Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Offalot

Weimaraner...Pros vs. Cons.

12 posts in this topic

I have always been thinking about getting a hunting dog but have never been able to pull the trigger so to speak. Well my wife seen a picture of a Weimaraner and she thought that it would be a good dog to have around the house. I don't know much about them and was wondering what kind of personality they are prone to have, and are they good around kids. As far as hunting goes the dog will be used for Pheasants and Grouse. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For the best grouse/pheasant/house/family dogs...Look no further than a Red or English setter wink.gif. I am biased, but they are hard to beat. I have NEVER been around a more pleasant family dog than either of my Red Setters, and they are absolutely AWESOME on grouse. Plus...They have tails!! wink.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do not own a wieme, but I have a pal that has one. His is a VERY nice dog. It's good with the kiddos and it hunts fairly well for the ringnecks. It's got a lot of energy so I'd hope you have a yard or someplace for it to get out and stretch it's legs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know anything about a Weimaraner but I would go with a German Wirehaired Pointer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Off,

I have hunted behind a couple of Weims in the past and they can be a very good dog. The individual dogs I have known were gentle, well mannered dogs, a little on the soft side for me. I would suggest that you and the wife find a breeder in the area and take a look at one in person, she may be surprised at how big they are. they are a tall rangy dog that will require a significant amount of space(yard) to raise. as far being good with kids, I have always found that to be a trait of individual dogs, not the specific breed. A dog that is around kids from puppyhood will learn how to behave around children. The dogs that have never been around kids can develop problems when exposed to them. In fact when my kids were little, my childless dog owning friends would bring their pups over for some play time to help with socilization. Just my .02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would second the notion of looking at some breeders. My neighbor has one and it is a very nice dog. Rather large, but a nice dog. Have never hunted behind it but have heard it does very well. Everybody has their own preference, find the kind you like. Good luck in the search. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My Uncle used to raise them in S/W Wisconsin... Very friendly dogs... did well on pheasant and very well on grouse. That was in the 70's into the early 80's... I remember him complaining about how they were wrecking the breed back then. He also had a hunting Irish Setter... lot's of complaining about what happened to them too. With that said....

MAKE SURE YOU RESEARCH YOUR BREEDERS!!! I can't say that loud enough. There are many breeders of pet and show Weims out there... Make sure it is from true working stock. They are neat looking animals... seem to be more methodical and a bit slower than a lot of the trial pointers out there... this bodes well for the walking hunter. As others have pointed out, they are rather large... especially the males.

As jbdragon said... you may want to look into a Setter too. Great family dogs and also beautiful on and off point. Someday in my 'old state', I may even wander over to the 'dark side' ( grin.gif) and get a pointer... I'd definitley lean Setter.

Good Luck!

Ken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Uphill, Not to start a dog war but I've got a friend that his German Wire hair can get a little aggressive around people on bikes. Or around their kennel, children or adults.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Weime's are great dogs to have. They are very well mannered dogs and are very affectionate. They are large (Up to 70+ pounds) yet are wonderful around kids. they can be territorial around someone they don't know, but just bark. They are wonderful dogs and have yet to see a bad one. Although, I would agree by saying an English Setter would be a better choice as they're smaller (up to 40 pounds), have a great temperament, yet are a VERY high energy dogs. They are great around kids, also. I grew up around the, literally. I got my first one at age 7 and have had one in the family since. And, having a little one on the way, I feel confident that there won't be any problems. You can pull their tails and ears and they'll sit there and take it. They're great for pheasants and grouse, too. I do a lot of hunting over my setter and she's wonderful. If you would like info on a breeder for setters, e-mail me at

[Note from Admin. - Please read forum policy before posting again]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Off,

Please don't attribute the behavior of your friends' GWP to the entire breed, that is just one dogs behavior problem and is not indicative of the GWP's personality in general. I don't like to see a breed get a bad rap because of 1 dogs problems. There are aggresive individual dogs in every breed, from poodles to great danes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that you shouldn't pin a whole breed on one dog. My neighbor has a Golden retriever that will bite your arm off if you get too close to him. Is that indicative to the breed? absolutely not. I'm not implying anything about anyone, but I think a lot of it has to do with the way it was raised and trained.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pros vs Cons

Pro,

Great family dog and also around kids but start early. The dogs nose is awesome and they work slow in the field which you may like. Will go at it all day long you will a break before the dog. Does not shed alot. Also very smart and does have the looks.

Cons,

The dog does have some energy so if in a kennel all day be ready to play run or work with when you get home or your home may become a racetrack! Very smart and will play you. They are soft but that can be a pro also. YOU can't be lazy and you will love this dog.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • ANYFISH2
      7/19 Day 5   Day 5 was spent celebrating my Isaacs 11th birthday!  Lots of cake and catering to him.  The exciting typical swimmimg and paddling ruled the day.  Grandma and grandpa DeZurik came up to celebrate his birthday as well.  Always nice to get both sets of grandparents together at the same time.   Fishing continued slow even more.  Still a successful night though. The birthday boy conceded his seat in the boat so grandma and grandpa cpuld join me for the evening fish trip.  My folks in all truth haven't been fishing for 2 years or more.  It was just nice to get them in the boat.   I struggled as the acting to put them on a consistent bite.  Mom as able to scratch out the biggest walleye at 17".  Dad brought home the honors of most fish caught landing a 14" and 15" walleye, 8.5" bluegill, and 2 perch as big aa his leech! I mustered up 1 small pumpkinseed.
    • ANYFISH2
      no doubt aboit the hooks, they are lottle stickers.
    • DLD24
      I like drifting with them and snap jigging them with a controlled fall...Almost every time you'll feel that tick just as it's hitting bottom... Last time I was on mille lacs that's all I could get them to go on. As far as colors I'd just match the forage Tullies in the lake use blue,purples,silvers....Perch use perch colors.. I think the jiggin rap is my new favorite way to fish, but it gets scary with them little hooks when you got a big eye on lol.
    • DLD24
      Fished Big Sandy from 8-2 today and got 10 eyes (no keepers) keeper crappie and perch.... Marked tons of fish, but it was tough to get them to go, Lindy rig with a half crawler was the best by far. I tried leeches,jigging rap, jig n plastic. Points and reefs were the spots, later in the day a lot of fish were off the edges of the reefs... Just one day this year I'd like a happy medium weather wise, either I'm in 4ft rollers or 90 degrees with zero wind haha.
    • Garmandu
      According to Al Linder you can do it all with them...on his video that I watched a while back he was in deeper water throwing into 15 feet and working it back to the boat.  I have not tried it yet but will have to sometime this year.  Sand or gravel bottom would be the best.
    • ANYFISH2
      Just started playing with these this week as a friend has been have goos luck all summer with them on the Cass lake chain. I have not any success yet but not real sure on the best way to use them with my set this week.  My friend searches pods of fish out with electronics then spot locks and vertical jigs. I have no electronics or spot lock so I have been control drifting and jigging.   My questions...   Is there a depth they work better in, shallow vs. deeper?   Better vertically jigged vs trolled vs casted and jigged?   prime colors? of course my be lake dependent.   typically, aggressive jigging vs subtle jigging?   Thanks for tips
    • Perchy
      Yes, insured. I will ask the adjuster, thanks.
    • Captain Acorn
      Thanks cliff and lb I have actually had better luck with the puppet minnows from northland but I have mainly jigged them vertically definently is a fun way to fish 
    • LBerquist
      I've been trolling at about .5mph while using a jigging rap. This way one guy can still drag a lindy. I keep the front hook intact but my boat has contributed about half a dozen to the lake so far this summer. Im still working on getting the hang of it. If I know I'm in a rough area I will attempt to keep the jig from hitting bottom which still seems to be effective. I did pick up a couple off brands that don't have a front hook that I want to try. This is just what I have been toying around with, I'm definitely not an expert at it.
    • fisherjmb
      Hi Everyone, a couple of questions, I know there is free public boat ramp in Stillwater just above the lift bridge. Is there another public boat ramp further down river? I thought I read somewhere that Beanies is or was becoming a free public boat launch. Is that the case? Also, I am thinking of heading there on Monday to try my luck. Any tactics/depths/areas that have been producing for anyone?