Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
Amandafish

Heater suggestions

Question

Amandafish

I tried to do a search here but did not have any luck.

We have a 8x16 perm. that is just about complete, one of the last things to do is find a heater, a friend suggested a Empire heater but with a price of $600.00, that is not gonna fly, it seems like alot and also the fact it can be stolen.

So we are thinking about a PRO COM radiant LP heater 25,000 btus and cost $160.00

it has a oxygen depletion sensor that will shut off the gas flow, if the oxygen level falls below safe levels.

If any one has this type of heater or reasons we should not go this route I would appreciate it.

Thanks, Amanda

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

13 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
ScottND

You may want to look at This link first...I'm have no pros or cons to you using one but I just ran into this.

[sorry, the unauthorized link has been removed. M-H]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
korn_fish

Amandafish -

I have something similar. It is a comfort glo blue flame heater. Price similar to what you are talking about. I sleep in my shelter all the time but I have a CO detector as well. My detector has a digital display so I can see if levels are rising well before they are dangerous. I can not get it to register above 0 with my blue flame heater, but with a sunflower type heater it goes off within 30 minutes.

I strongly recommend getting a heater with a thermostat. My house is a 7x16 and I have a 25,000 BTU with thermostat. It has variable settings of 1-10 and I seldom have it at 2. Usually somewhere between 1 and 2, and many times at its lowest setting.

I went the route of teh ventless heater for one of the exact reasons you mentioned. Theft. I can unhook the heater, slide the hose through the wall and take it all home with me.

I agree with everyone that pushes the vented heaters that they are more failsafe than a vented, but with the appropriate precautions and safety measures (a good CO detector) you should be happy with the heater you mention.

It has been mentioned that the blue flame heaters provide a more comfortable heat as it heats the air and not objects first. Which means, if you are sitting in front of the heater, a blue flame heater isn't going to bake your back/leg etc. when everything else around is cold.

A 25,000 BTU blue flame heats my shack up in as little as 5 minutes.

I am happy with my decision.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Eric Wettschreck

I'll take what Korn said a little further. I have a 7 x 10 very well insulated permanent. I use the 10,000 btu outdoorsman non-vented heater made by reddy heater. That little dude works wonders for me. Takes about 5 minutes to heat up the shack. Costed me about 160 bucks.

I'll always go with convection (blue flame) over radiant heat any day for the reasons Korn stated. CO detector is an absolute must. In a bigger house it doesn't hurt to have 2.

Also, if you have 12v wiring, I recommend getting a little computer fan. They are wisper quiet. Angle it slightly down to move air to the floor area. It will help keep the bottom foot of your shanty toasty warm also.

Good luck!!!!!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
GoodToGo

Has anyone had a problem with moisture in the house with the vent-frees? Venting also vents moisture, without it I would worry about condensation in the house. I will be putting a bigger heater in my permanent next year. This is the only outstanding question I have before I put in a vent free blue flame.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
FishnBear

I also have the Outdoorsman Heater that the Boilerguy is talking about $150.00 at Fleet Farm, It comes with a hose to hook to a 20lb tank. I use it in a 6.5 x 10 house and it provides more than enough heat, I didn't have any problems with moisture. I love it great heater.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
korn_fish

My windows fog up the first couple minutes when the house first heats up. But it's gone in a few minutes. I don't have any condensation build up anywhere that I can see.

There is a big mis-conception with vent free heaters. With a vent free heater, you will still need to crack a window or have some sort of venting. I have two windows in mine and the tops of each is cracked anywhere from 1/8th inch to 1/2 inch based on wind and how much air is being blown in. Although my CO test I did was with the house sealed up as tight as it could be.

If anything, cracking the tops of the window helps circulate air and keeps the tempurature in the house more stabalized from floor to ceiling.

I installed a thermometer that also tells humidity levels in the house. During hunting season, I noticed that the humidity levels actually went down when the heater was on. I think condensation comes more from voids in the insulation/shoddy manufacturing of the house, then the actuall heater. Although a bi-product of burning propane is H2O, ventilation (i.e. windows cracked) will take care of that bi-product and the interior heat will take care of the rest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
GoodToGo

Thanks Korn, very informative post.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
swampman

I have a pro com in my house this will be the fourth year on it, mine is a size smaller than the one you are looking at but is more than enough to heat my 6 by 12. mine doesnt have a thermostat and I really wish it did as it can be a pain adjusting it up and down. also when putting on a new lp cylinder it is a pain trying to get it to light (air in lines when you switch tanks) you have to keep pressing the igniter button till the pilot takes off. I havent had any problems with it otherwise and it does heat up the house very fast. above guys all make some good points. hope this helps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Amandafish

We are going to get one with a thermostat, the guy I spoke with at Northern said to get radiant for the reason you guys mentioned but he must of been mixed up.

There is no wiring yet that will have to wait we are just trying to get the basics done now so the house is fishable.

I will definetly pick a CO detecter.

I am still trying to figure out what to use on the bunks, I looked around online for some type of foam at the fabric and craft stores but did not find anything, I thought about picking up some of thoose egg crate foam pads and cuting them half, it would prob take two pads for each bunk to get them thick enough, any better ideas?

Thanks guys for all the help.

Hopefully we will be on the ice Sunday watching the game cool.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Moose-Hunter

I have a suggestion for you concerning foam for your bunks. Grab the yellow pages. there's a few actual "foam" dealers that will sell to the general public. Some places will even do custom cuts for you to virtually eliminate that "forced to buy extra" problem.

As far as what to get, a good quality, high density closed cell foam would be my pick. The high density type foam will "wear" better and actually give you better support in the thinner thicknesses needed for bunks. And closed cell, so they do not absorb moisture. Which can lead to all sorts of less than desireable things...

This type of foam may be a bit more expensive, but in the long run, the initial investment is well worth it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
tomfromblaine

how about lawn chair pads, probably can get a good deal on those martha stewart jobs at k-mart they look pretty comfy durable also. grin.gif P.S. where do you get those pro-com heaters?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Amandafish

I have been looking online at Northern Tool and Equipment,

Call ahead with a model # and see what stores have what it is kinda hit or miss if you just stop by.

Also they said print out any sale price online and bring it with and they will honor that price.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
korn_fish

I got my padding from Hancocks fabric (or something along that name) in Hopkins. I bought the 4" stuff and it is almost too much padding. It came in 24"X72" and was pretty much a perfect fit. In my previous permanent, I just used the padding that came with a cot purchased at wal-mart.

the padding I bought at Hancocks was around $70 for each bunk. I think I seen a fish house supply place that sold some polyurethane mattresses for that same price but theres at least had a cloth cover already.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • JerkinLips
      I drive by there 20-30 times per year on my way up north and always wondered what they all said.  Thanks for posting them.  With the warning sign "Danger No Trespass Injury Very Likely" and the barbwire fence around the signs, I would not enter his property if I worked for the US post office or UPS.
    • MrSchrute
      We fished Wednesday afternoon.through Friday out of Zippel. It was not as cloudy as the weatherman predicted. Our best day ended up being Thursday. The two of us in our shack limited out by noon, most were sauger. Hot lure was a 1/8oz glow red shiner Tingler spoon and a plain red hook under a bobber. We were in 26ft
    • Rick G
      Thanks Tom. 
    • Rick
      Landowners can generate revenue by allowing public hunting on their private land in 46 Minnesota counties through the Department of Natural Resources Walk-In Access Program. Sign-ups are Monday, Jan. 22, to Friday, April 27.  “This program is a win-win for landowners and hunters,” said Scott Roemhildt, DNR Walk-In Access coordinator. “And what’s more, by signing up for three years, landowners can qualify for habitat enhancement on their Walk-In Access acres.” For Walk-In Access, eligible parcels must be at least 40 acres and covered by high quality natural vegetation. Landowners are paid by the acre to allow hunting access from Sept. 1 to May 31. Bonuses are paid on parcels that enroll in a three-year contract, are more than 140 acres and are located near a state wildlife management area or federal waterfowl production area. “This may be an opportune time for landowners to sign up for this program because there is some uncertainty about how it will be funded in the 2018 Farm Bill,” Roemhildt said. In a change this year, landowners who enroll in a three-year contract also may qualify for up to $20,000 in habitat enhancements on their land for prescribed burning, removing invasive trees and brush, or planting native species. Walk-In Access parcels are for public hunting only and no motorized vehicles are allowed on conservation land. Bright yellow-green signs identify area boundaries and parking is along roads or in designated parking areas. Recreational use laws provide extra liability protection for acres enrolled in Walk-In Access. Walk-In Access began in 2011 and has grown to more than 26,700 acres in 2017. The program is currently funded through 2018 with a three-year grant from the Natural Resources Conservation Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, under number 69-3A75-16-509. Other funding comes through a surcharge on nonresident hunting licenses, a one-time appropriation from the Minnesota Legislature in 2012 and donations from hunters. Landowners should contact their local soil and water conservation district office for enrollment information. Details can be found at mndnr.gov/walkin. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick G
      Yea, the guys having issues with the k-drill/fuel combo are not claring out their ice shavings enough. I have had 0 issues with binding or overheating.  Have been drilling through ice that comes up to the foam the last three days.
    • Coldtrack
      We have been driving about anywhere we want on the lakes north of Winni  
    • AlwaysFishing23
      Possibly coming up in the next upcoming weekends. Is there any good areas this year that’s producing a decent bit I’ve heard it’s been pretty slow so far? I know last year there was a good crappie bite in halverston bay but ended up sticking close to the resort and got a few gills. Looking for eyes and crappies if no real good bite thinking of heading to the southwest and trying the gull area. Thanks
    • SkunkedAgain

      I took those pictures probably seven or eight years ago. If I remember correctly I was heading up north solo, and decided like many others that I'd never fully read the spectacle and would capture it for posterity. I've never met or seen the guy, but I'm sure it would be an interesting time if you drank a few cold ones together. Speaking of Cotton, does anyone have a report on the El Toro lounge? I've always meant to stop in there but have yet to do so.
    • SkunkedAgain
      Losing Sue is a great loss to the lake community and all of those that had a chance to interact with her. My young daughter has had to deal with a few close losses in our family this year/winter already, so she will be really sad to find out next spring that her favorite "ice cream lady' is no longer with us as well. Sue and Ron were always part of the experience of coming up north. Like many others I'm sure, my wife got corner by Sue last summer about how we needed to buy Moosebirds! I'll miss seeing Sue's smile each time we walk in the door to pick up some random forgotten item, for ice cream, or to find something "Moosebirds" to take home and support a good friend.
    • BriGuy88
      Not sure how everyone else is drilling their holes with the k drill, but I have the 8" on a clam drill plate with the M18 fuel drill and don't have any problems with the drill overheating or the bit not cutting.  In 20" of ice, I clear the shavings 2 or 3 times during the cutting process and the drill cuts like a hot knife through butter.  Instructions on the k drill float are pretty clear that you should clear the shavings to prevent the drill from binding when cutting in thick ice.  Love my k drill!
  • Share & Have Fun