Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Cooter

Symptoms of head gask failure

6 posts in this topic

My '96 Lumina has had issues with temp fluctuations, had a bud who is a good mech look at her and says I have freeze in the oil and oil in the freeze....intake gasket.

So I'm worried about head probs but guess I'm gonna dump the $450 for the intake and hope for the best. She's got 166K on her and is starting to rust - she's been so good but I hate to put a couple hundy in her and then have the head gasket or some other major bull break me.

So basically, anything to look or watch out for more upcoming probs than the head gask? - ways to separate head from intake problems with those 3.1 GM knockers....just like the 3.8s and all the rest? BTW - I can hear my old girl knock on a cold morning from inside the hut.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the oil is milky it its too late. Especially since you already metioned that it is knocking. These motors are especially sensitive to coolant in the oil. lower end bearing failure is common with coolant in the oil. Typically the 3.1's do not have head gasket issues but the oil in the coolant is a little troubling. The 3.4 liter is more prone to head gasket failure particularily in the minivans for some reason.

IMO, it is not worth investing in the intake gasket since you can already hear the signs of the motor failing. If it is in decent condition and you think it is worth it it may not be a bad idea to replace the motor with a good used one. Many salvage yards offer good warranties on there motors. Some replace all of the known gaskets that fail before you buy them. We have installed many of these over the years with no problems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wouldn't write it off just yet. Many of the 3.1 motors have piston slap noise when cold, it may be that. It depends on if this is a new knock or one that he had all along. Other than the intake problem these are quite incredible motors. I personally had one recently that had 227,000 miles and still ran great, used no oil, but knocked when first started. Always did! I have seen others with over 300,000 and still going. Its a bit hard to say without seeing it, but if the coolant hasn't been in too long, and the rest of the vehicle is ok, I guess I'd be probably inclined to go for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Macgyver, you bring up something I have been wondering about for a couple of months now. My 2000 GMC Yukon has started with the "piston slap" this winter. Sounds like a diesel for a couple of minutes when it is first started in the morning and then is fine. when I asked Mr. Goodwrench about it I was told it was piston slap and was "normal" I have 113,000 on the truck and dont plan on getting a new one any time soon. Are they blowing smoke up my skirt or is this an acceptable diagnosis of my problem. Doesnt use any oil and had the head gasket replaced at about 90,000.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd prefer to describe it as "common" moreso than normal. My own Tahoe is doing it now with 148,000. I don't like the sound of it myself. But, vehicles that have it dont suffer any ill effects from it that I know of, other than the noise. Several of our work trucks have done it for years without a problem.

Did you actually have a head gasket replaced, or do you mean the intake gasket? I've never yet had to replace a head gasket on a Vortec 5.3 or a 5.7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just went and pulled the original work order and it was a head gasket. Fortunately I discovered it before it could cause any other damage. I have done a little web surfing and see that a class action suit was filed against GM for piston slap but I am not able to determine the out come of this case.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Satchmo
      Looks like a Namakan fish.
    • CaptJohnWis
      Hit the lake before 6:00 this morning. Fishing very slow again. Lots of mayflies on the water. Water 64 degrees. Got a bass at first stop but no more of those. ABout 5 walleyes and four pike in nine hours. Quit just in time to fight the 22 MPH wind (twice what was predicted) all the way home. Fish in 25 FOW. Most on Fin-S-Fish. numerous missed bites. Yesterday hardly missed a one. Not so today.   June 27, 2017 video link    
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      Froggin is a blast! I couldn't get any topwater action Saturday but just under the surface with a spinnerbait they were crushing it. Early morning it was suspending jerkbaits on weedlines. Not a single swirl on top. 
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      The walleye bite the past couple days has gone from Boom to  almost Bust! There have been a couple of huge May fly hatches the last couple of nights along with a large Rusty Crayfish molt that have been making catching walleyes a real challenge! We are still getting some fish but now have to earn every fish! Lindys with 1/2 crawler fished VERY slow in 18" to 30" depths has been my best presentation. Cliff
    • Juan Grande
      Thanks guys!  We tried kayak fishing last year (around Labor Day I think) and the Rum was way too high.  We launched on CR 7 between Blue and Green lake and just ended up paddling the river.  Is that a good stretch for smallies?
    • ANYFISH2
      wow, that is one dark walleye!
    • ANYFISH2
      And no reports make forums no good. Participation is what makes this place great.   Do not discourage that!
    • IRISHSOBNO4
    • Chill62
      Decided to fish Big Detroit saturday with a buddy.  Had bites but my 24 v 75#  trolling motor couldn't keep me in place so that sucked.  When we left the access to go fishing I asked the young man how late they were open till so I could make it back in time to get washed since I was going to fish a different lake on Sunday morning with the nephews.  I will be here till 5:30!  Sounds good see you before 5!  Fishing sucked, Wind BLEW, RAIN SUCKED!  So we packed up at 4:30 drove to access get there around 4:40 and they are gone!  Hot on my heels is a local fishing guide and he wasn't happy also because he had the same game plan.  Was told that there would be one at Melissa till 5 pm religiously.  Got there by 4:55 and they were gone from that lake too.  I honestly don't feel comfortable enough to do a safe job washing since I don't have a pressure washer and I really don't want to spread the Zebra Mussels from lake to lake and I know it was only a few hours 5-6 but honestly whats the point of AIS being there if they don't stay till the house they are supposed to be?  There was an easy half dozen boat trailers still at the access so it wasn't like we were the only two left at the access.  
    • huskybass
      Had some fun Saturday morning crashing through the lily pads on a small metro lake.  2 fish over 5 lbs and every fish absolutely choked the bait.  All I want to do is throw top water now, haha.  Wish I had longer arms or a partner in the boat for a decent photo.