• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
thorski

Your Pinewood derby help....CONTRIBUTES TO SUCCESS!

Question

thorski

My son is in Cub Scouts and his first Pinewood derby is coming up late next month. Wondering if anyone has any pointers, suggestions, advice, etc? Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Recommended Posts

  • 0
BoxMN

Sand the nails/axles with fine steel wool, and use silicon smile

Also, don't let a little brother hold the car before a heat! ha, my bro dropped my fast car and three wheels broke off. I was bummmed...

I also think keeping weight slightly more in front of car is better than in back, but not sure...

Most of all, make sure you son gets to work on car, not just Dad and buddy doing it all. He will have more fun the more he gets to do on it. With that said, you will have to do plenty too, so it gets done wink

Have fun! It will be a great time, making the car and racing it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
PierBridge

Good advice I'm still crushed a wobbly back right wheel cost me advancing to the next round!.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
eyebjim

I agree the weight in the front is better.

Do a internet search of Pinewood derby and you will find a lot of help.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Jackpine Rob

Weight forward.

Box has the axle thing nailed.

Put the wheels in your electric drill (or better yet a lathe), and run them over emery sandpaper and emery cloth to smooth and get them trued and round. Those wheels may have some little bumps or imperfections.

Hope you and the boy have a riot with the project. Jr. and I sure had our fun back in the day, and his cars and trophies still grace the bookshelves in his room.

One year his car was shaped like a shark - another year it ended up being a black bear. Two others were more conventional, with one looking like a Formula 1 racer and another that looked like a 68 Camaro.

Edit: Oh yeah, and get as close to the maximum weight as you can without going over. A postal scale is very helpful. Lead is your friend.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

My son is a veteran of 5 Pinewood Derby's. A word of caution, read the pack rules very carefully related to car construction/lubrication. Sometimes Pack car construction rules differ from District car construction rules. If your son wins at pack level and gets a berth to district, but gets disqualified due to a construction rule/lubrication difference, he will be crushed.

Having said that, as mentioned before, there are tons of ideas/tips on the web. My son was pretty motivated so we did a lot of research. (But he did the all the actual work he was capable of, I was hands off.) Far and away the biggest factor in making the car fast is reducing friction (assuming you make sure that you are near the weight limit.) Weight positioning is actually pretty low on the list. Axel prep is huge, but larger still is alignment. Make sure the car tracks straight on a flat surface. It will drag far less on the guide strip in the center of the lane that way. Also, usually there is no rule stating all 4 wheels must be in contact with the track. Keep the 4th one just above the other 3 wheels and off the track to eliminate it's friction all together. It only hits the track if the car bounces a little. If your rules allow, trim your wheels to reduce the surface area in contact with the track..... You should be starting to get the idea, there are tons of little tricks. Just find out what is legal in your pack.

If your son is really serious about doing well, the research and construction is almost as much fun as the races themselves. There is a guy out there that did a physics paper on what factors play into it the most. He goes into great detail about a lot of things, one being weight locations. Optimum weight placement depends on the track shape, but after he goes through all that, he points out that in testing it made very little difference in overall speed as compared to the benefit you can get by eliminating or reducing all the various sources of friction. If you can find that paper/website, you will have all the hints you need. Have fun!

By the way, according to that physics paper, most of the track designs out there are run faster with weight rearward, not forward. That physics paper I mentioned has all the details, all I remember is the general statement. Something about gravity, the amount of time gravity can work on the weight when it is higher off the floor, etc. Again, we are talking miniscule differences here. But a much bigger reason to have weight back is that every time the car's front wheels contact the guide strip it is easier for the front wheels to realign themselves on the track with less weight on them. Less weight on the front says more weight on the rear. Reduces friction essentially.

(As I said, my son was pretty serious about this, we learned a lot.) grin

Most important, make sure your son has fun and learns the skills you are teaching. That is arguably more important than the races.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Hafnutz

Whatever you do let him paint/finish the car to make it "his". Some of the strangest looking cars win but the kids think they're really cool. I can't wait til the grandsons' are old enough to start doing the cars again

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Surface Tension

I know a little about Pinewood Derby Cars. grin

OK post those pictures.

Derby.jpg

A couple 1st places, and Best Overall. laugh We got two 2nd places cuz it was our rookie year. wink

The Cheez-it and Chartreuse Dragster were a big hit.

Yes Dads got to build a car too. cool

Most of the cars were foiled and some painted over bright.

All were clear coated to make the paint job pop.

You know you'd have to pay big money for this info don't ya. grin I'm only telling cuz I'm retired.

You'll need to take the casting off the wheel and make them round. Then narrow the contact surface. One front tire should be shorter or mounted higher to not make contact with the track at all.

The inside of the hub should be polished as well as the nail/axle. Check your rules, our troop does not allow and aftermarket axles, washers, or tires. Even then a parent would try and cheat but I still smoked them. Most of the weight should be on the rear tires. Don't make me explain the slingshot physics behind that, just do it or else you'll be in last place. Don't use the slots for the nails/axles, flip the car over and drill your holes and do that before you shape the car. When your all done shaping and painting, polish the side of the car where the axel inserts, then set your axles. You might have a dry lube rule in which case you'll use graphite, tip here, use a pencil. If they allow a wet lube use something very thin. Pledge furniture polish or kerosene. Just remember that wet lube will attract dirt and dust and you could end up in last place.

If you did a major mod and changed the distance between the wheels you better make sure its not going to scrape the nose in the transition. Get your weight up to the full 4 oz. I used 9mm bullets, drill a hole and press them in. Get a little tool box with some padding to put the car in to keep if from getting damaged. The top tray can hold your lube and special tools.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
DTro

I never had the chance to do any of this when I was a kid, and I don’t have any kids, but don’t you think it’s great how a block of wood a couple of axles and 4 wheels can create such a passion?

I mean you have “old timers” (sorry Frank smile ) recollecting about their toy cars and even still being able to “smoke” the competition who tried to cheat. I love it, keep em coming guys!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Love the variety! My son did a Cheeze Whiz car, a car shaped like a wedge of swiss cheese, complete with a bunch of dremeled out holes, plus a tiny mouse driver sitting in one of the holes. Also had a Spongebob Car, and a couple of interesting looking dragster type bodies. He's got a shelf full of trophies too. It was a blast. If I can find a pic of the Cheese Whiz I'll post......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
harvey lee

Yes, the Pinewood derby days. I won a pack championship and the metro championship in the cities.

We had a great time building and racing the car.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
hawkeye43

Our troop has a class for the dads, so they don't put all their time in the kids car. Trim the wheels so they only run on the very center like a tire thats overinflated. have it so only 3 wheels touch the track and run as straight as you can

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Boar

Ohboy Pinewood derby, I am a champion, my two brothers ore champions, my son is a champion, an my daughter is an open division champion, I am also a vintage division champion. One thing that has always helped us is to take the nails an insert them into a drill then put the drill into avise an lock it in the on position the take some fine emerycloth an sand of the rough edges especially the little tiny molding edge on the underside of the nail head, the take some 000 steel wool an tear off clump an twist it in your fingers so you have a small rope like piece of steel wool, with the drill still running finish smoothing off the axil. Now of course you have all used graphite, but what you need to look for is ultra fine graphite old hardware stores might still have some, I'm still using the tube my father used when I was in cub scouts. taking care of the tires is a very important factor, I finely sand down the tires to remove all molding blemishes. I also develope a very thin profile car. Good luck Boar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
fishorgolf

Why didn't I have this info back when I did derby? I would have been the king. Oh I forgot there wasn't the internet back then. And I am only 49. Man have things changed quickly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
thorski

I don't know what happened, but there used to be more posts on this thread? It must have been deleted, including my thanking everyone, so here goes again.....

Thank you for all the responses. I had no clue that pinewood derby was so technical! Thanks for the tips and advise. My son and I are really getting excited. I will post how he did.

Thanks again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
harvey lee

Good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Surface Tension

Good luck thorski.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
thorski

My son and I would like to thank everyone for their help and advice! My son had his Cub Scout pack's Pinewood derby yesterday morning. What a blast. My son won every heat except one, where he came in second to the car that ended up being the overall winner of the day. My son's car took second overall. The top 5 cars go on to the district competition.

I will post pics as soon as I figure out how.

Thank you all!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
B K'S DAD

They still have derby I haven't one in over 30 years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
harvey lee

Congrats to you and your son. I remember the fun those use to be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
redbandit

Thorski, I was in the same shoes 20 some yrs ago with my dad. I had the same 2nd place results in the pack as your son did. I still have that trophy stashed away in a box somewhere. You've brought back some fond memories that I'll never forget and I'm sure you and your son will have the same. Good luck to you at the distict competion and great job!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
thorski

Here are a few pics I promised.

First, I made him a carrying case for his car out of a plastic tool box he had. I just cut some foam out and used some adhesive to attacht the foam to the tool box.

3292008245.jpg

3292008247.jpg

Here is the winning car with the trophy and medal.

3292008285.jpg

Thanks everyone!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
PierBridge

Way Cool!

Good Luck in the next event!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Surface Tension

thorski, congrats to you and your son.

Good Luck at Districts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
tunrevir

Way to go! That is really cool, something your son won't soon forget. I still have my car and third place trophy from 30 years ago, lots of good memories.

Tunrevir~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
DTro

So I heard from a co-worker today that they have offically banned lead from the cars.

Curious what people are going to be using now??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Chris mo
      so i booked my first trip to mille lacs for a week on the southern portion in september for my pike fishing trip with my wife and dog. we agreed that we would try smaller lakes in the future and we actually went bigger!! 😀🙄 man that's a big (almost) round lake. i'm not asking for secret spots, but a push in the right direction please. i will look at my navionics this week and see how it looks but do i just go out and find some points or maybe work the backs of the bays? shallow or deep in mid september? i would think that first i would need to find some weeds. i always think weeds and pike. from looking at satellite pics it's hard for me to tell weeds or any other type of structure. any of your suggestions would really be helpful.  i know it's not rocket science to catch pike but any time that I could save looking would be a great help. you have all been really kind. thank you all! chris
    • chucker1101
      Tale of two days this last weekend. On Saturday, couldn't pull a fish out of the lake. On Sunday, had a four fish walleye limit by 11am, with a bonus perch as well.   Graphed fish on Saturday, just couldn't get 'em to move. On Sunday, went back and no fish to be found. Decided to get out of my comfort zone, so i started working spots that i hadn't been to in two years or more. 2nd spot i tried had 'em stacked. Not huge, but consistent 12-15". Good size to keep.   My take-away was get out and try some spots you haven't been to in a while.
    • imhatz
      Rick where is Elephant lake ? I have been going to Sand Point and Crane since 1983. We fish mainly in Sand Point ...Staeges, Grassy and Browns. We are tenting at Jensen site.
    • Wheezy Outdoors
      The sweltering heat, high humidity values, and intermittent thunderstorms have certainly provided some challenges for anglers but even as we enter the dogdays of summer the fish are still on the chow! As we all know there is never any shortage of action when one sets out to target Bass. Smallmouth Bass can be found along the deep weed lines, rocks, and sunken humps. Try using a Drop-Shot Rig tipped with a Leech. Largemouth on the other hand can be found working the weeds inside and outside the lines using Tubes, Spinner Baits, and Carolina Rigs. In the early morning, try working docks, shoreline structure and swimming platforms next to sharp drop-offs. Of course, usually by this time of year we have shifted our focus to chasing Large Slab Crappies. The weed beds are holding large numbers of both Crappies and Sunfish. Pay especially close attention to the cabbage along deeper drop-offs. Slip-Bobbers using live bait or plastics, Small Swim Baits, Spinners, Beetle Spins are all working well, these buggers have been hungry!! The Walleye bite is also one that has yet to relinquish to the torrid, humid conditions. A lot of techniques have still been producing good numbers of fish. Anything from pulling Spinners in the weeds, Lindy Rigs, Slip-Bobbers, jigs tipped with Leeches, Crawlers or Chubs… Cranks, Shiver Minnows and the list goes on!! It really is Dealer’s Choice it seems, trolling Cranks on the mid-lake flats has been best toward the evening hours until after dark, Spinners have been enticing them during the mid-day, as well as jigging raps for the walleye found out over the deep structure. -Cheers! Alice Wiese Wheezy Outdoors 218-275-7525  
    • Wheezy Outdoors
      The sweltering heat, high humidity values, and intermittent thunderstorms have certainly provided some challenges for anglers but even as we enter the dogdays of summer the fish are still on the chow! As we all know there is never any shortage of action when one sets out to target Bass. Smallmouth Bass can be found along the deep weed lines, rocks, and sunken humps. Try using a Drop-Shot Rig tipped with a Leech. Largemouth on the other hand can be found working the weeds inside and outside the lines using Tubes, Spinner Baits, and Carolina Rigs. In the early morning, try working docks, shoreline structure and swimming platforms next to sharp drop-offs. Of course, usually by this time of year we have shifted our focus to chasing Large Slab Crappies. The weed beds are holding large numbers of both Crappies and Sunfish. Pay especially close attention to the cabbage along deeper drop-offs. Slip-Bobbers using live bait or plastics, Small Swim Baits, Spinners, Beetle Spins are all working well, these buggers have been hungry!! The Walleye bite is also one that has yet to relinquish to the torrid, humid conditions. A lot of techniques have still been producing good numbers of fish. Anything from pulling Spinners in the weeds, Lindy Rigs, Slip-Bobbers, jigs tipped with Leeches, Crawlers or Chubs… Cranks, Shiver Minnows and the list goes on!! It really is Dealer’s Choice it seems, trolling Cranks on the mid-lake flats has been best toward the evening hours until after dark, Spinners have been enticing them during the mid-day, as well as jigging raps for the walleye found out over the deep structure. -Cheers! Alice Wiese Wheezy Outdoors 218-275-7525  
    • rumeye
      I live just off the Rum near walbo. Water high deer flies horrible. Yes good smallie and walleye when water down to normal. To high right now in my opinion.
    • delcecchi
      I wonder if there is any connection to the fact that when the dnr guys pull their seine on my beach they get 150 or so nice perch? Run up to 4 or 5 inches.   They seine at a number of places around the lake 4 times every July and have been for many years.   This is way above what I can remember as typical.  And that is without the young of the year which are still too little to show up much. 
    • james_walleye
      Wow that is ugly for sure! 
    • bassbouncer
    • TAJ
      I fished last Tuesday and Wednesday. Caught 5 walleyes in Lower WF on lindy and leach. 4 of the fish were caught within an hour on Tuesday early evening. Mornings were slow both days. Heading up again on Monday for a few days. Hopefully weather will stay stable.