Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
FishCat

McCarthy Lake, Eagan

18 posts in this topic

Anyone fish McCarthy Lake in Patrick Eagan Park? Does it hold bass? I was down there for the first time this weekend and it was beautiful. I've never heard anyone even mention it before. There were a few fait trails that lead down to the water, but otherwise, there wasn't much evidence that folks fish there. So I'm thinking it's one of those spots people don't want to share, or it's not really a good fishin' hole to begin with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The best way to find out is to go there a few times. I've never been there, but I'd just try it out. If anything you'll get some good solitude while still close to home.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's shallow and prone to frequent Summer and Winterkills. I figure this hot Summers's low water would've killed off most fish. On high water years fishing may be good but I haven't fished it for years now. Used to be some nice bass, losta bullheads and hybrid sunnies. But you never know until you try again. More or likely it's probably only a bullhead & minnow pond now.

Most of the lakes in Eagan probably have overturned already. They heatup and overturned quicker than most lakes in MN that I notice due to the weather. Fishing is pretty slow but you may still find a few bass active. Last week I caught a tiny Smallmouth Bass in a Eagan lake that probably wasn't suppose to have them. Maybe illegally stocked by locals.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

never tried that lake but I live in Eagan if you want to find a nice bass lake try Schwanz in trapp farm park i've caught a lot of nice sized bass out of that lake it also has crappie and perch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have read several posts about schwanz lake, so i fished it a few times this summer. i was using a fly rod to target bass and had really good luck doing so. one thing though, you can catch a ton of fish, but will rarely catch anything bigger than 8-10".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Try walking along the path around schwanz when the bass are spawning it's so cool there are many 4-6 lbers in there that roam the shoreline during the spawn. I have also got 2 fish over 20 inches this summer both released using senko's and other plastics.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The city of eagan site lists the lake as only having bullheads.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SkunkedAgain has it right. If you're wondering, grab the pole & a small tackle box & spend an hour hitting it. I've found a couple of gems in Eagan doing this. Of course, I've also wasted several hours, too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just moved to Eagan and haven't had much opportunity to fish this summer. I was only able to get over to Fish Lake a few times actually. I'd love to spend a lazy afternoon testing out new lakes each outing, but I just don't have that kind of time. After my traditional Bass Opener lake, I try 1 or 2 new spots a year. Sometimes I find a gem, but usually not. So it's helpful to gain insight on my local ponds from the folks, like you, who fish them also. You dig?

From the looks of it, McCarthy is a beautiful spot, but will probably not hold much bass. I was wary when I wasn't able to spot a single tiny fish from shore. I've also read on the city web site that it's only 4' deep.

But I'm intrigued by Fishing High's report on Schwanz. I've seen it mentioned here before. I have no idea where that one is, but I'm going to look it up for next summer. Many 6 ponders, huh? I'm thinking you might actually be high, but I'm going to try it out. Thanks for the tip. Thanks eveyone!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm telling you Ive caught a couple 5's and a bunch over 3 using buzz baits, spinner baits, and a lot of different plastics. It's good early in the year and later in the year when theres less weeds most lakes in eagan get weeded out in the summer. But I'm not high when I tell you that I've seen a couple of fish protecting the beds during the spawn bigger then the 5 pounders I have caught. It's located right behind trapp farm park off of wilderness run rd.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Schwanz lake is where I cut my teeth bass fishing when I was a little guy. Me and my buddies would always bike down there to fish with out rods across the handle bars, good times... When I used to fish it, we caught some good fish, but I wouldn't say it was phenominal. It actually had a pretty bad winter kill about 3-4 years ago now which also really put a damper on the size fish that used to be in there. The last time I went, which was probably 2 or 3 years ago, I only caught little fish. Sounds like things are starting to change though.

P.S. Fishing high.. be careful about giving a ton of info out on places where you are catching quality fish like that. I could care less becuase I don't fish there anymore, and its nice that you are giving info to people who want it, but more people read these forums than you can imagine..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I concur

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will say this about Schwanz for the fisherman who are looking to explore it.

It has mostly small bass & sunnies. Some small crappies. That is the truth. At some point of time the lake was reclaimed or sprayed with retenone & re-stocked a few years ago. Thats why you see lotsa small bass yearlings. The panfish are stunted due to abundance. The algae blooms gets pretty bad in late Spring through Summer even though it has been sprayed.

10 to 15yrs ago Schwanz use to have some really nice big bass but today most are small. The lake needs time maybe another 2 to 4 years to mature. There are however a few nice bass left here & there but nothing to brag about. Most are small barely 1lb or over. That is my honest opinion about the lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my experiences with schwanz are dead on what andy is saying.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm like you St.Croix you have probably seen me down, use to fish there a lot 2-3 years ago then I got my license and was able to drive up north. It's not my honey hole I barely ever fished it I just wanted him to get a little insight on where he can find some better keepers. Your right about the winter kill but there are still biggins in there. I'll be a little more careful giving out info next time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"I barely ever fished it." So, it's really a bum tip then? That's just plain, un-helpful.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I barely fish it anymore... I have fished many times I was giving you a lake you could try that I know has bass,crappie,perch instead of going to a lake that is 4 feet deep and you might see minnows and maybe catch a bullhead schwanz you will have better luck I guesse that was my tip...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's cool. I really do appreciate the advise man. Really. And I will try it out. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • metro fisherman
      wisconsin has lots of good stream trout fishing near river falls and ellsworth as well...Its also under 2 hours away too
    • monstermoose78
      That is a good sized jake
    • ANYFISH2
      Well,  it was a typical morning hunting turkeys.     This season has been a bit different for me than past years. I was hunting "new" property that i didnt know well and I had neglected to apply for my typical A season tag.  In turn, I planned on the first 2 seasons were devoted to the kids.  I did my usual early morning roost gobble runs and late afternoon field checks.  These confirmed we had birds around, but rarely did they use the field. So a "deep" woods hunt would be in order.  To keep this short, the goal of getting the kids out and a bird was met with frustration and missed chances.  The boy only wanted to go the first 2 days and the daughter i got out for one morning sit.  That was it for 2 weeks,  but i continued to get up early and try and then continue my long range scouting. Wednesday comes and it is the start of "my" season.  Took the morning off of work, and to the blind I go.  Beautiful icy cold weather greeted the start of the hunt.  The birds were quiet on the roost, but made themselves know once on the ground.  However, like most 3 seasons, the toms were locked in on the real hens.  They would pass by me a couple times but never come to my set.   Work beckoned me Wednesday afternoon and Thursday.   Friday, back out to the blind.  Once again no gobbling on the roost? Strange. Then again about 6 birds on onthe ground the SE of me gobbling away.  They would repeatedly work to about 70 yds of me back and forth.  Again, never leave the real hens.  His would go on till 10 am.  The things go quiet.  I would spend the 3 hrs, walking calling,  waiting and repeating.  Not one gobble!  At 2 pm i make my way back to the blind for the afternoon, took a little nap.  As i awake i have a splitting headach.  I try and fight through it, planning on moving the blind to where the birds seem to spend time after fly down.  The headache is too much, i just pack up a go home at 6.  I would sleep the rest of the night.   Saturday morning arrives, feeling refreshed.  In the blind i go, the birds actually gobbled on roost this morning!  They are some distance away.  I keep thinking i needed to go to the SE and sit by a tree and wait.  But i fear i may bump hens or quiet birds at that time of morning.  So i sit tight and wait.  Like clockwork, after flydown the gobbles get closer and closer.  Again, stopping about 70 yds away, not wanting to leave the live hens.  This morning, i decide to call softer, but more often.  Soon i get to talking to a live hen.  Lo and behold she works her way closer and the gobblers follow! Now they get closer, but not nearly close enough. I hear a new gobble directly behind me, it is very close, so I ready myself.  Well, it seems this new gobbler has made the hens and original gobblers retreat back over the ridge.  I call, but they will not get closer.   Soon i hear some rustling, so i peak out the NE window, i seen 3 turkeys working towards my set about 45 yds out. Sit back down and ready myself.  Seconds later i see 3 jakes step out onto the trail. Thier mind is already made up as they work quickly to the decoy.  One is in half strut the whole time.  I Look them over and decide i will take the half strutter, looks to be the biggest bird.  Took some time for them to separate to give me a clean shot. Jake is down. 19.09lbs  5" beard  2/16 & 3/16 spurs.    
    • curt quesnell
      40 inch pike are pretty common at Zippel Bay this time of the year.  The Ice Out Pike Derby at Zippel Bay is well attended again this year.....I talked to Nick Painovich about pike, the opener and other stuff I was wondering about......Here is the short dockside interview
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Only 39 degrees in the Pike River mouth yesterday! That is usually warmer then the main lake. Cliff