Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Giant_Jackpot

So...... Where is the border?

4 posts in this topic

I’ve done a search on this site and found a few older discussions on the topic and it looks like the consensus was that the DNR or MNR could pick the rule that best suited the conditions. Some say right down the middle of the river others say it is the middle of the navigable channel. Any recent opinions different than that? Below is a note a friend of mine sent to the DNR today. I doubt they will respond since they would not want to be on the hook if it became a legal situation……

Quote:

A group of us go to the Rainy River/Lake of the Woods to fish each year and we always come up with the same question.

What defines the US and Canadian border on the Rainy River? Some of us think its defined as the "navigatable channel" while others define it as "shore to shore". In most places on the river they are both the same but there are areas where the definition of "navigatable channel" and "shore to shore" can be extremely different.

The reason I ask is that a few years ago a boat in our group was ticketed by the Canadian DNR for being in Canadian water. The DNR person said that the border was defined as "navigatable channel". By that definition they were guilty of being in Canadian water but if applying the "shore to shore" definition they would have been in US water. The people were in an area that is very popular with Americans and the Canadians could have chosen to ticket a number of boats. We had always deemed this as American water as we had used the "shore to shore".

I know that is always better to error on the side of safety but we were wondering if Minnesota uses the same terms to define the border and where can I find the "official" document that defines it.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just look at the Mn. Shoreline and make sure Im closer to that than the Canadian side.

There is a grey area and if they want to nail ya in that grey area they probably could. I havent seen the Canadians be real unfair about the line but I know a few guys who have had issue with the line the Canadians lazered down the river. Just dont play out in the middle too much and you will be fine. Fishing last week was way better away from the middle anyways. Current was very strong in the middle 2/3rds of the river. 14-8' is where most of our fish came from.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks NL. I think the best thing to do is keep an eye out for the MNR and pick up and go if you see them coming

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you know who they are. Oh and at times they can be pretty slick. In the spring you can usually waych all the boats get out of the middle to the Mn. side more but in the fall there isnt usually enough boats for that. I just make sure I dont give them any reason to come by my boat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • tcwin
      Not sure if some mentioned Sierra Trading Post. I buy my Costa's there and have always paid right around $50.00 for them.  Sign up for email and get a discount flyer, they always are having a sale and free shipping etc.    
    • maxpower117
      All eyes on the forks now. Weather looks perfect for a steady slow release. Minimal impact this year but I'd bet this weekend and next week will be the worts of it. 
    • schucanoe
      The MN DNR website shows the Big Fork just opening up upstream and the Little Fork open for about half of it's length upstream. Flows are high but have been higher in past years so may not be high enough to cause problems. I would think within 4 -5 days one will be able to tell how severe the spring rise in the Forks will be. If the upstream gages begin to drop soon it will be a good sign as it will indicate the big push from upstream is past.
    • mrpike1973
      Got a Abu Garcia veritas medium heavy 7 foot rod paired with a revo sx 7:1 I believe ratio. Will this be a good spinner bait rod? I might play with some bigger bass jigs or 3/8 jig heads with swim tails. I have 2 other rods 7 foot mediums, one for cranks moderate fast action with Revo winch,  and the other all around use a veritas with revo s 6:4 also. tired of having to retie all the time. Should this work? I don't do the big football jig things much. and have spinning rods for wacky and small jigs. Just trying to get a better system worked out Thanks guys. Lots of help on here.
    • Wanderer
      Yes, good report!   I travelled 210 from Brainerd to Duluth and see the ice is getting dark but has only pulled away from shore in a few areas.  I didn't see anyone fishing but did see a few auger piles on the ice.  The piles suggested maybe 10-12 inches of ice.  It'll go soon.   One thing for sure is the stores are DONE with the ice season.  I picked up some custom rods from Northlander and want to put reels on em for this weekend but can't find any in lines anywhere!  Called around too.  Same story - all packed away to get the summer stuff out.