• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • WE CREATE LONG TERM, MEANINGFUL RELATIONSHIPS IN HERE ... PLEASE JOIN US.

    You know what we all love...

    RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE
    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
JBMasterAngler

When The Crappies Are Gone

Recommended Posts

JBMasterAngler

Did any of you guys fish red before that year class of crappies came from out of nowhere? Were any crappies at all caught before then? I'm just wondering what's gonna happen to the area when the crappies are completely gone in about 2 years?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LABS4ME

#1. There have always been crappies in Red... there always will be.

#2. How did they come out of nonowhere? They had to come form somewhere.

#3. Why are they all gonna be 'completely' gone in about 2 years?

Believe it or not there are other year classes of crappies swimming in Red. Maybe not the numbers we've grown to know, but there will always be some available to fisherman. Even the DNR does not have conclusive proof how long the '96 year class will naturally survive. There are reports of crappies living from 11 to 12 to 16 and all the way up to 19 years.... Go up and enjoy them. If they aren't biting enjoy the walleye or pike action. If none of them are biting enjoy the area! In 2 years I'm still gonna be up!

Good Luck!

Ken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hookmaster

Last Sunday to Monday the crappies I caught were 14 1/2, 13 1/2 and 2 at 12 1/2. They were all loners so I think that represents 3 different year classes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JBMasterAngler

The other thing I guess I want to know is, how is it that it was the crappies that exploded when the walleyes were gone and not the perch?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jerkbait

One thing I always remind people of is they say the AVERAGE life span of a Crappie is 10 years. That takes in to account predadation from other larger fish, which these year classes really have not seen until the word got out to the fishing community. Man has really been the only predator of these fish. Also there was not much competition for food either. Like Labs says you could see Crappies that are pushing 20 years old down the road. I know the Crappie hanging over the bar at West Wind is older than 10. As long as their biting I will be sneaking down to chase them. grin.gif

Is it Friday yet??? grin.gif

Will back back for one more weekend.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kelly-p

Remember that the perch were wiped out too. When the size of the nets was dropped to 1 1/4 inch to get the perch it also took the walleyes fingerlings.

The crappies,,,,they are too blunt in front to go into an 1 1/4 inch gill net. Also they do not have a sharp point at the end of their gill cover. The crappie have a rounded gill cover. Crappies do not get caught in gill nets and the MN DNR uses gill nets to test with. One of the reasons that no one has an idea of how many crappies were out there in "99" or are out there now.

What happened is that the numbers of all the other species of fish were knocked way down,,,,except the crappies that then then pulled off a once in a lifetime spawn. smile.gif

As far as years past there were always crappies but nobody targeted them. In July 1986 Jon came off the lake with a stinger of 15 crappies that were just as big as what we catch now. I yelled at him and called him a stupid kid for wasting the day catching those stupid crappies. blush.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jimmy from Cottage Grove

Did anyone ever hear anything about the wind being a factor in the class of 95? Someone told me that on a typical year the winds on red stir up and ruin the crappie nests. Yet in 95 there was hardly any wind at all. That is why it is the only class. Because the walleyes were gone and the wind was low. Any truth to that? Sounds believable!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JBMasterAngler

That makes sense, when the crappies were first being reported every article I would read in the outdoor news would always start out with something along the lines of "red lake isn't the typical crappie lake" or something of that nature. And obviously, red is more of a windswept lake than winnie or even mille lacs.

The fact of the matter is, crappies have always been there and will always be there. The point I was making when I started this was...after the '95 year class is dead and gone and the walleys are back to normal, the crappies will be a rare stray catch...and with no crappies, will that make the resorts/bait shops suffer because of a lack of angler interest in the lake?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LABS4ME

my father in law fished the lake regularily before the walleye crash... they always caught crappies. It was their way of knowing they drifted to deep and had to motor back into walleye waters... they had no use for crappies! They were up to catch walleyes. I don't think they were nessacarily rare, just not sought after. Will we ever have a '95 year class again? Probably not... but the '91 year class sure provided some darn good crappie fishing before the '95 stepped up to the plate... and there were still walleyes around then!

Good Luck!

Ken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
united jigsticker

A "rare" catch isn't so true.

kelly's story of Jon and his 15 Crappies in 1986 is one I have heard from kelly before.

How did Jon catch 15 Crappies in July back in 1986 when there were no "cribs"?

Ohhh I bet there were a bunch of them.

I also was told by another long timer of Red that when the Walleyes were in their prime, nobody ever ventured out more then 2 miles, spring, summer, fall, or winter. He said 7 feet of water was the max they'd fish, and they'd cleanup well. But the only time they'd ever hook a Crappie was in the spring.

I would bet that if you dump some cribs in 13 FOW out 4-6 miles, you would have Crappies on them suckers every day after June. I can even say that most of them would be on the west side of the crib walls in the AM, and the east sides of the crib walls in the PM.

If you wanted to make the Crappies in Red REALLY easy to target in the summer, you'd drag out 100's of floating docks past the Walleye and Pike zone. Man do them Crappies love shade.

As kelly said, Crappies don't get caught up in the nets, and furthermore, they are one species the DNR has quoted to have the "ability to negotiate" the nets...I assume that means they can navigate them like an Albino Rat in a plexi maze.

I actually wouldn't mind of the Crappies were "forgetten" about for a while. Give them a chance to dumb-up some.

Then again, who can forget about a 15" Slab???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mike L

Quote:

my father in law fished the lake regularily before the walleye crash... they always caught crappies. It was their way of knowing they drifted to deep and had to motor back into walleye waters... they had no use for crappies! They were up to catch walleyes..."

Same with my brother-in-law's folks. And just to give ya a time frame, my brother-in-law is 72. shocked.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
hanson

I'm not an expert on the lake by any means but I've caught crappies of all sizes this winter, from 12" to 15". Most crappies are either 13 1/2" or 14 1/4 to 14 1/2". So what that means to me is growth rates are different on the same age of fish, or we are looking at different ages of fish. It seems like a couple times every year, we catch "small" crappies. My gut tells me this fish are finding somewhere to reproduce.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Random guy

Quote:

How did Jon catch 15 Crappies in July back in 1986 when there were no "cribs"?


Jonny did not listen to his father...again. I was to check the Birches, the deeper rock piles and a few small areas for active walleyes to put clients on. I got bored with that in short order and decided I wanted to go to the north shore and catch some pike. Well I took off across the lake trolling a shad rap so I could tell Kelly that I did look for walleyes as I crossed deeper water headed for the north shore reeds. Next thing I know I had a bunch of funny looking rock bass. (Remember I was 12 and never seen a crappie before). The fish were always in the lake, just nobody fished deeper water before.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
WKSparrow

Now that's a good story!!!

... a 12 year old catching his first crappies and it's 15 of those monsters...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JBMasterAngler

Honestly, I think that's about how old I was when I caught my first crappie...I'm used to fishing the grand marais area for smallies mind you so please don't make fun of me for taking so long to catch one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
halad

The first limit of crappies i caught in Red was in the late 70s. Trolling for walleyes probably in 4-6' i caught one and put it back going back through the area i caught another. I didnt put it back dropped the ancor and caught a limit all about 6" long. Went back the next day and they were gone. It seems like we always caught a couple in the summer but never thought much of it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
WKSparrow

I just meant that you'd be spoiled for life if those were the first ones you caught... not making fun of anyone!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
klecker

Well my six year old sure is. If he goes to any other lake they better be 14" + other wise he puts them back.

Klecker

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
united jigsticker

Halad, did you forget the 1 on the 6"????

Were they 6" long or 16"? grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
brady_d

yea i don't know how much meat you could get out of a 6'' crappie? grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
halad

Hey it was close to 30yrs. ago about 6", hand size. I would much rather eat the small ones I have enough of those 13-16" hanging on the wall. Save them for the tourists.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kelly-p

Quote:

I have enough of those 13-16" hanging on the wall.


What did you do????? glue some 6 inch ones together. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Random guy

Quote:

Quote:

I have enough of those 13-16" hanging on the wall.


What did you do????? glue some 6 inch ones together. grin.gif


Now that is funny, especially if you know Halad. laugh.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
halad

Glue two sixes together. I really did a good job setting myself up for that. Ok maybe they were bigger but not as big as the ones now. Hey Labs you sure those wernt Sheepheads.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LABS4ME

Naw they were crappies... grin.gif he quit coming in the mid-nineties when he caught 5-10 sheepshead for every walleye... I got to see a couple of dandy crappies he brought home in '93... but I never thought to go up and try to actually target them... he said they were just flukes. Caught one every now and then...

Good Luck!

Ken

MMMM Sheepshead!!! grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

Announcements



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Jmnhunter
      i cant narrow it down, just ordered a new regulator  and hose assembly instead; cant find replacement hoses locally anyhow that i could test out
    • SkolVikingsGuy
      Wondering if this coming Memorial Day weekend would be a good weekend to come up or if the fishing is slow?  Would love to have the kids catch some easy walleye if possible.  
    • BobT
      Got a reply from the DNR to my last question, which included a reference to tournaments. She forwarded my question to another and I'm still waiting for that reply. 
    • PSU
      In case anyone is interested. The link says 2017, but inside the link says 2018 https://www.cityautoglasswalleyeclassic.com/copy-of-2017-winners  
    • Rick
      A region-wide effort to better understand West Nile virus in ruffed grouse is getting underway in Michigan, Minnesota and Wisconsin.  “In the Great Lakes region, West Nile virus has been found in a small number of grouse with no known population-level effects at this point,” said Charlotte Roy, grouse project leader with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. “Still, we want to let hunters know we’re in the first steps of monitoring the virus, and we’re planning to do some limited testing of birds this fall.” In 2017, West Nile virus was identified in more ruffed grouse in the Great Lakes states than in the past. The virus has been present in Michigan, Minnesota and Wisconsin for about 17 years. West Nile virus has been documented in more than 250 species of birds; however, not all birds develop clinical disease from the virus. Corvids (including blue jays and crows) are very prone to illness and death from the virus, while other species may be less so or may not develop symptoms at all. Last year, Michigan had 12 positive cases of West Nile virus in ruffed grouse. Prior to 2017, only one positive ruffed grouse had been found in Michigan, and that was in 2002. The virus was confirmed in one ruffed grouse in the early 2000s in Minnesota, and is yet to have been detected in a Wisconsin ruffed grouse. West Nile virus in ruffed grouse has become a topic of concern because of a recent study in Pennsylvania reporting that the virus may have contributed to population declines in areas of lower-quality habitat or where habitat was scarce. Michigan, Minnesota and Wisconsin are in the early stages of planning to test samples from grouse this fall but at this point there is no evidence that the virus is having a population-level impact in the Great Lakes region. “By monitoring birds at a regional level, we will be able to gain a better understanding of this disease in ruffed grouse,” said Kelly Straka, state wildlife veterinarian with the Michigan Department of Natural Resources. Ruffed grouse are hunted annually by around 300,000 hunters across the three states. Preliminary reports from 2017 hunters were mixed across the Great Lakes region. While the virus could impact brood survival of grouse, other factors such as cold, wet springs during nesting and hatching; drought conditions; or habitat decline can also affect birds seen and harvested. Biologists in the region are optimistic that the great habitat for ruffed grouse in the Great Lakes states will help populations thrive despite the virus. “We are looking to hunters and outdoor enthusiasts to help us in this endeavor,” said Mark Witecha, upland wildlife ecologist with the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. “This is an excellent example of agencies and organizations taking a proactive approach and working together to expand our knowledge about WNV and ruffed grouse.” Recently, the Midwest Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies Health Committee held its annual meeting in Traverse City, Michigan. West Nile virus was one of the topics for state wildlife health leaders. More than 25 wildlife health professionals from 13 Midwestern states and Canada were in attendance. Individual agencies are currently reviewing ways they will be monitoring their grouse populations for West Nile virus, and additional information will be shared when more details are determined. Like humans, wild animals can be exposed to West Nile virus and survive the exposure. Currently, there is no evidence of humans becoming infected by consuming properly cooked birds or by handling birds. Research has shown dogs can be infected but are very resistant to developing clinical signs of the disease and are considered an end host. Ruffed grouse hunting is open in the fall and Minnesota hunting information can be found at mndnr.gov/hunting/grouse. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • TheEyesofanAngler
      what temp is between 55-60 degrees in central minnesota 
    • gimruis
      Isn't that something how they don't recognize the blind as a problem?  I've had turkeys walk literally right next to it too.  Nice bird FishandFowl, hope you didn't pulverize it too bad.
    • Rick
      An angler from Stillwater has set a new record for lake sturgeon in the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources’ catch-and-release category.  Jack Burke and fishing buddy Michael Orgas were recently on a lake sturgeon fishing trip to remember. Fishing on the Rainy River in Koochiching County, the duo was having a lot of success fishing for Minnesota’s biggest fish, landing 20 fish in three days including six lake sturgeon over 60 inches before hooking into the new state record – a 73-inch long lake sturgeon. “We had been having some great action and knew there were big fish in the Rainy River,” Burke said. “This particular fish took about 45 minutes to reel in. When we got it closer to the boat it blew some bubbles and came to the top; I knew it was a huge fish!” Burke caught the fish on May 4, around 11 a.m. using a muskie rod supplied by his fishing partner Orgas, with 80-pound braided line rigged with a circle hook and crawlers. The fish measures 73 inches in length and 30 inches in girth. This beats the previous record by 3 inches that was set by two separate anglers who both boated 70-inch fish on the same day in April 2017. There are two kinds of Minnesota state records: one for catching and keeping the biggest fish in each species based on certified weight; and the other for the length of a caught and released muskellunge, northern pike, lake sturgeon or flathead catfish. The DNR announces new state records in news releases, on social media and on the DNR website. Find current records and guidelines for each type of state record at mndnr.gov/recordfish. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • gimruis
      I went out on Saturday for about 5 hours and my friend and I caught a lot of crappies but they were mostly all dinks (8-10 inchers).  We only caught 4 of them over 10 inches.  Plus a few small bass and one pike.  We released all of them.  Water temp was right around 60, a little warmer up shallow in a bay.
    • Rick
      Avid angler Dustin Stone caught a new state record silver redhorse in the certified weight category of the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources’ record fish program.  Stone caught the 10-pound, 6-ounce silver redhorse while fishing for lake sturgeon on the Rainy River in Koochiching County on April 28. He was fishing with 80-pound braided line tipped with a night crawler. “We had been doing very well fishing for sturgeon, landing seven fish over the 60-inch mark,” Stone said. “We started catching a bunch of suckers and redhorse before this fish, so this fish felt quite a bit bigger than the others.” Fortunately for Stone, his fishing buddy had extensive knowledge about fish like silver redhorse, and Stone almost released the fish until his partner advised him to check the weight and current record on that species of fish. The new state record silver redhorse was weighed on a certified scale at a meat shop in Granite Falls, where two observers witnessed the weighing. Two DNR fisheries experts in the Ortonville office confirmed the species identification of silver redhorse. The official weight is 10-pounds, 6-ounces with a length of 26-3/4 inches and a girth of 17-1/2 inches, beating the previous state record of 9-pounds, 15-ounces held since 2004. “I’m glad the DNR does this record fish program. It’s fun to see the records. I’m kind of addicted to this now and I’m going to try and break a couple more!” Stone said. There are two kinds of Minnesota state records: one for catching and keeping the biggest fish of each species based on certified weight; and the other for the length of a caught and released muskellunge, northern pike, lake sturgeon or flathead catfish. The DNR announces new state records in news releases, on social media and on the DNR website. Find current records and guidelines for each type of state record at mndnr.gov/recordfish. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.