Jump to content

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

How big is this muskie?

Recommended Posts

I need some help from some of you guys who have seen and know the approximate weight of muskies.
I am try to figure out the size of this muskie my 15 year old daughter caught this summer. This July while fishing in Ontario my daughter hooked and eventually landed a 52" muskie. We were fishing for walleyes with bottom bouncers and thinking that she would have a hard time handling the b.b. I set her up with a jig and leech (6lb. test line).
Pretty soon it looked like she was snagged but in fact had hooked this big tuna. The fish was hooked under the chin. I was in no way prepared for a fish this size (check out the landing net) and didn't even realize there were muskies in the system. Anyway about an hour and 15 min later we pulled this thing in the boat.

The fish is huge. I didn't get a girth measurement and I did a lousy job of photographing the fish (anxious to get her back in the water - she was pretty gassed. Luckily a neighbor had a digital video camera and I was able to take a few stills off of it.

Any thoughts on the weight of this fish? We marked our boat paddle to get a length and it was just over 52".

O.K. now I have to figure out how to post these photos.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

my brother got one last year at first ice that was 51.5". the best weight we got off the scales in the bait shop was around 37 pounds.
that should get some idea that it was a monster she cought.

nice fish, get those pics up


Link to comment
Share on other sites


Scott from ZOOMN.com here, I will try to get the photos that you sent me on here. Send them to me again as I think they are at home on the PC, not here at work.

I will get them on here for you.

By the looks of pictures that I saw this thing was a PIG... Only about half of the body is in the net. I would have guessed that it would have been 51 x low 20's!


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Forgot the weight part: L x G x G / 800

A 20 inch Girth would be around 26 lbs
A 24 inch Girth would be around 38 lbs
A 27 inch Grith would be around 47 lbs

All I know it is a nice fish!


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Scott
Nice job. When I first saw that fish I thought she had hooked a hippopotamus.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We boated a 52"er on Lake of the Woods, with a 24" girth, and it weighed 42 pounds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Niiiiiiiccccce Fish!

Careful about the 'child-eating' comment, see story below:

Posted on Sat, Aug. 28, 2004

Big fish puts the hurt on little boy

Bite wounds take 11 stitches to close


Duluth News Tribune

One moment, 11-year-old Mason DeRosier was hunting frogs. The next, he was fish bait.

Mason and his sister Katelyn, 9, were wading in about a foot of water on Island Lake, near Moose Lake, Minn., when he was attacked by a muskellunge or a northern pike. The resulting lacerations required 11 stitches.

Both kids are from Silver Bay, Minn., and were at a family cabin on Island Lake when the incident occurred about 5 p.m. Thursday.

Mason's father, Richard DeRosier, was in a paddleboat just offshore and witnessed the event.

"I was facing them, and I see a hell of a swirl," said DeRosier, a Lake County deputy sheriff. "Before I can say, 'Holy moly! Look at that!,' all of a sudden the swirl is by their feet."

Mason said he saw the original swirl just offshore.

"It was like maybe 5 feet in front of us," Mason said. "Then, it splashed right at my foot and bit me. It hurt."

The fish didn't let go immediately.

"I smacked it in the head and tried to pry it off my foot," Mason said. "He let go, but he bit my hand."

Both children were screaming throughout the incident, their father said. Katelyn wasn't bitten.

Mason was taken in his grandfather's motorboat back to the cabin, where he washed his wounds. Then he was off to the hospital emergency room in Moose Lake. He received eight stitches in his left hand and three in the bottom of his right foot. He has numerous other bite marks across the top of his foot, his dad said.

"I'll bet he has 20 cuts on his foot and 10 cuts on his hand," Richard DeRosier said.

Nobody got a good look at the fish. Island Lake, just across Interstate 35 from Sand Lake in Pine County, has muskies and northern pike, according to the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Either species would be capable of inflicting the kind of wounds Mason suffered.

Because Mason's foot hurts too much to walk on, the family decided to postpone a planned trip to Valleyfair.

Again, Niiiiiiiccccce Fish!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for all your help guys.
For all future storytelling I'm going to go with 40 to 45 lbs. as the estimated weight, (with the option of raising by up to 10% as may be necessary due to excessive beveraging or in the spirit of competition).

Again thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • leech~~
      Found a few today. 
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the south end... Ice roads and ice trails are extending out on Lake of the Woods looking to connect with schools of walleyes and saugers.  Some ice roads are out as far as 24 miles.   The subzero cold snap is good for extending ice into March, but it was tough on the bite.  Once the weather started warming up, so did the bite.   Most anglers report picking through numbers of small fish to catch eaters, slot fish and some true trophy fish over 28 inches. Depths vary depending upon outfitter based on where they are fishing, but as a rule, 32-36 feet has been the norm.  The morning / evening bite for walleyes in shallow water,16 - 19 feet, has been active for some. Jigging a lipless crankbait with vibration and rattles has been working well to catch some fish and also draws other fish into the area you are fishing.  Some fish in more of a neutral mood will slide over and take interest in your deadstick, a live minnow just off of the bottom. As a rule, glow and bright colors during cloudy days, the golds and silvers during sunny days.   A mixed bag for many being reported, including walleyes, saugers, jumbo perch, eelpout (burbot), pike, tullibees and even a few sturgeon and crappies.   On the Rainy River...   The golden hour (beginning and end of the day) continues to be the best on the river for those fishing for walleyes and saugers.  Some good reports this week. Some sturgeon have been iced at night by those hunting dinosaurs.   Ice conditions can vary on the river as there is current, work through a resort or outfitter for safety.   Up at the NW Angle... Resorts up at the Angle are hard at work staying on the walleyes.  As a rule, 24 - 30 feet of water is the norm.   Similar to the south shore, using a noisy, more aggressive lure has been effective, as has a jigging spoon tipped with a piece of minnow.  Work the jigging line in one hole with a deadstick and a plain hook a foot off of the bottom in your second hole.   Many eater walleyes caught this week with a variety of other fish in the mix.  Some anglers fishing the Ontario side for crappies are finding some nice slabs. Driving through Canada to the Angle no longer requires vaccinations or the use of the ArriveCan App. For those looking to access the Angle while avoiding customs, snowmobiling across the lake on the marked trails or utilizing the Lake of the Woods Passenger (bombardier) Service are best options.  Fish houses are out through March 31st, walleye and sauger season through April 14, pike season never closes. 
    • Rick
      Visitors to Minneopa State Park may soon notice fewer trees near the waterfall area of the park. The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources will remove 20 trees from the area, including 17 ash trees, beginning Feb. 6.Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • SkunkedAgain
      I can confirm that I have 3-4 bars the entire drive from Cook to The Landing. When I winter park at a cabin near CigarGuy, I get two bars way up on the hill but still through the trees. There is good reception out on the lake but I haven't exactly been riding around and pulling out my phone to check my cell reception.   Depending on where you are, you may have 4 bars or none. I have none still, but that's because I'm on the north side of a hill with tall trees between my cabin and the tower.
    • fishing_the_northland
      ~10" perch and an 8" bluegill
    • gimruis
      Something else to just keep in mind here now too is that the deadline to remove permanent overnight unattended shacks is in exactly one month in the southern 2/3 of the state - March 6.  Plan ahead and don't let your castle get stuck out there beyond the deadline.  The DNR can and will confiscate it on site because I know people who have experienced this.
    • monstermoose78
      I heard Green lake by Princeton has plowed roads and truck and castles out there. I will swing by to check it out. Please check the ice conditions for yourself. There is 4-6 inches if slush ice so take that off your totals as that is not very strong. 
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources invites anglers and others to comment through Wednesday, March 15, on fisheries management plans for several waters in Carlton and St. Louis counties.Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources invites anglers and others to comment through Friday, March 17, on fisheries management plans for several lakes in the Grand Rapids area.Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources invites people interested in fishing, wildlife and outdoor skills to tune in to upcoming webinars that will discuss burbot fishing and bald eagles.Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.