Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Brad0383

Muskie rigs

5 posts in this topic

OK, I have recently started fishing for muskies after I hooked into a 40 inch tiger muskie while fishing for walleyes. I am seeing a lot of controversy over a single hook sucker rig. I agree that this is not a good situation to have a hook swallowed first and then setting the hook. I understand that the "quick strike rigs" are the solution, however isn't it illegal to have more then one hook on a live bait rig in Minnesota? If so, this law needs to change for this exact reason.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Brad,

You are right on, the quick strike rig is the solution. In Minnesota you have to have a spinner blade on the quick strike rig within 2 inches of the hook to make it legal. Yes, it's a silly law and it's being worked on as we speak.

The use of the quick strike rig is strongly encouraged. Far better for the fish and a greater hookup percentage for the angler. It's really a win/win situation. Thorne Bros in Fridley carries them, they'll set you up.

Good luck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yeah that spinner makes the rig considered a "lure".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a very controversal question.. and I am not trying to start a controversy.

Yes, single hooks are prone to being swallowed if the fish is allowed to take the bait too long... its heavily determined on how the fisherman goes about setting the hook after a strike.. If you let them run for a minute, that hook is going to be deep.

On the other hand, quick strike rigs have a lot of hooks and they do tend to tear the mouth of the fish up, and anything near the mouth(gill plates, eyes, etc).. so its a trade off. Its also harder to remove a quick strike rig than it is a single hook most of the time.

I used to fish live bait for muskies regularly for about 5 years. I had many several fish days(especially this time of year). I dont think I have had more than 3 fish swallow the hook, and one of them was a walleye swallowing a decoy(go figure). If you set the hook early and miss the fish, most of the time it was a small fish.

Single hooks are humain to use for live bait presentations. Its up to the fishermen to set the hook before the fish swallows the bait. If you are using a large sucker.. set the hook, those fish have big mouths. If your using a decoy.. anything more than 10 seconds is longer than nessessary. Hook placement in your bait will be an important factor. If you hook the bait under the dorsal, or in the tail section, it will take a long time for the fish to get the minnow too deep(decoy size minnows).

Another option is circle hooks. I have had good results with them under a bobber. Its still not impossible for fish to swallow them if you let a fish take the bait too long. But, a circle hook will always be in the corner of the mouth if its not swallowed making for very easy hook removal, and minimal damage to the fish.

Think of it this way with any type of fish.. what tears fish up more, a rapala, or a plain hook? I guarantee after a couple fish with the rapala, your going to have some issues with excessively hooked fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had read an article about using a single circle hook in the mouth of the sucker for marchetty about a year or so ago. The results were mixed. The article did say that several of the fish were hooked deep, but the vast majority were hooked in the corner of the mouth and were released without any harm.

The fact is that a quick strike rig or any other hook style has the potential to damage fish. Utiliizing the quick strike or circle hooks at least demonstrates that a fisherman has put some thought into the healthy release of a fish. I think that is all we can ask of fisherman. The goal is to release your fish unharmed, but unfortunately that just doesnt happen every time no matter how careful we are.

It is very similar to hunting. A hunter can only take shots that are high percentage and kill 99% of the deer quickly. However, even the best of hunters have a bullet hit a hidden twig or have a deer jump the arrow and result in a bad hit. We have to try to do our best and that is all we can hope for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Posts

    • fins_n'_feathers

      Posted

      Usually we skip the the river until later in the year but it was the cleanest water we found and the only place we caught any fish. Heading out now to give it another try.

    • curt quesnell

      Posted

      Close to home is possible, try those places first?  I will be out this weekend (if this cold doesnt kill me first)  Better luck next time fins

    • Ok so every year Try to get the guys from work on a fishing trip. Trying to decide on where to go we usually rent a cabin and run portables.

      I am thinking Devils lake, LOW, or Red

      Devils we would do the lodge ice house package because the deal is too good to mess with bringing a trailer and sled or wheelers with.

       

      what would you choose and any other suggestions Leech or Vermillion?

    • I plan on taking all my ice fishing equipment out of my shed this week I cant wait

    • fins_n'_feathers

      Posted

      any  reports from today? we pounded through the washing machine waves all day and got nothing! Lead core,jigging, spinners haha! Ended up getting all our keepers within a mile of home when it was all over! Who else was out there? Am I the only one that did poor today?

    • proguide

      Posted

      Cool nights and only a few warming hours each day have water temps coming down into the 50s this week.  This is actually pretty normal for the last week of September so there is nothing to odd here. 
       
      The catfish have slowed down over the past few days with this cool off.  They are still around to catch.  They are hanging near structure, usually on the drop off to the channel right next to it.  They are also on the softer side of the current in holes.  It seems that longer sit times are in order this week to allow the fish to come out, find and decide to eat the bait.
       

      Sucker seems to be the bait of choice right now.  Frogs just have not been getting any attention.

    • leech~~

      Posted

      26 minutes ago, DANR said:

      From the fall Pelican Lakes Association newsletter - DNR Fisheries Update:

      You may have heard about the 454 adult cormorantsthat were removed from Gooseberrry Island this May by the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Wildlife Services Unit under a permit from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.  DNR staff looked at the stomach contents of 30 birds. Eleven of those birds had stomach contents including: 38 perch (mostly 4- inchers), 7 spot-tail shiners, 7 bluegills, 6 crappies, 1 rock bass, 1 pike, and zero walleyes.

      Thanks for the Update.  Hopefully they shoot 400 more next spring! :):)

    • FishinCT

      Posted

      They were really slow today. I fished hard all day and didn't manage much. Went over tons of fish and they weren't active at all. Should get better as the weekend gets closer...I hope

    • gizmoguy

      Posted

      Go with steel. Contact Isle supply.

    • From the fall Pelican Lakes Association newsletter - DNR Fisheries Update:

      You may have heard about the 454 adult cormorantsthat were removed from Gooseberrry Island this May by the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Wildlife Services Unit under a permit from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.  DNR staff looked at the stomach contents of 30 birds. Eleven of those birds had stomach contents including: 38 perch (mostly 4- inchers), 7 spot-tail shiners, 7 bluegills, 6 crappies, 1 rock bass, 1 pike, and zero walleyes. 



  • Posts

    • fins_n'_feathers
      Usually we skip the the river until later in the year but it was the cleanest water we found and the only place we caught any fish. Heading out now to give it another try.
    • curt quesnell
      Close to home is possible, try those places first?  I will be out this weekend (if this cold doesnt kill me first)  Better luck next time fins
    • ZachD
      Ok so every year Try to get the guys from work on a fishing trip. Trying to decide on where to go we usually rent a cabin and run portables. I am thinking Devils lake, LOW, or Red Devils we would do the lodge ice house package because the deal is too good to mess with bringing a trailer and sled or wheelers with.   what would you choose and any other suggestions Leech or Vermillion?
    • ZachD
      I plan on taking all my ice fishing equipment out of my shed this week I cant wait
    • fins_n'_feathers
      any  reports from today? we pounded through the washing machine waves all day and got nothing! Lead core,jigging, spinners haha! Ended up getting all our keepers within a mile of home when it was all over! Who else was out there? Am I the only one that did poor today?