Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Tyler Holm

Coldwater Troutin

Recommended Posts

Tyler Holm

RugbyGuy and I hitup one of SE MN's many trout streams on Saturday morning to see if we could wrangle with some Brownies. We selected a stream with blazing cold water in an area with loads of structure and shade from the sun.

Luck was on our side as we caught and released nearly 10 fish each in just a few short hours of fishing. Our biggest was the first fish of the day at 13" but we had several over 12" with the majority of our fish exceeding 10"

I've realized this for a long time, but really never put it into deep thought until this trip. It's the big flashes you don't hook up with that makes you want to go troutin again another day. Both Andy and I swear we had 18+" fish flashing/slashing/dashing at our lures, multiple times. While we never boated any of those fish, it’s the idea that they are out there that makes we want to go back. And I will...

We concluded that natural colors were the ticket today. For the most part we fished Rapalas in the #5-9 size. More and more, I’m starting to like the suspending/slash-baits.

Rugbyguy took a few photos that I’ll try to get posted in the next few days.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DEADhead

sounds like you guys had a blast; can't wait to see the pics!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
WxGuy

Sounds like a great day on the water! I'm looking forward to seeing some pics too. smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tyler Holm

Late, but here is a 13"er. All fish were happily returned to the water to grow even BIGGER.

ty_trout.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tyler Holm

Andy and I made it out to a similiar stream on Friday. We weren't surprised by the chocolate waters, but thought we could still wrangle a few. We ended the day with 4 browns: 1 dink, and 3 11-12"ers.

There was no exact science to catching these (at least we didn't figure out any). I caught 1 on a #5 floating Rap in the rainbow pattern, 1 on a 1/32 oz THO jig with a Berkley Power Bait trout worm on it (this was the dink), and 1 on a #9 FireTiger countdown. I tried the rest of the box, but to no avail.

I'll be out tomorrow AM somewhere on a trout stream. I learn a little more each time out. I'm thinking crickets/hoppers will find their way to the water tomorrow. That will be a first for me...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nate larson

Tyler,

Nice report. I can't wait to see the rest of the pics. To bad you didn't catch that BIG one!

Did you have any luck at Oxbow over the weekend? I am guessing that you didn't because I am sure you would have told us if you did.

Good luck trout fishing tomorrow.

Nate

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
monkplunk1

I have been looking at the board for the past few months, and it seems like very few Minnesotans flyfish for trout. It also seems like spin fishers tend to use unmodified baits(treble hooks w/ barbs, etc) when trout angling. Flyfishing is not qualitatively better and does not takes more skill but it is far easier on fish (see 2004 UCal- Berkley study on fish mortality)and provides much more enjoyment. Some enjoy ripping a Mepps across stream, but for some this too will get old.

For those of you who haven't had the opportunity to pick up a flyrod, I encourage you to contact you local Trout Unlimited chapter and they will arrange something for you - free of charge. This would also be a good opportunity to become involved in cold water conservation initiatives in your area, if not already. For those of you already involved with TU, send them an email and tell them you would like to start flyfishing. I'm certain they will hook you up.

Tight lines. grin.gif

[Note from admin: This post edited. Please read forum policy before posting again. Thank you]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nate larson

monkplunk1~

I respect your take on the trout fishing in Minnesota. I think one thing that is different in Minnesota is that a lot of our trout fisherman don't target trout as their primary species. Many of us typically do more bass fishing, walleye fishing, panfish, etc. It is an easy transition for us to fish trout with the same equipment. I personally love fishing trout with a spinning rod and think that it requires a lot of skill to do it successfully. I crimp my barb to ensure that the fish aren't hurt and return them to the water quickly(preferably in slow moving water.) I know that most of my fellow trout anglers on this website do the same. I have a lot of respect for TU and the work that they do. I actually was fortunate enough to get to help them with habitat improvement project in Southeastern MN. I personally haven't got into fly fishing because it is an expensive hobby and I already have enough of those! Haha.

Nate

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tyler Holm

monkplunk1,

Now that’s some good stuff. You’re always going to have who don't agree no matter what you do.

I hear people debating catching walleyes in the spring while they are spawning and vulnerable. Same goes with pulling crappies, gills, and bass off their beds in the spring. I’ve witnessed debates for catching trout in the extreme heat. There was a bunch of discussion and for “how to hold trophy sized fish”. Don’t lay your fish on the ice prior to releasing as it can freeze the eyes of the fish in seconds. Live bait fishing for trout is another. Fishing deep holes during winter for channel cats is another discussion. I could honestly go on and on here…

Some of these I’m guilty of, some not. The bottom line is somebodies always got a better idea or reason to do (or not do) this or that. This is the first I’ve personally heard of not spin fishing trout, but it’s not surprising.

I own 2 fly rods and I have caught fish from off of them. I’m certainly not an expert by any stretch, but I’ve put in a few hours here and there with the fly rod. I’ve posted the results and pictures of those as well.

I’m relatively new to MN and this is my first year trout fishing. I apologize, but a 12-13” trout still excites me. In fact it might excite me as much as a 5lb walleye, 13” perch, 13.5” crappie, 9.5” gill, etc. Sorry for any upset stomach feelings… or am I?

I think your statement about very few Minnesotans flyfish is pretty bold. First off, MN is not known for its “10,000” trout streams. I have a feeling that the vast majority of our fly fisherpeople simply don’t post much on the subject. There out there thou.

I can’t dispute that barbed/spin fishing affects fish mortality, because I do agree that it is tougher on the fish. Did you jump to the assumption that all our baits are unmodified… barbed trebles?

In 2 weeks, the season changes to C & R w/barbless hooks and quite honestly I’m looking forward to it. I’ve already got plans to grab only the fly rod and go about my business on some random trout stream. I’ll do the exact same thing for this upcoming winter trout season. It will be my first.

Thanks for the info and suggestions about Trout Unlimited as that is solid information and an excellent idea. That organization has had a huge hand in making MN trout fishing what it is today.

Maybe this is the little “shove” I needed to leave the spinning rod a home a bit more and keep the dust off the bug rod.

The original intent of this post was to share information and experiences that one of my best friends and I endured together. Please don’t take anything away from that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DEADhead

well put Ty. I'll have to agree that most fly anglers in MN aren't on this forum posting. Most trout bums are on the water, not behind a computer wink.gif

I'm a diehard fly fisherman. If I had my choice, that's the only way I would fish. However, there are many other methods of fishing that are just as fun. If I'm out to catch some meat for the smoker, I am usually using spinning gear to catch stocked trout in a lake. If I am fishing a river for trout on MN, I am almost always using fly tackle, as I personally do not keep any trout from a river, due to the fact that I do not want to harvest any wild fish. I am well aware of fish mortality, and effective techniques for reducing mortality rates on realesed fish.

To each his own; if a trout angler wants to use hardware and spinning tackle to catch trout, so be it. If he wants to be a worm dunker, so what. All I care about is that the angler treat the resource with respect, leave it in the same or better condition than when he/she arrived, and realize how lucky he/she is to be provided with such an awesome opportunity to catch such a marvelous being.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
WxGuy

Well said, Ty and JP!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • Bigfatbert
      Thanks for the reply JerkinLips...
    • sunniewally
      Man you can really see the standards of this site of have dropped.  A few years ago we were talking over $80-$100 Thorne Brothers Custom made Ice Rods.  Now a $9.99 dollar rod is the talk for the forum!   We need to bring back the Rich folks!  Finally getting smart!! 10.00 dollar rod will work just fine  
    • cookie129
      My no snow slow snow dance started off as rain? Guess I made a mistake and did a rain dance. Cleaning off the trucks last night I would say we got 3 inches far less then they predicted 9 to 11. The winds picked up last night and are howling right now. The snow was wet and heavy to start so I'm hoping its not blow in my landing to bad.
       Barny from Kellier is coming up today to do a little welding for us before we pull the house's off the shore line. Montana needs a hook re welded and the metal grade step repaired, Florida also need some work on the step.
       I got the radiator ordered for white Lightning aka Cheyanne. I'm hoping it arrives before Saturday and I can get Devon to install it while there here. We also have a lite bar for blue thunder that Devon gave me this summer. I noticed the wipers quit working on the red baron and we will have to check that out as there kinda important out there on the lake.
       Josh from Annandale is running a snowbear out there this year. He has a helper Travis that was out there yesterday guiding some customers. I talk to him briefly before the rain and snow started and he landed a 16 incher while I was talking to him, kinda curious how he did after that.
       I expect quite a few rentals will be working there way out on the lake starting Wednesday, my plans are to check my area one more time before I make the move onto the lake. I'm hoping to find 14 inches of ice the whole route so will see how that goes.
       I'm sure Buddy Hillmen will start dragging his road this morning if there's good visibility. He like to get that snow off asap to make the ice thicker on the road. Plus with a good wind a lot of it catches the air and its much less plowing.
       I know I have said it many times but it is one heck of a road and he takes a tremendous amount of pride in building it. Its a lot of work, a lot of ware and tare on the trucks, but I also enjoy being part of his operation.
       Crazy but I have heard and saw pics of a few. " More then 3" elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappies this  year. Deb and Jim did not fair to well sunday fishing. I think it was there first time on red lake. They did manage to get two in the time they fished and also missed a couple. They came off the lake before dark to be on the safe side.
       If you decide to come fish upper red lake in the near future please check in with the access resorts. With the snow cover they will have information Of any areas to avoid since they have all been checking condition daily. Remember common sense and if it does not look right it is probably not. Do not try and go to saved waypoints un tell we have weeks of ice making temps. Its just a fish. There's plenty of fishable ice that's average 10 inches. And the last Thing is remember as the old timer Dave told me" ITS A GRAND LAKE AND IT OWES US NOTHING!, NOTHING! City: waskish
      Remote Name: 209.191.208.74
      Date: 03/11/2003
      Time: 11:30:31 AM Upper_Red_Lake To all fishermen, If you spend 1/2 hour reading the past reports on here you should have all the knowledge you need to find those elusive crappies. Come and enjoy the lake , give every one plenty of room, Please bring your garbage home. Who ever left the 12 pack of empty bud cans I picked them up for you. Where do you think this garbage goes?I will tell you it ends up on the bottom of the lake or on shore so please take it home with you.This lake is pristine lets all keep it that way. THANKS COOKIE
    • leech~~
      I remember that video, pretty darn cool! 
    • leech~~
      Man you can really see the standards of this site of have dropped.  A few years ago we were talking over $80-$100 Thorne Brothers Custom made Ice Rods.  Now a $9.99 dollar rod is the talk for the forum!  We need to bring back the Rich folks!
    • slammer
      I think we should start a Go fund me for Cropduster to take his plane up and give us some pics. lol  He did it a few years ago but not lately.  Its pretty cool veiws from above when ice is forming.  I wonder if he is still lurking around here?
    • EyeChsr
      was out tonight, 6-8 in out from the dnr landing. wheelers and a couple perms out. still open water out in front of Peters resort on the south shore. It starts out a couple hundred yards from shore and runs to the north- northwest for a long ways. some of the spots that were open earlier this week have skimmed, be careful out there if you see different looking ice stop and check!!
    • JIvers
      Thanks for the report--about what I figured, which is why I stayed down here in Iowa this weekend. I am fairly optimistic about getting on the ice in southeast or south central Minnesota next weekend; whether I am on a lake around Faribault or Waseca, or one of my old backwater haunts on the Mississippi remains to be seen. Maybe Clear Lake, Iowa. Whatever I do I will post my results.
    • JerkinLips
      9-11am was best time both days.
    • littlebear
      If you are willing to go a little further into Canada, I would recommend Hollinshead Resort, a few hours north of Thunder Bay.  The resort is the only one on the lake, and in June offers excellent Walleye Fishing, as well as some dandy Northern Pike.  It's somewhere you can drive to as well.