Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • 0

Choosing a motor


Question

Posted

I'm thinking of buying a new boat (Lund 1875 Pro V bass), my choices of Mercury motors, 115 4S, 150 4s, 175 optimax, 200 optimax, 200 verado (L4). I've eliminated the 115, I don't believe I really need the 200 hp (due to cost possibly). So I'm wondering what are some opinions on the 150 4S or the 175 Optimax, which would be a better choice. I haven't ruled out the 200 totally, depends on the final price with the options. One opinion told me to go with the 150 4 stroke, great motor, Mercury has vastly improved the motor from when it first came out.

14 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted

Don't even look at anything but a 4 stroke.  Loud and smelly. I see them on the water and think to my self "What???" So now you are down to 150 4S and Verado.  I have a 200 Verado (L4) on a Pro V 1875 and love it.  Had a 150 on an 1800 Pro V  which I liked very much but but there is a step up in the performance having a supercharger.   Nor sure what people are looking for with the 6 cyl 200 Verado.  My Verado is super quiet at idling.  Super throttle response when you push it down.  I am sure you would be happy with the 150 as well but there is a difference.  HAVE FUN!!!

  • 0
Posted

I have a 150 4S on a  Lund 1800 Tyee.  Plenty of power and speed for me.  Have hit 50 with the boat with a light load but 45 is no problem whatever the load.  It will handle a 175 but boat dealer said it would only gain 2mph and overall performance about equal.  No brainer for the price difference.

  • 0
Posted

Just was out with a neighbor with a 150 4 stroke merc.  Pretty nice motor.  And the smartwhatever gauge was petty cool.  Nice and quiet and efficient. 

 

The 150 Suzuki is a pretty nice motor also. 

  • 0
Posted

Thanks for the suggestions. I believe I'll be going with the 150 hp. My next question is trolling motor, 24/36 volt? I have a 24 volt now with a MK maxxum. I would like to get the MK Ultrex, but that has a 80lb thrust and the 36 volt comes at 112 lb. Is there a noticeable difference between the two? I noticed they come in ipilot and ipilot link. What's the difference? Not sure if I would utilize ipilot since I don't walleye fish. I use the trolling motor a lot while fishing.

  • 0
Posted

I'd go with 112 if you have the room more power and I believe last longer on the water. I pilot is worth it. Spot lock to fan cast an area or to stay outside the dock that you just got broke off of are two benifits. I pilot link links up with your hummingbird unit if that's what you have for a depth finder. Let's you follow depth contours. Good luck with the purchases 

  • 0
Posted

I have my boat on order, won't be ready until end of September or early October, so it's going straight to storage until spring. I was wondering how often any of you use I-pilot link for bass fishing? Still contemplating between Ultrex I-pilot or the I-pilot link.  

  • 0
Posted

Remember ipilot link only works with Humminbird electronics.  You probably already knew that, but thought I would mention it.  

If Humminbird was my electronics, and I was spending all that money on boat etc, I think I would go with link.  Can do a variety of cool stuff. 

  • 0
Posted
1 hour ago, delcecchi said:

Remember ipilot link only works with Humminbird electronics.  You probably already knew that, but thought I would mention it.  

If Humminbird was my electronics, and I was spending all that money on boat etc, I think I would go with link.  Can do a variety of cool stuff. 

Yup, I'm getting the Helix 10 bow sonar gps and console si/di.

  • 0
Posted

Then I think I might well go with the link.   What's another 300 bucks? 

A buddy of mine on Vermilion rigged up his ultrex with an external transducer and a spring reel to manage the cable so he could have di and si on his trolling motor (at least DI for sure) which the built in transducer won't do.  Really works slick.   It used a deal like guys have to hang keys from their belt.  

 

  • 0
Posted

Do you use a transom saver for the motor?  The 150 hp 4-stroke is biggest motor I've had, coming from a 40 hp.  I know it's a personal decision and I've seen plenty boats going down the road without one. I don't know what to think with this size motor.  I'm leaning toward getting one so there isn't so much pressure on the transom.  If you don't use one what position do you put the motor while traveling?  

  • 0
Posted

A lot of people have switched from a transom saver to a hydraulic wedge.  It smaller, easier to use, and takes up a lot less space.  The mechanic talked me into one 3 years ago when I bought my bought and I had used a transom saver for 15 years on my previous boat.

  • Thumbs Up 1
  • 0
Posted

i got a 40 hp merc on a 17'6'' lowe roughneck. motor stops at the length of the transom saver never had a problem. i asked my mechanic about it . he said dont change a thing. its solid. my two cents.

tear it  up...fish face wise

  • 0
Posted
On ‎3‎/‎25‎/‎2018 at 6:06 PM, gimruis said:

A lot of people have switched from a transom saver to a hydraulic wedge.  It smaller, easier to use, and takes up a lot less space.  The mechanic talked me into one 3 years ago when I bought my bought and I had used a transom saver for 15 years on my previous boat.

I'll have to check this out. Never heard of hydraulic wedge.

  • Thumbs Up 1
  • 0
Posted

Its just a hardened piece of rubber/plastic that slides onto the hydraulic bar when you raise the outboard to a certain height.  Google "My Wedge" or "Hydraulic Outboard Wedge" and you'll find it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • leech~~
      I wonder like divers, if we let them decompress every 10' for 1/2hr. If that would help?  🤔  It would slow the bite down a bit!  🤭
    • carlsonmn
      That was a better study compared to last winter when they setup the vertical tube nets and tried to release exhausted fish from being studied and expected them to be able to swim straight down a 3' hoop net.     That lake's crappie population from this latest video was pretty deep at 40-50', and no doubt from those depths that is barotrauma for most.  That is deeper than most crappie holes but certainly how some are. However from helping give fish a good release from the 35' and less range and tracking them with live sonar most of them swim at a shallow angle back to the depths and I watch them rejoin the school and be active.  Uncut Angling's video helped counter some of the initial narrow findings.  
    • SkunkedAgain
      If you fished with me more often, you'd never have to make this statement...   38" of ice - love it. I'm really going to have to dig around for my auger extension. I don't think that I've needed it in over a decade.   Too bad nobody has a locomotive chugging across the ice to do some logging, like the good old days.
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the South Shore...  Ice fishing remains strong across the south shore of Lake of the Woods out on Big Traverse Bay.  Resorts and outfitters on some parts of the lake have ice roads extending over 16 miles staying on nice schools of walleyes and saugers.  Many fish houses are over deep mud.  Some are on structure.  It is always fishing of course, but overall, February has been very productive for most anglers.   Extensions are being used on ice augers as the ice continues to thicken.  The thick ice this year will be good for the extended ice fishing season Lake of the Woods enjoys with fish houses out through March 31st, walleyes and saugers open through April 14th and a pike season that never closes. Most fishing activity is taking place in 26-32 feet of water.  Anglers are finding a healthy mix of walleyes and saugers, with a good number of jumbo perch in the mix this year.  Some big eelpout are also showing up.  Anglers are reporting plenty of fish for fresh fish frys and usually extra fish to bring home.   The one-two punch of a jigging line and deadstick is the way to go.  On the jigging line, jigging spoons with rattles tipped with a minnow head have been consistent.  Lipless crankbaits and jigging rap style lures also doing well.     Lures with a light have been working well in the stained water.  Please remember, in MN, lures with a light or water activated light can be used as long as the battery is mercury free and the hook is attached directly to the lure and not as a dropper line.     On the deadstick, a plain hook or a small jig with a live minnow 6 inches to a foot off of the bottom.    Some days, mornings are better, other days, it's the afternoons.  There is no distinct pattern, they could come through at any time. On the Rainy River...  The start of the day and end of the day have been best for those targeting walleyes on the river. A jig and minnow or a jigging spoon tipped with a minnow head is also producing some fish. Some big sturgeon being iced by ice anglers targeting them.  It is a catch-and-release sturgeon season currently.   Although ice conditions on the river are good, they can vary significantly due to the current, so anglers should always consult local resorts or outfitters for the most up-to-date safety information and fishing advice. Up at the NW Angle...  Ice fishing has been strong in the islands area of Lake of the Woods. Resorts continue to move their fish houses around, staying on the best schools of walleyes.     Anglers are catching a nice mix of walleyes, saugers, and jumbo perch with an occasional pike or tullibee as well.     Big crappies are still being caught just over the border.  Fish houses are available, check with a NW Angle resort for info on crappie fishing.   Lake of the Woods enjoys an extended ice fishing season with fish houses on the ice through March 31st and walleye and sauger seasons open through April 14th. Perch, crappie, and pike seasons remain open year-round.    
    • leech~~
      Maybe you should put rattle wheels down, if your going to sleep for 6hrs! 🤭 😆
    • JerkinLips
      Monday was my worst day of winter fishing on Vermilion in the last 4 years.  Caught only one 14" walleye in nearly 8 hours of fishing.  Missed two other bites and was marking very few fish.  Maybe the fish were taking Monday off after a big weekend.   No more water came up on the ice under my house.  Think it was because I haven't banked snow around it for a couple of weeks so the bare ice around the house is getting very thick.  I measured 38" of ice under my house and the Ion barely made it through even with the extension installed.  Needless to say I banked around the house this time.  Another lesson I learned today is don't drill holes if ice is frozen on your blades.  I did that on one hole and it didn't center properly and drilled at an angle on the edge of the opening.  Hope I can correct the location and angle on my next trip up.   Not much change in the surface lake surface conditions.  The drifts may be a little higher and are definitely harder.  There are still a few bare ice spots on the lake.  Very little activity on the lake today.  There are about 3 dozen houses from McKinley Park out to Birch Island.  Another person pulled there house off today, and I am sure many more will pull theirs off this coming weekend.  Only 13 days left of walleye season.    
    • leech~~
      A good start for never picking up a bow!   IMG_1910.mp4
    • leech~~
      Um, #metoo   leech~~ Author 'we have more fun' FishingMN Builders Posted January 26 My whole goal for the rest of this season.  Is to watch KC lose and Taylor cry!  🥳
    • smurfy
    • Wanderer
      Smurfy is happy.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.