Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
Barony

3" vrs 3 1/2"

Recommended Posts

Barony

There was a post in another category by someone looking for a 3 1/2 auto and it got me thinking. My upland guns are 3", and my waterfowler gun is a 3 1/2". I like the 3 1/2" and think it's cool to have one, but does a hunter really need one? My dad still shoots 2 3/4 at ducks and thinks the 3"+ is "overkill". I wouldn't think of shooting 2 3/4. What are the opinions?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
iffwalleyes

Depends how good of shot you are grin.gif. I like a 3 1/2 just because I have more shot especially when shooting steel shot. But 2 3/4 and 3 will put them down just as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
huntmup

I Shoot 2 3/4 for upland and 3 for waterfowl. Like iff said, it's how good you shoot grin.gifgrin.gif.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
slotlimit

Being a good shot is only part of it. I have shot thousands of rounds at water fowl. Lets take Canada's. It it's a 20-30 yard shot anything will do. But if your going beyond the 40/50 yard mark you will never regret the 3 1/2. I shot a remington 1100 3 inch for 10 years and shot lots of waterfowl. Then I baught a Browning Gold 3 1/2 and can bring down Canada's from 40/50 yards no problem. Did I become a better shot? No. It isn't a night and day difference but it is a difference. If I was shooting with a guy who only had 2 3/4 i would wait until he was done shooting before I started. I would say even for a good shot a 3 in shell is good to about 40 yards. I'm sure lots of people have taken Canada's beyond that. But I used to not take many shots beyond 40 yards but now with my 3 1/2 it's 50 yards. Don't let anyone fool you. Close shots anything will work but the farther the shot the saying "bigger is better" is true.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FarByondDrivn

I really don't see the benefits for everyday hunting (I can't shoot a goose to save my life). I used to really like the 3 1/2 for turkey hunting but I have shot turkeys out to 50 yards with a 3" (misjudged the distance). It is true you get more shot but you also pay for it. It is nice to have in case you need it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
slotlimit

You're right for everyday hunting. I'm just talking about waterfowl. I shoot over 150 geese a year in Canada and the US. For deer, pheasant, clays, I shoot what ever shell I happen to have at that time. Clays and deer mostly 2 3/4. Haven't been on a Turkey yet. But I think I would go with the 3 1/2 but if it's close enough a knife would work. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
HateHumminbird

I can't speak for waterfowling, but regarding turkey, my recommendation is mixed. Much here, depends on lead vs. non-tox "hevi-type" loads.

Back when I shot buffered, copperplated lead (3 1/2"), you'd get such a boom out of the load, that you'd actually flatten some of the lead pellets towards the back end of the shot-string. These would then "frisbee" and be fliers for you anyway, giving you some benefit, but rather little compared to your average 3" magnum load.

The "hevi-type" loads, being harder and denser than lead, resist the tendency to do this, meaning you really are getting more bang for your buck with the 3 1/2" loads.

At least with turkeys, I'm convinced that what kills them is total pellets with enough ft/lbs energy to penetrate and break bone, in a dense, even, pattern. IMO, total pellets trumps most all else, given that you have enough energy at whatever range you're shooting at. A 3 1/2" shell has quite a bit more payload, thus more pellets to achieve this goal.

Many will say with turkeys and waterfowl alike, "keep your shots within your effective range," or "don't shoot past 40." However, these recommendations rarely mimic normal hunting conditions; with fog, rises/dips in terrain, and fast-action come errors in judgement of distance and otherwise. We don't hunt on a football field, and while I bowhunt and practice ranging targets and animals regularly, I can be as much as 10 yards or more off, depending on conditions, slope, location, etc.

If it's in your budget, I'd strongly consider it for turkeys at least, when using the non-tox shot.

Joel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
charliepete2

Hull length is not really a factor. Payload and velocity is what counts. I'm strictly and upland hunter, and I don't see the need to shoot more than 1 1/4 oz loads. A 2 3/4" shell will handle that fine. If I want to kill birds at 60 yards I'm more concerned about what choke and shot size I'm using than hull length.

Personally if I need to pack enough shot into a shell to justify a 3 1/2" 12 gauge, I'll be using a ten guage. With it's larger diameter a 10 gauge has a smaller shot string and is more effective.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
slotlimit

I would agree with the 10 gauge statement. If I was a strickly goose hunter I would by a 10 gauge or if I was rich and could afford a wide assortment of guns I'd have one for every occasion. But The difference in price from a 3inch 12 gauge to a 3 1/2 12 gauge isn't much. Plus it's added versitality. I wouldn't want to be the guy lugging around a 10 gauge all day through the cattails hunting pheasants. Plus if you ever go to resell the gun teh 3 1/2 is much easier to sell.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FarByondDrivn

Really good points guys. I particularly like the choke comment and the "not hunting on a footbal field". Man if I could just get a deer or turkey to walk on a football field!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • DLD24
      Is it always impossible to get a hold of Jeff?? It took me like 8 calls to get a hold of him, brought my boat down after I got a hold of him. I told him I was hoping to use it this weekend for one last trip...I've called him multiple times for an update and he never answers... Seems odd for a business.
    • MinnowBuckets
      You know it’s a good day when you’re thumb looks like that from lipping the fish! What sizes are you getting right now, Rick?
    • Rick G
      Last two days have been incredible for both size and numbers
    • Rick
      Recreational netting for whitefish and tullibee (cisco) is anticipated to open on several Schedule I Lakes in the Grand Rapids fisheries work area beginning in late October, according to the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Schedule I Lakes, which are more susceptible to sudden changes that impact water temperatures, will be opened and closed on a 48-hour notice posted at lake accesses, other public places, and the DNR website. Schedule II Lakes, will open Nov. 3. Schedule I Lakes (48 hour notice) Anticipated opening dates are as follows: Friday, Oct. 27 through Sunday, Dec.3, for Deer (near Deer River), and Turtle (3.5 inch mesh). Friday, Nov. 3 through Sunday, Dec. 10, for Side and South Sturgeon (1.75 inch mesh). Friday, Nov. 10 through Sunday, Dec. 10, for Big Balsam and Nashwauk (1.75 inch mesh). Schedule II Lakes Lakes open to whitefish and cisco sport netting Friday, Nov. 3 through Sunday, Dec. 10: Bass (north basin). Ball Club. Bowstring*. Little Bowstring. Cut Foot Sioux*. Deer (near Effie). Grave. Jessie. Maple. Pokegama. Round (near Squaw Lake –1.75 inch mesh). Rush Island. Sand (near Max)*. Swan.  (1.75 inch mesh) Twin Lakes (near Marble). Winnibigoshish* and Little Winnibigoshish* (1.75 inch mesh). *Bowstring, Cut Foot Sioux, Sand, Winnibigoshish and Little Winnibigoshish are designated infested waters because of the presence of faucet snails or zebra mussels. Nets and equipment used in infested waters may not be used in any other waterbody unless they have been dried for ten days or frozen for two days. Fishing regulations require that: Netters purchase both a whitefish netting license and angling license. A person may use only one gill net, not exceeding 100 feet in length and 3 feet in width. One end of net must have a pole, stake, or buoy projecting at least two feet above the surface of the water or ice. Nets must have an identification tag attached near the first float of the end that is projecting from the surface of the water or ice. Identification tags must be a minimum of 2 ½ inches by 5/8 inch permanently bearing the name and address of the owner. Identification tags for marking nets are provided by the owner. Nets may not be set after sunset or raised before sunrise. All gill nets must be set and lifted by the licensee only. Anyone assisting in the taking of whitefish or ciscoes must have proper licensing. Nets must be tended at least once every 24 hours and all gamefish and non-target species must be immediately released from the net. A net may not be set in any water deeper than six feet. A net may not be set within 50 feet of another net. Minimum gill net mesh size shall be no less than 1-3/4 or 3-1/2 inch stretch measure depending on the lake (see full list of lake and size regulations online). Nets used in designated infested waters must be dried for a minimum of 10 days or frozen for 2 days before using in a different water body. Nets should be dried for 10 days or frozen for 2 before moving from any lake to another. Nets used in spiny water flea and/or zebra mussel infested waters should be not used in any other waterbody Nets should be transported in sealed container. Whitefish and ciscoes taken by sport gill-netting may not be bought or sold. Whitefish and ciscoes taken by sport gill-netting may not be used as bait. Within the Leech Lake Reservation boundaries, the possession limit for whitefish taken by sport gill-netting is 25, and the possession limit for ciscoes taken by sport gill-netting is 50. Net placement should not inhibit use of the lake by other boaters. About 700 people obtain special permits to net for whitefish-tullibee each year. The DNR bases netting schedules on expected water temperatures, fish abundance and vulnerability of game fish. As the water temperature cools, game fish head to deeper water and whitefish-tullibee come to shallow water for fall spawning.  Netting is allowed when there is little chance that game fish populations would be negatively impacted by recreational netting in shallow water. Find information about sport netting by lake, minimum mesh sizes, and fishing regulations at http://files.dnr.state.mn.us/rlp/regulations/fishing/whitefish-tullibee.pdf or contact the DNR’s Grand Rapids area office at 1201 East Highway 2, Grand Rapids, MN 55744, or call 218-328-8836. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • bbfenatic
      It seemed cheap to me for all the functionality.
    • Coleman
      I think I'll give it a try today.  Looks like it could be windy, which can help a bit with the down river drift.   I might try to get out Sunday as well after the game.  But, I think it's time to start putting the summer toys away for the year.  Just not the boat yet.  Will keep that out for a another 2-3 weeks.  Will tell you how I do if I get out today.   Another thing I'll add.  I've fished above the SCSU dam a bit this time of year.  Always just went a bit north of the Wilson Park landing and pulled some cranks along the east banks.  Normally did pretty well. Would normally work all the way up past the Hospital.  
    • fishingdad
            I was wondering if anybody that lives on the lake has Satellite Internet Service?  If you do I have a couple of questions-  Who is it through?  What does it cost for the applicable data plan you have?  Do you have any complaints, compliments, concerns about it.         I would like to sign up & do it but I don't want to regret having a 2 year commitment or similar & find out it is bad-horrible connection. Do you burn through the Data extremely fast?  We are up to the cabin almost every weekend April - October  & then every other through the winter so not being there enough isn't the issue just wanting to justify having it.  
    • ZachD
      250 bucks no thanks
    • Bobber221
      Can anyone report on fishing on Rainy River this week?
    • Tony S
      Headed up this weekend for the first trip of the fall.  Thinking about fishing the lake with all the good reports from there, but has anybody been up to Clementson, Frontier or Birchdale  areas recently that could give a report?  Thanks.