Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
badfish

Channel or Flathead?

16 posts in this topic

I caught this fish the other night and wasn't sure if it was a flathead or a channel. It was one of the big fish of the night and it looked different then the other channels(in terms of color, size and shape) so thats what got me wondering, it weighed 6lbs. It was caught in the clearwater area. thanks for any help

100_0509.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice Channel Cat!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I didn't think it was a flathead but it looked different from the other channels...probably just cuz it was bigger. Thanks for clarifying that for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Channell Cats have a wide color range, I have seen them very light to very dark in color including Purple, Green, Brown and Silver.

Nice one!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, 100% channel cat. A flathead in that stretch of water is pretty much unheard of.

When in doubt, check the tail. Channels have a deeply forked tail, flatheads have a pretty much square tail.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not to mention that Flatheads grow significantly larger like this guy! grin.gif

hansonmonsterflatwf5.jpg

I'm not kidding, that fish was 20+lbs. I'm just not long arming him! LOL! grin.gif

They don't look as big when you hold them close to your body.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Such a cute little thing! (the fish, not Hanson!) grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are one of the very lucky to even see a flat caught up here, they look like the one Hanson is holding up. I have seen only a couple over the many years I have fished this area and they were small. Just like the flats range in color (green to yellow),

channels do to.

I only thing I have found is channels will change in body shape. I have seen some sick/bulging type to green smooth sleek looking. I am not sure what causes this. Of all the flat pics I have seen and fish I have caught, flats body stays the same threw out. Channels on the other hand sure come up weird at times .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Channels always have forked tails while Flats will have rounded to more square tails or caudal fin..

The different growth characteristics is due to sex dimorphism... Males get the big bulgy or bulbous look after a few years of spawning activity. Females generally look "sleek" compared to males, although they get quite a bit fatter.

Has not been a flatty caught above Coon rapids on the Miss anyway....

Hope this helps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You smokin crack again SH??? grin.gif

Who the heck knows what diabolicalmorpheusism even means?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see. Well I've learned a lot with this post so far, thanks for everyones info. One more question though...I've noticed on a lot of the bigger cats almost all of them have a sore right in the middle of there head, what causes that? I assume its from poking there heads under rocks looking for crayfish, Am I right? or is there some other reason for it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Smallie,

I value your opinion!

I do not have any evidence of flats on Miss. North, but I know what I saw. They were caught at night and I will not rule out a miss construed female channel! The one that was caught several years back at St Cloud dam is still embedded in my minds eye! It was a flat!

I would be interested in your trot line report, when you get it done!

Would DNR ever stock flats up this way or is this a lost cause? Why would a flat not survive in this area of the river? As time creeps on and no digital image of a flat from up here, my thoughts of ever seeing another one caught up here are fading away. I have targeted them with certain type of bait with no luck.

Also how did channels get up above CR dam. PLus, have you ever heard of one caught at Anoka dam. I have heard stoies of 40lbs and 50lbs fish caught down their. They could be bogus, but they sure we not channels.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I noticed this sore as well over the years. It looks like a bullet wound. I figured this has something to do with spawning also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hope they (DNR) doesn't put Flats in the upper Miss - they'll eat the smallies shocked.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bass/smash!

There are plenty to go around. They need a little thining anyways. Think of the monsters that would grow after the flats thined them out grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've heard that if flatheads are introduced to waters where only channels were originally native to, that they can do great harm to the population of channels. Plus I don't think there's too much demand for flatheads in the upper mississippi. I like the river the way it is, but if I absolutely HAD to pick a new fish to introduce it'd be sturgeon over flatheads anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • DLD24
      I like drifting with them and snap jigging them with a controlled fall...Almost every time you'll feel that tick just as it's hitting bottom... Last time I was on mille lacs that's all I could get them to go on. As far as colors I'd just match the forage Tullies in the lake use blue,purples,silvers....Perch use perch colors.. I think the jiggin rap is my new favorite way to fish, but it gets scary with them little hooks when you got a big eye on lol.
    • DLD24
      Fished Big Sandy from 8-2 today and got 10 eyes (no keepers) keeper crappie and perch.... Marked tons of fish, but it was tough to get them to go, Lindy rig with a half crawler was the best by far. I tried leeches,jigging rap, jig n plastic. Points and reefs were the spots, later in the day a lot of fish were off the edges of the reefs... Just one day this year I'd like a happy medium weather wise, either I'm in 4ft rollers or 90 degrees with zero wind haha.
    • Garmandu
      According to Al Linder you can do it all with them...on his video that I watched a while back he was in deeper water throwing into 15 feet and working it back to the boat.  I have not tried it yet but will have to sometime this year.  Sand or gravel bottom would be the best.
    • ANYFISH2
      Just started playing with these this week as a friend has been have goos luck all summer with them on the Cass lake chain. I have not any success yet but not real sure on the best way to use them with my set this week.  My friend searches pods of fish out with electronics then spot locks and vertical jigs. I have no electronics or spot lock so I have been control drifting and jigging.   My questions...   Is there a depth they work better in, shallow vs. deeper?   Better vertically jigged vs trolled vs casted and jigged?   prime colors? of course my be lake dependent.   typically, aggressive jigging vs subtle jigging?   Thanks for tips
    • Perchy
      Yes, insured. I will ask the adjuster, thanks.
    • Captain Acorn
      Thanks cliff and lb I have actually had better luck with the puppet minnows from northland but I have mainly jigged them vertically definently is a fun way to fish 
    • LBerquist
      I've been trolling at about .5mph while using a jigging rap. This way one guy can still drag a lindy. I keep the front hook intact but my boat has contributed about half a dozen to the lake so far this summer. Im still working on getting the hang of it. If I know I'm in a rough area I will attempt to keep the jig from hitting bottom which still seems to be effective. I did pick up a couple off brands that don't have a front hook that I want to try. This is just what I have been toying around with, I'm definitely not an expert at it.
    • fisherjmb
      Hi Everyone, a couple of questions, I know there is free public boat ramp in Stillwater just above the lift bridge. Is there another public boat ramp further down river? I thought I read somewhere that Beanies is or was becoming a free public boat launch. Is that the case? Also, I am thinking of heading there on Monday to try my luck. Any tactics/depths/areas that have been producing for anyone?
    • proguide
      I would call the catfishing this week seasonal.  It is a pretty normal bite for a period of lower water and heat.  The catfish are in post spawn and spread out in their summer haunts.  The more aggressive fish are in the deeper water in the middle of the river.  As usual stay on the move and keep the bait fresh. Bait does not seem to matter still but people with frogs are saying they are getting their better hits with them. 
    • Rick
      Wildlife artists can submit entries for the 2018 Minnesota Trout and Salmon Stamp through 4 p.m. Friday, July 28, according to the Department of Natural Resources.  2017 Trout and Salmon Stamp Competition
      First Place: Timothy Turenne Anglers can purchase the trout and salmon stamp validation with their fishing license for an additional $10. For an extra 75 cents, purchasers can receive the pictorial stamp. It is also sold as a collectible for $10.75. Revenue from stamp sales is dedicated to trout and salmon management and habitat work. Trout or salmon must be the primary focus of the design, though other fish species may be included in the design if they are used to depict common interaction between species or are common inhabitants of Minnesota’s lakes and rivers. Brook trout designs are not eligible this year. Artists are prohibited from using any photographic product as part of their finished entries. Winning artists usually issue limited edition prints of the artwork and retain proceeds. Judging will take place Thursday, Aug. 3, at DNR headquarters, 500 Lafayette Road, St. Paul. For more information and contest guidelines, visit mndnr.gov/stamps, or call the DNR Information Center at 651-296-6157 or 888-646-6367. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.