Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
kpj5br

5/6 Pepin

15 posts in this topic

Had a great day on the water today. Water temps are between 50 and 54 depending where on the pool you're at.

Ran cranks all day, for a reason. I wanted to do a somewhat scientific study of the "red hook" syndrome bringing in more fish.

So I used identical rod/reel combos with line counters, same amount of line out on each, same lure, but one with "factory" hooks and the other with gama reds. Did this with a number of different cranks.

What did I learn? I have to say, the reds definitely outfished the blacks. Amazing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Was the line size the same on all rigs, how about the hook size, were they the same size? Did you use the same brand line on all of your poles. Mono, florocarbon? Did changing out the hooks effect the action of the bait? Lots and lots of factors.

Let me know, I'm interested in the results, I'm kinda doing the samething this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, when I say identical, I mean identical in every way. One rod was out the left side of the boat, one out the right side, and I alternated them about every hour so they'd have equal time out each side of the boat.

The replaced hooks were the same size as the originals, they did not appear to affect the lure action, but one thing that's interesting is I believe they made a noise, but again can't be totally positive on that.

I really tried to execute this as close to being a true scientific control-group study as possible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What was the ratio? Just wondering

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10:1

Beyond all reasonable doubt with a ratio like that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

KPJ -

Can you elaborate a little on what you caught and the type of area you targeted, i.e. rip wrap, sand?

Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For this experiment it was sand flats, 9 to 14 FOW.

Ran several different cranks, as stated above always running were two identical cranks one with factory (black) hooks and one with red replacements.

All the baits were bright colored (fire, white, etc.) and running within 1 foot of bottom.

Area fished was mostly flats in Maiden Rock area, and just outside the channel at the head of the lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What did you catch? 10 walleyes to 1 walleye? That is is impressive reason to switch...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The ratio includes counts of walleye and sheephead, 10 were walleyes, with 2 on black and 8 on red (they were all small males), and 10 sheepies all on red, for a total ratio of 10:1, with the walley ratio being 4:1. The sheeps were all small as well, 2 pounders.

But I was not going for size at all with this, this was strictly a numbers gathering game.

Total fishing time was about 7 hours, of course with most fish coming in quick bursts, then for awhile nothing.

I forgot to reset my GPS odometer at the beginning, but I'd venture to say I covered between 13 and 17 miles of trolling in total.

I would have loved to do this in areas with bigger fish, but that just wasn't possible, all of the areas known to hold bigger post-spawn fish were just choked with boats making this type of fishing impossible. God knows how many tens of thousands of acres on Pool 4 and every walleye boat stacked up in fisherman's cut...

But it was reassuring that at least the smaller ones have indeed ventured back out into the flats, and the mamas won't be long after them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

18 fish caught on red hooks, and 2 on black hooks would yeild a ration of 9 to 1, not 10 to 1.

Don't mean to be picky.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

either way - it's good catchin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10 walleyes + 10 sheepies = 20 fishes in total. blush.gif

read more carefully if you intend to correct ones statement. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

18 Fish or red

2 on black

equals 18:2 ratio

reduce it to its simpilest form and you get 9:1

To get a 10:1 ration you would need to cathch 20 on red and 2 on black.

That would give you 20:2 or 10:1

Not that any of this really matters 9:1 still proves the red hook argument.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reason I started this is because I am a skeptic, and while I believe the results are eye opening, I also believe the sample size is still too small for a definitive "proof", and I will be repeating this thing at least 3 more times to try to get the sample size up to more statistically sound numbers. (and of course I'll post the data, making every effort to do the math right ooo.gif)

In a way I'm hoping this was a rogue day, as many times as I've said "there's no way red hooks can make a difference" I may have to be eating my own words...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

guess I should take my own advice tongue.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • jkrash
      I heard Casey retired and sold his boat.
    • Rick G
      Gills should be on or real close to beds. Crappies are on beds on some lakes, done spawning on others. Btw, welcome to Fishing Minnesota!
    • bowhuntingboy1
      It was on the opener last year.
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Frazer Bay is as far as I venture West but that bay can be very good at times. I prefer Lindy Rigs with a 5' leader,#2 or a #4 hook, red or green bead by the hook, and a 3/4 oz. sinker. That time of the summer minnows and leeches work best but do not be afraid to try 1/2 crawler on this rig! Like PSU said, look with your electronics for the fish, then fish for them! 12" to 32" depths. Cliff
    • LoonASea
      Fished the big lake this morning ,,, Weather didnt start out nice but the fishing more then made up for it ,,, Got my first double and triple in the new rig today ,,, There is a lot of mud covering this side of the lake but finding clear to tea colored water paid off ,,,Natural colored sticks took a majority of hit today and the cohos have grown 5 inches in the last month ,,, I had one 23 inches today 
    • Fish Head
      Welcome to our Forum Muzzy!  You may want to consider hiring a guide for a day or even 1/2 day to start your trip.  They can give you a lot of good information that will help you put fish in the boat for the rest of your trip. Cliff & Casey are regular contributors here and members of the Lake Vermilion Guides League.  https://lakevermilionguidesleague.com/.    Good Luck!
    • PSU
      Hello Muzzy,   Lots of good spots close to Oak Narrows. I will let the experts pipe in, but I've been doing well in 20-30 feet of water in the Frazer / Smarts Bay area. I would trust your sonar and find spots off reefs and follow down to 20-30 feet. Either jig or Lindy has been working for me with a Rainbow minnow 
    • Mike89
      2nd Lucas thoughts
    • BulldogInTC
      Finally making it up this weekend to the cabin since January.  Looks like hit and miss weather conditions over the weekend, but I'm hoping to get some decent time in the boat...as long as the father-in-law isn't cracking the whip too hard  . That's good to hear about the success in Frazier, Matt.  Always seems like we are fighting for walleyes, but I'm hoping to change that and try a few new spots this weekend.  Hope everyone has a safe and good fishing holiday weekend.
    • Muzzy33
      We are from Indiana (land of terrible eye fishing). Staying in a cabin in the oak narrows June 3-10.  This is our fourth year fishing the big V, but have always fished the westside.  Never had great walleye fishing yet.  We normally stay father on the westside like around wolf Bay or Norwegian, so we wanted to find a cabin closer to the Eastside.  Figured the narrows would be closer so we can fish spots on the west side that we've already learned and also venture to the east where I've heard the walleye fishing is better for keeper walleyes.  I'm looking for any tips or locations to try.  Maybe someone could help us out.  It would be much appreciated.  Thank you