Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      1st Please Post Your Fishing Report - Then Join the NEW - Private Fishing Report Clubs   01/24/2018

      Private Fishing Report Clubs - Click Here - Post Your Fishing Report Before Joining
      1st, be sure you post a fishing report in the forums, then ask to join after you post a fishing report in your area forum. The Private Fishing Report Clubs are where folks can share private fishing information with club members who have proven they know what's going on. Fishing Report Clubs Link also in Menu above. Apply to become a member today, while it's still easy. 
  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
SpringerGuy

Dog Food Rating

Recommended Posts

SpringerGuy

A few months ago someone posted a piece about dog food ratings. I wanted to print it out and then talk to the Purina guys at the Pheasant Fest about it on Friday. I did a search for it and could not find it. I was hoping that someone could help me out?

Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SpringerGuy

I found it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Augusta

Can you post the link. I would like to read it as well. Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
311Hemi

Let us know what they have to say.

This has been discussed in the past and it has some decent points and some questionable ones. Not going to get into it but by all means don't consider this a 100% accurate test......it is the opinion of the author.

 Quote:
Hi, i've never actually posted here or even visited this site before, but i thought i'd step in and say that *i* am the original poster of this dog food grading system.

My name is Sarah Irick and i am a Great Dane owner and rescue volunteer. i am a Civil/Industrial Engineer, not a veterinarian or animal nutritionist by education or employment. i do not work for a pet food manufacturer nor am i affiliated with one. i am just an individual who is concerned about what i feed my dogs and wants to help others decide what to feed their own. i cannot remember the exact date i designed this system, though i know it's been more than a year (probably 2-3 years ago). i was concerned with the way people sometimes throw out names of "good" dog foods that maybe aren't so good, and others take their words for it. Foods that maybe used to be good before their ingredients were changed for the worse or before better options became available are still being touted by some as being super-premium and i disagree. Since many pet owners do not have the time or inclination to do as many hours of research into pet (specifically dog) nutrition as i and many of you have, i wanted an *easier* way for them to compare labels. Unfortunately it is still a bit cumbersome (sometimes 2 people calculate the same food and get different scores even) but it's better than nothing in my opinion.

Is it exact science? No. i don't claim for it to be. In fact i've had to make a couple of changes over time (which the above don't reflect) for new circumstances i've run across, such as the food that contained NO MEAT (not a special diet just one that was so cheap it didn't contain any meat at all) and needs a steep penalty IMO but still scored a decent grade on the original or the newer kibbles that contain no grain and IMO if it still has sufficient fiber and carbs then it deserves extra credit that wasn't previously reflected. Also i've gotten comments and opinions that i take seriously and incorporate if it seems appropriate.

i don't have a permanent site host for this although seeing how hugely popular it is and how widely spread without accreditation it has become perhaps i should do so. It isn't that i care so much about credit but many people will ask the questions that your posters have about my affiliations and biases, etc.

i don't officially support any one food; anywhere that i personally posted grades on specific foods it was to give an idea of where these foods fell so people didn't always have to do the math.

Sarah Irick aka fredalina If you want to e-mail me with questions or comments, you can at fredirick@hotmail.com. This is my "spam" address, so put "Dog Food Grading" in the subject line or i'll probably delete it mistakenly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
tmvikings

You should check out the great food at Costco. My dog used to get the 30- 35 dollar a bag stuff until I found the kirkland dog food at Costco, this stuff is great and he loves it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SpringerGuy

I am a long way from a Costco. I am out in the sticks.

Tried talking to the Purina guys at their booth on Friday. I got the standard politically correct answers. I feed Purina Beneful and all of my dogs to great on it.

However in that post I was looking for it did not score well at all. I even took a copy of it along, and they were not even interested in reading it. One guy later came over and flipped through the pages, but did not read anything.

I got the answer of "it's our fastest growing dog food since we introduced it about 5 years ago. A 10% growth rate every year. And Purina would not put out a dog food that was not the best out there. Beneful is highly digestable and easy on the dog's system."

It's priced right for a 25% protein dog food and easy to pick up at Wally*World. Don't know what I should do. I feel like I should change, but my dogs are doing great.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DRH1175

Deffintly change foods. It is a very bad food in my opinion. Look at the ingrediants. Ground yellow corn, chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, whole wheat flour, animal The only meat in the first 5 ingrediants is Chicken by product meal. This isn't even meat. it is the by products of chicken that us humans don't eat. Take a look once at a quaility food like Nutro, nutri source, Eagle pack. You will see Chicken meal and rice. as the first two. Chicken meal is 100% cookec chicken meat protein and rice is one of the most digestable carbs for dogs to give them energy. Look past the protein% on the bag and look at the ingredients.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bryce

Pretty sure we've established that dogs don't attain energy from carbs like humans do. Also, anytime you see the word by-product, don't assume that it an assumable ingredient. Have brought this up before but is worth mentioning again. Big trick in the pet food industry is to dip carcasses in boiling water and then into cold water. The "jelly" is then collected. Although technically a protein source, it is not assumable by dogs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
311Hemi

Another site you could read for more information is dogfoodproject.....just do a good search for it. They have a section related to reading labels that may offer some help. They also have a section related to the dog for grading system posted above and the issues they see with it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
311Hemi

Another site you could read for more information is dogfoodproject.....just do a good search for it. They have a section related to reading labels that may offer some help. They also have a section related to the dog for grading system posted above and the issues they see with it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kallista

Eagle Pack

Holistic Select® Chicken Meal & Rice Formula

24% Protein / 15% Fat / Calories - 386 kcal/cup

for puppies and dogs, there are many different types to choose from, what ever suits your dog best in Eagle Pack.. I been to 5 vets, and all of them sell Eagle, as well as ely here now too

There is a reason why they are changing

I say change his or her food as soon as possible..

I hear a lot of well my dog eats Ol'roy from wally world, hes been hunting and lived to be 15, not all dogs do well like that, hes your buddy, feed him well, he does a lot for you

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SpringerGuy

But.... if Beneful is so bad, why are all 6 of my dogs looking so good? And the vet raves about how good and healthy or puppies look. Then why is a company like Purina making a dog food that is so bad? Wouldn't the other dog food companies jump all over them in their marketing?

PoleBender

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
311Hemi

Every dog is different and some dogs will do better on one food than another. This is a debate much like any other brand debate and everyone has their own opinion. The best you can do for your partner is do your research and find a food that fits you and your partner the best.

Are some foods better than others....definitely. Which ones can be debated. I think the majority of people you will talk to will say that Old Roy's is NOT a quality food and most will not feed it to their hunting partner. Could you feed a dog Old Roy's and have your hunting partner look to be in good shape.....and have a vet say you should not change a thing? My bets are on yes.

Are all the companies out there using the highest quality products because they care about animal nutrition....not because because they care about the bottom line? My guess is no. Some of these food are cheaper to manufacture than others.

Personally Tom (and wasn't referring to your post in my above comments)....I don't like the ingredient list for the Beneful Original (see below), but thats my opinion. I would first email/call them to see what grade corn they use as that is the first thing on their list. Second...their first and most quantity protein source is from chicken by-product, not chicken meal. Follow that by corn gluten meal, flour.....non-specific animal fat...sugar. I just think there are food that provide better ingredients for my partner.....but again...thats my opinion. Read through the dogfoodproject web site, and other sites, and come to your own conclusion.

INGREDIENTS

Ground yellow corn, chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, whole wheat flour, animal fat preserved with mixed-tocopherols (form of Vitamin E), rice flour, beef, soy flour, sugar,

Also....I do prefer to find foods with probiotic's (bacteria) in the ingredients. I think this helps with issues such as ear infections. Non-sweetened yogurt is beneficial to dogs because of the probiotic's it contains.

This would be an ingredient list from a food I personally prefer:

Chicken Meal, Ground Yellow Corn (high quality corn source), Chicken Fat (Preserved with Natural Mixed Tocopherols), Pork Meal, Dried Beet Pulp, Ground Brown Rice, Anchovy & Sardine Meals, Brewers Dried Yeast, Corn Gluten Meal,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SpringerGuy

Thanks Hemi, I appreciate the opinion & thoughts on this subject.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
David Kasten

Tom I have two hunting dogs 1 is a bluetick coonhound and the other is a black lab, both super athletic dogs and i like you cannot afford to pay 50 bucks a bag. Me and all the guys i run my bluetick with feed our dogs a food called hi-standards. It is around 16 bucks a bag they do not sell this is stores the only guy that sells in your half of the state would be ron waltz in st. cloud. Another food iv heard a lot of guys feed is diamond i dont know much about it but the guys that feed it love it, this is also about 17-18 bucks depending on who you get it from. All dog foods come in different fat-protein ratio. I feed my dogs a lower fat- lower protien level in winter (because they are not as active therefor do not need much more) then in summer and fall. Be careful not to feed your dog a super high protien food if they are not very active, i know a guy that had his dog dog last week her kidneys shut down because to high of a protein level in her food and she wasnt getting enough exercize to burn it off.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SpringerGuy

St. Cloud is like 3 hours away from me. How large of a bag is the Diamond at that price. I'm buying a 40lb bag in wall*mart for 23.00. I'm not too worried about the price, but I live with someone who is. I'll need to spend some time researching.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
shaky legs2

I would second the vote for Diamond. I hunt Pheasants exclusively and pretty hard (like just about every week October - January). I hunt Minnesota, and both Dakotas and many trips are for 3-4 days in a row. I hunt springers and have never had a dog [PoorWordUsage] out on me. During the hunting season I feed them the high protein brand (forget the name but I thing it is sporting dog -maroon bag) and in the off season they get the regular brand (green bag). I also give them a sugar cookie or two during the day and plently of water. I get the Diamond brand from my local elevator (Delano, Mn.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
tealitup

So, when I got my puppy I was giving it Science Diet - but wanted to stay away from Chinese made products. Now, I have started feeding Nutri Sources which I can only find at Gander Mountain. Although, not a big problem - would you recommend this food?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
David Kasten

why spend that much money on a bag when you can get something just as good for half the price or less? I have two bags of the highstandards stuff and plan on trying out the diamond food when i run out. One thing diamond has going for them is its pretty easy to get, a lot of feed stores and elevators sell the stuff plus a little of joes around the state sell it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fishtrap3

We feed Diamond also. Pup is doing very well on it..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Augusta

I feed IAMS, does anyone know if that brand is any good? Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tom7227

I looked at that website of the lady that did the rating - I think maybe she's a bit goofy. The dog food gets extra points if it contains fruit, loses points for this and that. I have deicded that Science Diet is out, but not based on anything this lady said.

I was at Pheasant Fest and there were some guys there selling the Native dog food. They were giving out coupons for $5 off at Chuck and Don's. Does anyone have any experience with this stuff? $30 for 40 lbs and it doesn't start off with "corn' as the first incredient.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
David Kasten

Hey Tom i talked to a couple guys i know the run hounds for coyotes,bobcat,coon,etc. Another food that was recommended that you look into is Black Gold that is also sold at a lot of feed stores and elevators

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • nytelyter
      how is the ice should i bring four wheeler or is half ton truck good to go??  
    • nytelyter
      So l@@king to saturday. i will be sporting the new otter lodge xt pro modded out and way ready to go will have my 8" lazer on the new 40v strikemaster and may bring the 3hp power head as well. my girlfriend will be coming and she is stoked for the fun time. thanks everyone for the awesome prizes and also the pre-fishing. will be checking the forum before saturday for updated info. has anyone volunteered to bring a garbage can or two along with some bags yet?? if not i can handle that i will bring some chips and a pan of mounds bars for lunch oh some "pie"  this event always has to have "pie"                         ' Born to Fish. Forced to Work  
    • trro0901
      Just hauled our shack out last weekend, didn't get a bite.  Graphed some, but no takers, could have just been the weather, or tactics, ha.  Haven't really fished the lake much in the winter, figured we should seeing it's a half mile from home. 
    • nytelyter
      i do plan on being there and hopefully a bit early.  
    • Fathom
      Set up deeper on rock reef for the rest of the weekend and only managed one fish (26" eye), missed a couple others. We wanted to stay deeper due to all the traffic on the lake. We did enjoy a good time at Fishing for Ducks, we saw a nice walleye pulled through the ice but it only measured 27.5". Talk about a bummer for that guy!
    • Jarrid Houston
      Roads to the islands always need to be taken very cautious and I would encourage going with someone who knows the area..  I believe they were shutting down the highway H extension due to this recent weather we just got?  Plenty of fish and opportune situtations in the bay.
    • cookie129
      Another crazy busy weekend is in the books. I really enjoy giving out my fishing/what's happening on the lake reports but finding the time has been tough. To say its a grind is a understatement.
       I can tell you again as the season winds down I'm never ready for it to end, as I truly love being out there in my trucks, moving houses, plowing the  hillmen highway, giving advise, helping other fishermen when they do something silly, Driving into a snow bank, dropping there gun down a hole or any other important object like there keys. Every year all the workers seem to get a little grumpy as fighting mother nature, going from sun up to sunset takes a toll physically and mentally. It also seems I ruffle a few feathers every year and its never my intent  so I have to chalk it up as a long season. If I stepped on anyone's toes it sure was not planned or intended as all most every day plan a turns to plan b and c. Mother nature dictates where I go sometimes as well as any plowed roads that can make our job easier. The cookie shuffle worked very well this year as I tell everyone that gets lost in my maze of trails. I'm not a road engineer.
       Man did we get overwhelmed with wheel house's this past weekend, any fish coming from southwest had to go threw a gauntlet of hooks to find my fishermen.
       I had two wheel house's  that I set up at the end of the hillmens highway and was surprised how bad they did. I guess I should of went south not east? The nw road has gotten to much to maintain, there's one lone house out that way that will need a new trail made .
       Its all started Thursday as jonnny boy and I prepped for the weekend with Joe, Zack, Adam and   his crew arriving fro florida. Zacks birthday wish was fishing red lake, they had a blast. They went to westwind where they enjoyed a fish fry, plus they took home a few fish with a couple even getting a ride in florida fish house as we moved a small distance to put it on fresh ice for there last night sunday. Last year when they came we landed on the elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie mother load? I think  they had dreams for a year of repeating that. Every year is different and again this year was no exception.
       Ben who proposed in old Minnesota to Shawna 8 years ago were in old Minnesota with there two adorable kids. Louie the fishing machine and his little sister Willa plus there friend Nelli.
       They had a blast also with Shawna getting a elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie to boot. They also managed to take home a nice batch of upper red lake walleyes.
       Hunter and his two buddies were in north Dakota. It was slow but they also managed to take home a batch of fish.
       Charlie and Rizzo were in montana , They were very serious about there fishing and went home with there 8.
      Jeromy and his gal were in north Carolina Saturday, sunday . They also managed to get there 8.
       Sunday was a very tough day as we had all 5 houses re rented. I was planning on moving all of them so we battled mother nature the whole time as a ne wind with 2 inches of snow made it impossible to see. At one point I was getting sea sick as I struggled to see, With the sky, horizon and the lake all the same color. wow what a struggle.
       It took us  7 1/2 hours but we got every thing cleaned, moved.
       Mother nature has given us another bout of snow so tomorrow I will let every one know how the houses did the last two days as its time to check the fluids and fire up the fleet
       
    • nickeleye
      Figured I should report back... I fished prime time on Saturday morning and Saturday evening. No action. It didn't help that I forgot to grab the vexilar on the first outing, but it didn't help to have it on the second outing either! ha! Marked a few but couldn't get them to bite. Used a GPS chip to punch some holes over structure, but when I came back with the vexilar, they weren't quite as deep as I hoped. Thanks for the pointers BrianF
    • LucasLongCaster
      Around this time last year this thread was started by @Royal_Dutchman. I got my trip planned for April but by the look of the extended forecast it's not looking to promising, especially compared to where it was at last year on Feb 23rd. 
    • osok
      Been a brutal hard water season for me as well, figured it was a continuation of my fall fishing luck. 
  • Share & Have Fun