If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.


    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  

Minnows, really big crappies and fall fishing

Recommended Posts


Years past I had the privelage of knowing and fishing with a gentleman who was a trophy crappie hunter. He has since passed away, however, I think of him often this time of year because that is when he was at his very best and consistently caught monster crappies. Jerry was a thinker, deep thinker. His choice of ammunition, minnows.
No, I am not talking crappie minnows like one would normally ask the bait shop for.
He used medium sized shiners like those going after sauger and walleyes. I used to give him a bad time about them and insisted he was a closet sauger/walleye fisherman and just got lucky with crappies. He would just smile and look down into his bucket brimming over with huge crappies. He would slowly explain to me that I had to remember the size of a large crappies mouth and the fact that crappie was so big. Sure he started out eating little bugs but as he got bigger, his appetite grew right along with him. He would then proceed to cast out and within a few minutes, bang another monster, many of which went right around two pounds. He would laugh and say he could catch crappies that ounce for ounce were bigger then some sauger and walleyes that fisherman were using the same shiner type minnows.
Thanks Jerry for the thought provoking memories.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ron...There are times when size apparently doesn't matter to crappies as far as food goes. I have taken many crappies, both spring and fall, jig fishing for waldo/sauger from shore. I have taken countless craps while trolling bait for waldo/ sauger and I have taken scores of the craps trolling number 11 and 13 raps for waldos and sauger. It is my theory that water temp/time of year comes into play with this. As the water warms in the spring, thru the summer months, and then slowly begins to lose temperature in the fall, the fish's metabolism is such that food is readily processed....they eat more often and demand larger offerings. At times the size of what they are willing to eat is governed only by how big thier chops are and a large crappie does have, in fact, a big mouth. If you are a devout bait fisherman, you will have had to notice the obvious preference to baits that get smaller and smaller as the winter water temps clamp down on the fish. Then again in the spring as water begins to open up, they begin taking larger minnows- the larger minnows correlate with the water temp...warmer=larger. Crappies are interesting fish to follow. Not only are they one of the most adaptable fish in fresh water, the way they behave makes them one of the most challenging as well. Understanding how water temperature is perhaps the biggest burden in figuring out how these fish operate and in this northern tier pile of states water temp is dictated by season. Right now is the season of large fish, thus larger baits may be needed.

Sure life happens- why wait....The Crapster....good fishing guys!
[email protected]

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Wanderer
      Well, we netted a half dozen fish with the new net and I think I like it.  The biggest was a 45 and everything worked out real nice. Bringing the fish in was easy and then laying the net handle across the gun wale of the boat was enough to keep the fish and bag in the water and in pretty straight shape to work with.  Even with my 40 that needed the hooks cut off, the fish was completely in the water the whole time.  The only time any were out of the water was for a quick measure and photos.  No twisted gnarled mesh to deal with for the most part either. It proved to be worth the space!
    • osok
      Beautiful day to be on the water, but such a struggle catching fish.  Marking a lot of fish and just as many bait balls or some other underwater clouds that the game fish were keying in on.  Ended up C&R a lot of really plump Sunnies ( thinking they haven't spawned yet?),  2 Northerns, several pieces of timber, 2 slot Walleyes, and a great sunburn. All within 12 hrs of fishing.  
    • GeluNumber1
      I'll try to make it. Does 8 am work? Might go for other species too for fun.
    • Bigfatbert
      Another good a.m bite for me and my wife today , ( Thurs ) on Big bay . Nice fish again . Our limit of keeps , also put two back . 8:00 - noon. . . .  Hey Cliff , I’m gonna try to send you a p m .
    • Bigfatbert
      Was in Big Bay once again today and saw a few more Mayfly today than Tuesday . I agree things are just kinda getting going with the hatch , and also believe that these bugs will last until well after the 4th of July . With that being said , I also believe that fishing should hold up for awhile until the fish become so gorged out that things could come to a screeching halt later into this whole bug period . 
    • delcecchi
      Need to change their name to "juneflys" 
    • delcecchi
      was down for a while over the weekend, as I recall.
    • Parmer
      Mine does not have an auto fan setting on the dial. I wish it did. 
    • papadarv
      Setting the fan to high or low the fan runs continuously. Set the fan to auto fan will start/stop with the compressor. 
    • PRO-V
      Dragfoot, where do you go trail riding up there? South of Roosevelt?