Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Ely Lake Expert

Line color

Recommended Posts

Ely Lake Expert

I am just curious. What does everyone think about the affect of different color lines for catching different kinds of fish?

I personally won't fish walleyes with bright green line (yellow). I seriously think that is it a deterent to them when it is tyed to your hook without a liter. For other species, I guess I don't know. I always try to use clear line.

Ely lake expert

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Having grown up in pre-monofilament days, when a guy was in hog heaven if he could afford to buy Gladding braided nylon line (all strength tests in uniform black), I am one who believes line color to be largely irrelevant.

But, most of my monofilaments are clear, with the exception of Stren in a coffee brown, and Berkeley Big Game in green.

For super braids, I prefer Berkeley Whiplash in green.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Wow -- I know guys who are absolutely fanatic about line color. No opinions on this besides mine?

How about some input.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Wow -- I know guys who are absolutely fanatic about line color. No opinions on this besides mine?

How about some input.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

When fishing in faily clear water I would chose a color of line to match the color of the water to make it less visible to fish,however I have seen only a few instances where line visibitlity made a diference in catch ratios by two guys using the same baits with different line.I usually spool up with the low vis green,if I feel that the fish are likely to be spooked.Or I attach a flourocarbon leader.I have never heard of an instance of where the line was actually an attractor but I am sure that in some cases it could happen.
Hi vis color line is great for detecting bites when a tight line is a disadvantage(pitching light jigs in cross current)or as my brother has shown me fishing plastics for bass.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
KING

I definately would not be afraid of the bright green line. If you watch any of the tournament anglers you will see the bright stuff on most all of their jigging rods. Watching your line sometimes is the only way to detect light bites or bites from fish feeding up. If the bright line makes you nervous tie on a 18" flourocarbon leader. I think the application of the various types of line for the technique you are using is more important than color in most, but not all, cases.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
delmuts

i agree that line colors depends more on preference. i use solar xt as much as i can. (wish they still made it in the 2lb.) do use braided on several rods,but mostly for throwing lures and toothy critters. have a hard time seeing most of the clear lines ;helpful when fishing alot of small jigs for panfish.my son uses clear and i use solar. haven't noticed much difference in catch ratios. del

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

OK...Here is my theory on line color.

Fish have brains the size of a pea. They have no concept of line and have no idea what is on the other end. Get any good quality line be it, clear, green or purple. You can catch a fish on rope if you could feel it hit.

Colored line does have applications as to the abilty of the fisherman to detect hits by seeing line movement.

Line size usually means much more but that is over rated too for most fishing applications. Line diameter gives the lure a different action depending on the displacement properties of the line in the water.... rate of fall, ability of the bait to fight against it or the depth that your lure will travel blah blah blah.

Next topic... presenting a crawler "naturally". wink.gif

------------------
Kevin Neve's Devils Lake Guide Service
fishingminnesota.com/kevin-neve-guiding/
e-mail: kneve@stellarnet.com
Phone: 701-473-5411 or 701-351-4989
Minnewaukan ND

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fathead

Hello Yall,

When talking about line color, one factor is "what are my choices for the method of fishing and style of line I want to use"? What I mean is...
When I want to fish Lindy rigs, I am usually targeting neutral to negative fish. I firmly believe that line size and color make a difference! I usually use a 4 or 6 lb clear or lo-vis green line, like vanish or stren magna-thin.

When I am fishing slip bobbers, I took the advise from PWT Norb Wallock. He suggests to use Solar XT (Brt grn) for your main line and connect a 3'or 4' lo vis mono (4# or 6# test) for a leader. The solar xt is absolutely great for picking up line of site from the rod to the bobber and for visually reducing slack before you make your hookset. It is also great for night fishing if you have a blacklight on board (it illuminates).

For crankbait fishing, I use a 10/2 superbraid by PowerPro. It has 10# test strength in a 2# diameter. It works well for getting your cranks down a little deeper than mono and it doesnt have the stretch, so it telegraphs the fish strike much better. Not to mention if your crank is fouled with weeds, etc. But one thing I additionally do is add a 4' no-stretch leader of 10' vanish to make the presentation look more natural.

If anyone has further input of suggestions that I might experiment with let me know! I am always up for learning new and better ways!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Kevin Neve --

You make lots of good sense to me. How often we forget that fish are NOT rational, thinking beings. (Of course, if we can convince folks that fish are smart, we can excuse ourselves when we don't produce.)

One myth I particularly like is the notion fish have seen a lure so often they "know" not to strike. Hogwash!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I have to disagree with Kevin...

When it comes to Crappies and Bluegills especially, line thickness makes all the difference in the world.

2lb test will outfish 4lb, 4lb will outfish 6 lb, and so on and so forth.

Fish don't feed if things don't seem quite right...They will approach the bait, but may get leary or spooked.

Even when fish are really active, lighter line still outproduces heavy line, at least in my experience.

I fish without a leader when fishing Walleyes, and I also re-tie after every other fish...And I do lose alot more jigs...But I feel I benefit productivity that much more to make it worth my while to not use a leader on my line, and lose a couple extra jigs as a result.

Got off the topic somewhat... As far as line color, I use clear mono 99% of the time.

Loosen the drag a little and let em' play some.

Good fishing,

PCG

[This message has been edited by Pro Crappie Guide (edited 03-28-2002).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I agree with Procrappie. The fish don't know what line is or what is on the other end but they can tell that it does not look like what they are used to eating.

Before I started fly fishing for trout I didn't believe that line size or color made a difference. There is no doubt that it makes a difference with trout and my success with walleyes has also improved since I started to use the smallest diameter line possible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

For those of you who believe I said line diameter doesn't matter, re-read my post especially paragraph three (3). It just does not matter for the reasons we believe it matters. It could matter to as how your bait is presented. A fish still can feel the presence of your line through the lateral line even if they do not see it.

Most folks give to much credit to the fish. Why does a fish hit a chunk of hard plastic with 6 hooks ticking out of it?

No emperical data exists that suggest most of the myths we have in regard to catching fish and what is going on between a fishes "ears" are even remotely accurate. Something such as line lenght and diameters effect on lure depth while trolling we do know, but that tells us nothing to as why a fish reacts.

Next topic...jig color. wink.gif

------------------
Kevin Neve's Devils Lake Guide Service
fishingminnesota.com/kevin-neve-guiding/
e-mail: kneve@stellarnet.com
Phone: 701-473-5411 or 701-351-4989
Minnewaukan ND

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • monstermoose78
      Saturday is the day I will open blue lake wide open If I have to
    • opsirc
      I had too go to his face book page
    • shaneD
      my dad grew up in The Pas, my grand parents owned the avenue hotel and they had a place on Clearwater. Summers we would go up and fish and ski and such. Lots of good memories, other than the horseflies (Bulldogs). My experience was always it really didn't matter what you used, for lakers as long as it was shiny it got hit. Our technique was pretty simple, drop it to the bottom and reel is up fast. they hit hard on the way up and its clear like superior so you can see them a long way down if you have good ice. The river right out of town is good for char too.
    • Poseidon
      Yeah, ok, I'm using the 8. My drill also overheated after punching 5-6 holes in quick succession. Thanks for the responses... sorry for hijacking the thread
    • shaneD
      So I just came back from Lake Winnipeg, and the 3 feet of ice they have there and found my auger lacking. I gave up the gas auger years ago to switch to the clam plate and drill. Around here, even Bemidji where I fish the most, I have never had a problem with getting through the ice. Lake Winnipeg is a different story. Anyway, I have a 6 inch bit now, and when with drilling a couple holes side by side to deal with the big fish but thinking back to my old 10 inch strikemaster I was almost willing to deal with all the issues I had with it to have some space to wrangle a fish. Soooo, im looking at going with an 8 inch bit, with the Milwaukee and the clam plate. I know that clam had a gearbox in the past that would help with that but seems they no longer offer it. will I tear up my drill with the bigger auger? I have two 9 amp batteries  and double the torque now too so I'm figuring a few  extra holes compared to the five amps and 650inc pounds I had for the previous drill setup. Suggestions? thoughts? other than getting a gas auger, cuz that isn't happening.
    • mrpike1973
      That would make a difference now wouldn't it?  Oops my mistake I have a 6 inch just got done fishing today with 5 amp battery I got 27 holes at 19 inches of ice. I noticed the drill seemed warm after drilling 5-6 in a row but no problems. I don't have a gas auger any more but I see what the guys are saying about a power auger.
    • Pat McGraw
      Thank you.
    • Capt. Quicksteel
      If you want to get in there by snow mobile or walking over, Wolf Lake is worth a try.
    • westguy
      Same.....Even when logged in it tells me I have no permissions.
    • Pat McGraw
      Thanks all. FYI I'm located on Frazer Bay on Vermilion. Give a shout out if/when you may be on the water up there. I may give the Pike River Flowage a try tomorrow or Saturday. I'll provide a report if I go. Thanks again.
  • Share & Have Fun