• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
opsirc

Marine or automotive, does it make a difference

Question

opsirc

I have a 71 chevy engine in my boat that needs a new fuel pump. I can get a automotive one for a fraction of the cost of a marine one. Is there that much of a difference between the two that would prevent using the automotive one?

thanks

O

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

6 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Whoaru99

Some marine parts have special features and certifications regarding safety and reliability.

After all, you don't want a fuel leak or gasoline vapors filling the bilge area. Nor do you especially want to try to walk back to shore in the event of a failure.

Also, if anything were to happen, I'm just guessing an insurance company could reject your claim if there was an incident even remotely tied to a non-marine grade part.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
opsirc

Whoaru

thought about that, but I have taken the old one apart to try and rebuild it, did not seem to be anything special about it. the one they use is just a single stage diaphram pump.

O

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
upnorth

From my experience the biggest need for Marine over automotive is you stuff like distributor caps, wires, and that like. Because there is likely to be some gas fumes under the cover most times you don't want anything that will spark.

Fuel pump? I would go with the automotive, the manufacturer probable did grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Surface Tension

I vaguely remember the fuel problem you were having.

Inside the tank is a drop tube/pickup line with a check valve on the end. If that line is rotted or the hose clamp is bad you'll be sucking air. Also it takes a considerable amount of suction to open that check valve which will compound an air leak. Its also possible that valve is corroded or stuck shut and needs a good soaking in a carb cleaner.

So if you haven't tested the pump with new lines that should be done first.

About the automotive fuel pump. I don't know what if any differences there are. If there are it would be in quality and in the in case of failure the marine pump might not dump fuel. You could try asking the manufacture what the differences are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Valv

If you have a Chevy engine in boat you already have a car engine, not marine. If you have a Mercruiser or Volvo GM engine then you have a marine motor.

The automotive pump will dump fuel into bilge if diaphram ruptures, the marine has a special bowl wnd return to avoid spillage in case of failure.

I would go with marine, lookup online and you'll find many places that sells them discounted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
opsirc

thanks for the input guys. the shop mannual claims that it is a GM inline 4. only two lines; one in, one out. it has a small bowl but nothing coming off of it. the carb rebuild kit came from NAPA.

Frank; if I remember from last spring when I took everything apart, there was no check valve in the tank tube. thought it was strange myself, but it worked fine the previous year. did not have problems till I had to tear everything out to rebuild the whole in side. rotten mice grin.gif might have to put a in line check valve before the tank.

Sam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • mbeyer
      I know this....not as many smallmouth coming up shallow on this fall trip as compared to spring. Could not get a top water bite regardless of time of day and depth of water.   Found a few stragglers in the few hours we chased them.
    • plot0015
      thank you!   and thank you for the advice... i will try it out in my boat this week, and report back
    • leech~~
      Welcome to the forum.   Go try it out in 5 feet of water before you write it off.  The older units need a pretty solid water column to send the echo back and forth.  Good luck.
    • plot0015
      So i recently picked up a Zercom Clearwater Classic for 15 bucks off craigslist....     I fired the unit up and the LCD screen works, back light works, and when i plug the transducer in, i can hear the transducer "clickling" (i can see a slight change in the LCD lines when i plug the 'ducer in....so its almost like it recognizes that its there....) but as i'm messing with it i can't get it to see my hand or the floor...  (ie. the LCD lines never move off 2 ft)   I thought it might be the Transducer.... but this 'ducer has an old school RCA jack the reminds me of the old Red/White/Yellow cables from my Nintendo....(see image)  Obviously zercom isn't around anymore so getting a tranducer is brutal.   Marcum bought zercom, but they couldn't help when i reached out to them.  Called Fishlectronics, they didn't have anything....    See the pictures to see the LCD lines that never move and the 1990's tranducer plug.....      Did i waste my 15 bucks?    
    • leech~~
      Sounds like a worn wire grounding out some where.  One of my trailers I just pulled the whole wire harness off and put on a new one. Not fun but it worked. 
    • Hookmaster
      I checked out the truck wiring and it looked good. I towed my duck boat last weekend and the running lights worked. So, it must be my fishing boat trailer. I'll check light bulbs first but may need to rewire since it's seen 20 summers.
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the main basin... Good fall walleye fishing continues.  Jigs and frozen shiners working well in 28-32'.  Anchor up and jig.  If not finding fish, drift with spinners or troll crankbaits to find active fish.  Fish starting to stack in front Pine Island and other south shore locations.  Some days fish are sliding shallow.  Shiners continue to run up the Rainy River.  On the Rainy River... Shiners are running.  Walleyes are just starting to enter river.  Anglers reporting success both jigging and pulling crankbaits.  Increased sturgeon activity.  Walleye activity is increasing as shiner run continues.     Up at the NW Angle... Fishing is excellent.  Strong numbers of walleyes being caught on mud flats and adjacent to islands. 15 - 25'.  Spinners, crankbaits and jigging all still producing.  Walleyes starting to move towards structure and outside mouths of bays.  Crappie activity strong, guides helpful for crappies.   
    • leech~~
      It would be nice to have a massive private slough or hunting woods but for the majority of us poor folks it's part of the game. Some days you win and some days the other guy does. Or you just sit home do nothing and play with yur doober!  😕
    • DLD24
      Had a nice little surprise yesterday walleye fishing  20180924_085152.mp4
    • Sunset Lodge
      Hello from the NW Angle!

      Lake of the Woods water temps are steadily falling into the mid to low 50’s. This past week cold fronts and strong winds have fish schooling up and feeding heavily.

      In Minnesota, look to rocky bays and adjacent reefs in 15-22ft. of water.  A jig and minnow is all that is needed to catch a limit in a short period of time. Bottle necks between islands in the NW Angle are also worth fishing in the evenings.
       
      In Canada, the fishing has been excellent.  Crappie, walleye and perch are all schooling up and taking a jig and minnow.  With the water temperatures dropping, expect to see the muskie bite increase while trolling. 

      We will be closing October 22nd for ice in! Contact us for availability for your fall fishing trip!

      We hope to see you soon,
      Sunset Lodge