• RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
eyepatrol

VMax Carb, VMax HPDI and 4-stroke F series ?'s

Question

eyepatrol

Being I don't know much about the Yamaha line of motors, I was wondering if someone could explain to me the differences of the above brand motors and also how these motors would rank against each other in price.

Thank you!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

13 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Wave Runner

The HPDI stands for high pressure direct injection, the carbed model is the "old school" in technology and the F Series are the four stroke models. The V-Max HPDI is an HPDI with a more streamlined lower unit, usually only comes in 20" and was originally designed for bass boats.

I've owned two HPDI's (a 2002 150 V-Max HPDI and a 2004 200 HPDI) These two are the best two outboards I've ever owned and I've owned a bunch. I had the 2002 V-Max HPDI on a 2002 Lund Pro-V that still had a 20" inch transom and that was a sweet running rig. Great hole shot and good top end.

I owned the 2004 200 HPDI on a Pro-V also and the 200 HPDI is one of the most reliable products Yamaha has ever made. A little less aggressive than a V-Max HPDI but still impressive in terms of performance.

With either HPDI, starting is instant. Even right after winter storage, they just start right now.

The HPDI's and the four strokes are virtually identical in terms of fuel economy with a modest edge in performance to the HPDI series. Either of these stand well above the carbed models which are being discontinued soon if not already.

Pricing difference between HPDI and Four Stroke is not much. Good deals are available on both if you time your purchase right. Both of these are proven products with excellent reputations. The carbed model was also in it's day but that's in the past now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
iffwalleyes

Bass a hpdi would be very similar to the Optimax that you have had and are familiar with. Then a 4 stroke is a 4 stroke of course quit and clean. The HPDI are also very quite and clean too. Kind of the ford vs. chevy deal 4 stroke or HPDI. Performance wise HPDI will probably have more top end etc. The the 4 strokes on the market are pretty darn good too in the performance end of things.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
CASTnBLAST

There was recently a shootout of the 250hp motors available in Bass and Walleye Boat magazine and it may be on their website also.All were 4 strokes except one and it was quite interesting how the comparisons blew holes in all the theories about fuel consumption/emissions/noise levels etc. of the 4 strokers. Check it out if you get the chance it's a good read.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Valv

Hey, don't you wish they made a TDI (Turbo Diesel Injection)

It would have so much torque...... grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
eyepatrol

Thanks for the helpful info all. I had an incling that those were the differences, but wanted to be certain.

Speaking of motors, I received an E-tec dvd a week or so ago where they compared their motor to the Yamaha 4-stroke and the Verado. Some interesting differences, but the one thing I found most interesting was the race they had between 3 Triton bass boats all rigged with 225's. In 2 miles the E-tec outran the Yammi and Verado by 4 seconds (not much really), but what I really found interesting is the Yammi and Verado crossed the finish at basically the exact same time. Seems to me those Verados aren't as supercharged as they lead one to believe. A little unfair to be comparing 2-stroke DI's to 4-strokes IMO, but it was an interesting video.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
marine_man

Regarding the DVD you received... remember that the DVD is made by Evinrude... so the results very well could be biased a little... Bass and Walleye Boats is a good, objective magazine that typically has pretty good reviews and gives you all the numbers from their tests.

marine_man

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
eyepatrol

I agree. I thought the video was a bit biased and to some degree unfair trying to compare 2-stroke vs. 4's, but then again they don't make a 4-stroke so they're trying to sway opinions I think.

I went on that website last night and read all kinds of good info on the various comparisons, tests, etc. Very informative!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
PerchJerker

The supercharger in the Verado was to give it more punch out of the hole than a typical 4-stroke, which I think it does. It costs you some fuel economy at WOT though compared to other 4 strokes and DFI motors.

4-strokes are quieter than DFI motors, but at high rpms there is not that much difference in noise.

You know which way I went with my motor, the yamaha HPDI was my 2nd choice. If I wanted a 150 HP the F150 would have been my second choice, maybe even my first choice.

Stay away from the carbed versions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
iffwalleyes

Quote:

Thanks for the helpful info all. I had an incling that those were the differences, but wanted to be certain.

Speaking of motors, I received an E-tec dvd a week or so ago where they compared their motor to the Yamaha 4-stroke and the Verado. Some interesting differences, but the one thing I found most interesting was the race they had between 3 Triton bass boats all rigged with 225's. In 2 miles the E-tec outran the Yammi and Verado by 4 seconds (not much really), but what I really found interesting is the Yammi and Verado crossed the finish at basically the exact same time. Seems to me those Verados aren't as supercharged as they lead one to believe. A little unfair to be comparing 2-stroke DI's to 4-strokes IMO, but it was an interesting video.


God I hope they didn't show the guy in his pink thong in the Video grin.gif.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Rockin Rod

Ok, I have another question related to this: I have a 2000 v-max 150 that is EFI, but not HPDI. What is the difference between these?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
PerchJerker

EFI is fuel injected, it is not the same has HPDI which is direct injection. I can not explain in detail the differences between the two but it has to do with how the gas, air, and exhaust are treated and burned inside the engine. HPDI is the newer technology, much more fuel efficient, much lower pollution.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Wave Runner

They're both fuel injected but the HPDI stands for high pressure direct injection. Depending on the model year, the fuel is pumped into the cylinders at between 700 and 1,000 PSI by a fuel pump that runs off the flywheel.

The HPDI starts instantly compared to the EFI's habits (cold blooded sometimes) and the fuel economy of the HPDI is much better than an EFI.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
ricqik

In EFI, fuel is usually injected to the cylinder thru the intake ports. In a HPDI, the fuel is injected directly into the cylinder.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • leech~~
      Smoken!
    • smurfy
      so eyeguy.......you keep them? picklin material???????? to many bones for anything else!!!!   nice pictures.!!!!! how many line tangles already!!!😄
    • eyeguy 54
      Hello thursday
    • Smoker2
    • maxpower117
      No wake is in effect currently and will be for the weekend opener.  Spread the word. 
    • Pat McGraw
      I wouldn't read too much into the open water in Oak Narrows. There's been open water there for more than a month. There's clearly forces other than air temps or sunshine at work there. With that said, considering the data shared by delcecchi, and the current 15-day forecast I am not without hope.
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Enforcement Division has promoted four officers – Chelsie Leuthardt, Brandon McGaw, Jen Mueller and Brett Oberg – to the position of regional training officer. They’ve been in their new positions since April 18.  The Enforcement Division’s six regional training officers are responsible for training the state’s conservation officers on topics such as defensive tactics, firearms and use of force. In addition, they train and work closely with the 6,000 volunteers who are integral to delivering the division’s education and safety training program. (The largest number of volunteers, about 4,000, are firearms safety instructors.) Regional training officers also spend a portion of their time performing the traditional field duties of a conservation officer. Following are brief bios of the newly promoted officers: Chelsie Leuthardt has been a conservation officer for four years and most recently patrolled the White Bear Lake area. “I’ve made strong connections with many instructor groups and look forward to working with them more closely,” said Leuthardt, whose area includes the southeastern part of the state. “I enjoy working with our user groups and helping to form how we train our next generations of outdoor enthusiasts.” Brandon McGaw has been a conservation officer since 2007. For most of that time, he’s been stationed in the Mora area. He’s also been a Conservation Officer Academy instructor, field training officer, firearms instructor and use of force instructor. “I really love teaching,” said McGaw, whose area includes 10 counties north of the metro. “I enjoy connecting with the students as well as the older adults who take safety training courses.” Jen Mueller began her career as a conservation officer in the Hutchinson-West station in 2012. Mueller, who was promoted after serving as an acting regional training officer, said she learned quickly that participating in the Enforcement Division’s youth safety programs was one of her favorite parts of the job. “I’m amazed by our volunteer instructor groups and how passionate they are about what they’re teaching,” said Mueller, whose area includes the southwestern part of the state. “I also enjoy teaching our officers and helping them become better equipped to deal with situations they may face in the field.” Brett Oberg has been a conservation officer for 13 years and spent much of that time in the Hutchinson-East station. He’s also been an armorer, field training officer and use of force instructor. “I really enjoy training others and seeing youth get excited about the outdoors, especially firearms and hunting,” said Oberg, whose area includes the south metro and south-central part of the state. “I also enjoy teaching at the Conservation Officer Academy and helping the new recruits become conservation officers.” The four officers join Regional Training Officer Mike Lee, who covers the northeastern part of the state, and Acting Regional Training Officer Greg Oldakowski, who is responsible for the northwestern part of the state. Bruce Lawrence is the Enforcement Division’s statewide recreational vehicle coordinator. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Calves mark successful introduction of Theodore Roosevelt National Park herd genetics With new bison calves expected at Minneopa State Park in the coming weeks and months, managers with the Department of Natural Resources Parks and Trails division are reminding visitors to keep calves’ safety in mind by remaining in their vehicles along the park’s popular bison range road.  “The bison cows are incredibly protective of their calves, and it’s tempting for park visitors to get out of their vehicles to take photos,” said Parks and Trails area supervisor Craig Beckman. “However, it’s important for people to remember to stay in their vehicles for the safety of these calves, their mothers and other park visitors.” The new additions are offspring of the bison bull that was introduced in December 2016. That’s significant, Beckman said, because the bison bull comes from Theodore Roosevelt National Park and possesses a genetic line that’s not well represented in the Minnesota Bison Conservation Herd. That genetic line will contribute to the herd’s overall genetic health and diversity. While Minneopa State Park is seeing its first successful additions to the herd, the bison herds at Blue Mounds State Park and the Minnesota Zoo are also seeing new calves this year. For visitors viewing the bison at state parks, patience can be rewarded. “Newborns need time for maternal bonding, and may be hard to see from the road for a while, but as they grow and mature, they become more visible,” Beckman said. “We tell visitors that they will be more likely to see the bison if they are patient and take it slow as they drive through the range.” Bison viewing tips: The bison drive begins near the campground off state Highway 68. A vehicle permit ($7/one-day or $35/year-round) is required to enter the park. Bison may be difficult to spot at times. Drive slowly and keep a watchful eye through the range. Remain inside vehicle while driving through the bison range. Bison should be given clearance of at least 75 feet from people and vehicles at all times. Dogs can make bison nervous, so pets must be kept on a leash while in the park and hiking around the bison range. Bison get nervous around loud noises or lots of activity, so keep voices down and movements to a minimum to help keep the bison within easy viewing. Hiking is not allowed inside the range, but there are hiking trails all the way around the outside of the range that can provide some fantastic views of the bison. The bison are part of the Minnesota Bison Conservation Herd, managed through a formal agreement between the DNR and Minnesota Zoo. The partners are working together to preserve American plains bison and plan to grow the herd at several locations, including Blue Mounds and Minneopa state parks and the Minnesota Zoo. The goal is a 500-animal herd at multiple locations. Genetic testing of the herd from 2011 to 2014 found them largely free of any genetic material that would have come from cross-breeding with cattle. Less than 1 percent of all American plains bison tested so far have been found free of cattle genes. Visitors at Minneopa can check the park website for updates on the bison herd and its new calves at mndnr.gov/Minneopa. The site also provides more information about the park, including a virtual tour. Minneopa State Park is located off U.S. Highway 169 and state Highway 68, 5 miles west of Mankato. The bison range road is open Thursday through Tuesday each week from 9am to 3:30pm. For more information about the Minnesota Bison Conservation Herd on the Minnesota Zoo website or visit mndnr.gov/bison. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources has scheduled an auction of confiscated hunting and fishing equipment for Saturday, Aug. 4. The auction, which is open to the public, will include items from people who forfeited their equipment after committing serious game and fish violations. More than 200 firearms, over 40 bows, and a variety of other hunting and fishing-related equipment will be available.  The auction will be at Hiller Auction Service in Zimmerman. Public inspection of the items will be available in advance of the auction. All equipment will be sold as-is, including all defects or faults, known or unknown. Once they’ve been purchased, items cannot be returned. Background checks are required of anyone who purchases a firearm. Revenue from confiscated equipment auctions goes into the Game and Fish Fund, which is the DNR’s primary fund for delivering fish, wildlife and law enforcement programs. Details about the auction will be available as the date draws closer. For more information, see mndnr.gov/enforcement/auctions/index.html. A list of equipment to be auctioned will be posted online approximately one month in advance of the auction at www.hillerauction.com. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Some anglers go above and beyond to make fishing better in Minnesota by purchasing walleye stamps that help the Department of Natural Resources add walleye to lakes where there otherwise would be none.  “Buying a walleye stamp is a concrete way to help maintain fishing opportunities in Minnesota,” said Neil Vanderbosch, DNR fisheries program consultant. Funds from walleye stamps go toward the cost of purchasing 4- to 6-inch walleye called fingerlings from private fish farms for stocking into lakes. A walleye stamp is not required to fish for or keep walleye. Anglers with a fishing license can purchase the walleye stamp validation for $5, and for an extra 75 cents can have the pictorial stamp mailed to them. Walleye stamps can be purchased anywhere Minnesota fishing licenses are sold, online at mndnr.gov/buyalicense or by phone by calling 888-665-4236. Alternatively, anglers can download a form found at mndnr.gov/stamps and return it to the DNR to have the stamp mailed. The DNR raises and stocks walleye, but also buys walleye fingerlings from private producers to be stocked into lakes – walleye stamp sales help pay for these fish. Since 2009, funds from the walleye stamp have purchased over 40,000 pounds of walleye fingerlings that have been stocked in the fall, all over the state. Walleye fingerlings generally are stocked in lakes that do not have naturally reproducing walleye populations. A vast majority of the walleye Minnesota anglers catch come from waters where the fish reproduce naturally – about 260 larger walleye lakes and in large rivers. But because of stocking, walleye can be found in an additional 1,050 Minnesota lakes spread throughout the state. More information about habitat stamps can be found at mndnr.gov/stamps. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.