Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
Lake Trout

Lowrance vs Garmin GPS

Recommended Posts

Lake Trout

I know there's a lot of info in the search feature, but Garmin seems to get better reviews online than Lowrance for handheld GPS. I want it for fishing in my boat with a good map. Navionics w/Lowrance and LakeMaster for Garmin, I guess. Any thoughts as to the "best" unit to an insecure GPS buyer? Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ralph Wiggum

From what I have heard, Garmin probably makes a better GPS, but you'll pay a lot more for comparable features with a Garmin as opposed to a Lowrance. The H2Oc give you a big screen (for a handheld), color, and plug-n-play map chipping and a pretty reasonable price, and that is why a ton of people have them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BobT

My impression is similar but slightly different. I agree that the Garmin is probably the more durable unit but I don't agree that the price is that significantly higher, although I agree it probably is higher.

From what I've heard on this site however, the mapping software/chips available for the Lowrance products seems to have the edge over the Garmin based on comments made here.

If I were looking I think I would take a look at both closely to see which meets my needs more.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wishing for walleyes

I am garmin all the way.But i have never owned a lowrance.I have 2 garmin gps map 188 c sounders,chart/plotters and really like the gps accruacy.Puts me on my spots within 3 foot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
computerboy

Garmins get better reviews because most of the people reviewing them don't use their GPS for fishing. Garmin makes a very accurate, user friendly GPS that is great for geocaching, hiking, driving, navigating, etc. However, Lowrance is far better in terms of availability of software for fisherman, and that's the most important consideration to make based on your requirements (IMHO).

With most Lowrance units, you can use plug and play chips from LakeMaster, Lowrance ProMaps, and Navionics that are available almost anywhere. With a Garmin, you have to buy proprietary BlueChart chips (or CD's depending on your unit) that are much harder to find and aren't updated nearly as often as their Promap/HotMap counterparts. Whatever you do, just make sure the make/model of your GPS is compatible with the map chips you want to use.

Bottom Line:

If you're looking for a handheld GPS that has good mapping capability to use for fishing, it's really a no brainer - Lowrance iFinder H20/H20C.

Good Luck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JDM

I have one of each on my boat and there are likes and dislikes for each one. Overall, they are both good. I do like the Garmin's tracking system better because it is much smaller and you can really see in detail where you have already been when you are working some structure. The Lowrance I have is much larger. Maybe I could fix it with a setting? I don't know.

I have a chip in each. It is interesting to note the differences in each one. Buy whichever one you like the best. Both are easy to use.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

I have a magellan and I hate it. Don't get that one. That was a bad choice made about 5 years ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lake Trout

Ok. That's what I needed. Sounds like the Lowrance H2Oc for me. What's the best map chip for the buck considering I'm only fishing MN? Thanks tons, guys. You made me a secure GPS buyer now! LT

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BobT

One thing I will say is that my only experience is with a Garmin handheld Rino120 and GPSMap76. Because I use it for travel, hunting, fishing, and ATVing I have various software packages including USTopo, USRoads&Rec, and Minnesota Lakemaster. In all cases, the software is incredibly accurate especially the lake mapping software. Without having any experience with the Avionics products or Lowrance GPS products my opinion is probably quite biased but I really like my Garmin and especially like how the software interfaces with my PC.

As far as the reviews on this site are concerned I get the impression that Lowrance H2O has top of the line honors, hands down. It seems more of our colleagues speak about those than any other GPS products.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
computerboy

If you're fishing Minnesota lakes and using the Lowrance iFinder H20, there are only two options I would consider:

- Navionics HotMaps Premium North - appx $149

- Lowrance LakeMaster Minnesota ProMap - appx $99

The Lowrance Promap MN chip is cheaper, has faster read times when "scouting", and allows you to zoom in farther than Navionics. What the Navionics lacks in those areas it makes up for in sheer numbers. The premium north chip covers thousands of lakes throughout the Midwest and parts of Canada. I have both chips and like the Navionics for coverage, but prefer the zoom of the Lowrance Promap. If you're the kind of guy that is going to different lakes every other weekend and might venture outside of Minnesota to fish Oahe, Winnebago, Big Stone, etc, the Navionics would be the way to go. If you only plan to fish Winni, Otter Tail, and Minnetonka then go with the Lowrance ProMap.

Before you run out and buy a map chip though, make sure to review the lake lists for each chip to see what matches up with the bodies of water that you fish. What you're looking for is a high definition map in 1' or 3' contours. If neither chip has high-def contours of the lakes you fish (which is possible), I wouldn't bother buying either one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BobT

Good advice!

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pfluemis

Quote:

Garmins get better reviews because most of the people reviewing them don't use their GPS for fishing. Garmin makes a very accurate, user friendly GPS that is great for geocaching, hiking, driving, navigating, etc. However, Lowrance is far better in terms of availability of software for fisherman, and that's the most important consideration to make based on your requirements (IMHO).

With most Lowrance units, you can use plug and play chips from LakeMaster, Lowrance ProMaps, and Navionics that are available almost anywhere. With a Garmin, you have to buy proprietary BlueChart chips (or CD's depending on your unit) that are much harder to find and aren't updated nearly as often as their Promap/HotMap counterparts. Whatever you do, just make sure the make/model of your GPS is compatible with the map chips you want to use.

Bottom Line:

If you're looking for a handheld GPS that has good mapping capability to use for fishing, it's really a no brainer - Lowrance iFinder H20/H20C.

Good Luck!


Not only does LakeMaster sell ProMap for Garmin, they also sell Garmin's!

I just ordered the 76CSx which is basically Garmins version of the Lowrance H2Oc..but much, much better, with way more features, and a far superior, more sensitive receiver. Well worth the extra $$$, IMO. Been looking at, and trying to justify a GPS for quite some time. I'm now looking forward to driving to new places with turn by turn navi, marking spots on lakes, and mapping snowmobile trails this winter...if we get snow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PierBridge

Thats a step in the right direction but its tough too justify $600 "with pro map" for a hand held GPS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pfluemis

Quote:

Thats a step in the right direction but its tough too justify $600 "with pro map" for a hand held GPS.


???? $238+$99 for the H2O, $330+$84 for the Garmin. That's only a $77 difference. Yeah, the Garmin maps need to be download from the CD to the card, but I don't see the big deal in that. For a $96 savings, I'll spend a few minutes downloading/programing the card. I just can't see paying $180 for a preprogramed card.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
delcecchi

So the fancy Navionics Lake Maps come on a CD so you can download them to the Garmin? I am referring to the ones with the 1 foot contours

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pfluemis

Quote:

So the fancy Navionics Lake Maps come on a CD so you can download them to the Garmin? I am referring to the ones with the 1 foot contours


Are you asking me??? I don't know. I'm new to the maps for gps technology. The maps I'm refering to is the LakeMaster Promaps. 72 surveyed lakes, and 600+ lakes from DNR maps. I don't know if they are the same maps that Navionics offers, but the LakeMaster Promap CD is $84 online, while the preprogramed "chip" is $180 for the Garmin. Yes, the CD downloads the maps to the "chip" in the Garmin. If you go to lake map (Contact Us Please) com, and look up digital gps maps, it will tell you, better than I can, what the maps are.

Here, I just cut and pasted the information on the CD I'm refering to, direct from the LakeMaster website:

Garmin® is proud to release LakeMaster® ProMap data for your Garmin® GPS unit. With amazing bottom detail and one-foot contours for many lakes, LakeMaster® is sure to help you key in on prime fishing locations in Michigan, Minnesota or Wisconsin. LakeMaster® maps contain high definition contours, structures, and bottom information created from on-the-water surveys. Lake detail includes islands, reefs, points, bays, access points and more. Your Garmin® GPS will accurately place your boat on the map as well as show detailed tracklines and waypoints. Incredible zooming capabilities down to 80 feet in scale. Available in MapSource CD-ROM, Data Card, or microSD Card formats.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
delcecchi

yes, I was asking because it used to be that the lakemaster maps that came on a cd couldn't be downloaded, or so I thought. So I have both the computer version and the chip version.

If one will work for both that would be a real plus. I will have to check it out.

I wonder if the Vermilion map is newer and and significantly better than the 3foot one. I did hear that navionics was up with a couple of boats.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pfluemis

Quote:

yes, I was asking because it used to be that the lakemaster maps that came on a cd couldn't be downloaded, or so I thought. So I have both the computer version and the chip version.

If one will work for both that would be a real plus. I will have to check it out.

I wonder if the Vermilion map is newer and and significantly better than the 3foot one. I did hear that navionics was up with a couple of boats.


From the little bit of reading I have done on the different versions, it is my understanding that the 2007 version has a new Vermilion map. I don't know for sure though. It's not a lake I fish, so I didn't dig too deep into the matter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • LBerquist
      What got me hooked on musky fishing when I was a kid was topwater. Nothing more exciting than watching the water explode. My first musky came on a rubber frog while bass fishing, my little brother casted over my line and as I lectured him and reeled my line up as quick as I could, WHAM. Since then I have had some of my best memories from topwater. Poe's giant jackpot, prop baits, creepers, klack/buzz bait. He's going to spend a lot of time casting, giving him something to watch helps pass the time and when he gets follows they will normally be shallow so he will be able to see them. 
    • leech~~
      Yes, she just doesn't want to have a bad Christmas every year!   Shes not a Big New Years partier! 
    • eyeguy 54
      did she ok it for after that?? lol   stay dry! 
    • leech~~
      Thanks for the reports guys. It will be after New years before I get up in the area to try some fishing. I made a deal with my wife that I can't die ice fishing, before Christmas! 
    • OhioVike
      I have $50 to spend on Musky lures for a 14 year old boy.  Last fall he caught a nice musky, from my kayak, and was unable to land it to get a picture.  He did get it up to the kayak several times so he got a good look at it and has been bit by the Musky Fishing Bug.  I am looking for suggestions for the young man and was hoping to get some help here.  
    • titelines
      Last year I rented a house through Hunter Winfield's Resort in Isle.  I looked around at many options and they seemed to have what I was looking for.  Their wheel-houses are very nice and have everything you list above.  Bathroom, TV/DVD, electricity (didn't have to fill the generator once), stove/oven.  I reserved an 8' x 16', but they upgraded me to an 8x20' - nice surprise.  Real nice, and plenty of room for two adults and 2 kids.   I had so much fun I'm going back in January.
    • Chill62
      Buddy had a camera down on Saturday and he said he'd get a mixture of panfish to come in then they'd fly out of the hole and in comes a pike or two.  He said that when the gills would leave it was because a pike would be around the hole and he knew it was safe again when he'd see his first panfish.  That was in 18-22 fow.
    • redneckdan
      Just pulled two out of st Mary's in eveleth. It was close. Please make good choices out there.   That said, I'm off to find a cup of hot chocolate and a long finlander hot shower....
    • Rick
      No chronic wasting disease was detected in more than 11,000 precautionary samples from deer that hunters harvested this fall in north-central, central and southeastern Minnesota, according to the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.  “This is good news for Minnesota,” said Lou Cornicelli, wildlife research manager for the DNR. “The results lend confidence that the disease is not spread across the landscape.” In all, 7,813 deer were tested in the north-central area, 2,529 in the central area and 1,149 in the southeastern area outside deer permit area 603, the CWD management zone. Researchers still are submitting samples from cooperating taxidermists so final results will updated online at mndnr.gov/cwdcheck as they become available. Given no deer with CWD were found in north-central and central Minnesota, the DNR will narrow surveillance next fall to areas closer to the farms where CWD was detected. A fourth precautionary surveillance area will be added in fall 2018 in Winona County because CWD recently was detected in captive deer there. Precautionary testing in north-central and central Minnesota became necessary after CWD was found in multiple captive deer on farms near Merrifield in Crow Wing County and Litchfield in Meeker County. It also was conducted in the deer permit areas directly adjacent to southeast Minnesota’s deer permit area 603, the only place in Minnesota where CWD is known to exist in wild deer. Minnesota’s CWD response plan calls for testing of wild deer after the disease is detected in either domestic or wild deer. All results from three consecutive years of testing must report CWD as not detected before DNR stops looking for the disease. Three years of testing are necessary because CWD incubates in deer slowly. They can be exposed for as long as 18 months before laboratory tests of lymph node samples can detect the disease. Proactive surveillance and precautionary testing for CWD is a proven strategy that allows the DNR to manage the disease by finding it early and reacting quickly and aggressively to control it. These actions, which were taken in 2005 to successfully combat bovine tuberculosis in northwestern Minnesota deer and in 2010 to eliminate a CWD infection in wild deer near Pine Island, provide the best opportunity to eliminate disease spread. Precautionary testing is necessary to detect the disease early. Without early detection, there’s nothing to stop CWD from becoming established at a relatively high prevalence and across a large geographic area. At that point, there is no known way to control the disease. “Overall, hunter cooperation and public support has been tremendous,” Cornicelli said. “While there are always challenges when you conduct this type of surveillance effort, it really couldn’t have been successful without the cooperation of hunters, taxidermists, landowners and the businesses that allowed us to operate check stations.” Complete information about CWD and DNR efforts to keep Minnesota deer healthy are available on the DNR website at mndnr.gov/cwd. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Boundaries for a special late-season deer hunt to help control chronic wasting disease in southeastern Minnesota’s Fillmore County have been expanded to include portions of three surrounding deer permit areas, the Department of Natural Resources said.  The expansion of boundaries for the nine-day hunt that lasts from Saturday, Jan. 6, to Sunday, Jan. 14, became necessary when CWD test results of harvested deer revealed two infected deer in Forestville State Park and a suspected infection north of the disease’s core area around Preston.  During the upcoming hunt, deer may be taken in an approximate 10-mile radius surrounding the new discoveries. That area includes all of deer permit area 603 as well as the portion of permit area 345 south of Interstate 90, the southern portion of permit area 347 and the northern portion of permit area 348. A map of the area and complete details are available on the DNR’s website at mndnr.gov/cwd. “Hunters must plan ahead,” said Lou Cornicelli, the DNR’s wildlife research manager. “Private land makes up most of the area and hunters must have landowner permission. Public land in the area likely will be crowded. And hunting opportunities will be limited and available only by permit at Forestville State Park and Pin Oak Prairie Scientific and Natural Area.” Within 24 hours of harvest, each deer must be taken to one of four stations where DNR staff will register the deer and collect lymph node tissue for CWD testing. All electronic registration will be turned off. With the exception of fawns, deer cannot be moved from the hunt area without a test result that shows CWD was not detected. Prior to test results, hunters may properly quarter their deer and bone-out meat but the head, spinal column and all brain material must remain in the area until the animal’s test results show a not-detected status. Designated dumpsters where hunters can dispose of carcasses and parts will be available in Preston and Forestville. A refrigerated trailer will be available in Preston for temporary storage of the entire carcass if hunters choose to wait for the test result before processing their deer. After receiving a not-detected test result for the deer, the hunter can take the entire deer out of the area. Since the mid-September start of the archery season 1,334 deer have been tested in permit area 603 and results have shown six confirmed and one suspect cases of CWD. Although the number of CWD-infected deer is down from the 11 positives found last season, three of the new positives were found outside the core area. “We were glad to see the prevalence go down but we’re unsure if we have a disease expansion or if males recently moved into a new area,” Cornicelli said. “Test results of deer taken during this special hunt will help us determine what the new disease management zone boundary will look like in 2018.” Complete information about CWD and DNR efforts to keep Minnesota deer healthy are available on the DNR website at mndnr.gov/cwd. Special hunt rules Hunt dates are Jan. 6-14, 2018. Hunt is open to residents and nonresidents. There is no bag limit, the antler point restriction will be eliminated in this area and cross-tagging (party hunting) will be allowed. Hunters can use any unfilled 2017 license or purchase disease management tags for $2.50. You do not need a deer hunting license to purchase disease management tags, which are valid for deer of either sex. Legal firearms are shotguns, muzzleloader or crossbows using either a firearm or muzzleloader license. Archery equipment must be used if the person is hunting with an archery license. Centerfire rifles are not allowed. All deer must be registered in person at one of the stations below. Registration stations will be staffed 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. daily during the season: Chatfield – Magnum Sports, 20 Main St. S; Preston – Preston Forestry office, 912 Houston St.; Forestville State Park; Rushford – Pam’s Corner Convenience, at the intersection of Minnesota highways 16 and 43. Submission of a CWD sample is mandatory. All deer will be tagged and tested by DNR staff. Fawns will be allowed to leave the zone. Carcasses from adult deer must remain in the zone until a “not detected” test is reported. This test takes three to four business days so hunters should make the appropriate arrangements prior to killing a deer. Test results can be checked on the DNR website at mndnr.gov/cwdcheck or by calling the DNR Information Center at 888-646-6367. Hunting at Forestville, Pin Oak Prairie and Cherry Grove
      Forestville State Park and Pin Oak Prairie SNA will both be open to limited deer hunting during the special hunt. To avoid overcrowding, permits for these areas will be issued on a first come, first served basis starting at noon on Monday, Dec. 18. Forestville State Park will remain open to visitors during the special hunt. Hunters must have a filled or unfilled 2017 firearm or muzzleloader license to obtain a permit. There is no group application for these hunts. Permits can be obtained online or wherever DNR licenses are sold. There is no fee for these permits. The same hunt rules as described for permit area 603 apply to these areas. Successful hunters can use any unfilled tag, or purchase disease management permits for $2.50. Specific hunt numbers, dates and available permits are: 801: Forestville State Park, Jan. 6-9, 2018, 130 permits. 802: Forestville State Park, Jan. 10-14, 2018,130 permits. 803: Pin Oak Prairie SNA, Jan. 6-9, 2018, five permits. 804: Pin Oak Prairie SNA, Jan. 10- 14, 2018, five permits. The Cherry Grove Blind Valley SNA, which adjoins the Cherry Grove Wildlife Management Area, also is open to deer hunting and no special permit is required. Food safety
      The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that, to date, there have been no reported cases of CWD infection in people. However, the CDC advises people not to eat meat from animals known to have CWD. Go to www.cdc.gov for more information. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.