Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Wingmaster

Heaviest Whitetail Bucks?

23 posts in this topic

I was wondering what some of the heaviest whitetail bucks people get in different parts of the state. I hunt near Aitkin and we seldom see a buck that dresses out over 200 pounds. I know that the NE part of the state seems to have some really heavy deer, but I am not sure about the Southern part of the state. Anybody have and photos of some of their heavier deer to put on hear. I do'nt know about you guys, but I like seeing the big bodied bucks even more than the slender racked 10 pointers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The heaviest whitetail ever taken was a buck shot by Carl Lenandor in 1926 in Minnesota (I remember reading an article about it last year before rifle opener-I think it was somewhere in St. Louis county?). It had a dressed weight of 405 lbs, and was conservatively estimated to have a 500 lb live weight.

A buck shot in Maine, by Horace R. Hinkley, in 1955, had a dressed weight of 355 lbs, with a live weight estimated at 488 lbs. This deer is in one of Gary Clancy's White-tailed deer hunting books. It is huge.

Here is a cool recollection from that buck from Maine Fishing and Outdoor Magazine:

Maine's Record Buck: The Whole Story

by R.G. Bernier

For unexplainable reasons even to Horace, he never moved or made a sound. Something within (a gut feeling most successful hunters have learned to trust) told him there was more action to come. No sooner had that thought passed when the buck of any hunter's dream was sneaking directly towards Horace.

By the time your eyes light upon November's column, this buck hunter will have already buried himself deep into the wilderness of Maine. Hopefully, an oversized set of tracks will be laid out before me yearning to be followed.

My expectation is to be hunting the giant buck that eluded us last fall. He undoubtedly will rival the state record in regards to weight. The Berniers' goal is to catch up to this behemoth and end his career by the only fitting way we know - a projectile fired from a Bernier-held rifle.

Each fall, the annual gathering of the red coats brings on a renewed enthusiasm and expectation. As groups of hunters find their way to their traditional hunting camps, talk of big deer abounds. The anticipation of meeting up with the buck of your dreams fuels the desire as you encroach upon his domain.

One such buck in Maine's rich deer-hunting history met and surpassed even the wildest dreams of a 59-year-old hunter back in 1955. Horace R. Hinckley did what no other hunter has been able to match since, by shooting the heaviest whitetail buck on record within the state of Maine. In fact, Hinckley's buck places second in all of North America, only to a Minnesota buck shot in 1926 by Carl Lenandor. Carl's buck topped the scales at 402 pounds dressed.

The events surrounding the taking of this enormous animal are Horace's own words, excerpted from the August 1969 issue of Outdoor Life. I certainly would not want you to think I had any first hand knowledge, seeing as I was nothing more than a mere twinkle in Pop's eye when this momentous occasion occurred.

Little did Horace know as he struck off that morning that he was about to embark on a whitetail record that would stand for forty-three years. Days off for a lumber worker came only on holidays and during inclement weather. Vacations were out of the question, especially to go deer hunting. The Hinckleys hunted when they could, and because of expected rain on the first Saturday of deer season, they jumped at the opportunity to hunt.

Trophy hunting as we view it today had no bearing on the Hinckley mindset. They hunted deer out of enjoyment and to lay up sweet tasting venison for the coming winter.

Horace, his wife Olive, their son Philip and his wife Madeline traveled 60 miles from their Augusta home to hunt Northwest Bingham. The area is located on the western side of Fletcher Mountain. Once reaching the desired location, the elder Hinckleys hunted an old tote road for the first hour. Due to the lack of fresh deer sign, they stopped to ponder their next move.

While talking it over, a jeep approached. The driver was the foreman of a local logging operation who offered to take them to the end of a remote, almost undriveable road where he had seen lots of fresh sign two days prior. At the end of this two track, the Hinkleys made their way up through a winter beech valley encompassed on both sides by rising mountainous terrain. By 9 a.m. they had each taken a stand a few yards apart, in what appeared to be a great spot.

They didn't have to wait long before the action started. Twenty minutes after taking his position, Horace heard a twig snap, spotted a buck and fired. Fortunately for him, he completely missed. Within five minutes his wife's rifle echoed, only to be followed by her excited voice yelling for Horace to come see her nice buck. For unexplainable reasons even to Horace, he never moved or made a sound. Something within (a gut feeling most successful hunters have learned to trust) told him there was more action to come. No sooner had that thought passed when the buck of any hunter's dream was sneaking directly towards Horace. It only required one shot from his .30-06 to put this monster down for the count.

As astounding a morning as it was, there would be much more excitement to come before darkness fell on this day. Quickly realizing the two deer lying before them were more than they could handle, the couple started back to retrieve help. Not finding his son at the vehicle, they drove to his brother Ralph's house a short distance away.

Approaching the kill site with Ralph to help in the dragging chores, a six pointer was jumped and taken by Horace's brother with one quick shot. Instead of easing the burden, Ralph only added to it with the third Hinckley buck. Once the two men had finished getting the six pointer and Olive's big buck out, they jubilantly spotted Philip making his way toward them.

By now, the events thus far would have been more excitement than any hunting family could have expected in several lifetimes, but there was more good news. Philip's wife had shot a spikehorn, and during the dragging process to get her buck out, a big 200-pound plus ten pointer materialized. Philip made the shot count, and thus gave the Hinckley family five bucks in the space of one hunting morning. The story should end here once Horace's mammoth buck was laboriously hauled out, but it doesn't.

It was three days before a scale large enough to handle a buck of this proportion could be found. Once this great buck was hoisted up in front of several witnesses, including state sealer of weights, Forrest Brown, the giant deer pulled the scales to a whopping 355 pounds. It was calculated that Hinckley's buck had an approximate live weight of 488 pounds. Several measurements were then taken which included: neck girth - 28 inches, body girth behind forelegs - 47 inches, greatest girth - 56 inches, and a total length from antler tip to rear hoof of 9 1/2 feet.

Because of the constant influx of inquisitive viewers, Horace was unable to butcher his buck. To add to his dilemma, the sheer weight of his buck after six days of hanging collapsed the barn roof. When the animal finally reached the freezer plant the next day, it weighed almost 100 pounds less. A cloud of doubt now hung because of the unsuspecting discrepancy to the original weight. Due to the length of hanging time and the amount of trimming Horace had to perform since shooting his now famous deer, it was determined that shrinkage could easily have diminished the weight of the buck.

Unfortunately, and not without much difficulty, it took Horace over a year to have his buck validated as the heaviest ever recorded in the state. To you who think a buck of Hinckley's status is a thing of the past, and a record that may never be broken, I need only to remind you of Mark Maguire and his 70 homeruns. I, for one, know that a buck of that caliber not only exists, but I am also in hopes of dethroning the reigning king with the taking of him.

I can visually see him in the recesses of my mind, and perhaps this buck will become - the buck of my dreams.

********

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please tell me you copy and paste.

We have shot deer in Southeast MN that easily go over the 275 live weight. I shot a 2 1/2-3 1/2 year old 8pt. last year that weighted 192lbs. dressed. It took 4 guys to drag it 300 yards. He had a stomach full of apples, corn and soy beans. He really was eating well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That wasn't committed to memory, if that's what you are asking grin.gif

I popped open Clancy's book this morning to see that but the thread triggered a memory from reading that story about the MN deer last November. Probably looked like a Hereford beef bull it was so thick!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My heaviest SE Minnesota buck. We weighed it the next day on an old spring scale and it said 210 lbs. I thought it was more, but then I think it is pretty common to over estimate weight.

342053.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone know where to find pics of say the state record or other bruisers?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've shot a couple that went just shy of 200. My biggest to date is 235 lbs fully dressed out. He was a late October buck and was a real bruiser. I shot another nice buck a couple of years ago during the muzzleloader season. He had a large framed body but only weighed 165 lbs. Chasing all them does must take a lot out of them. When I pulled the hide off he didn't have an ounce of fat on him.

JEV

Deer13.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've shot a couple around 180 & they were big deer, long, but not the real bruisers. I'm guessing them both at 3 1/2, but am not sure, maybe only 2 1/2. I'd guess most 2 1/2 year-olds are in that 140-165 range. Very few yearling bucks will weigh more than about 130, most less.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

4 years ago in WI, I shot a decent buck, nice spread but a skinny rack. Thought maybe it was a 3 1/2 year old, but the body was huge, and he was a lot grayer than normal on the face. Everyone in camp was guessing a young deer that should've walked, but I felt it's body was to big for a young deer...

4 days after shooting him, he weighed 198 dressed. When I cut him up, there was not enough fat on him to fill a coffee cup. We have a rule in camp, if you shoot a buck you have to mount it. I questioned mounting him as his rack was skinny, but he did have a nice spread, both brow tines were broke off, so in essence he was a 20" 6 point. My buddy asked when I was going to get a 6 point that big again? and a rule is a rule. So I took him in. When at the taxidermist, the DNR stopped by to get jaw samples so they could age some harvested deer... when I got my slip back, the biologists estimated him to be 7 1/2 years old. He was on his way down instead of up.

That being said, I agree it takes years to put pounds on as well as inches. That was the biggest (body) deer anybody I hunt with has taken.

I know 200 pounders are out there, but many 180 pound bucks are touted as being 200 pounds... just like a lot of 28" walleyes become those magical 30"ers.

Good Luck!

Ken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wasn't going to post this picture because I know that there are much bigger deer out there but nobody is posting pics of their bruisers. This was last years bow kill dressed out at 204.

204lbpics033.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tippman, thats one very fine buck you took there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's a big deer, he sure was fat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My Mom shot a deer north of Bovey in the early '60's with a .410 that my Dad brought to the neighbors cattle scale to weigh. Just a tad over 230.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's a lot of deer for a .410. I trust she must have made a very good shot. Of course I supposed if it was really close it would still pack quite a wallop.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Luck had some to do with it. She was close, about 30 yards and the slug went between 2 ribs on the way in, right through the heart and came apart on a rib on the other side. No exit wound!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my family has have hunted in the ne part of the state since the 60's. It is has been very commen that the 8 pointers weight the most we rarely weigh our deer but the ones that I can remember were around 180 to 190. no bruiser since I started hunting in the 80's. My dad tells a story of how they helped a guy get a 8 pt out of the woods by quartering it because they couldn't drag it. he got one back in the 70's that went over 200 the scale they used bottom out at 200. my 14pt non typ went 189.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have shot one buck, 13 pt non-typical that was 212lbs dressed. I also shot a doe that was 180. I have shot lots of deer and to only have 1 over 200. Its like the majic number to reach in this area.

I have seen one about 10 years ago that I bet was pushing 300 lbs. It was the weekend before deer hunting. I seen it in the field about a mile from where I hunt, there was 3 of us in the truck, staring at this monster, it was dark out and it was about 60 yds in the field. It wasnt to afraid of us, we sat there and watched it for a good 10 minutes, then it walked in the woods. I seen it during deer hunting briefly. I was walking to my stand in the afternoon, it jumped out from the creek bed, at up over a ravine faster then I could get my gun aimed at it, I ran to get a shot, but it was gone! You just dont see deer like that at all, it was my once in a life time thing, and I blew it frown.gif .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shot one on a Metro Bowhunt a few years back that was 200 even. I had to drag it about 20 feet to gut it. It was all I could handle by myself.

Don't you love those commercials where the guy has his bow in one hand and the bruiser in the other dragging it out by himself?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been part of a very special hunting group in NW MN that has been hunting together since 1942 and we keep records of wieght etc thats 64 years. The heaviest buck our group has taken was 252# field dressed and the #2 buck was 250# field dressed. The largest set of antlers scored 198 5/8 non-typical and is displayed at the fargo scheels taken in 1951 that deer may have been the heaviest but was never weighed. The other two were taken in the mid 70's and early 80's

J

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

I shot one on a Metro Bowhunt a few years back that was 200 even. I had to drag it about 20 feet to gut it. It was all I could handle by myself.

Don't you love those commercials where the guy has his bow in one hand and the bruiser in the other dragging it out by himself?


Yes there called Texes deer. My yellow lab with antlers!!!! grin.gifgrin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My heaviest was last years 202 dressed, I have shot alot in the 150-175 range and I didnt think this was was much bigger but once on the scale we had to shorten the chain being this deer was so long... I just noticed the date was 1 year off, it shows 05 but it was take on opening day of Michigan archery season of 06.

HPIM0126.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is by far my biggest buck, shot in Wisc. weighed 193 field dressed...

190buck1-med.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My Grandfather shot a 14 point in 1958 by Hinckley that weighed 290 dressed he is 91 now and still has the rack hanging on the wall.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • ZachD
      I guess I will have to call the dnr about the couple spots I am in question of. Ones a darn and you can easily pick them off all day almost year round
    • Stick in Mud
      Thanks for the great report.  We fished up there all last week, and we found shiners to be the only bait we *couldn't* get bites on. Very, very strange, but by far our best bite was on crawlers.  I think our total was something like 8 fish on shiners and 80 or 90 on crawlers (between two boats).  We didn't start fishing with crawlers until Thursday, either, so all those fish came on our last two days, with the windier Thursday being best.
    • Dale S
      Thanks guys for the informative replies. Can you also comment on the walleye limits?
    • noska
      Hey Barefoot on the main lake or current areas? 
    • jkrash
      a tournament-record 10-pound, 2-ounce beauty was big fish and A record 110 boats fished this year’s tourney, held out of the marina at Fortune Bay Resort Casino. 492 walleye, another tournament record, were weighed and released at this catch-and-release event.
    • Bowfin
      My daughter is shooting my 12 gauge 870 Wingmaster really good. Im looking for a nice looking, nice shooting and dependable pump shotgun for her at a decent price. I'm not liking the newer 870 Wingmasters as much as I did when I bought mine 30 years ago. I recently saw some Weatherby PA08s. Very nice looking gun which rival the looks of old Wingmasters with walnut stock, deep checkering, fairly light for $350 new. Reviews I see from 2011-2014 have me concerned a bit about hard trigger pull and shells sometimes not ejecting. Anyone have any experience or knowledge about these Weatherby pumps? If there were issues, you would think Weatherby would have fixed them by now.
    • jb426
      I did this a while back.  If you have basic carpentry skills you can do it for under $200. Here's what I did.   Get 2x8 treated board.  Cut to length of back bench.  Attach a swivel seat to board then attach board to back bench using screws and glue.   Buy two sheets of 4x8 3/4" sheeting that's rated for exterior and a gallon of deck stain.  Stain said sheets.  Cut out one for floor and one for casting deck up front (i used the front bench with a little bracing in between).  Use left over 2x8 for bracing casting deck.  You will also need one 2x4 treated board for bracing of the floor.  Install casting seat up front.  Looks good and is cheap and easy.  I used cedar stain and bought cedar colored treated lumber.  If I remember correctly I cut out the middle bench.   Only problem was it added a lot of weight so had to upgrade to 15 horse.  Sold it  a couple of years later for a $100 profit.  Just an idea.  
    • Walleye #1
        Walleyes on Leech Lake found themselves spread out but actively feeding on shiners.  A Jig and shiner or a plastic and lindy rigs with shiners and leeches were the go to presentations during the course of the week.  Somedays walleyes were wanting it dragged along which is where lindy rigs worked well and other days snapping or twitching a jig and minnow was the ticket.  So being diverse in your presentations, changing up colors and cadences, and getting away from the crowds is the ticket.     West End - Fish were found on West Goose Flats, Star Point, Grand Vu Flats, Duck Point, Pine Point, Stoney, and on some of the breaklines in Traders Bay.  Depending on the day depths changed, but it seemed the best bite was in 8-14 feet of water.  Find the shiners and you found walleyes closeby!     East End/Main Lake - Main Lake Rocks are still producing a large quantity of fish in the 20-26” protected slot, with some keepers mixed in.  Annex, Submarine, Five Mile, Pelican Island, and Rogers Point all had decent bites. Fish were typically found in that 8-12ft range on this part of the lake and finding areas with sand and boulders was the key.  Portage Bay also reported a good bite up near Federal Dam.  Look for emergent cabbage in Portage, especially on those bright and sunny days where those walleyes will look to find cover.  Pitching a jig and minnow or jig and plastic for these Leech Lake Walleyes in the cabbage is fun way to catch them.     Jumbo Perch are also showing up with the walleyes, but often times will be shallower.  Found some of our best perch bites in 6-10ft of water, with some really nice jumbos mixed in.     Jason Freed Leisure Outdoor Adventures Fishing Guide Service
    • HugeHogChaser
       Any boat restorers here in the twin cities area?  Looking to get some information and possibly a quote on a 12 foot aluminum boat. Would like benches re-done with carpeting, and possible floor work. Thanks in advance, I appreciate it!
    • HugeHogChaser
      Good evening,   i recently inherited a 12 foot aluminum boat, and I would like to re-do the interior. (Add carpet to the benches, possibly add marine grade plywood to the floor and carpet the floor as well.)   does anybody have any experience doing this, or recommend anybody that is good with this type of thing?    Trying to figure out if it's worth it to pay someone to do it, or try and figure out how to do it myself with no experience.    Anyways, thanks in advance!