• RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
hartner62

Coaxial vs. Bicone marine speaker

Question

hartner62

Looking for a couple of new speakers for the boat and in the cabelas website it gives two options either a bicone speaker or a coaxial. Whats the difference?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

7 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Whoaru99

A bicone probably refers to what is usually called a "whizzer" cone speaker. It's like a little inverted cone-shaped attachment usually attached to the periphery of the center dust cover. Check here.

A coaxial would have a second active driver (generally a midrange/tweeter) instead of the paper "whizzer" cone. Check here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
ishgood

Coaxial will give you better sound.

If you are looking for the best sound available, check out Alpine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
pulsar_nx

My experience says go wizzer cone unless your getting a higher end coaxial speaker. The problem with coaxials is that they send the full range to all speakers (the same as a wizzer) so they still don't sound all that good yet. I've found that a good aftermarket (Jenson comes to my mind) wizzer can sometimes sound as good or better and it costs less too.

If you look at the higher end coaxials (component) they will come with crossovers, now these will blow the socks off of the other two. But they cost alot more. Plus there may not be any marine ones out there.

Alot of speakers and decks are all about what looks cool not what sound cool. So you always want to test them out in the store if possible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

There is usually a crossover (high pass filter) to the tweeter otherwise the bass would fry it the first time you cranked it up (unless it's a piezo tweeter - they really don't need a high-pass filter, but tend to sound harsh). The filters are generally very simple 1st order (6dB/octave) consisting of a capacitor to block the low frequencies from reaching the tweeter.

I do agree that higher-end coaxials and the component speaker setups generally have more sophisticated 2nd order (12db/octave) or better crossovers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
vikingmeatwad

have you guys put non marine speakers in a boat before? With those poundings of rain we can take up there I'm a bit worried about non marine and I need to replace my speakers and deck soon.

And to answer the question I believe it's about 1 way vs. 2 way vs 3 way speaks. The more the better as it seperates the sounds for better handling of highs/lows/mids.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
hartner62

You guys really know your speakers. Thanks for all the help

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

I have non-marine speakers in my boat for the last few years. However, they are not paper cone, and they are very well protected from the elements as they reside well underneath the dual consoles.

If the speakers will be fairly exposed, I'd stick with the marine speakers.

Mine are coaxials, and are plenty good for the type of listening I do in the boat. Even the "whizzer" cone speakers probably will be fine for listening in the boat unless one is an audio enthusiast, or setting up a party barge.

As for the more the better, perhaps, but it's not a guarantee. Some VERY highly regarded home speakers are only 2-way designs.

In order for more to be better, extra work needs to go into the design to properly integrate more drivers. That's not always the case.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • krustykrab
      The Pine River stripping station will begin running on Monday, April 23rd.
    • laportian
      I live on the north side of Cass on the Pughole. We had 30 inches of ice out in front of my dock yesterday. Pughole is the flowage between Kitchie and Cass. I'm 200 yards off Cass and the current is pretty strong there. Top few inches was pretty mushy. Nothing happening as far as fish yet. But they are coming. Jumbos move in soon. Also seen a truck out off of Star Island on Monday evening. I imagine they have more ice out on the main lake than I have. I'm for sure going to be out ice fishing through next week at my place. Ice hasn't even begun to pull from shore at my place. 
    • Bigfatbert
      Hey there DUCKHTR . No need for a guide to hunt divers on Leech or Big Winnie . Your spots that you hunted early season on Leech will also be good spots for later season . I don't duck hunt anymore , but I used to hunt a lot on Winnie , mostly all my hunting there was on the north end Third River Flowage . Travel north from Deer River up Hwy 46 to the sign that directs you to turn left , then travel west on that gravel road for about 10-12 miles to the 3rd river boat landing . You should have no problem launching your boat there . From the landing outward is a lot of tall reeds on both sides of you  , this flowage widens out as you go farther out ,and depending on your wind direction on the day of your hunt , you can just pick and choose a spot  , all the way out , and down to Mallard Point where it really opens up to big water on Winnie . You will need to buy up 3-4 dozen Bluebill decoys , and also use your Mallard decoys you must already have . We used to have great shoots in that area of the lake . In the dark of the morning when your heading out you may have other hunters shine a flashlight your way , they are just letting you know that they are already set up in that spot , don't worry , there is plenty of room for many different hunting groups in the flowage . Once you get a few hunts below your belt , you will then have a better understanding of some of your favorite spots to set up ..  I had one particular spot we used to call the "Meat Market" because we used to kill so many ducks there in that spot . Just put out your decoys in the spot you choose , and then  pull your boat into the reeds parallel to the water , wait for legal shooting hrs , and have at it . From my recollection the Bills would start to trickle down from the north around the 20th or so of Oct .. I I hope this helps you out somewhat .
    • gimruis
      Well played.  Wish more people had that attitude.  Even a reduced statewide limit and/or a minimum keeper size would be fine by me.
    • gunner55
      I crossed paths with the person that works over there yesterday & got to ask if they would be netting on the Opener? Their reply was it might be July.  We'll see, may run into them again in the near future.
    • paceman
      Went for a short hunt yesterday morning. Heard a few gobbling on the roost on the neighbors land. They did not come my way and did not make any sounds once they flew down. It was great to be in the blind with the bow again. I am always amazed how loud the spring woods are. Every bird in the country was going crazy. Ducks, geese, crows, woodpeckers... music to my ears! Might get out again Sunday afternoon with my son and then myself Monday morning depending if we see anything Sunday....
    • OhioVike
      Tom, good thoughts now we need good weather!
    • OhioVike
      I have to admit I never heard of it.  I will certainly give it a try.  I am surprised by the number of people that haven't done the cheeks before.  This will really get em.  Thanks.  
    • imhatz
      I heard back from Michael Schwanke a guide working out of Crane Lake that I have known for several years. I told him we are heading up on May 17th. He said it will be close real close. I depends on the night temps need to remain over freezing.....we will keep fingers crossed for a week or two and then decide what to do.
    • Wakemup
      This is great! I’ve never heard of this either Skunked, thanks for sharing- will give it a shot this summer!