Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
uptracker

County Rankings for Deer Hunting

11 posts in this topic

How good are Carlton, St. Louis, Lake, and Cook counties for trophy animals?

How's the hunter density? Is the area considered "pressured"? Is it tough getting permission to hunt private land?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It not easy to get on private land unless its yours or someone in your families, but there is enough public land but you will see people. For Trophies go to a ranch in Texas or something if thats all you want, so far i have shot 2 bucks up there the first was my first deer a small 8 point and my second is going on the wall. Pressured it is because the deer tend to be in bunchs and where the deer are so are the hunters. If you want to get away from people go into the BWCA paddle in 2 days or so and you might not see any one else hunting and i have seen some big bucks in there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the info!

But why is St. Louis Co. ranked #2 in the U.S. for B&C bucks then? Just confused and trying to get info, that's all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did you ssee the pictures from the duluth hunt?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't tell you the main reason why it is ranked #2 but St. Louis county is a huge county filled with nasty swamps and a lot of backcountry. You can't just park on the road and walk in the woods 100 yds and expect to shoot a B&C buck. Do some scouting and research. Walk in there 2-3 hours. It is hard work but it will pay off in the end. My first year hunting was the Halloween blizzard of '91. We were hunting Mille Lacs refuge and my dad had his stand dang near right in the middle of the refuge. We got to the parking lot at 4:15 a.m. and started walking. The snow was so deep I wanted to stop and hunt and he would always say "almost there". We got to his stand at 7:30 a.m. He shot a 14 pt. at 11:15 a.m. He came and got me and we started dragging and did not get out of the woods until 7:30 p.m. The drag sucked but it was worth it in the end. We call the buck the "Halloween Blizzard Buck". Go the extra mile and it will pay off.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Did you ssee the pictures from the duluth hunt?


No, I didn't. You wanna give me some info?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

CIty of Duluth has a bowhunt within city limits to control the deer population. Many large bucks taken. They are protected by shooting ordinances the rest of the year. Only threat they have is the car traffic which is why they ahve the hunts.

Don't plan to shoot a trophy on public land. Its usually "brown its down" mentality. Not that they are not there, but its harder and harder every year.

Also, don't get caught up in which counties have the most B&C or P&Y deer registered cause its exactly that. If you don't register it doesn't go on the books. My buddy shot his first "big buck" last year around 150" with the bow so its Pope and Young. It won't be in the book cause there is not much point to registering it in the record book except to read your own name.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hear ya on that. Thanks. So basically, it's starting to get to the point the U.P. of Michigan is at. Most hunters have the same mentality here nowadays and with 300,000 bowhunters and 500,000-700,000 gun hunters, it's hard to keep people happy.

How about up closer to the ON border?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well its BWCA along the border or a national park. Any areas that are easy to get to get hunted hard. When I went to college in Ely every spot i wanted to deer hunt was full. I did hunt just not the areas i had been seening the deer in. Bow hunting was much better for me, but grouse hunters can make the tuff as well. The BWCA has deer in it just not in super high numbers because no logging is allowed. That means not as much food for deer. I have seen some dandys while fishing in the BWCA but come november it would not be alot of fun. But give it try and let us know how it goes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Moose: The reason I was asking is I may be looking to relocate and I wanna stay in the north, BUT I also want good job prospects and superb deer hunting mixed with some trout and salmon fishing. I'm a deer nut and I'm always looking for the perfect place to set up shop. Guess I may keep looking a bit. Thanks for the help!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

St.Louis county has had the most B and C bucks taken, then Itasca and third is Aitkin. This trend is changing though now the bigger bucks seem to be taken from south eastern MN. To bag big deer in any of these northern counties is going to be harder than the broken farmland. To find trophy deer more consistently try Illinois, Kansas, and in my opinion the state that will eventually take the trophy books over, Iowa.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Deet
      Anyfish2 - thanks for the reports. I believe it was you who had written a little summary that included a rough estimation of when the LF river busts open and muddies the Rainy.    Can you (or anyone) comment on when that's looking likely to happen? anyone know when the river cleared the Frontier landing? I think you said that happening gives a 1-to-2 week notice on the LF breakup.
    • cabsav
      recommendation for first timers to northern Minnesota?  we need decent lodging, boat or sitontop kayak, smallmouth is our favorite but we will fish for anything that will bite artificial.  thanks in advance for any help.
    • cabsav
      My Alaska trip fell through, so I'm thinking having never been to Minnesota that should be my destination. thinking a week in august. Probably start International Falls or Duluth. We need a resort with sit on top kayaks or aluminum boats, comfortable lodging without being plush and not ripping our heads off pricewise.  We will target Smallmouth, but if it will hit a lure I will fish for it. any recommendations would be greatly appreciated.
    • Chill62
      Went out of Stoney Point sunday morning.  FYI Watch for deer almost smoked a few on the 20 mph section coming back into the access!  There is an ice heave forming off of the rocks going straight north.  If you want to fish Paris Trench people were crossing instantly using boards.  We weren't gutsy/brave/stupid enough to cross there since we were pulling a trailer behind a four wheeler and had 3 of us with all our gear.  The ice was sketchy from access to point at the point the ice heave goes a little further away from shore and it allows you some room to avoid the point's tip.  There is open water immediately around the point tip but ice looks great if you follow the tracks and avoid huging the tip.  We couldn't find a place to cross the ice heave to get to Paris Trench so we were going to try a few spots further north since we could see a few groups set up north a ways.  About 5.5 miles north of the access the ice heave quits and you can cross it without any worries.  Since we could cross the GPS spot we wanted to fish was only 2.5 miles away and we fished there.  Out in the middle we had 26-28" of ice and barely made it through.  While fishing a plane landed on the lake and a 1/2 ton extended cab pickup came from the NE some where, it was too foggy misty to see where and we didn't see him leave.  Coming back from Stoney Point's Tip to the access was very sketchy.  Made me nervous since there was a lot of slush and water but ice held us up.  If you plan on going out next weekend you may need to find a different access, or atleast I would!  Talked to a guy who came in behind us, they crossed the ice heave at the access using boards how they did and they said it was very slow and only got two.
    • james_walleye
      I've got a 53" ski...41"pike and an accidental 22" smallie on V. I have caught a 31" eye but not on vermilion.  Id  like to get a 30 out of there.