• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
papadarv

Jawjacker or Auromatic Fisherman?

Recommended Posts

papadarv

Minnesota is the ONLY state in all of the Ice States that does not allow JawJacker or Auromatic type of "Tip Up" devices. The reg's state you cannot use any "Spring Device" for fishing, while at the same time they promote Down Riggers and Out Riggers which is the same technique/process used on the Jawjacker or Auromatic Fisherman. I feel we in the hardwater arena are being short changed by the law. Anyone else have an opinion on this?? Is there any actions we as a group can take to change this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jarrid Houston

Write them.  Thankfully I live on the border so I am able to use my jack jacker on WI waters.  Fun fishing device for the Brown trout of Lake Superior..

  • Thumbs Up 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
papadarv
3 hours ago, Jarrid Houston said:

Write them.  Thankfully I live on the border so I am able to use my jack jacker on WI waters.  Fun fishing device for the Brown trout of Lake Superior..

Tried writing last winter, no response. I believe a lot of ice guys need to write for anything to happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MN BassFisher

I know there was a petition going around 2 years ago and it gathered a few 1000 signatures but I don't think anything was ever done. I have spoken to the owner of JJ and he has said that the head of the MN DNR is very bullheaded and he doesn't see them being legalized here anytime soon. Which sucks. I had 4 from when I lived in CO and they are highly effective and perfect for a 2nd rod. I use them still when I fish in WI but unfortunately that's not more than a couple trips a winter.

  • Thumbs Up 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Big Kype

Minnesota, the land of 10,000 rules where it's barely legal to fish.

The main selling point is that the JawJacker and Autos are a conservation tool. It sets the hook right away as soon as the fish bites. So a lot less fish get hooked deep and die after being released. There are limits on all these lakes anyway so it's not like people are going to over-fish lakes because the limit is the same regardless of what you use to fish with. There is a rule in the Minnesota rules that says you can't fish with spring loaded hooks. A spring loaded hook is actually a device from the 1920's and 30's that was banned because when a fish bit it would somehow latch onto the fish's mouth and disfigure destroy the fish it clamped down so hard. So the rule dates back to the 1920's and 30's and was put in the regs to ban that specific device. You might be able to find these spring loaded hooks somewhere like a fishing equipment collectors guide. So they have forgotten the specific reasoning behind that regulation and interpret the bent rod as being a spring loaded hook now which it is not and deviates from the original intent of the regulation. To change laws and regs you almost need to have some sort of a lobbying group, like a sportsmans group to pick up the cause to push the issue or talk with your local state government officials to pick up the cause. In Wyoming a CO once was saying that if a sportsmen's group or activist group comes to them and shows how the regulations have changed in states around them and they feel like they are falling behind the times on certain things then they will review the issue and change the regs if they feel that is necessary.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
oilandwater

Guys, this could be doable, but we need to look at what the law is and where it is.  MN State Statute (state law passed by Legislature, can only be modified by legislative action, not DNR Commissioner rule) 97c.325 says that fish “may not be taken with a spring device that impales, hooks, or captures fish.”  That’s different than a “spring hook” or a bull-headed Comissioner’s rule. If our elected legislators get enough pressure, and yes that means from angling individuals and groups, they will change it. The DNR may try to influence one way or the other depending on their science of the day and internal politics, but ultimately they are an administrative agency that answers to legislative law and funding.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • CJH
      Anybody have an updated water temps for the Le Homme Dieu Chain?  Specifically Le Homme Dieu, Darling, Carlos?  Putting the boats in this weekend.  Thanks!!!   CJH
    • Pat McGraw
      SkunkedAgain,   What Bay are you in?
    • MN BassFisher
      Spoiler Alert for those that don't want to watch the video...   (38" Northern Pike)  
    • Hoey
      I'd recommend the Warroad river, park, and public access area.  Bear 55 may have more info and details.  The Rainy is another 30 mile drive past Warroad.   Good pizza at the restaurant there too.  
    • Hoey
      Todd and Jim, It was good seeing you all this past week.  I ended up jumping in Byron's boat on Thursday afternoon, after the wind settled down and the clouds cleared off.  We fished the islands from 2 to 6pm or so.  30 fish total.  Many slots,  biggest was 28.  We kept 3 eyes and a sauger.    On Friday i was able to get my boat in the water, 2 to 5pm.  I went south, started off in 4 ft and worked outward.  Found milting males in 19 ft, got a couple keepers.  I found females out a couple feet deeper.  Biggest was 26.  Caught 20 or so for the day.    Looking forward to fishing Thursday to Monday of this coming weekend.  The water remains cold at 48 to 49 degrees F.  Talk was the wind will help mix the water to get the temps rising.   Hoey!!!
    • Rick
      The 19th class of candidates to take part in the Department of Natural Resources’ Conservation Officer Academy has begun training at Camp Ripley.  This year’s class includes 14 recruits who bring with them a wide variety of backgrounds and experiences. Some of them have been sheriff’s deputies and police officers, while others serve for the Minnesota National Guard or decided to make a career change and study to become a conservation officer. “As with all the men and women who’ve proudly served this division and the people of Minnesota since 1887, I’m confident these 14 people will continue our tradition of enforcing natural resources laws and understanding the importance of education and outreach as we serve the people of Minnesota,” said Rodmen Smith, DNR Enforcement Division director. The officer candidates began training at Camp Ripley on May 20 and will continue there until August, learning about topics ranging from fish and wildlife laws to patrol procedures, and rules of evidence to fish and wildlife investigation. They’ll also learn about the vital role conservation officers occupy in their communities and the part they play in developing the next generation of anglers, conservationists and hunters. Upon graduation, they’ll spend several months field training with experienced officers. The candidates will be assigned to their own stations in December. “Conservation officers live in the areas they serve and, due to the nature of their work, become integral parts of their communities,” said Smith. Attendees of this year’s Academy bring with them a wide variety of experiences. Some have a traditional law enforcement background while others took part in a program called CO PREP, which provides candidates before the Academy with law enforcement training such that they’re eligible for Peace Officer Standards and Training certification. Over the years, the CO PREP program has been highly successful in creating a conservation officer workforce that more closely reflects the state’s population. There are 155 conservation officer field stations in Minnesota. Currently, 27 of them are vacant; this current class will reduce the vacancies by about half. Each station covers about 650 square miles. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Moldy birdseed and unclean bird feeders can make birds sick. Homeowners who enjoy feeding birds can takes steps now to help birds stay healthy, according to the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.  In spring and especially in warm, humid weather, it is common for mold to form on wet birdseed. The mold can cause an avian disease called aspergillosis, which affects the birds’ respiratory systems. Salmonella is another disease that affects birds and is associated with unclean feeders. Both diseases can be fatal to birds. To clean a feeder, use a solution of one part bleach and nine parts water, and scrub the entire surface. Always allow the cleaned feeder to dry out in the sun, as the sunlight will help kill bacteria on the feeder. Hummingbird feeders should be cleaned about every week to 10 days during the summer, to keep the sugar water from producing mold. Staff from the DNR Nongame Wildlife Program urges bird enthusiasts to also rake or sweep up any fallen seeds and seed hulls under their feeder to prevent moldy conditions from occurring on the ground. Seeds left on the ground can also attract meadow voles, house mice, other rodents, raccoons, deer and even bears. Keep the feed dry by using a hopper-type feeder or a fly-through feeder, and always scrape out old seed that accumulates in the corners. Tray feeders with a screen bottom will allow seeds to dry out from above and below after a rain shower, but thick layers of seed could still trap moisture, so consider more frequent fillings with less seed. More information about bird feeding is available at mndnr.gov/birdfeeding. Books about attracting and feeding birds include, “Wild about Birds: The DNR Bird Feeding Guide” and “Landscaping for Wildlife.” These books were made possible by donations to the Nongame Wildlife Fund. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Docks and dock platforms provide access to Minnesota’s lakes and rivers, and are regulated to help protect public safety as well as aquatic habitat. As summer approaches, the Department of Natural Resources encourages property owners and lake service provider businesses to review the regulations, to ensure the equipment they own, sell or install is in compliance.  Extensive dock systems may shade out important aquatic plants and eliminate critical habitat where fish spawn, feed, grow and find shelter from predators. They can also obstruct navigation or even create a safety hazard if they are too large or improperly placed. “The current regulations have been in existence for many years, but not everyone is familiar with them,” said Jack Gleason, DNR public waters hydrologist. “The DNR worked with property owners, public water users, and business and industry representatives to develop these regulations. They’re designed to balance the need for reasonable access to public waters with habitat protection and safety.” To ensure this balance, a dock may not be more than 8 feet wide and may not be combined with other similar structures to create a wider dock. A modest platform at the water end of a dock is allowed under certain conditions. A single, temporary platform up to 120 square feet measured separately from the access dock, or 170 square feet including the area of the adjacent access dock, is allowed if the following conditions exist: The access dock must be 5 feet wide or less, and The dock must be on a lake with a shoreland classification of General Development or Recreational Development. Docks must not be a hazard to navigation, health or safety and must allow the free flow of water. A dock should not close off part of the lake or river to other users. Docks must also comply with any local ordinances. A document about state dock requirements is available on the DNR website. The DNR website also contains links to other helpful information for property owners about shoreline erosion control and restoration projects to help improve water quality and fish and wildlife habitat. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • SkunkedAgain
      I didn't fish the tournament, but did luck into my PB 13" crappie off the dock while slip bobbering for walleye.
    • Xplorer
      Glad you had a good first week!!