letter from all his neighbors...   I need ideas...
    • hamboneco
      My buddy and I are hoping to make it in to Little Trout Lake the week after next.   Sitting a canoe has become a little less comfortable over the years, so our idea is to row/pole our way through the channel from Trout Lake in our 16' boat, then row around and drift in Little Trout, while catching some nice walleyes.   Hoping we can get through whatever remains of the beaver dam in the channel without getting in the water.    If anyone has been in to Little Trout lately, does this seem doable?    Poling through the channel always worked years ago when motors were allowed on Little Trout, but of course, things can change in 40+ years.   The only bummer is that I was hoping we could leave the motor on the boat and just not fire it up on Little, but the Ranger Station in Cook told me I must remove it and stash it on the Trout Lake side.  Also, although I spent quite a bit of time on Little Trout in the late 50's through the early 70's, I've only been in there a couple times since.  If anyone has any advice on fishing locations, I would gladly accept them.   
    • Better Than Working!
      Thanks! I have to admit that the plan starting the day was to pitch for smallmouth but the wind where we wanted to fish pushed us to plan B! Another reason to tell my wife why I need so many rods and reels and tackle boxes!
    • Tom Sawyer
      Nice fish!
    • Better Than Working!
      Not seeing any reports from Mille Lacs so here is my 1st report! Hit the pond Saturday afternoon for a few hours of getting the rust off the boat, equipment and skills. Found the fish in cabbage in 10-12 feet of water. Trolling stick baits 2.0 - 2.3 mph. Only got 4 walleye (24", 25" and two 28") but they were very healthy! Not bad for a few hours of fishing! Good luck out there and make some memories!