• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
opsirc

Marine or automotive, does it make a difference

Question

opsirc

I have a 71 chevy engine in my boat that needs a new fuel pump. I can get a automotive one for a fraction of the cost of a marine one. Is there that much of a difference between the two that would prevent using the automotive one?

thanks

O

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

6 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Whoaru99

Some marine parts have special features and certifications regarding safety and reliability.

After all, you don't want a fuel leak or gasoline vapors filling the bilge area. Nor do you especially want to try to walk back to shore in the event of a failure.

Also, if anything were to happen, I'm just guessing an insurance company could reject your claim if there was an incident even remotely tied to a non-marine grade part.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
opsirc

Whoaru

thought about that, but I have taken the old one apart to try and rebuild it, did not seem to be anything special about it. the one they use is just a single stage diaphram pump.

O

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
upnorth

From my experience the biggest need for Marine over automotive is you stuff like distributor caps, wires, and that like. Because there is likely to be some gas fumes under the cover most times you don't want anything that will spark.

Fuel pump? I would go with the automotive, the manufacturer probable did grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Surface Tension

I vaguely remember the fuel problem you were having.

Inside the tank is a drop tube/pickup line with a check valve on the end. If that line is rotted or the hose clamp is bad you'll be sucking air. Also it takes a considerable amount of suction to open that check valve which will compound an air leak. Its also possible that valve is corroded or stuck shut and needs a good soaking in a carb cleaner.

So if you haven't tested the pump with new lines that should be done first.

About the automotive fuel pump. I don't know what if any differences there are. If there are it would be in quality and in the in case of failure the marine pump might not dump fuel. You could try asking the manufacture what the differences are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Valv

If you have a Chevy engine in boat you already have a car engine, not marine. If you have a Mercruiser or Volvo GM engine then you have a marine motor.

The automotive pump will dump fuel into bilge if diaphram ruptures, the marine has a special bowl wnd return to avoid spillage in case of failure.

I would go with marine, lookup online and you'll find many places that sells them discounted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
opsirc

thanks for the input guys. the shop mannual claims that it is a GM inline 4. only two lines; one in, one out. it has a small bowl but nothing coming off of it. the carb rebuild kit came from NAPA.

Frank; if I remember from last spring when I took everything apart, there was no check valve in the tank tube. thought it was strange myself, but it worked fine the previous year. did not have problems till I had to tear everything out to rebuild the whole in side. rotten mice grin.gif might have to put a in line check valve before the tank.

Sam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Dash 1
      I just wrote to those five people. I am amazed at how I live in the South Haven area and yet every time I learn about these meetings after they happen. And they don’t understand why we feel they want us to stay off “their lake”.  Need to be more open and up front publicly about these meetings. As I have stated before in another forum, I have not fished Sylvia since this was implemented. Also I have not bought bait or boat gas in South Haven the last 2 years. I will spend my money where it is welcomed. I have been cleaning my boat at landings for years, plus power washing it when I get home. I am sure many good anglers/boaters do as well and for them to make us go through this inspection, which is out of the way and not even open 24 hours is rediculous. I am all for stopping the spread of AIS, but there needs to be better ways of doing a it than keeping the lake from all users.  We need everyone to get involved in this even if you don’t live near these lakes.  AIS is affecting us all but we need everyone to speak up about how it will be dealt with, or more lakes will be “closed” to the public with this inspection program.
    • CLPDB
      Ten Point what resort were you out of?  Thinking of going up this weekend.
    • gimruis
      I haven't seen many yet. I did see a good number of pheasants on a drive to and from Pierz the other day though.
    • gimruis
      My point was that I don't want ANY ethanol in an engine/motor that gets used for a while and then sits there - that's why I run ethanol free premium in them.  The ethanol sits there and gums up vital engine parts.  All of my irregular use engines are modern 4-strokes that run very smoothly and use a minimal amount of fuel and I'm going to do everything I can to keep them like that.  I use normal 87 or 89 octane unleaded in my truck because I use that almost every day all year round.
    • BIGFISH.JZ
      Got 5 nice 12"ers to fill my special regulation lake limit.. Morning bite was as good as evening bite has been. Released another 7 smaller 10" class fish. Fished 545-700 am. Crappie minnows were the bait of choice today. 1 rod was all I could handle with these suicidal slabs. Had one snap my 4# test flourocarbon leader on the hookset. 
    • creepworm
      The issue with that is, the DNR strongly supports "AIS Prevention" such as these inspections. So I doubt the DNR will stop funding activities on lakes that are doing something they would like to see expanded.
    • BIGFISH.JZ
      This is from a major marine engine maufacturer, YAMAHA, perhaps you have heard of them... "Not long after the introduction of E10 gasoline, boats using it began experiencing problems. Almost immediately mysterious substances began clogging fuel filters that were later identified as a byproduct of mixing fuel still in the tank containing *MTBE with ethanol-blended gasoline, but that was only a harbinger of things to come. Fuel lines approved for gasoline engines on boats reacted badly with the ethanol additive and started breaking down causing clogged filters; and in cases where the problem was not identified quickly, possible fuel leaks were the result. Any sludge deposits in older fuel tanks began dissolving and were pumped into the fuel system, damaging components and making a mess of filters. And boats with fiberglass fuel tanks were subject to the added nightmare of ethanol actually eating away the resin, which required replacement of the tank and in many cases, serious damage to expensive engine components like valves, carburetors and injectors." *MTBE was used to boost octane pre-ethanol. We won't even go into my opinion of damage I've personally seen in the last 20 years. But if you would like more direct quotes from big name industry leaders let me know.   As I stated before I won't comment or advise unless I have first hand knowledge on the subject... I know NOTHING about biodiesel. Until boats are powered by it, it doesn't even exist in my world. Sorry Bob, I got up early to slay some slab crappie, not research diesel issues. Crappies don't catch themselves!🎣😉
    • BIGFISH.JZ
      This is from Chevron lubricants, released in August 2018, listing the 3 main problems with ethanol blends. "Phase Separation: Gasoline oxygenated with 10 percent ethanol is capable of dissolving far more water than conventional gasoline alone. When this gasoline, ethanol and water blend is cooled, both the water and some of the ethanol become insoluble. The result is that the fuel separates into two layers or phases: an upper gasoline layer and a lower, ethanol-rich water layer. The gasoline layer will have a lower octane number and may cause knocking. The fuel also is less combustible; an engine will not run on the water-ethanol layer.   Corrosion: When water finds its way into the fuel system and combines with air, corrosion of iron and other metallic surfaces can occur, potentially affecting fuel pumps, injectors, fuel tanks, and other metallic components, causing them to degrade and decreasing their useful life. Water resulting from phase separation can also cause rust or corrosion over time.   Deposits: When gasoline components react with the oxygen in the air, the result is the formation of peroxides or gums. Soluble gums can lead to engine deposits, and insoluble gums can plug fuel filters. Deposits can also form throughout an engine’s intake system, including the fuel injectors, carburetor, intake manifold, intake ports and intake valves. The result is a noticeable decrease in engine performance, power and fuel economy, while increasing emissions and drivability." 
    • monstermoose78
      Seeing lots of birds turkey 🦃 time
    • Ten point
      Just got back from LOTW fishing for us was slow. But if you put the time in and watch your electronics it can still be good. We're fishing in 32ft lot of small fish just need to keep the hook away from them several good fish still coming thru. A few slot fish up to 26 1/2 inches walleyes 15 to 17 saugers 14 to 16 lot of water under the snow in spots.