Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

Recommended Posts

Hey all:

Figured it was time to put up a thread of actual hands-on reports for the area, so I'll start with mine from this afternoon.

I hit two small lakes within 25 miles of Ely. These are always among the first lakes to freeze.

Both were locked up tight. Both had 2-3 inches of ice within 50 feet of shore. Both are dangerous to walk on. Here's why.

There's about 4 inches of new, heavy snow on top of that fresh ice, and the lakes I tested were already developing slush, because the snow had pushed down on the young, thin ice and cracked it, forcing water up through and forming the slush. The ice formed clear and hard and was good strong ice until the snow. As it was, the ice cracked further with every step I took.

There's 3-6 more inches of snow forecast this afternoon/tonight (it's snowing again now), with a break tomorrow and more snow on Wednesday night/Thanksgiving.

The snow that's already there, coupled with whatever additional snow falls, will make these lakes unwalkable, and the insulation will retard ice development.

It's a gol darn shame, too, because if we weren't getting all this snow, forecast temps in the next several days would have made it pretty easy to be fishing on these lakes by week's end. As it is, I would not recommend it at all.

So let's post what ice reports we have on this thread, so folks looking in will have solid info to base decisions on.

Thanks, everyone! smilesmile

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 140
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Steve Foss

    31

  • Mike Stark

    21

  • Cliff Wagenbach

    12

  • shamrock7

    11

that snow really put a damper on the ice making timetable! it is also going to make for another year with sloppy slush on the top of the ice. its really a bummer but i'm still excited that ice season is almost here

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jake, slushy starts on the small lakes usually firm up when really cold weather hits, but by that time we're most often onto the bigger lakes which, being still mostly open water when it snows this early, aren't impacted by this week's snow.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

you beat me to it foss.

i also checked one small lake outside ely that foss had not checked and found the same conditions. hopefully we dont get the 6in they are calling for. if we only get a little more snow and some cold temps we MAY be alright. the snow/slush is very wet. if it gets cold i think the slush layer will freeze up good.

just have to wait a little longer to go fishin. im dyin here!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's going to be wierd this year if the big lakes freeze nicely after the snow...ice conditions would really vary from lake to lake. Maybe this isn't a bad thing since we still have a good shot at decent ice on the lakes that aren't locked up yet. Thanks for the report foss.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey guys just wondering how the fishing is on Vermillion in the winter. We will be up for the "grand opening" of my wifes' parents cabin on Big Bay new years weekend and i plan on snooping around. Can a guy scrounge up some eyes out there?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Similar report from Da' Range. Most lakes are open, with a few little guys locked up and turning into slush pits.

Hoping for a cold, dry few weeks after this last blast of snow to lock up 'em all up and make a good base before the next round of snow.

I have a feeling we're in for a very white winter!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vermilion should be good for walleyes this winter! The bite was very good in late fall and the average size has improved a lot also.

Cliff

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Four more inches of fluffy snow overnight here in Ely. Nice cold weather here now, with more to come in the next several days. Hope the Thanksgiving snow forecast peters out and this cold can penetrate the new snow.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yesterday, Daisy Bay was wide open as far as I could see. This morning, there is only a small patch of open water on the NW side of Banana Island. It appears that the wind has pretty much blown the new ice clear. It's 15 degrees here at 11:00.

Be Safe,

MarkB smile

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Frazer Bay is open but we are locked tight. No real snow on the ice, looks like the ice was very thin or wet and the snow just turned to slush as it fell. Should freeze up good. Just got home last night so this is the first I have seen it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I appreciate the reports fellas!

I got the chance to meet up with Steve Foss a few years back for early ice....and as I keep my eyes open on your posts...I am hoping for another "cannonball run" to Ely again in a week or so.

Keep me posted, and if anyone in that area is going to venture out anytime soon....let me know! I figure the more the merrier when it comes to early ice safety!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

She's locking up real fast we'll be fishing soon!! Everett Bay narrows...FYI - (EARLY ICE HOTSPOT!!) full-34587-3658-015.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Frazer is froze over this morning. Wish it would have stayed open until after this coming snow.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

skied out to a small lake with a max depth in the mid 20's. found only an inch maybe 1.5in of black ice with 3in of snow/slush ice on top. closer to shore the slush/snow ice was not completely frozen...one good wack with the axe and the axe broke through the ice. not safe to fish on. one good thing was that there was hardly any snow on the ice, even back in a windblown bay.

also while driving i saw skim ice on a couple other bigger lakes. shouldnt be long.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The deer are walking out to Duffy Island in Pike Bay. Two sets of tracks yesterday morning.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I measured just a little over 2 inches of ice in front of my dock today in Pike Bay, a lot of slush though! I had the security of measuring from my dock as it stays in the water year round....otherwise it would not support my phat arss! Drove down to Mckinley Park today and ice was formed out to Birch Island, too bad it froze last night with the snow coming down tonight.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

checked the same small shallow lake today. found 2in of black ice with 5in of snow/slush ice on top. the 5in of snow/slush ice was not completely frozen yet. not safe enough for my liking. also check shag and found 4in of cloudy snow/slush ice. didnt find any black ice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 inches on small lake in Morrison co. this morning,4 darkhouses out and one guy had about a 4 lb. slimmer ouside his shack. I got a couple nice eyes in 6 ft. water on tip ups...using light no. minnows

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very hard to tell what is going on out in Big Bay without being able to get out there to check.

Not enough ice to be safe even for walking as far as I am concerned!

Cliff

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well heres what it looks like at BayView right now for those of you not in the area. We have ALOT of snow! I talked to one of our regulars tonight who said he has seven inches 50' out in front of his place in Daisy bay with 2" of watery slush on top of that. I think we still might be ok If it would just get cold. I had a fairly busy weekend with the snowmobilers so it won't be long now.

full-34587-3849-dsc00479.jpg

full-34587-3850-dsc00480.jpg

full-34587-3851-dsc00481.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Got out to check ice this afternoon on two area lakes.

I checked one small lake that got pretty much the whole dump of 18 inches or so of snow we've had in the last couple of weeks, and one large flowage/lake that only received the last couple of snows.

One Pine (small lake) had a minimum of 3 inches of solid ice everywhere I went. Two guys were fishing it. There were some areas with an 1.5 inches of frozen slush on top, then an inch or so of water, and then the 3 inches of ice. Other areas were solid all the way through and 3-5 inches.

I went to two commonly fished areas on Birch (large flowage/lake) and found generally the same conditions as on One Pine. There are more areas on Birch that were simply slushy snow on top of 3 inches of solid ice, and when my spud bar went through, water did not well up very long or very hard, so the ice doesn't seem to be getting weighed down too hard. Other areas were solid 5 inches, and others just like the crust/water/ice of One Pine. There was one guy fishing on Birch.

In no case was snow or snow/slush deeper than 3-4 inches. This will all be tightening up even further with the temps we're getting starting tonight.

So for my money, when you figure that and the guys fishing Shagawa in Ely the last couple of days, it's game on for the weekend. But as always, use care and all available safety gear/precautions. We know that even thick ice can have open spots and unexpected pockets of thin ice, and when the whole ice sheet is in this condition, it can be even more uncertain.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

found 5in of ice on shagawa today. there were some areas where the slush ice on top was not completely frozen. that should lock up tonight or the next night. not much snow out on the lake.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the reports! Crazy how this year panned out. I was gunning to run up there for a 24 hour fishing marathon last weekend but instead did just fine down here on 3-4 inches of good clean ice. Can't wait to come up to God's country again this winter though, cheers!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It hasn't even been every year since I moved here about 8 years ago that I could get onto One Pine by Thanksgiving weekend. Maybe half the years, so this would be about average.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • smurfy
      oh you know where i mean..........where all your friends are!!!!!!!🤗
    • Mike89
      Charcoal Briquettes are great for low and slow cooking as they produce long-lasting heat. Lump Charcoal burns hotter and adds more flavour to your food; therefore is great for hot and fast cooking.
    • leech~~
      Back page?  I've been on here for years, did I miss that page?  
    • Big V Bobcat
      Fake News Alert. Head East 😝
    • SkunkedAgain
      This was posted in the Timberjay this week, and should be in the upcoming LVA publication. Great news for those of us on the west end.      https://www.timberjay.com/stories/west-end-is-suddenly-hot,21403   LAKE VERMILION— How things have changed on Lake Vermilion’s west end. Not that many years ago, resort owners on the lake’s western half were bemoaning low numbers of walleye, particularly fish smaller than the protective slot limit. Those complaints aren’t likely to be heard this year, at least based on the results of the DNR’s fall fish survey, the results of which were released last week, averaged 22.1 walleye per net, the highest number of walleye ever recorded in the western basin. Those strong numbers helped keep the lakewide average walleye catch rate at 16.7 fish per net, according to the report issued by Matt Hennen, large lake specialist with the DNR’s Tower area fisheries office. It was the fourth year in a row of above-average walleye numbers and was virtually unchanged from last year. The eastern basin, which has long been the go-to for walleye anglers, walleye numbers averaged somewhat below the long-term mean, at 13.1 fish per net. That’s in the bottom 25th percentile historically for that basin. As usual, the populations continue to be driven by recent moderate to strong year-classes in 2018 and 2021. But a weak year class in 2022 appears to be responsible for the decline in total walleye numbers, particularly in the eastern basin. But that decline is unlikely to be noticeable to anglers this summer, as the prospects for angler success remain high. “Overall, decent numbers of fish can be found from 13 to 20 inches, which is generally the size range anglers prefer to harvest,” notes Hennen in his report. “Additionally, above average numbers of small fish from 10 to 13 inches were present in the population last fall. These fish will grow throughout the 2024 fishing season and provide ample catch and harvest opportunities in 2024 and beyond. High numbers of fish 20 inches and larger will continue to provide memorable catch opportunities throughout the lake.” While the average walleye count on the eastern basin was relatively low for Vermilion, it was still exceptionally high for most lakes in Minnesota, reflecting the remarkably productive fishery that Lake Vermilion represents. According to Hennen, Vermilion’s walleye population is heavily dependent on the strength of individual year-classes, which have tended toward boom and bust in recent years. The lake experienced strong year-classes in 2016 and 2018, while preliminary estimates point to 2021 as another strong year-class. By contrast, the 2017 and 2020 year-classes were weak, and 2022 appears to also be weak. The outlook for the 2023 year-class, however, looks hopeful. As part of the DNR’s annual survey on Lake Vermilion, fisheries staff conduct electrofishing to detect young fish too small to capture in nets and the results from that effort offer the first glimpse at the strength of that year’s reproduction. According to the report, the electrofishing tallied 118.3 fish per hour, which was on track with the long-term average, suggesting that 2023 will, at least, be a moderate year-class. The fish samples averaged 5.6 inches in length, which was slightly above normal. That can bode well for the percentage of young walleye that survive the winter. Yellow perch Anglers on Vermilion should find plenty of perch this year as well, including many large enough to harvest. “The 2023 lakewide gill net catch rate of 30.0 fish per net was slightly above average compared to previous surveys,” noted Hennen’s report. “The average size of those fish was fairly large with notable numbers over 10 inches and even some fish over 12 inches.” As with walleye, the perch results showed differences between the lake’s two basins. The western basin’s catch rate of 38.5 fish per net was impressive, but more of those perch were small— more a nuisance than a harvest prospect. On the east end, the perch numbers were lower at 24.3 fish per net, but many more larger perch were found there. And even though the numbers were lower on the east end, the results still showed perch numbers above the long-term average for the basin. Northern pike The northern pike population in Vermilion continues to show a declining trend and in the 2023 survey, the DNR caught just 12 northerns, or an average of 0.6 fish per net, ranging in size from 25 to 39 inches. The decline in overall pike numbers coincides with a shift in the population toward larger fish due in part to the protective slot limit, which has been in place since 2003. Panfish The DNR conducted spring trap netting of both crappies and bluegills in 2023 and found sufficient numbers to justify targeting these species, even though Vermilion tends to hold fewer panfish than many other Minnesota lakes. The trap netting found higher numbers of both species on the lake’s west end. The survey found an average crappie size of 10 inches, with multiple fish over 13 inches sampled from both basins. Anglers looking for bluegills would do best focusing on the lake’s west end. Bluegills captured averaged six inches in length, with fish over nine inches found on both ends of the lake. Muskie The DNR did not conduct an assessment of the lake’s muskie population in 2023. The muskie population was established via a stocking program that began in the late 1980s with the goal of providing a low-density, high-quality fishery. During the most recent targeted assessment conducted in 2019, muskies averaged 44.7 inches with over 40 percent of fish measuring 45 inches or larger. Additionally, about 11 percent of the fish sampled were 50 inches or larger. Assessment options for obtaining adult population estimates along with evaluating recent stocking strategies and natural reproduction are being considered for the future. Fisheries management As one of the state’s largest lakes and a popular fishery, the DNR conducts fish surveys annually as part of the agency’s management efforts. In addition to fish surveys, the DNR conducts regular creel surveys, water quality monitoring on Vermilion along with fish contaminant and disease inspections, zooplankton surveys, and aquatic invasive species surveillance. The DNR is reminding anglers that special regulations exists for walleyes where all fish from 20 to 26 inches must be immediately released. There is a possession limit of four walleyes with only one fish over 26 inches allowed. Anglers are also reminded that since 2019, northern pike have been managed under the Northeast Zone regulations requiring immediate release of all angled fish between 30 and 40 inches with only one over 40 inches allowed in a two fish possession limit. Separate regulations exist for dark house spearing which allows spearers to have two pike in possession but only one may be over 26 inches. All other fish species are managed under current statewide fishing regulations.
    • smurfy
      Never tried it. Pretty happy with the Kingsford     There's all kinds of food threads on the back page1🤗
    • leech~~
      Since this site doesn't have a Cooking thread.  Here's one.   Lump coal, anyone ever tried it on the grill?  How's the flavor and does it last longer then the Kingsford?  
    • Djsnej123456
      Appreciate the help
    • gimruis
      No, that is not legal since bass season is not open yet.   As leech stated, it better be something small that would work for crappies.   You can do all the scanning and scouting you want with your graphs at any point.  Just don't be tossing bass-sized lures.
    • leech~~
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.