Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

Weimaraners


tomahawk

Recommended Posts

Does anyone know of any weimaraner breeders that have decent hunting dogs? My wife is absolutley positve that this is the dog for her! We have always owned britnys or shorthairs and actually have had great luck with both,but now are trying weimaraners ...if we can only find one! I dont want to buy one because the breeder tells me they are great bird dogs I want someone who has purchased one to tell me they are great bird dogs. Thanks for any help at all!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just my .02 but, the two I hunted behind found birds alright. That was after they got into fights with the other dogs, chewed up the interior of one owners truck, and bit one hunter when the dog decided he wanted to keep the bird. Oh yeah, my biggest grouse of the year crushed to mush with one fatal crunch of the jaws. Bad trainer, bad day, or bad dog? They're built like a tank and all but do some breed research before you decide. I'm biased from hunting behind three excellent Brits for the last five years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've had the same experience chunky had. This male was real stronge headed and did'nt listen at all to its owner. That could have been the owners fault. The most feared dog on my paper route as a kid was a wiemer(grey ghost) chased and bit anything that came into turf. It might have just been a bad one,but I would check it out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is just my opinion and observation so do with it what you will. I have been around pointing dogs for a long time, I have studied them, trained them, judged them and talked to endless numbers of trialers, breedres and owners, I'm not claiming to be an expert just informed. Weimies in recent years have gained in popularity. Because of this demand for the dogs there has been a lot of breeding, and with that comes a lot of uninformed breeding which results in sub-par gene pool which in turn creates sub-par dogs with defects. Whether it be hearing, temperment or inability to hunt, once you introduce that many unfit dogs into the breeding pool you are going to have problems.
Exapmles of this in recent history are the Gordon Setter, Cocker Spaniel, Golden Retriever and in the non-huntin category Dalmations. Most of these dogs were bred because of the way they look and not the way they perform in the field, which is the case now with the Weimie. I am not in any way saying you can't find a nice dog that is going to be able to hunt, I'm just saying that I would be very, very careful. I would sit down and decide what is important to you and your wife in a dog, is it the way it looks, or the way it behaves. Then do lots and lots of research. Good Luck on your search.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My experience with them is the same as chunkys. The ones I know of(2) have been bull headed. The most feared dog along my paper route when I was young was a wiemer(gray ghost). He would chase and bit anything or anyone that came into his area. They might have just been bad ones but I would check there temperment out.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Thanks so much for all of the insight.I have talked to only one person who owns one and he seems to have gotten a good one.Im sure its the result of careful and precise breeding.I sure hate to gamble on a ten year plus commitment. I wont fix it cuz it aint broke.Got my 3rd shorthair today.....let the wife pick it out.Shes happy and so am I!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tomahawk, congrats on your new hunting partner!! Good choice and timing, The pup will be a great learning age for the upcoming season.My GSP learned alot at 7-8 months old as the season started.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...

Tomahawk,

The choice of the GSP was a good one. I think I would fall under the same category as your friend in which I truly enjoy my weime and she has worked out as an excellent hunter. She has been wonderful around the kids and at the same time been very good out in the field. Like other types of dogs, i feel it is a mix between the trainer and luck on how the dog turns out, not the breed itself. Good luck with your GSP. my .02 cents

[This message has been edited by STILLNOFISH (edited 07-30-2003).]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Wanderer
      I haven’t been as far north as the chair yet so I have no idea what condition leech has left in in!  I think he should take it home and restore it.   Big Rice has was a b*ch to paddle.  I didn’t miss it this weekend and won’t miss it any other weekend I don’t make it there.
    • Wanderer
      IKR!   I’m hopefully gonna be in Ely in a couple weeks but I’ll be chasing ducks more than grouse.  Not the best place to go for ducks but I love it up there in October.
    • Kettle
      Still biting lindy rigs. Had to get some fish before I head out to chase birds 
    • smurfy
      roughfish!!!!!!!!!!👍🤣🤣   dandy fish sir!!!!!!!!!!!👍
    • Kettle
      Put a few on the metal meat leash today 
    • monstermoose78
      As long as the birds don’t fly I am good. I can catch fish through the ice fairly well. 
    • MarkB
      My cousin and I just returned from beautiful Lake Vermilion after 4.5 days of the most spectacular walleye fishing you could ever hope for. Usually our mutual friend joins us but his father passed away and he had to opt out. We arrived late Saturday afternoon and packed things up after our morning outing Wednesday. We stopped at Cabelas on the way up and found them to be sold out of pike suckers. While they had them, they were charging 99 cents each! We then stopped at Harris bait shop and found a help yourself situation that was also out of pike suckers. They sold them while available for 6 for $6! We eventually found them locally for the same price as last year. During our stay, we used pike suckers, rainbow mix, and crawlers. The walleyes hit them all but, I believe, the rainbow mix caught the most, the crawlers were almost as productive, and the pike suckers produced the biggest fish.  We caught them in depths ranging from 13' to 27'. They were in the rocks and in the mud depending on the time of day. We caught walleyes all day every day with 5 o'clock PM to ~7 o'clock PM being optimum for quantity. The weather was absolutely HORRIBLE with high winds and non-stop rain early in the trip. Boat control was very difficult and I struggled to keep our speed around that .4mph to .6mph. Hits were fast and furious but the hit to catch ratio was at best 5 or more hits to one catch . We stuck with the 1oz bottom bouncers, 3 red beads, and a size 2 hook for the big suckers. I found a shorter 3' leader to be most effective. We caught 153 walleyes on our trip and I would bet we had at least 5 times that many hits!. Now, with all that said, we don't feed line to walleyes to help avoid gut hooks and that certainly gives rise to a poor hook-up ratio. We ate fish twice and brought home our limits. Everything else went back. The walleyes ranged in size from ~13" to 26". We caught lots of slot fish and fair numbers of 15"-19" fish. In addition, we caught 10 smallmouth and only one jumbo. Our really big fish were never landed. My cousin had a true giant walleye laying on top of the water right beside the boat and grabbed her by the base of the tail in an attempt to scoop her into the boat. She was having none of that and with a major flop, snapped the leader. We didn't use a net because I forgot it at the dock. Getting old is a bitch. I had two different walleyes(I'm sure) hooked on Tuesday that came off directly below the boat. Both fish I thought were snags when they hit. Anyone who thinks walleyes don't fight have never caught a truly big one. Both fish ran off several yards of line while fighting to get free. Eventually they both succeeded. I would hesitate to say how big I think my cousins fish was that he had beside the boat, but, my wife and I have caught some really big walleyes in Lake Vermilion and I know what a big walleye looks like. That walleye was absolutely enormous.  We've decided to bring my cousin's two sons back up for a short trip a little later on. Hopefully, the walleyes will still be in a feeding frenzy. Lastly, I usually like to include pictures with my posts. I have a big problem this time, I got a new phone and I know nothing about transferring the pictures. That will be remedied when we come back up. In the meantime....... Good Fishing, MarkB🙂
    • leech~~
      I don't think Moose needs my help, he seems to do pretty well with the ice fishing and grouse hunting by the pictures! 👌
    • smurfy
      looks to me like your gonna need to be on the ice ALOT to get them all checked out!!!!!!!👍🙄 mayhaps Leech could help ya out!!!!   at least he wouldnt be "accidently" locking any more threads!!!!!!🤗🤣🥴
    • monstermoose78
      I got some cool jigs this year this a picture from Slab Bait Shop. The 2nd to last photo is one of my jig boxes with them in it. The last photo has some Macula jigs and if your eyes are getting old these are awesome to tie!! I won the auction for the last photo so I got all of the plastics and jigs.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.