Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Connect, BE BRAVE - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

       
       "Post Your Thoughts" - Leave YOUR mark, make each place you visit "a little better"! Post please......

      Join the Minnesota Fishing Report Club, where only club members see what is shared. Just 99 cents to join. Click here please.

      Because you want others to share great outdoor information with you!!!! Share what you 'love about your area'.

      EMOJI those posts you 'appreciate, please.'

      Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Red Miller

New Regs?

Recommended Posts

thatoneguy

Quote:
Are you suggesting that hooking mortality of larger fish is causing a depletion of smaller fish?

That's not what he's saying (I think) but it's probably part of the equation. Hooking mortality of larger fish = fewer spawners = fewer fry = adding to the recruitment problems. At least in theory.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kyhl

Are you suggesting that hooking mortality of larger fish is causing a depletion of smaller fish?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CaptainMusky

The mortality of the larger fish has an indirect relationship to the mortality of the 14 to 18 inch fish. How so? Since you can only keep the smaller fish obviously that is what most people are targeting. They filter through the 22 to 26 inchers hoping for a "legal" fish. A legal fish dies because its kept. A portion of the 22 to 26 fish die due to mortality.

If the "slots" targeted larger fish the mortality of the small fish (majority of them being kept) would dramatically decline. My feeling is the mortality of the larger fish would decline as well because people wouldnt be sorting through 22 to 26 inchers to find the legal fish and quit fishing with their 1 or 2 fish (whatever the limit would be).

Concerns about hitting the harvest quota so fast are valid though, but IMO the mortality number should be dramatically reduced in a scenario like this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bandersnatch

Is he really going to argue that dead 22-26" walleyes are causing there to be no 14-18 size fish? crazy Sheesh.

Do people even read what they are typing?

To save you re-reading my original post, and maybe not understanding what I posted all over again.

Over and above the hooking mortality, and the wasted fish that the slot causes in than manner, The Slot targets the same size fish as the Nets do.

What does that mean? ( I don't want you to be further confused so I'll answer that for you)

A) That means that most of the pressure has historically been on the 14-18 inch Walleye in the lake since The Slot was adopted.

and

B) That about a third of the Allowable Safe Harvest has been wasted year after year by throwing dead and dying fish back into the lake to rot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Red Miller

Bandersnatch, Thank you for spelling it out for the some who cant or refuse to understand. Its not rocket science.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
eyechoholic

Just two years ago it was anything up to 20" which the mistake in that is no minimum. They should have atleast had a 14" minimum because plenty of people just want to get a limit and would keep 12" to 14" to do so. The entire state is 6 fish with one over twenty their should be a minimum there to. But I think now mille lacs should adopt a 14" to 20" slot you can keep one and you can keep one over twenty with a two fish limit total. And put a ban on lead core trolling its not fishing anyways its driving around snagging to me kind of boring.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kyhl

Over and above the hooking mortality, and the wasted fish that the slot causes in than manner, The Slot targets the same size fish as the Nets do.

What does that mean? ( I don't want you to be further confused so I'll answer that for you)

A) That means that most of the pressure has historically been on the 14-18 inch Walleye in the lake since The Slot was adopted.

and

B) That about a third of the Allowable Safe Harvest has been wasted year after year by throwing dead and dying fish back into the lake to rot.

A.) I guess you guys are better at this than me. I catch 24's in the same place as 14-18, if I see a 14-18 at all. I'm glad that others are able to target just the 14-18" fish while successfully avoiding the larger ones. I'd like to know your secret.

B.) That is sad. I agree. I feel sad every time I see a floater. It is a waste.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CaptainMusky

A.) I guess you guys are better at this than me. I catch 24's in the same place as 14-18, if I see a 14-18 at all. I'm glad that others are able to target just the 14-18" fish while successfully avoiding the larger ones. I'd like to know your secret.

B.) That is sad. I agree. I feel sad every time I see a floater. It is a waste.

Kyhl wouldnt you agree that pretty much every "legal" walleye that is caught out there is kept? I do, since they are few and far between. I dont believe he insinuated that the larger ones were avoided, but those fish are released and many do survive. I would guess that vast majority of legal fish are not released however.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bandersnatch

A.) I guess you guys are better at this than me. I catch 24's in the same place as 14-18, if I see a 14-18 at all. I'm glad that others are able to target just the 14-18" fish while successfully avoiding the larger ones. I'd like to know your secret.

B.) That is sad. I agree. I feel sad every time I see a floater. It is a waste.

How much float fishing do you do Kyhl?

The Ol Man and I had been on flat edges , where it was all day 8" 10" 12" dinks with the occasional 24" 26".

In the past float fishing day time caught a lot of small fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kyhl

Kyhl wouldnt you agree that pretty much every "legal" walleye that is caught out there is kept? I do, since they are few and far between. I dont believe he insinuated that the larger ones were avoided, but those fish are released and many do survive. I would guess that vast majority of legal fish are not released however.

Yes. I agree that there is probably a 99% mortality rate of the legal fish, and this leads to a narrow target size to be whiped out.

In my thinking, part of there being few fish in the 19-20" window was also caused by the slow action to narrow the slot or the limit. Last year and the year before there weren't any 17-18" fish that would grow into the "keeper" size. And there also were very few 15-16 to grow into the 17-18 size. And there weren't many 13-14.... You get the idea. Where do you suppose they went?

I'd also like to point out that it takes someone to make the choice to keep the fish to make it a 99% mortalitly rate in that keeper size.

Which is worse? The 99% mortality rate over 2" or 80% mortality rate over a 4" range. And who knows what the exact numbers are. It would be nice if the DNR published them. It might be 90% over a 4" range. I doubt it is less than 50%.

Which I'd like to point out is still 2.5 times worse than the highest point of C&R.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kyhl

How much float fishing do you do Kyhl?

The Ol Man and I had been on flat edges , where it was all day 8" 10" 12" dinks with the occasional 24" 26".

In the past float fishing day time caught a lot of small fish.

I'd call that great news. I saw very few.

And I don't do much bobber fishing. Maybe a little in the spring but I put the bobbers away after memorial day.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CaptainMusky

In my thinking, part of there being few fish in the 19-20" window was also caused by the slow action to narrow the slot or the limit. Last year and the year before there weren't any 17-18" fish that would grow into the "keeper" size. And there also were very few 15-16 to grow into the 17-18 size. And there weren't many 13-14.... You get the idea. Where do you suppose they went?

I agree I feel that was a major contributor as well. I think most of us can agree it wasnt any one thing in particular that caused the problem so it will likely take multiple changes to reverse the trend we see right now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gregg52

theres is no slots on nets

does the hooking kill fish

yes it does circle or no circle hooks

people bounce the fish around in the boat for 5 mins trying to un-hook it then throw it back and yes it gets worse as the water warms and the fish come out of that deeper water

the fishing was the best when it was one over 20 before the nets

i'm not blaming the dnr they were more or less forced into action which i'm sure the didnt like either cuz no matter what they did some were going to say its wrong

although targeting those same fish year after year i think might have been a mistake

i kinda see the same thing going on up on winnie over 10yrs at the same slot

and now its getting hard to get the smaller eatin fish

I hope they change it

I've said many time here ...dont fool with mother nature

man ruined a marvel of nature ....no 2 ways about it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
maxpower17

Quote:
i'm not blaming the dnr they were more or less forced into action which i'm sure the didnt like either cuz no matter what they did some were going to say its wrong

I'm not sure exactly what action you are referring to. The slots that were implemented were advised against by people that know the lake.

Regardless of what people think, they just need to move on and admit what they did was wrong. That's the only way you can make it work again.

Slots ruined the lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gregg52

I'm not sure exactly what action you are referring to. The slots that were implemented were advised against by people that know the lake.

Regardless of what people think, they just need to move on and admit what they did was wrong. That's the only way you can make it work again.

Slots ruined the lake.

as i said everybody knows more than the DNR....lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kgpcr4

Then how did we do so well for so many years with slot limits? In 92 we had slot limits and the lake was on fire. It has had MANY great years since then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gordie

Then how did we do so well for so many years with slot limits? In 92 we had slot limits and the lake was on fire. It has had MANY great years since then.

The lake has finally been bled out of the same size walleyes that everyone is chasing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fish_hunt_guy

The lake has finally been bled out of the same size walleyes that everyone is chasing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
river rat316

The lake has finally been bled out of the same size walleyes that everyone is chasing.

+1000

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
desert_bulls

Just curious, when did the netting begin?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • cookie129
      Well we made it home from my moms funeral in Iowa late last nite. Fishing report to follow.  Jonny boy and Richie will be busy today as they get out on the lake to make some  decisions on what we can do for the up and coming weekend.   After slamming on blue thunder last week installing a used rear end in blue thunder she lasted all of one day . While plowing out our driveway after a long day before banking un banking plowing moving houses etc she broke a front outer axel shaft. All this snow and slush has put my poor trucks through a work out. Getting stuck then trying to get them out is so much harder on them. I have always babied my fleet as much as possible. This year that is all most if not impossible. We were able to find parts on the way home so hopefully with a little luck we can get her up and running asap.  Some of the outfitters have pulled the plug for this year. Rumors fly on the internet making our winter even tougher? Most of the outfits that live here year long are still open. The wheel houses  have drawn the short straw this year.  Every season is different when it comes to mother nature. It is just the way it is. I have been preaching for 20 years she is the boss . One year the ice froze like a skating rink . I could of ice skated all the way to the north shore, another year the lake cracked all over the place? Another year we had over  3 feet of ice maybe closer to 4. Another year we hauled snow from shore to bank the houses. Another year it was 40 below for 5 days with highs 30 below.  Trying to share how all the house's did last weekend again is kind of  a nightmare. We headed out of town sunday while everyone was staying tell Monday. Sarah and her crew did manage to get 4 over 17 with a total of 15 fish taken home. From what I gathered the fish started to bite sunday? No one got skunked as far as I know. Again the rest of the houses caught some fish but I have no  numbers. Not being able to visit and get to know my customers  has been tough on me. I want to get in a truck right now  so I can go checkout the lake my self. After the little slip a couple weeks ago I keep telling my self I can not help period. I'm still hoping I can atleast do a little fishing in old Minnesota before the season ends. As long as I do not catch one over 10 lbs since that my weight restrictions  of what I can lift. If I do get any fish I will just have to hoist them out of the hole since bending over is tough with this brace on plus the brace is to stop me from bending.  Again sorry about the poor fishing report, its been a long week traveling  to southern Iowa and back.  At this time we are going day by day or week to week as we see what mother nature throws at us.   Again a few tid bits as we all try and make this world a better place.  Laugh more you only live once, laughter is the best medicine.  Be honest its a lot easier to remember the truth then to make things up. Give complements, open doors, lend a helping hand.  Call your parents,  Don't hold grudges. forgive and forget.  Love thy neighbor,  Pay it forward, 
    • Paul Waldowski
      For what species?
    • Wanderer
      It’s so pretty it looks mounted already 
    • Rick G
      Suspended 10ft  off bottom, over basin area. 4mm black tungsren with white finnesse style body
    • BobT
      This morning I found a solution. I had an old pair of cross country skis that I haven't used in 25 years. I got some 1" PVC pipe and made a frame and fastened it to the skis similar to the Smitty Sled design. Took about 1-1/2 hours to make it. Tried it out this afternoon and it worked great. 
    • Huntin&Fishin
      Paul, have you heard of any depths that have been working lately?
    • Wanderer
      I sure hope you have a fantastic trip!  Never done Trout myself in all the times I’ve been in the area.   I don’t want to sound like a Debbie Downer but have you heard anything about snow and slush conditions on Trout?  Hopefully it’s not as bad as the Big V reports but they are neighbors.
    • EW6
      The Whistle Binkies Warm Up to the Polar Plunge Ice Fishingcontest is this coming Feb 1st from 12:00 Noon – 4:00 P.M. at Whistle Binkies South in Rochester MN. This is just one of many great events happening all day at Whistle Binkies to benefit Special Olympics.   Entry fee is $10, with an optional $1 big fish pot. Half of the entry fee will be donated to Special Olympics with the rest paid out to the winners. Big fish pot is winner takes all. Contestants can weigh a total of 4 fish composed of any combination of crappie, sunfish or perch. Big fish pot is open to any legal species. Registration begins anytime after 10:00 A.M. in the main building or 11:00 on the ice at the far end of the lake – ask for Eric Korman.   Hoping to see you there! Whistle Binkies Event Website  
    • Rick
      Ummm...hmmmmm... Minnesota offensive lineman Daniel Faalele is still learning football, but at 6'9" and 400 pounds...he's not undersized. If he is, I like that kind on the Gophers line.   Maybe PJ just likes over-achievers with a big motor because they can relate? Ya think!!! 🙂😁😎💜💛💜
    • SkunkedAgain
      PJ Fleck was an undersized, over-achiever with a big motor. I think that he looks for the guys with the same qualities because they can relate.
×
×
  • Create New...