• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

Recommended Posts

Guest

believe it, there are lots of people out there catching and keeping 11 and 12 inch walleyes, stealing your future, bragging about catchihg there limits. these fish are especially vulnerable because they school heavy and are not bothered by cold fronts as much and seem to bite in any condition. i say naughty,naughty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mistermom

If you see them doing it on Goose lake call the CO cuz they're breakin the law (17" minimum).

mm

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
snapjigger

What lake are you refering too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
#Boater#

Just a question. Whats worse. To keep 1 24" or 2 12"?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jim W

1 - 24

Keep the rods bendin'!!!

Jim W

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mistermom

The answer isn't that easy. If its a lake with natural reproduction 1-24 for sure. If it is a stocked lake with little or no natural reproduction....? I personally wouldn't keep either sized fish.

mm

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

keeping a 12 or two isnt the problem ,once you catch 1 you more than likely will catch alot more. put 3 people in a boat or 4 or more people on a pontoon all keeping 6 theres the problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MnIceman

Myself and the friends that I fish with do not keep any walleyes under 14" and 24-25" is probably the biggest we keep.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Redlantern

Hey Guys, I was wondering if any one can tell me the answer to this. Are male fish able to breed more than once a season? The reason I ask is that there is a lot of talk about releasing certain size fish since they are most likely females. If the males can only breed once a season, doesn't it make sense to spare them too, or is it that there are more male fish capable of breeding? Just wondering out loud, not trying to p**s any one off. Thanks

------------------
Erik

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pikemania

If it is a naturally reproducing lake I would rather see someone keep 12" to 16" because it only takes a short amount of time to reproduce a fish that size where a 20" to 30" fish takes a much longer time to get a fish to that size and they are the main spawners keep the lake thriving with the smaller walleyes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
East Rush Rules

You know what i think, I think that there is enough fish in the lake for everyone to keep a limit. It doesn't really matter. Thats my opinion.

cool

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CorynTracySellHomes

Hey East Rush Rules.

You are right.....You are intitled to your opinion. But.....I strongly disagree. I think one person could quite easily damage a lake by themselves.
With todays fisherman being a much better angler overall than they used to be, at certain times of the year, someone could really damage a lake. That is why selective harvest is a GREAT idea! Take a few smaller fish for the table, and leave the bigger ones to go! The days of catching and keeping everything and giving them to your neighbors and friends has got to end.

Thats just this guys opinion!

Cory Frantzick

------------------
Visit us on the web at www.Athomeonthelake.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Paul Waldowski

Cory,

Super Post!!!! I couldn't agree more. If we are to ensure good fishing for future generations (like East Rush Rules) everyone will need to practice selective harvest. Keep a few medium size fish for the table and release the rest. smile.gif

------------------
Paul
[email protected]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EBass

My .02

First off I just don't like to clean fish. So I very rarely keep any, but if I do (winter) I'll only keep the 14-17" waldos. Anything bigger or smaller I feel bad. Heck I feel bad if I keep any. Just don't take my steak away.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jim W

East Rush,
Keep thinking that way. Won't be long and you'll be complaining there isn't a good walleye bite any more!

Jim W

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I'd like to weigh in on this topic and see what you guys think. One of the posts said that in general anglers are better...I agree to a degree...equiptment is much better for sure. I believe in the adage 10% of the anglers catch 90% of the fish. Fortunately, the 10% are generally committed to C&R. I do know that meat fishing is bigger here (MN) than any other place I have fished. Ham and Eggers will catch fish and sometimes catch big fish. My opinion is that they paid their license fees and they are entitled to catch and keep what they want (within the regs). Most of these people don't have the ability to damage a lake. I realize I am speaking in generalities but that is my opinion. I see a lot of guys that look like they know what they are doing but when I talk to them at the ramp they usually just talk a good game. I agree with EBASS that I personnally prefer steak or chicken but a fresh walleye sandwich on a Sat. afternoon rocks. I catch a lot of fish during the course of a season and better than 95% are released...Anyone who would look down their nose at me for keeping any walleye that I choose..that is your opinion but I think that some of us go a little too far with the need to return all fish to the water. Most of the fish are dying of natural causes faster than I can catch them!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • BrianF
      The water temp had dropped to anywhere between 44 to 40, depending on where you were. Saw as low as 37 in Bystrom Bay. The temp we saw the most was 41.  It’s cold!
    • Tom Sawyer
      A bit of a hike in, but well worth it, Mud Lake off the Inchon Trail I'm sure.....maybe we can meet up Brian and Tracie, I'll bring the potatoes and baked beans 😎
    • Wanderer
      Probably Lake Alott.   It kinda looks like a lot. 😉
    • Agronomist_at_IA
      I seen on JR's Facebook they had a pic of a tournament on upper red.  It showed a #8, #12.6, #14.4 and a #15 walleye......I thinking this was some kinda joke....can anyone enlighten me. When I talked to a guide a year or so ago I asked him how many #10 walleye he seen come out of upper red......he said he hadn't seen one since he started to guide.    
    • Agronomist_at_IA
      After reading all the post and having gone to upper red once a year sometimes twice (Started renting shacks then got a wheel house 3 yrs ago) for the past eleven years. I find this entire thread and topic somewhat laughable. The locals and resorts seem to complain about an issue they've brought upon themselves. I kinda agree with the post you've put up to a point.    Here is my view.....maybe it is wrong. I drive 7+ hours from Northwest Iowa pay the fees to fish in Minnesota for a couple days. Pay the resort fees for roads, pay for services at the resorts. I tend to buy fuel, bait, propane, and food at the places we use, and sometimes other services. These people make a living using the lake to BRING the business to them. Then when they get the people to the lake and get some money flowing and are having success with people showing up.......the big problem is trash......Seems pretty simple to me if your a resort......figure out trash management for you customers. They showed up and are using the services you provide. A simple $5 tagged onto a road fee with avalible dumpsters could solve the problem. I actually have never had any issues with trash on my trips....so I'm a bit supprised by all this. I mean people are going through the resorts for services and willing to pay. If $5 was a deal breaker.....then why wouldn't people just go out of the public acess points, and not pay any resort fees.   The first 7yrs the guide we use had a trailer on the lake and had his customers throw tied off bags of trash in it. Then he disposed of it. The last three years with my shack the resort we went out of had a dumpster to throw the trash in. I'd gone out of JR's Access, West Winds, and Rogers. When We came off the lake we stopped in and asked if we could throw our trash away....they always said yeah put it in the dumpster.   
    • SkunkedAgain
      Thanks. That's one of the ones that I was considering.
    • SkunkedAgain
      The water temps were 44-47 degrees over most of the lake this weekend. Black Bay partially froze Friday night into Saturday.
    • SkunkedAgain
      I saw a lot of guys running planner boards. We braved the cold ride Friday and Saturday, going from the far west end over near Shamrock. We spot locked in the wind and had pretty good success with the 11-13" walleyes but nothing of size except a few beautiful jumbo perch. We just used jigs in 30-35ft of water with rainbow minnows, the smaller the better. Big minnows were useless.   We didn't stay at any of the west end locations too long, but mostly because we weren't marking fish and weren't getting any bites. I would have liked to work longer for the bigger fish.
    • ANYFISH2
      Care to share where in Ripley this feeding flat is?  Maybe I shoot a deer and catch fish in Ripley this year!😁
    • seifjr
      As usual Curt, thanks for all the reports you provide to us folks that only get up to LOW 4-5 times/year.  Coming up again for the MEA weekend, fishing Thursday-Saturday.  Looks like Thursday's going to be nice with warmer temps and WSW winds.  If we get the heavy WNW winds on Saturday, is the LP area fishable.  Seems like the more west it is the comfort level goes up dramatically.  Bringing the kids this trip, so there not real big fans of the 4-5 footers if you know what I mean.  Hope to see ya Thursday, we'll be in a 2150 Lund and 18.5 Alumacraft.