Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

Another article in the Tribune


Jameson

Recommended Posts

The deer population in southwestern Minnesota is too low, and major changes -- including reducing the take of antlerless deer -- are needed to restore good hunting there, a coalition of hunters says.

Too many does are being killed via antlerless permits, youth tags and muzzleloader tags, in the opinion of the Southwest Minnesota Deer Coalition.

The group argues that many youth tags are being used illegally by adults to shoot antlerless deer. And the increase of muzzleloader hunters is adding to an overharvest of does, they say. The group recommends that antlerless tags be restricted and that no automatic tags be given for any type of license, including youth, muzzleloader or archery.

"There are almost no deer down there compared to what it used to be like," said Kirk Schnitker of Champlin, organizer of the group, which hunts in the southwest. "We need to quit killing does."

The Department of Natural Resources agrees with the premise. "We can't control the antlerless harvest under the current system," said Lou Cornicelli, DNR big game program leader.

The DNR says abnormally high success rates for youth antlerless permits confirms that adults are using them illegally. "The youth permits are being abused by adults, there's no doubt in my mind," Cornicelli said.

"The solution is to go bucks-only for a few years, which I'm not inclined to do, or bucks-only with limited number of youth antlerless tags."

The deer group focused its attention on permit areas 237, 238, 250 and 295, which are in the Slayton-Worthington-Heron Lake-Jackson region. But Cornicelli said the DNR likely will consider changes to a much broader area of southwestern and western Minnesota where the deer population is below goals.

The group is meeting Monday with the DNR. "We want changes for the 2009 deer season," Schnitker said.

Drop party hunting?

The group also issued several secondary recommendations to the DNR, including outlawing party hunting; moving the firearms deer season out of the peak rut and starting it on the third Saturday in November; condensing the archery season to one month starting in mid-October; and shortening the muzzleloader season to nine days.

...

Agree? Disagree?

...

I gotta say I always thought it was a bad idea to not have the doe lottery apply to all deer seasons. I archery, firearm, and muzzleload hunt in a Lottery area, and hope that we soon have ONE doe lottery that covers all three seasons.

Youth antlerless permits being abused? Not too sure of the rules here, but pretty sure a youth could get a permit at age 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, and 12. Six possible youth tags! I say make a max of 2 or 3 youth tags per lifetime. Sorry youths frown but at least it wouldn't totally do away with the youth tags.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"There are almost no deer down there compared to what it used to be like," said Kirk Schnitker of Champlin, organizer of the group, which hunts in the southwest. "We need to quit killing does."

I dont believe that a guy who lives in the cities should be trying to change the regulations in southwest mn cause of a bad year for hunting. There might not be the deer that were here a few years ago but low numbers I dont believe that. There might of been 100 deer less this year but the conditions for hunting was bad The new 9 day season could of had somthing to do with low numbers to with so much preasure they choose not to move. Lets not forget about the fields that were in to at least were I hunted there were some left. Maybe some should get out of there trruck a bit more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Aside from being hunters, what qualifies the Coalition to ascertain the right approach to take? Having fewer deer than previous doesn't necessarily mean something is wrong. Maybe, there were too many deer previous and now it's more in line with what the environment can support? Could be many factors and a hunter's coalition may be too emotionally involved to be impartial enough to do what is truly right.

Maybe the deer herd is smaller because they are practicing AR or QDM. In order for these programs to play out, don't the numbers have to come down?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Remember this Schnitker guy is also the anti-muskie guy who is at the helm of no more muskies I think that was the name of the web page or some website was all about the stopping of muskie stocking. We had a pretty interesting debate last summer about that. As far as the deer go I would think it is less QDM and more just brown down pounding and finally it is catching up in that area, just overharvest then again I'd let the DNR investigate that area and see what is around.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Musky Buck I think yoou are right about this guy and the muskies to. He even has a website "muskytroubles".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Right on LOTW, it was the muskytroubles, I guess I'll admit I lost my cool with him last summer and I did apologize. I was thinking the same about the gull lake stocking issue. To each there own but he likes to hold the reigns in controversial topics. There are pockets all around the state with low deer densities and others are still strong. I have the Sunday Trib and haven't really read the article yet, will tonight, no more shooting does, sounds interesting and unrealistic, but what are the true deer densities in SW MN ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I live just east of the area in question. From my perspective, I do not see a decrease in overall numbers. I live on 13 acres northwest of Fairmont. The number of deer on and around my property is as high or higher than it has been since I have owned it (since 1995). The number of big bucks is lower than it used to be, but there are plenty of small bucks, and more does than I can keep away from my new trees, and garden.

I think this is another example of some one sitting in an office in a larger city looking at statistics of an area that he has never visited, and deciding that more legislation is the answer to every problem out there.

-just my opinion though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not trying to take this off topic but after our discussion about AR and QDM a couple weeks ago and the position that I took at that time, I find it interesting how you have noted a change in the buck maturity ratio. I'm still listening even if you didn't think I was before.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think his basis is part because of his family members or friends that hunt that area that maybe have had recent poor success. Last years opening weekend of firearms wasn't very pleasant with a lot of wind. If it was windy in the thick swamps and forests I can only imagine what opening weekend must have been like for CRP and open land hunting like I think the southwest part of MN is like. If he lived in the area and had a scope and sequence of many years of hunting and living there to see what the wintering herds are like and such, I'd listen much more closely and it would carry much more weight.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Bob what we are all hearing is some people pass on fawns, some on does, some on young bucks, but few if any on mature bucks. Some pass on female ducks, some do lots of catch and release. Some deer hunting areas like his have lots of subdivided land and it is very difficult with multiple stands on small properties to ever see a mature buck because a large % are gunned down every year, our harvest is something like 62% are yearlings and in some areas that is probably a much higher number especially since about that 1995 and on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am just happy this debate doesn't involve the SE. I am in SE MN where the deer are thick as ticks and the freezer gets filled up every season. I have been many years since I have taken fewer than 4 does in a season, and now can be choosy about taking the tasty young ones. We keep the numbers of breeders down to save the crops, but they keep oozing back in from the nearby suburban woods to replenish our freezers each year!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just moved down to Worthington right before christmas. I do not see how the land around here can hold much for deer. A very large percentage of the land is fields, about the only trees that grow are around people's houses (or where houses used to be), and around the lakes. There is also some crp and cattails. The deer would seem to have food and cover in the summer, but slim in the winter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So what type of per square mile deer carrying capacity can the area have and if it was much higher what were the circumstances that led to that, I know we had quite a few mild winters in a row for a few years a few years ago, interesting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you were asking me, I don't know. don't know enough about deer population concentrations or the area to make an estimate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Rick G
      St Cloud has a good access at Wilson park,  Sartell has a nice access off NE River Rd,  another access above Blanchard dam on East side off Hilton Rd  and at Lindbergh state park...Little Falls  has a access right above the dam.   Water is pretty high and dirty.  Crayfish colors have been good again this week.  Smallies have been using anything available that breaks the current so finding them most days has been pretty easy
    • Brianf.
      Interesting...   You're doing better than most.  The biggest bass weighed-in during the recent MN Bass Federation tourney was only 4.33lbs.   The winning bag was less then 20lbs.  To have several over 5lbs during your trip is pretty special.   Congrats!  
    • Jetsky
      Question.  I have guests coming who may want to fish for muskies.  I've cast for them in August along shorelines and at rock piles.   Do I fish for them that way in June?   Should I troll shorelines or drop offs for them?  Thanks.
    • partyonpine
      Yeah was up for a week.   As other alluded to the weather was brutal.  Did catch some larger walleyes on slip bobbers on windy points in under 5 feet of water.  As for minnows they were at Lucky seven in Virginia and Grubens has some nice minnows as well.  Smallmouth fishing was terrific given the circumstances.  
    • partyonpine
      Brian   That is funny and shows how things are anecdotal.  Just got back from a week we caught as many fish as we wanted, however our average size was 16.5-17 inches.  While no 6 pounders we did score several 5 pounders.  We did not catch any or very few fish under 14  inches all week.  I was just commenting that the average size has increased substantially.  We were throwing larger artificial and live bait but again did not really catch any small smallmouth.  Fished smallies for 5-6 hours each day and walleyes at night.  Overall was slow but the weather was horrendous.  Did go home with enough walleye to satisfy me.  
    • Brianf.
      I haven't been up to fish smallmouth  in a couple weeks.  My partner and I caught about 300 over the  course of those two days.  That sounds great - and it is if you like numbers. However, few of those fish were over 3 pounds and even fewer were over 4 pounds.  Most of our catch comprised fish between one and a half to 2 1/2 pounds.   I've been fishing the lake for 20+ years and feel that the size structure of the smallmouth in the lake has changed quite a bit during that time.  When I first started targeting smallmouth 20 years ago, half our bag seemed to be comprised of four pounders - and five pounders were in the mix with an occasional six pounder here and there. I haven't caught a 5 pound smallmouth bass in five years on Lake Vermilion!   They are a daily occurrence on places like Mille Lacs and in Door Co.   What has changed on Lake Vermilion?     I have some theories about why the size structure has changed, though curious what others are seeing.  Anyone have thoughts about the state of the smallmouth fishery on Lake V? 
    • SkunkedAgain
      Don't forget about the times that they unwittingly fly into your fishing line.   Normally I would say that ebbs and flows in food source would be a good sign. However, even with this bountiful mosquito population available there just really aren't enough bats around for the natural cycle to capitalize on it to any noticeable degree. The DNR says that roughly 90% of the bat population in the Soudan mine has died off. If that 90% is representative of the entire area, even a mosquito all-you-can-eat-buffet will not bring the bats back for many years.   Hopefully the little guys can make a comeback.
    • Dash 1
      Made it back to the chain today. Sunfish are spawning but finding them in the thick weeds is nearly impossible. My main reason to get out was to test my minnkota after rewiring it. It definitely made the difference. Never shut down once and I ran it for several hours.  Now I just need to relearn how to catch fish.😂
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the south end...   A good week of walleye fishing with some big fish caught along with good eaters.  All of that despite some fronts that came through and lots of wind.  Being in a charter boat a few days this week was an advantage for sure.     Wherever you fish, there are days the wind will blow.  Here are some good options for anglers when the wind blows on LOW.   -Fish on a big charter boat -Fish the 42 miles of navigable Rainy River -Bays such as Four Mile, Bostic and Zippel Bay -Slide behind one of the thousands of islands that being up at the NW Angle -Trailer your boat to a leeward boat ramp and fish that shoreline A jig and frozen emerald shiner was the go to presentation for walleyes.  Most boats are anchored up and vertically jigging.  Some are starting to use spinners and minnows or crawlers with success.  This pattern will pick up steam as the walleyes are starting to transition with warming waters. Walleyes have been caught this week in various depths.  As a rule, 21 - 32 feet of water was still the range.  Again, various areas across the lake are holding fish.   Various rock reefs have been good.  Fish are transitioning to mud as the season progresses. On the Rainy River...  The river is flowing strong right now as water is being released from the dam which controls its flow.  With the heavier current, fish are being found in areas with a current break.  Even a slight break that still has current is a fish attractor when the water is moving.   Jigging with a minnow, pulling spinners and trolling crankbaits along shoreline breaks against the current in 6 - 12' of water is producing a mixed bag of walleyes, saugers, pike, smallmouth bass and an occasional crappie.   Casting to shoreline structure and even docks is also an effective method.   For those who like fishing for dinosaurs, the sturgeon season opens July 1st. Up at the NW Angle...  A great week of fishing amongst the island area of Lake of the Woods.  Guides fishing the Canada side of LOW reported big numbers of walleyes along with a mixed bag.   Minnesota waters also produced good fish.  Many of the walleyes are being found in deeper than normal water for this time of year, in that 22 - 28 feet.  As hatches begin and shiners begin to spawn, there will be some shallow water opportunities as well. The goto presentation continues to be a jig and minnow.  Pulling spinners with shiners or crawlers and trolling crankbaits also putting walleyes in the fry pan.     As is common in these parts, a mixed bag of walleyes, saugers, pike, jumbo perch, crappies, pike and smallmouth bass being caught.   Muskie anglers, the season opens on both sides of the lake Saturday, June 15th.  A glorious day for those who target the almighty predators!  
    • leech~~
      Over the years the only sure time I have been able to see bats or know their around.  Is sitting by a fire or down by a dock at sun down when there's just a bit of light left when looking up, and seeing them diving in and out.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.