Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
smallie_hawgin

The measuring debate!

Recommended Posts

smallie_hawgin    13
smallie_hawgin

Ok, I have not been a contributor long, however, I have read an aweful lot of posts bragging about river smallies over 21". I have lived here for 5 1/2 years, fished the Mississippi from day one, I work the river as well. I have many fish close to the twenty inch range, but, non that were true 21+. It seems odd that Xcell energy and the DNR have electrofished the river for a combined 30+ years have NEVER, I repeat NEVER, seen fish that measured 22+, and very few over 20. So my debate is over proper measuring techniques. I have this strange feeling that we as anglers love to give a bit extra when we measure fish. I challenge all of you to measure the fish mouth closed tight, tail pinched and swipe by the number. Always hold nose at 0 and tail at measured length. Let me know what happens. I have a feeling that most of those stories of true 22+'s might turn into 20 1/2. Just my thoughts. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Royce Aardahl    0
Royce Aardahl

Take a look at the nice smallies and pictures post. A real live 21 1/2 incher. They are out there. No tail pinching. Just one heck of a fish. I had one spit me 2 nights ago that I'll bet was it's twin. Keep your lines wet. <>< <><

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kevin Turner    1
Kevin Turner

Hey guys....I'm hope it doesn't sound like I'm bragg'n...
I (we) have had many over 21" in my boat.(last week the DNR was electro shocking and I gave them a 21" to survey, Pete from River Run Guide service, had a 21 1/4" the day before) My (our)three biggest were over 22"
I have not seen any over 23" personaly.I realize this thread is about measuring. I measure with closed mouth and tail.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mille Lacs Guy    0
Mille Lacs Guy

I think I'll weigh in on this one or measure in as it may be. I have said it before but according to the DNR and the electo fish literally 1000s of fish per year and do creel surveys, etc and they have never seen a fish over about 21 inches above the St. Cloud. I have fished the stretch around Little Falls for over 10 years and I have had a lot of 20.5 inchers but that's the biggest. If someone told me they caught a 21 above St. Cloud I would believe them but those fish are few and far between.

Below St. Cloud is another story. The river water temperatures are a little warmer which allows the fish to get a little bigger. And when I say bigger I mean maybe a touch over 22 inches. I personally now the guy that did creels on the stretch between the SCSU dam and down past Clearwater and he never saw one over 22 inches. This creel person would talk to Dave Genz everyday and Genz can catch fish and fishes A LOT and he said he never saw a Smallie much over 22 inches and the 22s were very rare.

Anybody who says they are catching fish close to 23 inches is full of it in my opinion and they need to learn how to measure. Kevin fishes the Clearwater stretch as much as anybody and he said his biggest are around 22 and I believe it, but there aren't any much bigger than that.

Just my .02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Navigator    0
Navigator

I was reluctant to respond to this post...but here goes, I too have been fishing the St. Cloud area Miss since 1987 and log approximately 170 days on the water. I would say that 1/2 of that time I am fishing some-where on the river. With this in mind, I have one smallie in the 23" range and two around 22", otherwise most of the fish I consider BIG and catchable are around 19" to 21". I consider a 21"+ fish rare and a trophy.

I'm not here to dispute anything that has been posted about who caught what, just to share what I have seen in the last 16+ years of fishing in this area.

The three big smallies I caught were extraordinary and I feel very fortunate to have seen a bass that big. The 23" fish was definitely at lifes end (very sickly looking) and I get asked to this day why I didn't have it mounted. I wasn't thinking about that at the time I caught it. It was pretty much a surprise that I didn't know what to do with!! That was over 10 years ago.

What I have witnessed is there are seasonal transitions when the big fish get active as a group. They are on the move and actively feeding throughout the day, which increases your opportunity to get a trophy smallie.

Just my thoughts. Nav

------------------
Jon Navratil
Navigator Guide Service
www.naviguides.com
Serving Central MN rivers & lakes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kevin Turner    1
Kevin Turner

BTW, My freind Carl caught one of the largest Miss smallie I have seen boated and released. We were having a extraordinary day, so I had video cam in hand. I taped the top water hit (white buzz), the landing, and the release. It scaled at 5.8 lbs. (5lbs 12.4oz if my math is right. In our rush to put the big girl back (it was during the fall release only season, so we did not want to put her in the box) we scaled it but did not measure it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smallie_hawgin    13
smallie_hawgin

Hey guys, I am not doubting there are a few larger fish out there. I just think its funny how quite a few people say they have caught fish over 21". Do we all measure using a keeper board or similar type of measuring stick? Somehow I think not. Most of us probably have a sticker taped on the boat and inaccuracies are definitely the rule rather than the exception. To me a **** nice fish is anything over 17" So I am not questioning wether they were nice fish or not. Hell, some say I may get one over 20 from the river and I will be **** sure I measure it right. If nothing else to practice when a record is on the end of my line cool.gif
I am glad to see so many die-hard river smallie fisher folks it is awesome!!! Fish-on!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mark Christianson    0
Mark Christianson

S_Hog
I now have a "nose board" and it sure makes it easier to get a true measurement on fish. I have a 36" aluminum ruler screwed into the deck of my boat, but having a scale that you can butt the nose of the fish into, sure makes the pinched tail swipe easier and much more accurate.

My buddies dad is the classic. Good ole Uncle Jon.
Hold the fish up to the tape pasted on the side of the boat, kind of get an idea of what it measures, and toss it over the side.
"Hey, that was 29 inches!"
(Yeah, he's not the master fish handler).
He's from the old school, and its always entertaining to watch him. ALWAYS!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest   
Guest

I don't have the hooks up to post picts on the Internet. But I am holding pictures of a 24.5'' Smallmouth Bass cought below Blanchard Damb in my hand as I speek. I cought this fish two years ago and it was full of eggs. I measured it with a closed mouth and a pinched tail with a cloth type tape measure. There were 3 others there that witnessed this fish. Maybe I'll go to my uncles and try and post the picts. By the way, I released the fish. If you don't belive me, it your loss. There are sate record fish out there, you just have to fish for them. The earlyest they will be up is by this weekend.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Royce Aardahl    0
Royce Aardahl

I for one would love to see the pics! That's a dandy! Email them to Rick and he'll put them on for you, that's what I did.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kevin Turner    1
Kevin Turner

I would very much like to see a 24.5 incher. Please post the pics. I just can't get above the 22" mark. I need to have something to strive for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest   
Guest

Who's Rick and whats his e-mail address. I can send them to him right now but I need his address. I think it will work.

I found Rick adress but when I tryed to send it to him some errors came up. so I will try to get them up Sat. after I get back from fishing. I fish alot and have cought my fare share of bass over 20'', most of them largemouth. Maybe I'll post some other pictures also.

[This message has been edited by JoeLewis (edited 08-14-2003).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Grabs    0
Grabs

Use the "Contact Us" link

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smallie_hawgin    13
smallie_hawgin

Well, I can finally say I have broke the 20" barrier on the river. Yeee-Haww!!!! Managed to get a 20.5 (legitimate, proper measuring technique) tonitght on a buzzer, Thanks Kevin. It really does work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Royce Aardahl    0
Royce Aardahl

Rick owns fishing minnesota see email him there. Send the pics and he will get them on for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mark Christianson    0
Mark Christianson

Joe L

Here is Ricks email to send the pics:
rick@fishingminnesota.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jim W    0
Jim W

If you still can't get through to Rick send them to me jwernimont@wfdi.ws.

Keep in mind that bass numbers in creel surveys aren't real good in depicting numbers in any given body of water. Most surveys point this out.

WHose to say that fish larger than 22 are void of areas surveyed?

It's interesting. Believe it or not I have landed 21 inchers in a river you guys would consider a "trickle". If they can get that big in these waters I wouldn;t doubt larger fish. Rare, but possible.

Keep in mind the length of time it takes to grow these fish people. Please make sure you have in your mind, before making that first cast, what your intentions are and be prepared to follow through with them.

In the Root River in SE MN it takes 12 years to grow a 16 inch smallmouth. Not much quicker ,if at all, than on the mighty Miss.

You guys have me all pumped for some Fall smally action!!

Keep the rods bendin'!!!

Jim W

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EBass    0
EBass

Jim, about how old would a 20" smallie be in the Sippi? 16yrs old or more? They sure do grow slow. Are smallies in Mille Lacs likely to grow at the same rate? Just curious.

Thanks
EBass

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jim W    0
Jim W

Ebass,

Of course we need to take into consideration each fsih may grow at varied rates, but I would say your pretty close.

I am not a Mille Lacs expert. However, not battling current and ever changing levels, flow and at times easier access to prime forage it would be safe to say Mille Lacs smallmouth grow faster. To want extent I cannot answer.

Good question for the area fisheries guys. They should have some great info on smallmouth. If you have time to dig it up, let us know, I am very curious.

Jim W

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smallie_hawgin    13
smallie_hawgin

Ebass, Honestly, they are very difficult to age. I do know that by the time they get to 15 inches in the Miss they really slow down. There are fish that grow less than 1/2 inch per year when they reach 16". Oldest aged so far has been near 18. Although, as I stated earlier it is very difficult to age scales from river fish due to the varying conditions they are exposed to. Check out the DNR fisheries website for Montrose http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/areas/fisheries/montrose
There is extensive info on the river as well as other things you might find interesting in Wright, Stearns and Sherburne counties. Pass it on.

Jim W, I couldn't agree more on knowing whether you plan to keep or release a fish prior to casting. This fishery (the Miss)while seeming as though it can keep getting better, is fragile. All it takes is a couple of high water years in spring and year classes are minimal, add on any harvest of spawning stock legal or otherwise, and you could potentially minimize the fishery. Thanks for the genuine concern. Fish-on.

[This message has been edited by smallie_hawgin (edited 08-21-2003).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
river rat316    130
river rat316

hey as you can tell I am a insomniac and a fm addict I was just cruising old posts and was wondering if this guy ever posted the picture of this 24" er? If not I guess it was bs huh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Royce Aardahl    0
Royce Aardahl

dude you need serious help!! wink.gif go fishing and shut down that computer. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
HawgTide    0
HawgTide

I'm with you on this one. It's either prove it or BS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kevin Turner    1
Kevin Turner

Hey guys, I just got a email from a fellow FMer asking my advice on where to get a replica made. I don't have a clue who to refer him to, any thoughts?

Opps...I'm in the wrong thread...sorry for the hijakn'...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mark Christianson    0
Mark Christianson

Send him my way. I recently started repping on the side for Fibertech.

mark_christianson@cnt.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • curt quesnell
        Fall is very nearby and things are going the way they should.  Fishing is good, it is too windy and the water is cooling down quickly.....On this weeks report and important bit on our very own Aquatic Invasive Species......Enjoy it!  
    • Wanderer
      That's understandable given how you use the back reel technique.  I haven't used it the same way. Most of my trolling is done with baitcasters or levelwinds with counters.  The jigging part I hadn't considered before. "David, have you ever parred with a 7 iron?" "Well, Roy, it never occurred to me to even try." 
    • Rick
      An independent laboratory has confirmed zebra mussel larvae in Garfield Lake in Hubbard County. The lab provided photos of two zebra mussel larvae, called veligers, found in a water sample taken from the lake. Property owners on Garfield Lake hired the lab as part of their own monitoring. Invasive species specialists from the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources found no zebra mussels in the lake during a six-hour dive survey. Garfield Lake will be added to the Infested Waters List for zebra mussels, with the provision that it may be removed from the list if future surveys continue to show no zebra mussels in the lake. Whether or not a lake is listed as infested, Minnesota law requires boaters and anglers to: Clean watercraft of aquatic plants and prohibited invasive species, Drain all water by removing drain plugs and keeping them out during transport, and Dispose of unwanted bait in the trash. Some invasive species are small and difficult to see at the access. To remove or kill them, take one or more of the following precautions before moving to another waterbody, especially after leaving infested waters: Spray with high-pressure water. Rinse with very hot water (120 degrees Fahrenheit for at least two minutes or 140 degrees Fahrenheit for at least 10 seconds). Dry for at least five days. As boat owners begin taking boats and equipment out of the water for the season, the DNR reminds them to carefully check for aquatic invasive species and contact the DNR with any suspected new infestations. Look on the posts, wheels and underwater support bars of docks and lifts, as well as any parts of boats, pontoons and rafts that may have been submerged in water for an extended period. Minnesota law requires that docks and lifts be allowed to dry for at least 21 days before being placed in another body of water, whether aquatic invasive species are present or not. People should contact an area DNR aquatic invasive species specialist if they think they have found zebra mussels or any other invasive species that has not already been confirmed in a lake. More information is available at www.mndnr.gov/AIS. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      City may apply for DNR pilot project treatment The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources has confirmed zebra mussels in Lake Marion, in the city of Lakeville, in Dakota County. Five adult zebra mussels were found at the public access by a lake consulting business, as part of an early detection monitoring program conducted for the city of Lakeville. The city may apply for a pilot project treatment after a more thorough search of the lake is completed. As boat owners begin taking boats and equipment out of the water for the season, the DNR reminds them to carefully check for aquatic invasive species and contact the DNR with any suspected new infestations. Look on the posts, wheels and underwater support bars of docks and lifts, as well as any parts of boats, pontoons and rafts that may have been submerged in water for an extended period. Minnesota law requires that docks and lifts be allowed to dry for at least 21 days before being placed in another body of water, whether aquatic invasive species are present or not. Minnesota law requires boaters and anglers to: Clean watercraft of aquatic plants and prohibited invasive species. Drain all water by removing drain plugs and keeping them out during transport, and Dispose of unwanted bait in the trash. Some invasive species are small and difficult to see at the access. To remove or kill them, take one or more of the following precautions before moving to another waterbody, especially after leaving infested waters: Spray with high-pressure water. Rinse with very hot water (120 degrees Fahrenheit for at least two minutes or 140 degrees Fahrenheit for at least 10 seconds). Dry for at least five days. People should contact an area DNR aquatic invasive species specialist if they think they have found zebra mussels or any other invasive species that has not already been confirmed in a lake. More information is available at www.mndnr.gov/AIS. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Extensive multi-agency search showed no other zebra mussels The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources has confirmed that a single zebra mussel was removed from Lake Harriet in Minneapolis. Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board (MPRB) staff reported one adult zebra mussel on a boat cover recovered from the bottom of the lake. No additional zebra mussels were found during 67 hours of diving, snorkeling and wading searches involving the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District, MPRB, two MPRB contractors and the DNR. Lake Harriet will be added to the Infested Waters List for zebra mussels, with the provision that it may be removed from the list if future surveys continue to show no zebra mussels in the lake. “We’re grateful that no zebra mussels were found during the extensive dive, snorkel and wading search of Lake Harriet,” said Heidi Wolf, DNR invasive species unit supervisor. “Strong partnerships and interagency cooperation are key, and we thank the Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District for their ongoing efforts. “While we regret that Lake Harriet will be added to the Infested Waters List because one zebra mussel was confirmed, we’re hopeful that the lake may be removed from the list if future searches continue to show no zebra mussels in the lake,” Wolf said. DNR invasive species specialist Keegan Lund said Lake Harriet will be carefully monitored the rest of this season and next year, but no treatment is necessary at this time. Lund said individual zebra mussels sometimes die after they are brought into a new lake, before they become established. “There is a common misperception that zebra mussels are everywhere and that their spread is inevitable. The reality is, of Minnesota’s 11,842 lakes, fewer than 250, about 1.8 percent, are listed as infested with zebra mussels. More Minnesotans than ever before are following our state’s invasive species laws,” Lund said. “People spread zebra mussels, and people can prevent their spread.” Whether or not a lake is listed as infested, Minnesota law requires boaters and anglers to: Clean watercraft of aquatic plants and prohibited invasive species. Drain all water by removing drain plugs and keeping them out during transport, and Dispose of unwanted bait in the trash. Some invasive species are small and difficult to see at the access. To remove or kill them, take one or more of the following precautions before moving to another waterbody, especially after leaving infested waters: Spray with high-pressure water. Rinse with very hot water (120 degrees Fahrenheit for at least two minutes or 140 degrees Fahrenheit for at least 10 seconds). Dry for at least five days. People should contact an area DNR aquatic invasive species specialist if they think they have found zebra mussels or any other invasive species that has not already been confirmed in a lake. More information is available at www.mndnr.gov/AIS. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Meterman
      I fish the big water of Minnesota side of Lake of the Woods almost exclusively and purchased my boat with what I will call "truck suspension" shock absorbing seats at the helm (first row).   In the waves of LOW, these will bottom out and your back still takes a pounding.   I am planning to replace the helm seats (will need seats, pedestal and base) with one of the above mentioned shock absorbing pedestals next spring.   My boat does have high sides so will need a taller pedestal. Looking for others to comment on their experiences with these.   Thanks.
    • Meterman
      I have typically used the back reeling feature more for letting out line when trolling or jigging.   When fighting a fish, I let the drag take care of business.   I guess it is just a pain to now get used to no back reeling on a new reel . . . may have to switch to another brand?
    • JBMasterAngler
      Well, fishing wasn't very good. But the weather certainly didn't help. Fished caribou the first day, marked lots of cisco and lakers, but no bites. Planned on bluewater on Monday, but because of the wind, we took the channel to trout instead. Caught several nice bluegills and a 30 inch pike. No lakers, but I did get stuck in weeds in 35 ft of water, never had that happen before. Was going to launch at same access on wabana on Tuesday, and go to bluewater, but wind was even worse. We took a drive and went up to Larson lake. Lost a nice pike, but nothing else. Thought for sure I'd at least catch 1 splake! Survived the storm that night. Stopped at pokegama on way home and fished for a couple hours. Lost a muskie, and had a big pike break my line. My son was really excited to catch his first rock bass. It would be nice to come back someday, but it might be awhile. Caribou could be good in the winter, maybe. Oh well. Final camping trip of the year is in the books!
    • BSLNORTH
    • BSLNORTH
      Hi, I am selling my 2012 Polaris Ranger 800 XP camo. Very low miles, 1200. Full hard cab, flip out glass windshield, windshield wiper, almost like new still. Great for ice fishing, hunting and work around the house.  I also have this ad on C.L.  10,000 b/0 text me for pics, thanks.  I am located in west metro 763-two34-0837