Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Scott M

Why the slot animosity?

15 posts in this topic

I read the first part of this story in the St. Cloud Times with the usual quotes from the DNR and some information but was a little surprised at the quotes towards the end of the article. Two business owners knock the DNR regarding the slot. Read it for yourself At Mille Lacs, be wary of limit

Quote:

"They (the DNR) made it real clear a few years back that they don't care about the business community up here," Lundeen said. "This will have a dramatic impact on this area and I don't know how the angling public will react this time, but I know how they reacted last time and it wasn't good."


Quote:

"The biological factor should be the decision maker when it comes to slot regulations, not quotas," Johnson said. "This lake is in great shape from a walleye numbers standpoint, and it needs to managed so that remains, not so a certain poundage of fish can be caught each year."


I like to stroll over to the URL section and read what the Petrowskes say about slots and protection after not being able to fish for almost a decade. I'm pretty sure they are happy with the quota and slot system on Red. I can't believe how people can't think that the smaller slot is used for protecting the fishery, and that the long term picture isn't what is in focus. Those are some caustic statements and accusations, IMO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think a lot of people look at it as a court/political decision... not necessarily one for the betterment of the fishery. The court says each party can take X pounds so the lake is managed for two takes of x pounds. When the slot is tightened, it isn't done so with the betterment of the fishery in mind, it is done so to stay under the court mandated number. I think that is where the frustration stems from.

I personally am not a fishery biologist, nor am I a resort owner on Mille Lacs. I'm not sure what to believe but I write this simply to illustrate where some of the hard feelings originate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will throw my $.02 into the bucket. I think the DNR went a little overboard on this one. If the harvest had been on track, the protected slot would have been shortened to 22-28". The fishing usually slows down this time of year and so does the pressure. This year the DNR says we are ahead of harvest. I haven't heard the final numbers, but I really can't believe it is much over. Leaving the slot at 20" would have been a change in the plans for this year and it would have decreased this year's harvest. Last weekend I witnessed the slowest bite this year and the least amount of anglers on the lake. These two factors would have been enough to slow the harvest rate way down. I know we all go there to catch big fish. Not me. I have never kept over my legal limit (daily or posession), but I do like to eat fish. I know first hand of a handfull of people that have cancelled trips based on this slot change. I can see why places like Lundeen's would be upset and they have a right to be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just my opinion: I don't believe you can compare the situations between Mille Lacs and Red Lake as apples to apples.

On Mille Lacs it is very tough to catch a walleye in the 14-16" slot. Which will end up hurting the resort owners because people will not go to Mille Lacs and fish.

On URL, the lake just openned for fishing after the walleye population was eliminated for certain non-angling reasons. The walleye population is still in the process of building.

Fisherman can still catch many slot fish, even though the limit is 2, hence they can take some home so they will still go there,

I believe in slot limits to control harvest, but I think the DNR should look at other types of management styles other then this type of harvest poundage quotas and then shut the lake down with a slot that will make it very tough to hit. In essence taking the fishermen off of Mille Lacs.

On ML, Maybe the limit should be 2 all summer and keep the slot the same. At least that way the resort owners don't take the knock-out punch when the slot is changed to a slot in which you rarely can catch a fish.

I would have to say I am on the side of the resort owners on this one. They need fishermen to come to the lake to spend money so they can support their business and families.

This style of fishery management is not in the best interest of everyone.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They should just make the limit 3 state wide and nothing over 20" statewide as well. This way, it would be an equal playing ground statewide and people would still fish ML. I think this would help many of the lakes around the state that receive too much pressure. Many of the fish could then reach their potential and more lakes would produce the trophy class fish we all seek.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[note from admin: Please read forum policy before posting again. Thank you.]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oops . Your hood is showing .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Oops . Your hood is showing .


This post is an instant classic! Time to wipe down the monitor. At least it was only water....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your hood is showing .

LMAO!

There's tons of other lakes to catch eaters on.

If you want hogs,spend the $3plus a gallon gas to drive to the big pond.

It' makes no difference to me as I do not go down there much.

I've got plenty of water to fish around here.

Too bad for the resorts though.They really have to be taking a hit!No wonder leeches sell for 40$ a lb.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Things could not better for resorts or business's on Mille Lacs right now.

I doubt the pressure will subside much but it sure would nice to pull up on flat without litterly a hundred boats on it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally I do not think the slot will hurt the tourism because I have been to ML 4 times ( 5 next week) for one reason to catch trophy fish. I can catch all the eaters I want at other lakes but to have the chance to catch a fish of a lifetime or my kids fish of a lifetime is priceless. It is almost like having Lac Suel in the U.S. to the people who are complaining - there are 9,999 other lakes to choose from to get your fish for the pan. Let ML be THE lake for trophy walleyes IN MN and let em go!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes the resorts have done Very well this year. I just hoped they banked some for the next few months.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know I am going to get blasted for this, but,

(I'm not a resort owner)

You may think the resorts have done very well this year, but with the 4-5 months they have had to make real money.

2 in winter and 2 in summer so far. Kind of hard to put some away with 4-5 months of good tourism.

The point is with this slot change, the people will not be coming up like they were. 4-5 months of revenue do not make a good year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We usually take a trip to the pond about this time every summer. But after spending a week at another lake where the slot was increased and only catching protected fish, we are staying home this year. I only want to bring home some eaters for the mom's. If I want to throw fish back, it's just as much fun to fish bass and northerns close to home. I'm sure that's fine with a lot of you, and it's fine with me too. But it's probably not with the resort owners on ML.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've talked too dozens of people in rochester here about the slot restriction and i've yet too have 1 person say they are changing plans or would change plans and not go too Mille Lacs because of it. Everyone has the same response, "I dont go too Mille Lacs for fish too eat, if i get some great, i go too catch big fish. It doesnt matter what the slot is." If this attitude is across the board than there shouldnt be that big a drop off in tourism from what thing would have been without the change.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • RainyRat
      'Pout   The 'Pout bite has been great   Adrian's has made yet another road to the east of the 2 previous, now abandoned, roads.  The new road is a bit rough for my liking but take it slower and no problems.  The good part about it is that the little snow that is out there (maybe an inch or two) is rock hard and you can now drive anywhere you want.  I saw 1 ton diesel trucks pulling wheel houses across the white and I doubt anyone was even in 4 wheel drive, its just not needed.  We can all spread out, anywhere we want.   BTW, stay off the old plowed roads where the ice looks smooth.  Some of them had a foot or so of water on them before it cooled off again and as of yesterday they were not all frozen back down to the original ice. I saw one truck got a little surprise.  Again take it slow and pay attention and you can go anywhere.   Good luck with those 'pout!   RR    
    • jkrash
    • CigarGuy
      Del, it looks like the first time posters are coming after us!  I wasn't going to say anything else on this topic, but as long as Vermilion Boater called me out, I'll say a few more things and be done.  I've been a lake home owner up here for only 5 years , but I've been to The Landing numerous times over the last 5 years.  I've taken part in fancy 4-course meals, had the daily special and just a burger or a cocktail. Sat at the bar and Bs'd with the bartenders Justin and I think her name was Jesse and they were great.   I've been to (not really my favorite) The Crescent less than 10 times total!  I don't go to the lake to spend time in a bar, but once in a while, it's a nice change of pace.  When we have company, I'll usually bring them to The Landing, because the setting is hard to beat.  The service, meals have been great at times and not so great.  You never know if there going to be open all week, Thur-Sunday or Friday-Sunday!  I'm not giving my "drive bye" opinion of the place!  I've talked to locals, people working on my place, fishermen and read reviews here, FB, Trip Adviser and see that reviews are in-fact, all over the place. So, it's not my "narrow-minded" view!  I don't seek out opinions, they come up in conversation.  I'm glad you, your neighbors and friends enjoy it!  BTW, your vast knowledge of the competition, leads me to believe, you might have a vested interest in the place.  Ok, I'm done with this thread! 
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      I just came back from checking ice conditions on Big Bay. I found about 22 inches of good ice out there and very easy going! No real snow cover left, no slush, and smooth ice almost every where! Cliff
    • cookie129
      Well another game fish season has came to a end. The dnr will be having a meeting this week in Kellier to discuss the up and coming open water season.. I be leave our cabins are wide open with narly a date penciled in this summer including opener?
      Grab a cup of java because this is going to be a long blog.
      The first thing is what a great ending to another game fish season .
      The biggest thing and this come from my heart is" Thank you" to all my new and repeat customers . With out all of you I would not be able to enjoy working on such a grand lake. When that old timer Dave shared that with me I was in Awe. "Its a grand lake and it owes me nothing, nothing was his quote and boy did that stick. The walleye fishing this year could of been better. I'm all most to the point of calling them the elusive upper red lake walleye?
      Just like every season for 14 years now we have had great fishing, good fishing and poor fishing. I guess its the luck of the draw when you come up. We caught a couple,, we caught some and we caught a few over the season. The fishermen have become a little more tight lip about there walleye catches over the last couple years. Its so funny when You ask a fishermen how they did. The ponder and say oh we got a few? I've always been like how many is a few? Its always well we got 18? To me a few is 3, a couple is two and some can be 1 or more.
      The dnr will be releasing a summery of what's happening on the lake in the next upper red lake association news letter. If your interested in joining and becoming a member its 25 dollars a year or 50 if you want your business listed on there web site.
      I have a few gripes I want to share also. Some you will have to read between the lines.
      The first thing is Saturday night I was coming off of the lake on Hillmens highway. Buddy Hillmen is so dedicated to his road and there is no one prouder when it comes to maintaining a ice road.
      As I was coming on to the landing a big wheel house turned off the highway. I new right away they did not pay 10 dollars and there's a sign right there that says 10 dollars. I rolled down my window and he was like wow I did not know where to pay. Where do you pay? He had no problem finding the access but did not see the lights on in the bar with a few vehicles there? Give me a break.
      Kelly, Buddy Hillmens mechanic got 3 Thursday night pulling in. If you can not afford 10 dollars a day for your wheel house ? I personally think wheel houses should have to pay more?
      I also had a few customers that tried to slide by this year and its very frustrating . The deal I have with buddy hillmen is I can use his access and in turn my customers have to pay 10 dollars a day. I'm on call 24 hours a day for any ice road work ,plowing, bridging, etc. Over the years I have been accused of fishing where some one was going to go? fishing on some ones way points? Cutting someone off. Every year its something and again this year was no exception? Any side roads I personally plow to my houses are always open. Do I want fishermen by my houses? Nope. My customers pay good money and I do not want them looking out the picture windows and seeing a wheel house 30 yards away. There is always plenty of room where I plow as I'm the rouge plower. I have no problem plowing out a driveway for a wheel house as it helps pay for my equipment as it takes a beating out there.
      Its been a crazy season and its not over for me as I again chase the elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie. to be continued