Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

ID this Fish out of the Sunrise River


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 89
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Fisherman For a Lifetime

    25

  • john.wells

    6

  • Deitz Dittrich

    5

  • bobbymalone

    5

Are you kidding me? 3385 people have viewed this link!! Post a pic, drawn a pic or download an image of an alien from outer space but let's get some closer here people.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

You can pretty much rule out American Eel, as they bear their young in the Atlantic Ocean. Only adults make it this far north. This is truly a mystery, I might have to go down there and see if they are still around! Wish I read this post earlier....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Found this image on a search for MN minnows, and it came right from this own site! It appears to be a sturgeon fry, and it certainly fits the description and would be logical to be found below the Kost Dam. Hope the link pops through...

minnow1.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think we have a winner here. That certainly fits the description. As they get a bit bigger, they would square off like FF said. Shall we call you Detective Wells?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like the sound of Detective Wells! After a little more research and by going on the hunches of others on the thread (carp and other game fish I think it is called) I can tell you all it is most likely Shortnosed Gar.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Man, I hate all these rough fish and so forth that are being spoken of but I gotta say, this is exciting. I just read 5 pages! Let's get this figured out!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guys,

That is absolutely, positively not it!!! Read the original description and that may help.

Oh man, I wish I had a camera there............

I cannot believe it isn't ID'd!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How close does the picture come? It has the silver bottom, dark side band, and lack of dorsal fin. The eye looks kind of beady, but I agree that the mouth description seems to be off. What do you mean by a "straight mouth"? Do any of the characteristics in the picture match, even slightly? I thought I knew my species pretty well, but this is a neat little mystery.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not close whatsoever, that would have been an immediate ID out of the water.

The mouth was straight across, not turned under or up.

There was a small nub on each side of the mouth.

The eyes looked like a Catfish, they were not Catfish though.

Very dark top in the shape of a Northern with the long sleek top without the center dorsal fin just like a northern. NO spots, just a dark top, a "graduated" darker stripe on each side, then the sliver lower sides and underneath.

That's it - super easy description - it's just that nothing describes them and they were SO DARN EASY to catch, LOL!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I sure wish I had read the post earlier when you were getting them, as Kost Dam is minutes away from me and I sure would have liked to have seen one up close and personal! I go there quite a bit in the spring, but then move elsewhere once the bullheads start to dominate. I know it is a very cyclical spot with various species coming through at certain times, so I will have to put it on the to-do list next fall to go and see if they are schooled in there again. Until then, I will continue the quest to ID them! The fresh descriptions will sure help smile

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eyes are way smaller, has a dark streak on the sides. I don't think it had a dorsal fin. It was also "snakey".

Anyone?

Do you know for sure it didn't have a dorsal fin, or just don't recall it having one?

You can't always trust a picture of a fish when identifying one in hand. Sometimes different areas will have different variations in markings do to specific genetic traits of that specific population of fish, especially among juveniles of a species. Just because it doesn't look like one picture doesn't mean that that's not what it is.

Anyhoo, we still have a mystery fish to determine here people! Lets put our heads together on this one!

Of the above guesses, which would you say it most closely resembles? American eel, eelpout, or something else that hasn't been mentioned?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No center dorsal fin. There was a fin on top, but it was way back and was not extended.

The width was just a normal slight taper and was no where near what an eelpout is. Absolutely no spots or colors.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nope, not a Creek Chub.

Eyes are way smaller, has a dark streak on the sides. I don't think it had a dorsal fin. It was also "snakey".

Anyone?

"I don't think it had a dorsal fin." Is a maybe. The picture of the previous creek chub pic that was posted does not have a pronounced stripe.

When a creek chub gets bigger its eyes dont get much bigger, a 10 in creek chub has eyes that look very small. I found one pick that shows the stripe and large size and small eyes. The dorsal dose not stand up when you catch them. 2009-chub1.jpg

Recalling a image memory 100% correctly can be difficult. This post you said I dont think it had a dorsal, then a few posts later you said it did not. Your testimony will not stand up in this court Lol.

There are many color patterns and species of small fish and so many look very different. One picture of some species is not a fair representation of all individuals of that species.

This post has much interest for me, a child I fished a creek in the Burbs of Chicago and some old folks that lived on the creek said that there were trout in the creek. I believed them and kept fishing for them and never caught a trout, so I brought a creek chub to them and said "hey is this a trout?" and "yes" was the reply. That was when I learned not all adults were smarter than me. I was 8 or 9 Y/O.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: Fisherman For a Lifetime
Nope, not a Creek Chub.

Eyes are way smaller, has a dark streak on the sides. I don't think it had a dorsal fin. It was also "snakey".

Anyone?

" The picture of the previous creek chub pic that was posted does not have a pronounced stripe.

When a creek chub gets bigger its eyes dont get much bigger, a 10 in creek chub has eyes that look very small. I found one pick that shows the stripe and large size and small eyes. The dorsal dose not stand up when you catch them. 2009-chub1.jpg

HEY - WE HAVE A WINNER!!!

Mystery solved, that does not match a previously seen picture of a creek chub on the internet, but that is it!

Finally! grin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

creek chub smile I have to admit, I used to put on the smallest little fly on an ultra lite rod and have a blast catching them! They are agressive little buggers!

Fisherman for a lifetime... you must have been losing a lot of sleep over this topic since you solved it at 3 am! smile Get some sleep buddy and enjoy the upcoming hard water season! Good work detectives!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats what it sounded like to me at first. As long as the mystery is solved thats good. Should have kept a bunch for cutbait for cats.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Creek chubs are amazing bait!

used alive i would catch big bass, and crappie (very big crappie).

And a pike can not resist one.

Used as (cut bait) they are the best catfish bait I have ever used.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Wanderer
      Might not have to wear ear plugs when I mow!      That’s a spendy one.  It wasn’t hard to find one of those for $6k.  Comparatively and Ariens of the same size is $4,200.  A home owner grade JD for $3,900.  You could get into a commercial grade Z700 for maybe $8k.   I think the work I did today with mine would’ve killed that one there.    
    • monstermoose78
      Muskies? Lol
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the south end...   This year's MN Fishing Opener weekend was not only great weather wise, the walleyes and saugers were caught in good numbers.  A main fish gut hauler working with a number of resorts commented it was one of the most productive opening weekends he has seen based on the amount of fish guts collected after the weekend. The goto presentation was a jig and frozen emerald shiner.  Emerald shiners are a staple in LOW and walleyes love them.  Other minnows worked also, but emerald shiners are a favorite of anglers for good reason.   Four Mile Bay held good walleyes in 12 - 18'.  Not a surprise as the walleye bite on the river during the spring season was good and as of late, sturgeon anglers have been reporting catching walleyes on sturgeon rigs.   The Lighthouse Gap area, Morris Point Gap and just in front of Pine Island held nice fish in 12 - 15'.  Across the south shore, 18 - 22' was holding good numbers as well.  As you can see, there are lots of fish around.     A quarter ounce jig in gold, glow white, pink, orange, chartreuse, or a combo of these colors tipped with a minnow worked well.   As a reminder, the limit of walleyes and saugers is a combined limit of six fish, up to four of the six can be walleyes.  All walleyes between 19.5 - 28.0 inches must be released.  One fish over 28.0 inches can be kept.  The possession limit in MN is one daily limit of fish. On the Rainy River...  Some nice walleyes were caught on the river this weekend, although most anglers hit the lake.  10 - 15' of water was the norm.     Sturgeon fishing on the Rainy River has been excellent.  The catch and release season continues through May 15th and then closes until the keep season starts up again July 1st. Up at the NW Angle...  Some nice walleyes were caught in 18 - 25 feet of water, a little deeper than anticipated.  Points were good as were areas with structure.  The morning and evening bite was best.       As water continues to warm, go to spots for walleyes will be neck down areas, shoreline breaks, points and bays.     The goto presentation was a jig and minnow.   
    • SkunkedAgain
      I found this dock wheel floating in Black Bay. If it's yours or you know whom it belongs to, go and grab it.    
    • SkunkedAgain
      Most years for opener I drive up on Thursday. This year it was Friday afternoon so I figured bait would be tight. The only place that I stopped was L&M in Virginia. They said that they sold out of rainbows by 11am. I got crappie minnows and never needed the rainbows. All my walleye were caught dragging raps. The crappie minnows....well, you know what they caught.
    • leech~~
      That's a good first step. But are you ready to buy this for the ranch and save the plant more? 🤭   EGO POWER+ 56V Battery 52" Zero Turn Lawn Mower. PRICE $8,899.00 534842_main.webp
    • gimruis
      I got a nice Tom in season B and posted photos in the local thread (Moose's report).
    • Wanderer
      Did you have any luck?     I got a bird but didn’t really do much for pics worth showing.
    • Wanderer
      It depends on a lot of factors, I suppose.   I hung on to my last gas auger for a few years after getting into electric but I never used it so I finally sold it.  Haven’t missed it one bit.  You bet it was reliable though.  Still started on the second pull for the new owner.   After trying several options in the electric world, I’m currently settled on a Strikemaster 40V with Liteflight bits.  With 2 fully charged batteries, I fish all day in Canada, cutting 10 inch holes.     What I’ll agree with is, if you search by drilling and flasher sonar, you will probably be more comfortable with the run time of a gas auger.  When you start incorporating GPS mapping, forward facing sonar, and saved waypoints, you don’t need to Swiss cheese every spot you fish.  I can still run through both batteries when the fishing isn’t great but I never feel like I have to count my holes.  It’s more like: Did I need the second battery before the middle part of our fishing hours?  If I still can’t catch fish after running out 2 batteries, it doesn’t matter cuz the fish just ain’t biting.   That’s fishing on the dark side! 😉 
    • Wanderer
      Thanks.  Yep, iPhone. Photo mode, not portrait. No flash.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.