Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

Recommended Posts

Rip De Lips

Is the special 40 inch min pike reg for this lake gone? I only see a 10 per day sunfish limit listed. Thanks 

Link to post
Share on other sites
gimruis

I don't fish this lake but from what I can tell there are not any special pike regulations other than the general state regulations.  It lies in the Northeast Zone which is defined as being east of Hwy 53.

 

Northeast Zone: 2 (not more than 1 over 40" in possession. All from 30-40" must be immediately released.)

 

Looks like you are correct with the sunfish regulation.  Not sure why anyone would even WANT to keep a pike over 40 inches.  You could easily get a replica made instead and eating one that big not only would taste terrible but also probably eliminate the apex predator in system.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Rip De Lips

Thank you for your reply. Like you, I would have no interest in keeping one over 40". It was a lake specific regulation for many years and I just didnt see when it ended. I fish this lake (but only once / year) and the pike are everywhere in it now. I was hoping more people would keep smaller ones to thin it out.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
gimruis
21 hours ago, Rip De Lips said:

I fish this lake (but only once / year) and the pike are everywhere in it now. I was hoping more people would keep smaller ones to thin it out.

The lake you speak of is a statewide problem on many lakes here.  So many of our small to mid size lakes are over run with small pike because the large ones were harvested too often.  I worked on this very issue when I was employed by the DNR.  Anglers complained that all they could catch were hammer handles and I would ask them what they did with a bigger one.  The answer was almost always "I kept it."  I foresee us going down a similar path with panfish too, unfortunately.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Getanet
1 hour ago, gimruis said:

The lake you speak of is a statewide problem on many lakes here.  So many of our small to mid size lakes are over run with small pike because the large ones were harvested too often.  I worked on this very issue when I was employed by the DNR.  Anglers complained that all they could catch were hammer handles and I would ask them what they did with a bigger one.  The answer was almost always "I kept it."  I foresee us going down a similar path with panfish too, unfortunately.

 

I know it's a thankless task, but sometimes I wonder if the DNR spreads themselves too thin on some of this stuff.  For example, about 8-10 years ago I received an email from the DNR and there was a section on lakes with special recommendations/experiments.  The lake my family's cabin is on was listed as one they were trying to increase the size of pike on.  I was really surprised because the lake is only about 250 acres and while there was an access - it wasn't one owned by the state or county so it's not a real popular lake and the DNR kind of leaves it alone.

 

They were asking people to keep pike under a certain size and let ones over 30 inches go. Nobody I spoke to up there knew anything about the DNR plan, and I never heard anything more about it in the following years on whether people followed that guidance and/or what results were achieved.

 

My guess is the initial "notice" was the beginning and end of that effort.  

 

Rather than trying to experiment with too many lakes, I wonder if they wouldn't be better served doing a real good job on one or two lake and document the results.  My guess would be if they could show an increase in the size of certain species through experimental regulations that Lake Associations would be knocking down their door to voluntarily implement some of these changes and would spread the word to people who live on the lake. I realize Lake Associations don't own or control a lake, but there are thousands of lakes in MN that aren't fished often by people that don't own property on the lake. 

  • Thumbs Up 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
gimruis

I can't speak for Elephant Lake or the lake you speak of Getanet, but the number of lakes in trouble with stunted populations of pike is easily in the hundreds.  When I was employed by the DNR in the mid 2000's, they were thinking of implementing special pike regulations on a number of lakes in the Aitkin area so I was responsible for surveys on these lakes all summer.  I would interview anglers and ask them what they thought.  You'd be shocked to hear how many people were against it.  Presumably because they still wanted to harvest a big one.  I didn't get into that portion of the conversation with any of them because that wasn't a part of the interview outline.

 

A big pike nowadays caught in Minnesota inland waters from a small or mid size lake is very rare.  In many smaller lakes, a 30+ inch pike is often the apex predator and there isn't very many of them.  So harvesting one or two every year for a few years quickly depletes it.  Now there's no top predator left.  So the small ones go unchecked and the genetics for growing big ones are removed.  Big pike are the best controller of small pike too because they are cannibalistic (most predatory fish are).  The Biologist responsible for this new experimental regulation told me all this information when I worked there.

 

Then the problem snowballs from there.  The lake is stocked with walleye fingerlings or fry and it just feeds the bellies of the small, aggressive pike.  Meanwhile, people catch them regularly and often don't harvest them.  Then people complain that there's no big ones left.  Having a 10-fish daily bag limit in most of the state may help but its going to take a long time before you see results.

 

Bigger lake systems have mostly avoided this issue because they usually have muskies.  Muskies help keep small pike in check too but for a very long time, winter spearing was banned on lakes with muskies.  For example, the most recent pike sampling study in Mille Lacs revealed that about 1/3 of all pike in that lake are over 30 inches and 10% are over 36 inches.

 

I do a lot of bass and muskie fishing and I catch a lot of pike by accident wherever I fish.  90% of them are of the smaller variety.  That alone tells me that we have a problem that isn't going away anytime soon.  I catch maybe 2 or 3 all season that exceed 30 inches.

 

I can't make people keep the small ones and would never fault someone for that, but its vital to release any over 26 inches in length now.  In order to restore balance in these lakes, we need more big ones and less small ones.

Edited by gimruis
  • Thumbs Up 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
delcecchi

As a pike fisherman on Vermilion, I hated the 24 inch max regulation.     That meant that if I should choose to harvest a pike for dinner I only had about 1 1/2 inches between too skinny and in the slot.   I thought the Ontario 27 inch (actually something in cm) was preferable.    And now suddenly it is 30 inches...   So I'm happy and hope the fisheries guys know what they are doing.    Not a big fan of spearing (or harpooning, as the columnist for the PP back in the day called it).   It's fun and all, but too harvest oriented for the modern era.   

Link to post
Share on other sites
StillFishin'

Yea, I wasn’t a fan of the 24” pike reg either.  With the 30” now I can keep a 24-28” for a meal.  Anything bigger goes back.

Link to post
Share on other sites
delcecchi
On 3/30/2021 at 7:42 AM, StillFishin' said:

Yea, I wasn’t a fan of the 24” pike reg either.  With the 30” now I can keep a 24-28” for a meal.  Anything bigger goes back.

That's what I like, a 25-28 is big enough to be worth cleaning.    Bigger goes back.  And I only need one.   

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Similar Content

    • leech~~
      By leech~~
      Whats your guess? 
    • rayguy
      By rayguy
      For those of you planning on a trip to the egg taking station on the Pine River forget it till next year.   Due to the covid regs.  there will be no visitors allowed this year. Hope they are having a good run.  Rayguy
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      By LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the south end... Most of the lake is still ice covered with the exception of large areas adjacent to inflowing water such as the Lighthouse Gap (Rainy River) and Morris Point Gap (Bostic Creek) areas.  Open water is expanding daily.  Anglers are allowed a limit of walleyes and saugers on the lake, but catch and release only on Four Mile Bay and the Rainy River through April 14. 
      Open water is becoming available in many of the back bays around the lake where pike spawn.  The pike season is open year round on LOW and the Rainy River.  3 fish per day, 30-40 inches must be released, one over 40" allowed.  
      On the Rainy River...   River fishing started out strong, slowed down with cold weather and the Big Fork and Little Fork Rivers spilling mud into the Rainy River and now is picking up again.  The water is clearing and water temps are on the rise.
      A 3/8 - 1/2 ounce jig is working nicely tipped with a minnow or a plastic.  Bright plastics and frozen shiners working best on jigs.  Walleyes caught in various depths down to 35 feet.  
      Some anglers trolling crankbaits with success to cover water.  Walleye season is catch and release only on Rainy River and Four Mile Bay through April 14th.
      Sturgeon fishing continues to be good with good numbers of sturgeon being caught.  Sturgeon aren't as affected by dirty water as they feed by scent.  Sturgeon catch and release season through 4/23/21.  Keep season 4/24/21 - 5/7/21, (45-50", or over 75")  Catch and release 5/8/21 - 5/15/21.  Closed 5/16/21 - 6/30/21.
      With lower current, a 3 ounce no-roll sinker combined with a sturgeon rig (18" snell of 60 lb test with a 4/0 or 5/0 circle hook) with a glob of crawlers, frozen emerald shiners or both is the ticket.  Local bait shops have rigs and bait available.
      Up at the NW Angle...  Various areas are starting to open up.  Looking ahead to open water, there are various ways to travel to the NW Angle this summer without crossing the border.  If you have the right boat and expertise, boating across is an option.  There is also the Lake of the Woods Passenger Service (charter boat shuttle to Angle).  And finally, Lake Country Air flying service, a float plane service out of Baudette and other locations.  
       


    • Mata Eveleth
      By Mata Eveleth
      Hey just trying to find a report that says like on March 20th, 2021 the water level measured at Crane Lake was.. say 18 feet 6 inches.. measured again on April 5th, 2021 and the depth is now at 17 feet six inches.. something simple. been searching around this web site.. and way to complex.. KISS   Keep it short and simple.. over and out.. same thing any web site you just want a bit of info.. and all this run around crap.. pffff.
    • JBMasterAngler
      By JBMasterAngler
      Made my long awaited return to the Rush yesterday. Never got a WI license last year, so it was good to be back! Beautiful weather! But conditions could not have been worse for trout! Water was lowest I’ve ever seen! And gin clear, without a single cloud in the sky. We were fortunate to catch the 3 we did. Way too many people out for my liking. But our gear worked, and our boots didn’t leak 😁 so it was a great day as far as I’m concerned.
       


    • PeachyHans
      By PeachyHans
      Hey all! Tomorrow (Apr 3rd) I'm taking some friends out to do some fishing. We usually target rivers, and live around the metro, but I'm willing to drive a ways to find good spots. No boat, so this would be shore fishing.
      We aren't after anything specific but would be nice to get something to fry up later! Which of course means targeting legal fish like carp, suckers, cats, panfish, etc. 
    • leech~~
      By leech~~
      I heard a few lakes are starting to have ice moving and piling up in this two day wind storm.  Folks could end up with some shore line damage?  😬
    • Adam1642
      By Adam1642
      Does anyone know if you can get a pontoon from Mayo to Sibley lake?  Looking at property on Mayo.  
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      By LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the south end... Ice fishing is all finished up on the main lake.  The focus is on back bays for big pike and areas of open water on the lake for walleyes.  The pike season is open year round on LOW and the Rainy River.  3 fish per day, 30-40 inches must be released, one over 40" allowed.  
      Anglers are allowed a limit of walleyes and saugers on the lake, but catch and release only on Four Mile Bay and the Rainy River through April 14.  A limit of walleyes and saugers is a combined limit of 6 fish with up to 4 being walleyes.  Walleyes 19.5-28.0 inches must be released with one allowed over 28 inches.  The walleye season runs through April 14th and starts up again May 15th for the MN Fishing Opener.
      On the Rainy River...   Five boat ramps are open on the Rainy River and there are 42 miles of open water for fishing.  Nelson Park in Birchdale, Frontier, Vidas (near Clementson), Timbermill Park in Baudette and the Wheeler's Point access at the mouth of the river 12 miles north of Baudette are all open.  
      River fishing has started out strong.  Good numbers of walleyes are being caught by some with trophy fish in the mix.  A 3/8 - 1/2 ounce jig is working nicely tipped with a minnow or a plastic.  Walleye season is catch and release only on Rainy River and Four Mile Bay through April 14th.
      Sturgeon fishing continues to be excellent with big numbers of sturgeon being caught.  Sturgeon catch and release season through 4/23/21.  Keep season 4/24/21 - 5/7/21, (45-50", or over 75")  Catch and release 5/8/21 - 5/15/21.
      With lower current, a 3 ounce no-roll sinker combined with a sturgeon rig (18" snell of 60 lb test with a 4/0 or 5/0 circle hook) with a glob of crawlers, frozen emerald shiners or both is the ticket.  Local bait shops have rigs available.
      Up at the NW Angle...  Looking ahead to open water, there are various ways to travel to the NW Angle this summer without crossing the border.  If you have the right boat and expertise, boating across is an option.  There is also the Lake of the Woods Passenger Service (charter boat shuttle to Angle).  And finally, Lake Country Air flying service, a float plane service out of Baudette and other locations.  
       


    • whateverisbiting
      By whateverisbiting
      Looking to set up my new Alumacraft Trophy boat.  Anyone have experience with Alumatrac?  Stuff available from Alumacraft is plastic and looks weak and the options are quite limited.  Stuff from other makers I have seen (Brocraft, Traxstech, Depth Raider, Colliflower) is metal and a number of reviews say they don't fit or scratch badly.  Seems the tolerance on this track may not be very tight.  Colliflower states they have a top adjustment to account for the poor tolerance but their options are limited.  Looking at all options including rod holders, downrigger holders, and other gadgets.  Trying to decide whether to buy for the track or just mount directly to the gunwale.  Any help is appreciated.
  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.