Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
vister

tournament oops.

11 posts in this topic

A buddy and I were in a sportsmans challenge this last weekend. Fishing and sporting clays. At weigh in, a guy and his partner were one bass over their legal limit. Of course, they just set it aside, as they said it was their last, AND the smallest of the day. It was no big deal to the judges, but the fisherman involved in the challenge were rather irritated. Anyone else out there ever come across a situation like that? Should they have been deducted points for the illegal fish? Just curious. We managed to win it all anyways, so oh well! cool.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

should they have been deducted points, no, they should have been disqualified and be no longer able to compete in tournaments.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One bass over as in 13 fish? Or one bass over the tournament bag? If they had over 12 fish I dont think a DQ is out of line. But if they were within MN's legal limit whats the big deal? I dont fish tournaments but if its not a stated rule that you may only have X amount of fish in your livewell then they really didnt do anything wrong.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

they were not within the states legal limit. that is where they were over the limit, not tournament limits. A game warden would have gotten out the pen had he/she saw the livewell.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They violated a fishing regulation, and more than likely violated tournament rules as well. Should have been DQ'd IMO.

If I were to guess, that fish was NOT the last one they caught.

I just don't see how you'd keep more than your limit in a tourny. I know how many fish are in the livewell, approximate size of all of them, and my game plan from that point forward.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You would think the person would figure it out when transfering fish from the livewell into the tournament bag for the weight in..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was in a tourney a few weeks ago, and a boat had an "extra" fish. They were balance beaming on shore, and a few people saw and even reported it. Tournament officials didnt have any written rules handy, and the issue was basically blown off.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Should be DQ'd - otherwise everyone will do the same thing.

It's as fair as BLB's fish cage near the 169 bridge. I mean... tongue.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are in a team/partner tournament and you can have 12 total fish between you guys by state law and the tourney limit is 5 fish. You can hold 12 fish if you really wanted too, and only bring 5 to the scale. It's not the tournaments fish or official until you place it on the scales. If they handed the bag over with 6 fish in it, 1 over the tourney limit to the measurer person, then they should be DQed, otherwise, they can do whatever they want in there boat or on shore until they turn those fish over to the weigh-master person.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most tournaments do not allow you to have more then the tournament limit in your live well at any time and you can not cull a dead fish.

Also once you put your DNR limit fish in the well you can no longer cull. At least that is how I understand the MN DNR possession limit rules. Good Fishing!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been in quite a few tournament where people brought in an extra fish by accident. In cases like that.. THe largest fish was pulled from their limmit. I have never been in a tournament where someone was over the LEGAL limmit... I would assume in that case... DQ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Early Riser
      The statistics from my journal for the 2016/2017 spearing season have been compiled. I had 21 sits, on 7 different bodies of water across 3 MN counties (Cook, Washington and Hennepin). Average sit was 4.4 hours. Number of pike seen averaged 1.08 per hour. Along with some old favorites, I added some new spots and 3 new lakes to the repertoire and they ended up being new favorites.    I saw, and passed on many pike over 30 inches. I was fortunate enough to have great views of 4 muskies, and more than a few big bass. Interestingly I only saw one walleye, one bowfin and one carp. Those numbers are down.     Here are a few of my pictures from the past season. Not the best quality, but they are from an old LG slider phone.    A trio for the pan and  the days swim team (Johnson red/white and sunfish; Dennis Bertram shiner). Dave Pawlak spear. Larger pike had been attacked by a bigger fish…she was cut up and scaled ahead of the dorsal fin.      Pike, some panfish and a Kraemer 9 tine spear.      I have a few more pictures of some fish n the hole and will try to add them later when I have time. 
    • Big A
      16-18ft Aluminum Boat with 3 people fishing plus gear.   What size trolling motor is needed to keep vertical jig? 55pounds? 100pounds?   What do you use?    Thanks for input/help
    • moneyback2
      fished 2/25 on agency bay for perch.  four guys fished 6 hours and kept 40 perch.  caught alot more little ones    moved around alot
    • metro fisherman
      This ice season  has been in the books on the st croix for about a week now. I ended my year out there with a 50" sturgeon.
    • Cret Jigs
        What is working for 2 fishing buckets, ion auger & Vexlar for walking out on early/late ice?   Appreciate to hear what works for walking out for a hole hopping Crappie freak