Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
xedge2002

Want some opinions

16 posts in this topic

Hey guys and gals take a look at this buck and let me know what you think. If you had a shot at him this year either archery, firearm or muzzleloader would you take him out? I know that culling bucks has been talked about before, but do you think his rack on the one side will grow normal in the years to come and that he may just become a nontypical?

MDGC0075.jpg

MDGC0052.jpg

MDGC0054.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I probably would not take him. Could be as simple as that side sustaining an injury during the early antler development stages, could be back to normal next season. But it could be a natural deformation as well I suppose. I'd let him go. Neighbors would probably shoot him anyway...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would let him go in hopes that he would be a bigger nontypical next year. Pretty small buck yet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

last year we had a deer aroud just like that one only ours was 4 on one side, we let him walk and have not seen that type of rack on our cameras this year so I would let him walk.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd let him go - if he stays the same but gets bigger cool. I've heard injury related antler growth stays with them for life. If so big deal, isn't genetic related. Then again if you want a unique rack on the wall....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let it him grow!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Give him another year or two. It may have just been something that happened early in antler growth, as has been said previously. That, and even if it turns out to be a permanent thing, he'll be bigger next year. He's obviously still pretty young, so I'd give him at least one more year before taking him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let him go. Does it look like he has a bum left front shoulder? It looks like there is no muscle at all. Maybe he is just really young.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

being that its my first year bow hunting here is my response

bow===take him

firearms/ let him go another year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let him go, I took one last year with 14 pts, nine on one side five on the other, dont know if he was always like that or not. He had a club foot so who knows. He looks a little goofy but hey he looks great on the wall. cool.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That buck looks young, it looks like a 1 1/2 old to me. Let him go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree, probably just a yearling. Looks to me like his antler was broken during early development. He'll be much nicer next year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can GUARANTEE you one thing, if you kill him you will never know what he could become! He'll probably be about a 280" NT in 3 years grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only way I'd shoot that deer is if it's late season & I haven't shot a deer yet. If you haven't shot many deer yet, never gotten a buck with your bow, or you just want to, go ahead & shoot him, but like a lot of guys said I don't think he's a cull buck at this point. Body wise he looks like a pretty small yearling buck to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with TrophyEyes... he looks a little gimpy, like he got clipped by a car which could have messed up his shoulder and antler.

Take him if this is the case... leave him if he walks okay.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well if I see him I think I am going to let him go and see what he looks like next year. I agree that his left front shoulder looks a little funny. There are a few other bucks in that area that are a lot bigger than he is. I had one on my camera last year that looked really nice and I haven't seen him yet this year. I think he is still around because I haven't heard of anybody getting a big buck in the area last year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Sushilicious
      We only fished for 5 hours (only 2 hours were worthwhile 29 ft).  
    • Sushilicious
      OK so day before father's day we had terrible weather. 1st spot was in 14 ft of current n we caught 4 eyes. Did c a sturgeon role but waste of time other than that. Next spot 6 eyes still a wasted time cause of the weather but the old man did caught a 20 in so it wasn't all that bad. But once the weather allowed we catch  26 eyes n in 29 ft of water n one was 24 in.
    • Sushilicious
      Definitely have 2 disagree with with u 2. I understand the drive n the worry but if you've fished the csn chain for 10+ years there shouldn't be a worry 2 find a campsite cause you've driven past plenty of them. Also we're in the same boat regardless of the travel distance to fine a campsite. Yes it is nice 2 have a guaranteed spot but since they went 2 paid 2 camp regulation they have taken out a number of campsites so it limits options. ALSO U R WAY WRONG ON SAYING MORE PPL R AT THE PARK NOW. I went last Saturday  (day before father's day) n we seen like 4 or 5 more boats than canoes. It's nice for ppl who don't know the csn chain but it's terrible for the economy.   Fyi. First time I went fishing on the chain I went lake trout fishing on David......... I was 6 weeks old ......... I'm 32 now..... my dad's been fishing the csn chain for 65+ years    P.s. love how there's less pressure=better fishing.
    • Rachelkate21
      Hey! Does anyone know any brooks/steams/rivers that would be full of trout? Preferably near lakeville, mn but ill travel!
    • redlabguy
      Nice fish, Jeff. And good lesson on 1/2 crawlers, Cliff. I'm off the water for a few days with family doings, but should report I've seen a lot of mayflies in Frazer and near the portage. Clouds on the sonar and slicks of the water. I'm guessing it's not the big hatch, but it's providing a lot of food for fish. good luck out there.
    • osok
      Just got back into town from a slightly too long "vacation" dealing with relatives. Anywho, how has the fishing been on Superior, are the fish local or have they migrated N.E? 
    • AaronTC05
      I just bought a new Elite 7TI and the sun cover it came with doesn't really snap on very securely.  I'd say it just rests loosely on the outside.  It won't fall off if I flip it upside down, but it feels like it wouldn't stay on going down the highway or withstand any sort of jarring.  It takes hardly any pressure to pull it off.  Is this normal or is it a defect?  I've never owned a graph with a sun cover so I'm not familiar, but I imagined it would be a lot more snug.    
    • leech~~
      We will see if Sailorfly is another ask a silly question one hit wonder? 
    • jiggin9
      I have a Lowrance Elite 7 and was curious what lake chip most of you recommend for Lake of the Woods.  The insight pro chip that came with my unit is very basic for up there and was looking for a more detailed chip.  I'm not sure what brands are compatible with the Lowrance and which ones aren't.        Thanks in advance! 
    • Hines R
      Glad it didn't take a swim. My buddy had one of the cheaper Minnkotas deploy while he was up on plane using the main motor.  Needless to say it was a weak pin in the release system. It was a rental boat so he didn't have to deal with it. Bent the heck out of the stem portion. It was fully modified!   Didnt know now you were still going up to LOTW. Thought you were selling the place. Assuming you don't have the Sportcraft anymore since I don't think you'd put a Minnkota on that. If you still have the Sportcraft I know someone that might be interested in it.    I head up to South end out of Wheelers point tomorrow after work. Up for 2 weeks. Touch base with me if you are coming up or have the Sportcraft still for sale.   Ryan