Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

Recommended Posts

Posted

We caught a dogfish this week. What do people here do when they catch rough fish? confused.gif

Posted

Throw it back!!! It's a native species doing no harm. It's been swimming around here since before the bass and walleye were here. Let him go free! Bowfin (dogfish) are an absolute hoot to catch!!!

Posted

That's what we did. I caught him on an ultralight which really had me excited. Thank You for your input!! grin.gif

Posted

I have fun reeling in whatever it is, then hold it high in the air proclaiming it's a walleye for everyone to see, then I slip it back in the water before anyone has a good look. cool.gif

Posted

I dont think that bowfin are considered a rough fish.. Release it.

Posted

Bowfin definitely not rough fish. Even with rough fish I see no reason or obligation to kill them. I either eat a fish or let it swim. I suppose I would not want to release one of those jumping carp but in reality the rough fish a sportmans catches then kills probably does little to control overall population and just creates a stinky mess for a while. Someone should start a post about handling rough fish. Maybe it will reach the epic proportions of the powerloading debate......

Posted

Like most other people on here, i either eat a fish or let it swim. I have no problem with rough fish and i greatly enjoy the fight that they put up (other than those pesky bullheads). I have seen many big bowfin caught and it surprises me that the state record is only 10lb 15oz.

Posted

I agree - if you don't eat it, throw the big doggie back! They are *SO* fun to fight!

Posted

You ever notice that they never get off, despite the fact they fight like crazy??? Just when you think you hit the 8 lb bass......... grin.gif

Posted

Quote:

You ever notice that they never get off, despite the fact they fight like crazy???


I caught one last year that I netted, and as soon as I got it in the boat, it let go fo the hook! Dang thing wasn't even hooked, just wouldn't drop my senko!!!

Posted

I think they are a fun fish to catch(see my avatar). I caught one this spring that went 27" on the Wisconsin, my biggest so far. No spot or anything, just pure grey. Cool fish.

Posted

I sure like dogfish too. Never fails when I'm fishing other species....look down and see one, and whatever you drop in front of their nose, they eat! They put up a darn good fight too. Sometimes in the spring when they're numerous in the shallows, I tend to forget what I was after in the first place. Sightfishing them is a hoot! Have fun catching them..then let em go.

Posted

This past weekend, I caught a dogfish that might have rivaled the state record. But clumsy me, while I'm telling my friend where to get the scale, not paying attention to the fish, it wriggles out of my hands and over the side of the boat. frown.gif

Posted

you all could trying smoking them. they are great, I think better than carp. we have also done a few other things but I'll save them for a later post!

Posted

It seems like I catch a dogfish on Lake Mary(state record lake)near Alex almost everytime we go out, big ones too. Last year my 10 year old had one on that broke his rod in two that was probably close to 8 pounds. They are fun to fight but everytime I get one hooked I think this is finally the time I get my trophy walleye just to be disappointed in the end. They kinda look like a big walleye when you get your first look at it in the water.

Posted

Anderson,

Once I was in twins bay on the big pond and there was hundreds of them. I went back next day none. We thought they were post spawn walleyes at first, but found out right away they were bowfin. They were not ealpought, they were dog fish. Never saw that again.

Posted

Dogfish tastes good.. Try it! LOL

Posted

Hooked one on a rocky flat. The way it pulled I thought it was a big smallie and it when it jumped and I saw that brown color I swore I had the state record smallie on my line, until I got the fish close to the boat and saw it was a dogfish.

Another Dogfish story: My dad had just purchased a chatterbait at the sportsman show, when they were the hottest lure out there and not even in stores yet. So about 10 minutes into the breaking in the chatterbait, he hooks a dogfish, gets it into the boat, release it and starts casting the chatterbait back out again. He just happens to notice the chatterbait looks strange after the catching the dogfish. Turns out the Dogfish broke the hook off from the jig head. Making the hottest bass bait of the year, actually the hottest bowfin bait of him.

Posted

Anyone here ever try frying one up? Most anyone I've talked with just says, Eeeeuw but with teeth like that, they must be more than just a scavenger. Even if they are, so are just about every game fish to some level.

Bob

Posted

BobT...I don't know man? I've heard that they have something on them that is poison? Maybe it's on the skin, maybe in the intrails, maybe it's just an old wives tale?

I seen one skinned once and the meat looked pretty red along the lateral line area and it had a greenish tint to the white meat along the top and bottom....didn't look very appetizing.

There are alot of good fish out there, I think I will wait awhile longer before I try to eat the prehistoric looking dogfish.

Took me quite awhile to work up to trying eelpout and for the last couple years I have been contemplating sheephead, but that is as far as it has went.

Those dogfish put up a nice fight though....always make you think you have the something else record! grin.gif

Posted

I saw the "potential" new state record dogfish, held it, measured it, weighed it, and then it went home with the gentleman that caught it. He was so proud of that fish!

31" Long, 10 1/2lbs from Medicine Lake in the Cities a couple years ago.

I believe my scale to be fairly accurate so it would have been close, probably not quite there for the record but its the biggest dogfish I've ever seen.

Posted

Quote:

I think they are a fun fish to catch(see my avatar). I caught one this spring that went 27" on the Wisconsin, my biggest so far. No spot or anything, just pure grey. Cool fish.


I used to live in Wisc. Rapids and one time I was musky fishing near the 54 bridge right in town from my kayak when I hooked what I thought was a decent musky. I mean, it really struck my bucktail! Turns out it was about a 7 lb. Dogfish!

I then started fishing musky at Petenwell with moderate sucess (people in the boat I was in caught some). Fishings good out there, eh?

Posted

I have caught and bowfished a lot of dogfish on Jefferson and Sabre lakes over the years. Usually they end up in the garden with the carp and sheepies.

Posted

I've only caught a few in my time but two notable ones - one on a Zara Spook on the Horseshoe Chain - missed it several times so I slowed WAY down and it creamed it.

The other was on a bass jig skipped under a dock on Forest Lake - thought I had the state record bass on that one.

Daze Off

Posted

I'm pretty sure I had the state record once... only I didn't know what the record was at the time I caught it. I hooked into one on Linwood in Anoka county several years ago. It put up a nice fight! I saw later that the record length was 32" and 10 lb 15 oz. I'm sure the one I had was at least 32" or better. We thought it was a 15lb Northern before it got close to the boat and saw it was a dogfish. Nobody wanted to net the thing though, so the exact size I'll never know, but it was big. I was reaching for the pliers to take the hook out next to the boat but before I could get to it the hook bent straight. Biggest fish caught on a crappie minnow. tongue.gif

Posted

Quote:

BobT...I don't know man? I've heard that they have something on them that is poison? Maybe it's on the skin, maybe in the intrails, maybe it's just an old wives tale?


I read somewhere that the liver has some sort of poison in it. I have also read tht people eat them. crazy.gif

Posted

I've never caught a dogfish. Why are they called Bob Barkers???

Posted

Quote:

Why are they called Bob Barkers???


Think about it brother boilerguy... barker.. bark.. what barks.. Dogs.. Hence?... Bob Barker.

Posted

Ah, now I get it. Bear with me guys, I'm slow. grin.gif

Posted

Last night I saw a dogfish swim by the dock in Brown's Bay that had to be at least 30". At first I thought it was a carp or muskie, then I saw it from the top.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • leech~~
    • smurfy
      🤣 did your nose just grow a bit!😏🤭
    • Wanderer
      I hope to be fishing….  It’s so rare that I get to go, I hate passing up the opportunity. 😉   
    • leech~~
      Since the Vikings are never in it. We use it for an excuse to make some fun stuff!  Last year was a bit light. Hot cheese bean dip, hot wings and pepperoni cheese bread! 😋
    • Hookmaster
      That snow and the 15-25 mph winds on Thursday with higher gusts will be nasty drifting. I didn't go to LOW (can I say that in the this thread?🤫) this week because of it.
    • smurfy
      Who's watching the big game Sunday? More importantly what's ya'all cooking!   I like good football si I'm tuning in. Food... yea no clue yet 
    • Wanderer
      Hard to see em well enough to tell.
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the South Shore...  Ice fishing is strong across the south shore of Lake of the Woods out on Big Traverse Bay.  Most anglers are targeting deep mud with others fishing structure if available where they are going out of.  There are fish in both areas.     Some ice roads are now extending more than 16 miles out, with over two feet of ice reported in most areas. Resorts and outfitters continue increasing weight limits. As a rule, fishing continues to be very good with consistent action for anglers.  Most fishing activity is taking place in 26-32 feet of water.  Anglers are finding a healthy mix of walleyes and saugers, with plenty of opportunities to enjoy fresh fish frys and bring fish home.   On the jigging line, jigging spoons with rattles tipped with a minnow head have been consistent.  Lipless crankbaits and jigging rap style lures also doing well.   On the deadstick, a plain hook or a small jig with a live minnow 6 inches to a foot off of the bottom.    You never know when the fish will move through.  Anglers fishing the entire day normally have success.  Electronics are a big help as well. On the Rainy River...  The morning and evening hours are the best for fishing walleyes. A jig and minnow combination has been a good presentation.  A jigging spoon tipped with a minnow head is also producing some fish. Catch-and-release sturgeon fishing is still producing some big fish through the ice.  There are two sturgeon seasons on Lake of the Woods and the Rainy River, a catch and release season and a harvest season in which you can keep one fish per calendar year.    The harvest season runs from April 24th – May 7th and July 1 – Sept. 30. The catch and release season runs May 8th – May 15th and Oct. 1 – April 23rd.    Although ice conditions on the river are good, they can vary significantly due to the current, so anglers should always consult local resorts or outfitters for the most up-to-date safety information and fishing advice. Up at the NW Angle...  Ice fishing remains good at the Northwest Angle.  Resorts continue to move their fish houses staying on fish.  Some fish houses are set up on structure while others are targeting deeper mud flats.    Anglers are catching a nice mix of walleyes, saugers, jumbo perch, pike, and tullibees.  Good numbers of big crappies are still being caught in select areas and hard sided fish houses are available to target them.  Check with a NW Angle resort for info.   Jigging one line, deadsticking the second is effective.  Some days the jigging line is hot, other days the deadstick.  Some good colors have been gold, glow red, glow white, wonder bread, pink, chartreuse and orange. Lake of the Woods enjoys an extended ice fishing season with fish houses on the ice through March 31st and walleye and sauger seasons open through April 14th. Perch, crappie, and pike seasons remain open year-round.  
    • JerkinLips
      Same story, different day (Monday).  Caught several small walleyes (biggest were 14 and 15 inches) with the best bite from 2-5pm.  Caught my record walleye this winter at 6½ (inches, not pounds).  Was wondering why the bobber kept going down a couple inches for several minutes until I finally reeled it up.  Fortunately it was just hooked in the lips.  Having a lively minnow definitely improved the action.  I put down a pike sucker for the first time this winter and got an immediate hard bite.  When I went to set the hook, the line broke just above the hook.  Don't know if it was a northern bite-off or just weak line by the hook.  May try some pike suckers next trip.   Ice conditions were very good except for heavy drifting (even with very little fresh snow).  Didn't see any vehicles traveling off road except for snowmobiles and a tracked SxS, although there weren't many people out on the lake.  Water came up around my house about 1½ inches but froze very quickly with the cold weather and no snow on top.  Will probably have to block it up again next time up.   Good luck fishing and be careful of severe drifting of snow, especially with the 3-5 inches they are predicting for Wednesday night.  
    • leech~~
      Why, do they all only wear Sitka camo over there? 😏
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.