Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Buckslayer

Early season water

Recommended Posts

Buckslayer

Just wanted to get everyones thoughts about being able to hunt water for the early goose season. I understand that the DNR opened it up to allow hunters to shoot more birds, but it seems to me that we would shoot more if we couldnt hunt water. I do a lot of scouting and that has definetely become more difficult. A lot of birds in a lot of different areas have seemed to vanish on me the last couple years. Now dont get me wrong, I know that just means I need to work harder to find them, and I do, but after they get shot off the roost, finding geese becomes a lot more difficult. It just seems to me that if we were not allowed to hunt water, it would keep geese in an area longer, scouting would be easier, and in turn hunters would help the DNR out by shooting more geese. What is everyone else's thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
tearin' lips

Agree/Disagree. If we left them alone on the roosts they would definately stay around longer. They would in a sense have a place of comfort. But Laker Taker can attest to this fact. On Rainy lake where we occasionally hunt early season geese, we are not hunting their roosts. There are certain spots that geese go to thoughout the day that they feed, preen, etc. The islands and rice beds that we hunt are an example of this. If we shoot the geese here they just go back to their roosts, on beaver ponds and backwaters where no one can get.

So it gets to be a gray area in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sartell Angler

agree with tearin' lips

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
eyepatrol

The lake that I hunt isn't a place where the geese roost per say. With all the storm water ponds around and wastewater treatment lagoons around, the geese go and roost on those rather than the lake. The geese I get on the lake here are coming from other areas north of me, where they're getting shot at on fields and such. And, nearly every one that I get or see come to the lake are loaners or pairs. Those geese that are roosting on the ponds and lagoons steer clear of the lake. I watch them every year go well around the lake, by a half mile or better, then they make a turn and go on into the pond or lagoon their roosting at.

My situation is spot specific though. It may very well be different in other areas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rost

Who would want to put on waders and sludge through a slough anyways? I like a dry field where I can lay in my comfy SUB smirk.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ec30_06

It seems that there are a lot less geese flying over my field after the first few days of the season, and the geese seem a lot harder to decoy since it was opened up to hunting on water. I am sure it does not help that all the lakes by me get pounded opening two weekends of the early season with very few birds actually killed and lots of skybusters. Also seems like it has been distrurbing the locall ducks a bit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ironman

I'm not quite convinced that shooting geese off the water makes them leave. These are the local geese, that we hunt in the early season and the same geese we hunt in the late season. These geese dont migrate. Now they may relocate, to refuges and such but not leave. If they did leave I would think the dnr would encourage more water hunting, because the sole reason for the early and late hunt is to reduce local numbers. Not only do we have a large number of local geese that stick around all year, I'm starting to notice flocks of mallards that stick around as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
shae1986

I disagree, now down by the cities maybe this is true but up here the geese i am shooting in September are totally different birds than i am shooting in October. I do believe that hunting geese off water makes them leave. Thats how i feel, but i do hunt water as a last resort to have a decent hunt. I would much rather sit in a field, to me its a way of keeping the birds in the area. Now the probelm is that some people cant find decent fields to sit on so they are forced to sit on the water to shoot birds, there is nothing wrong with hunting over water to shoot geese. If there was then it wouldn't be legal. Again i do believe that birds shot off the roost will leave the area, ive seen it happen. But i have also seen geese leave there roost not get shot at and not come back either, which makes them fun to hunt bc these birds can be unpredictable. I hope everyone is haveing a good and safe early hunt and good luck chasing birds this year.

A. Shae

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
huntnfish

I would personally rather see the DNR close the early season on water. On opening day I saw quite a few flocks very high and vee'd up heading south. I am pretty sure they didn't go real far, but they still left the area. I took a drive past the roost pond after we were done picking up and there were a few pickups there. I don't know if they waited for the geese to leave in the morning or if they jumped them at first light, but either way, if geese have no where they feel comfortable they will leave the area. Ever since they opened up hunting on water in the early season, the only decent day of hunting is opener. After that it is hard to find enough birds to justify even putting out any decoys. Before they opened up hunting on water there were plenty of birds around all of the early season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
woody1975

I agree with anyone that says they should shut down the water hunts. I have personally witnessed a decline in the number of geese harvestes in our area. I attribute this directly to opening the water to hunting. My group gets together with about 5 other groups that hunt in our area at the end of the day, just to discuss things. We all agreed with huntnfish! Back in the day, these geese would get shot at and head back to the lake for refuge. They would stay there for quite a while. Now it seems they get shot at on land, they go back to the lake, get shot at and head out. Just my .02.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ironman

I assume everyone that is opposed to water hunting also has access to feilds...not everyone has that opportunity. Although I would be willing to be converted if anyone is offering. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
huntnfish

It seems like every year there gets to be less and less fields to hunt. I don't have any land, nor do I know anyone that has any land. All that I have ever done is find some geese and then try to secure permission. I have never paid to hunt on someones land and I don't think I ever will. Sometimes I have to travel a little farther from home to find birds and sometimes I find places closer. It just takes a little leg work. If you were closer to the area I would be happy to take you along. Once you hunt in a field it is hard to go back to the water.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ironman

I would love to hunt some fields!! I'm sure I would stick with it because water hunting is kinda a pain in the butt, but it's all I have available right now. Anyways, I havn't shot at any geese yet this year so have no fear at least in the areas I hunt....your roosts are fine grin.gif In fact I would love to gain some access to fields for duck hunting as far as that's concerned, it seems every year the most productive reports come from flooded fields....that would be sweet. I guesss I had better start volunteering for some hay bailing next summer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • leech~~
      I remember that video, pretty darn cool! 
    • leech~~
      Man you can really see the standards of this site of have dropped.  A few years ago we were talking over $80-$100 Thorne Brothers Custom made Ice Rods.  Now a $9.99 dollar rod is the talk for the forum!  We need to bring back the Rich folks!
    • slammer
      I think we should start a Go fund me for Cropduster to take his plane up and give us some pics. lol  He did it a few years ago but not lately.  Its pretty cool veiws from above when ice is forming.  I wonder if he is still lurking around here?
    • EyeChsr
      was out tonight, 6-8 in out from the dnr landing. wheelers and a couple perms out. still open water out in front of Peters resort on the south shore. It starts out a couple hundred yards from shore and runs to the north- northwest for a long ways. some of the spots that were open earlier this week have skimmed, be careful out there if you see different looking ice stop and check!!
    • JIvers
      Thanks for the report--about what I figured, which is why I stayed down here in Iowa this weekend. I am fairly optimistic about getting on the ice in southeast or south central Minnesota next weekend; whether I am on a lake around Faribault or Waseca, or one of my old backwater haunts on the Mississippi remains to be seen. Maybe Clear Lake, Iowa. Whatever I do I will post my results.
    • JerkinLips
      9-11am was best time both days.
    • littlebear
      If you are willing to go a little further into Canada, I would recommend Hollinshead Resort, a few hours north of Thunder Bay.  The resort is the only one on the lake, and in June offers excellent Walleye Fishing, as well as some dandy Northern Pike.  It's somewhere you can drive to as well. 
    • monstermoose78
      Caught 20-23 gills and 6 crappies. Fun day on the 10 inches of ice. The whole lake was close to the same where I cut all the holes out and around
    • Wanderer
      I’m still seeing very random thicknesses all over.  In the past few days I’ve been from St. Cloud to Winnie and have seen vehicles on the ice and open water on the same lake. I’m in Little Falls.  Tonight I checked 2 lakes NW of town.  Both had people fishing.  One looked to be safe for wheeler travel and the other, very near it, still had an open lead and you could see the difference between the first sheet of ice and the second. I hope it doesn’t get covered with snow anytime soon so we can still tell where the changes are. Be safe. Bring floatation and picks.  And don’t drive yet! Ruh ro....
    • Bigfatbert
        Nice fish , great pics ,, what times of the day were best for you ?