• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • WE CREATE LONG TERM, MEANINGFUL RELATIONSHIPS IN HERE ... PLEASE JOIN US.

    You know what we all love...

    RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE
    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Corey Bechtold

Panfish limits...

Recommended Posts

Corey Bechtold

I made this comment in the Crappies/Sunfish forum but was wondering what the overall concensus of this idea would be...

Typically when the houses have to be off the lakes and we need to buy new liscences Panfish are sliding shallow and are really volnerable to overfishing. Wouldn't it make sence to at least lower the limits again up until Walleye/Pike Opener? That way we could insure that there would be some fish left to make a good spawning run and be able to defend their nests from predator fish when the spawn occurs. Maybe dropping the limits in half during that time period would make sence. Who really needs more than 5 Crappies and 10 Sunfish for a meal or two anyway?

Just food for thought,

Corey Bechtold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Matt Johnson

You know how I feel about this Corey... I'm another panfish geek grin.gif

I think lowing the limits during those times would be a good choice. As you mentioned, these panfish are very vulnerable to fishing pressure. Not many times can an angler sit and catch ten 28-30 inch walleyes in one spot, back to back, but it's very possible to catch ten 9-10 inch sunfish in one spot back to back during those times. And those 9-10 inch sunfish will stack up and are considered trophy fish to a lot of people. Panfish are more vulnerable in general, and to a lot of people, they are considered nothing more than table fare. People generally agree that a large walleye goes back in the lake, but to many people a large sunfish is seen as a nice fillet.

Lowing the limits during these vulnerable times could ensure a better spawn as well as the future of that given body of water...

Just a few words from a biased angler wink.gifgrin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BDR

I totally agree!! I do think that to really protect them it would need to entend into mid June. Yes you can really pound the Pannies early but it seems later when you can pinpoint the huge ones.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
harvey lee

Why shouldnt we have the limits lowered to 5 crappies and 10 sunfish? As staed above that is plenty for a meal for most famlies.I do believe that the younger generation is very good at policing themselves as they have been brought up with CPR.

I also believe that some of the older fisherman still have the bring home a pail of fish mentality.Some also will double dip every day during a good bite.

If we as sportsmen want to continue to have a good population of fish to catch we have to start to do more and control what we keep.It only makes sense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cyberfish

I would like to see some kind of regs that would encourage harvest of smaller fish and release of the big ones.

We don't have a problem with panfish numbers. Especially in the metro, these lakes are jammed full of sunfish and most of them are small. Now if people took home 20 6 to 7 inch gills and threw back the 8 to 10 inchers, the lakes would be better off.

On lakes that have a lower limit or all release, is seems at first the pannies get huge, but then they spawn, and spawn and spawn, and if there are not enough bass to thin them out, they over populate and get stunted. How about 20 sunfish under 8 inches, and only one over 10?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rockingroy

I think this depends on the lake. I love panfish above all other species for the table but some lakes are actually better later in the season especially for Crappies. I know a lake near the metro where a limit of crappies is hard to come by in the spring, but from mid August on through October, limits are the norm and I won't keep a Crappie under 9". I'd prefer a slot on these lakes (9" min 1 over 12" for example) Other lakes should be all fish between 9-12" should be immediatly released with 1 over 12". Similar restrictions for Sunfish would be great, but the bottom line is DNR enforcement of such limits would be difficult. Angler restraint is unfortunately the best thing we have going right now, and when it comes to panfish probably the best we can hope for since limits have already been slashed by 33% recently. I wouldn't support 5 and 10, however I would support 7 and 14. I would also support no more than 1 crappie over 12" and no more than 1 Sunnie over 10".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
eyepatrol

I think for the first time I'd have to agree basically 100% with every post that's been written so far! smirk.gif

I share the same concerns here that Corey is talking about. I know what Matt is saying, and I agree to some extent with Harvey Lee's assessment of the younger generation vs the older generation, although I don't want to sound like I'm generalizing the entire older generation into one big group though, because I know there are plenty of people in that age group that do practice C&R.

I also agree with what the others have said in regards to lowering limits for specified periods of time, and even having size limits. It may be tough to police, but I wouldn't think it would be that much more difficult than policing the size restrictions for other fish such as walleye.

I personally would be in favor of either a reduced limit for a period of time, or a "slot" limit of sorts. Either would be fine with me.

Just to take this discussion a step further, and I don't mean to ruffle feathers on this thought, but I also have a concern on whether or not a fish becomes stressed from being caught to a point where it affects their spawn. Along this same line of thought, I know and understand that it's fun to go out and catch a whole bunch of sunnies and/or crappies in a day, but is it really necessary to do so during the spawning period? After the spawn, sure, I don't have a problem with catching numbers of pannies. I guess if I had some reassurance that catching the fish doesn't put overdue stress on them and doesn't affect their spawning, my thoughts on this wouldn't be so concerning. However, if catching pannies during the spawn does affect their spawning, I'd be concerned about the numbers people catch in a day. Anyone have info on this thought?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Corey Bechtold

I understand what you are saying basscatcher. Smallmouth bass are especially prone to stress when removed from their spawning sites. The ideal spots are taken by doninent fish and removing the fish for a few seconds allows other fish to come in and destroy the beds. I think there was a good article written in an In-Fisherman article a while ago. Panfish aren't that different in that sence. I have read about how there are "sneaker" Sunfish that will spawn with females when the Bull males are away from the nest for a brief time. This stops the good genetics from the Bull males and aides to stunting in a lake.

Good topic so far guys, thanks for being civil about the thought. smile.gif

Good luck,

Corey Bechtold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
riverrat56

I'd be against lowering the limits, once the houses are off very few people are out fishing anyways, there are some on some lakes, but the numbers really drop, also once vehical travel is dones numbers drop further, and that normally is only a week or 2 in time. Although I do see the theory behind it, I don't want another law to deal with, theres to many regs already. Also how do you tell people that they can only keep 5 crappies when all year they could keep 6 eyes? I understand the reasoning for the idea, but I'm personally not in favor of it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FRESHWATER PETIE

Slot size limits on panfish sounds like a good idea, on certain lakes. Some lakes need it while other lakes, maybe not? Certain lakes just get more pressure than others. Other things also factor into why some lakes produce large panfish while other lakes don't.

I think the DNR has done a good job, and will continue to improve our fishing. With specific slot sizes, and limits.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Chad Halvorson

I hardly see anyone on the lakes anyways in the last month of ice, so there is no reason for it. Also, 5 Crappies is barely enough to feed a Big Fella like myself (10") Crappies.

7 Crappies and 12 Gills would be a happy medium IMO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lunker

I agree. I was doing a netting survey with the fisheries society here at my school this weekend, and I was amazed at some of the fish coming out of the shallows. Numerous 13-15" crappies and 9-11 inch gills. At no other time of the year are trophy fish this concentrated. And they are very vulnerable. It's a tough sell though, people don't hold panfish high on their charts of fish to protect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Corey Bechtold

Appartntly there are also some people who don't understand that "Daily" and "Posession" limits are the same. I fished with two of my kids today and saw several of the same boats that I saw two days ago. They were still filling the live (death) wells. I also had one guy ask me if I was out yesterday. wink.gif That means that he was out there Sat, Sun and today. Never saw a fish go from hook back to lake. Just from lake to livewell. frown.gif

Panfish are the most sought after fish specie according to the DNR's website. So my gripe is why don't they try and protect some of the fish in these lakes. Fishing Panfish right now is pretty much like shooting fish in a barrel and some people obviously don't have any restraint. They just call a friend or two on the cell phone, go pick up someone on shore and get back to the fish so they can bang up on some more fish.

I'm sorry about venting.

Good luck,

Corey Bechtold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gorrilla

Ten of each is cool with me. I don't like cleaning more than that anyway, ever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PikeBayCommanche

Cory, I agree and it makes me sick to hear about those people. It must make them feel better or something to go home and clean all of those fish. I bet I only took my limit for any species 2 times this year in Minnesota. I like to eat fish but its not even good to eat it more than once a week due to Mercury levels. I am proud to say that living most all of my life in Iowa and catching Thousands of fish I have kept no more than 40 fish. With the lack of fishing options in Iowa I see people keep about anything they catch (10-11 inch Walleyes) and have figured that the more I can do to keep populations up I will do it because I don't need the fish for food.

I just don't get it. Personally I would rather go out and catch a few large fish and get pics than come home with a limit of panfish or whatever.

I would like to thank those responsible fishermen and women who continue to give those fish back for other anglers to report of having a great day of catching fish on the water. wink.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nytelyter

now some one correct me if i am wrong. but i have always been told that a sunfish will spwan multiple times in a summer now how can you protect a fish during spawning if they spawn more that once. i have caught nice sunfish well into summer months that have eggs in them. i am for and do practice c n r but i do also like the little critters an table fare. another thing i do is i have a few elderly people here in town that reap the benifit of a good days fishing. i do not over fish but i love to see the smile a package of fillets puts on their faces. ... paul

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
eyepatrol

I for one agree that pounding the fish and taking limits day after day is not a good practice and could potentially cause systematic changes whether during or after the spawn. I do feel it is okay for a person to keep a limit of panfish, since that is what they are entitled to, however, during the spawn I would still have to agree with the intent of this post, that limits should be reduced (or people use restraint). Spawn is an important time for the panfish (or any specie) and it would be nice to see people use caution when keeping fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
vikingtom

I want to kow who gets limits day after day. Don't they have jobs. I've gone fishing alot and never got my limit day after day. Guess I'll have to find these guys and park my butt next to them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
eyepatrol

I know there are a number of retired guys where I'm from that are able to accomplish this. They've been fishing for years and years and know what lake to go to, and when to go to it. Most people though are likely working.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cyberfish

mabye we should quit callin' them PANfish !grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
shorefisher

Reading this post and many like it always make me think am I realy a bad sportsman for fishing 4 days in a row, causing stress to panfish by fishing in the spring and eating a few confused.gif If you do not want to cause any harm to fish or the fish population just don't go fishing. I for one do not need any more laws. Just my thoughts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
katoguy

Shorefisher, as long as you obey all regulations and never have more than your personal limit in your possession (including freezer)... then I'll agree that you may not be a bad sportsman for fishing 4 days in a row.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Walleyeguy31

The alleged size limit you are mentioning would keep me from fishing my lake of choice. I have never caught a crappie under 14 inches in the 20 years I have fished it. It pretty much never has an issue giving up limit upon limit of crappies at given times in the Winter, Spring and Fall.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Matt Johnson

Quote:


I have never caught a crappie under 14 inches in the 20 years I have fished it.


I'm in! When are we going? grin.gif Or how about a trade? Big crappies for big gills? smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Hoey
      ....is a City Park.  Land of Memories  with a lot of Minnesota and Blue Earth River shore access and I believe you can access the confluence of the rivers there as well.   Another attraction not really connected to fishing is Minneopa State Park with the falls on one side of the road and drive through buffalo herd area on the other.  Parks require a car window sticker for entrance.   Good Luck
    • mrpike1973
      I like them when it's dead calm they seem to work great then. When it gets a little ripple on top not as effective but still learning with them. Thanks for the report jigginjim
    • Mike89
      class of 70 here, and the park across the river  is Land of Memories if I remember correctly...
    • Rick
      Anglers can play a role in a proposed fishing regulation change for northern pike on Lake Vermilion that would simplify northern pike regulations by bringing them in line with the new statewide zone regulation starting in May 2019.  Anyone who wants to ask questions and give input about the regulation proposal can attend an open house scheduled by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources for 6 to 8 p.m. Wednesday, Aug. 22, at the Tower Civic Center, 402 Pine St., in Tower, Minn. Lake Vermilion northern pike are currently managed under a special regulation that requires all pike from 24 to 36 inches long to be released and only one fish over 36 inches is allowed in a three-fish possession limit. Under the northeast pike zone regulation, all fish from 30 to 40 inches long must be released and no more than one over 40 inches is allowed to be kept in a two fish possession limit. Spearers would be allowed to take any size pike but would be allowed only one fish over 26 inches in the two fish possession limit. “We are interested in the public’s preference about this because either regulation will help maintain the size of pike anglers enjoy on Lake Vermilion,” said Edie Evarts, Tower area fisheries supervisor. “Northern pike have done well and average size has increased under the special regulation that began in 2003. But a shift to the statewide zone regulation would simplify regulations while still protecting a portion of pike.” Public comment on the pike regulation can be submitted through Wednesday, Sept. 26. Questions or comments may be directed to the Tower area fisheries office, 650 Highway 169, Tower, MN 55790, by calling 218-300-7803, or emailing [email protected] Additionally, an open house about this proposal and other fishing regulations under review is scheduled for 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Sept. 26 at the DNR Central Office, 500 Lafayette Road in St. Paul. Staff will take comments on this proposal and other fishing regulations under review around the state. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources has confirmed zebra mussels in Bay Lake, near Deerwood in Crow Wing County. Last fall, a lakeshore owner reported finding the shell of a dead zebra mussel, but additional searches with DNR zebra mussel detection dogs could not confirm the presence of live specimens. Recently, a guest of another lakeshore owner reported finding a live specimen that a DNR invasive species specialist confirmed to be an adult zebra mussel. Additional water sampling showed the presence of veligers and in-lake searches confirmed a reproducing population of zebra mussels in Bay Lake. “Most of the new zebra mussel reports are brought to our attention by people who are out using Minnesota’s public waters in the summer months,” said DNR invasive species specialist Tim Plude. “We appreciate the vigilance of folks reporting them to the DNR, as well as the partnerships we have with lakeshore owners.” Signs at lake accesses have been updated to alert boaters to the presence of zebra mussels. Zebra mussels are transported over land by human activity, and lake users can prevent their spread. It’s an important reminder to follow the state’s invasive species laws:
      • Clean watercraft of aquatic plants and prohibited invasive species,
      • Drain all water by removing drain plugs and keeping them out during transport, and
      • Dispose of unwanted bait in the trash. The DNR also recommends boaters take one or more of the following precautions before moving to another waterbody:
      • Spray with high-pressure water.
      • Rinse with very hot water (120 degrees for at least two minutes or 140 degrees for at least 10 seconds).
      • Dry for leave least five days. When transporting water-related equipment such as boat lifts, docks, swim rafts or associated equipment, Minnesota law requires a 21-day drying time to destroy attached organisms, before placing that equipment in another lake. Zebra mussels are an invasive species that can compete with native species for food and habitat, cut the feet of swimmers, reduce the performance of boat motors, and cause expensive damage to water intake pipes. People should contact an area DNR aquatic invasive species specialist if they think they have found zebra mussels or any other invasive species. More information is available at www.mndnr.gov/AIS. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • rumeye
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      PSU, Lindys, bobbers with leeches and crawlers. Trolling with cranks and spinners are now good also. Cliff
    • ANYFISH2
      Thanks everyone.  Will spinning gear hold up along the river? I have a couple heavier casting rigs i will bring to handle the cats(hopefully). Any tips on gear/lures/bait to have? Also, considering I am from very central MN, I have caught your usual species.  Any species in the river there, we/I could target that are not very prevalent here? Examples, goldeye, quillback, drum, ect.  less than common fish? Always looking for new fish to add to the list. Thanks again.
    • Lohmwil
      I'll plan on being there.  Sounds like fun
    • Hoey
      That park is Sibley Park.  Areas there for parking with a very short walk to the river.  Water is high i believe.  And plenty of areas for your family to enjoy as well, with a playground and picnicking areas.  I grew up in Mankato, a Scarlet from the class of '78.  40th reunion this year.  I will be in town on Saturday, driving my Mom around to visit family, graves, and places we have lived.  Good Luck!!!