• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
mwal

prey study in Pioneer Press

Recommended Posts

mwal

Check out article in Pioneer Press. Smallmouth are not eating walleye. Looks like walleye cannibalism is the worst offender.

Mwal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wormdunker

Hopefully the DNR can now reconsider reversing or relaxing their recent knee jerk Small Mouth regulation change. Coincidentally it would have been nice if they would have used this scientific data to begin with. Kind of proves they are just throwing Shart at the walls in St Paul!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mwal

I went out on the net and there are lots of published studies on the smallmouth eating walleye fallacy. Ontario MNR, SOUTH DAKOTA Dept F and game. Various college papers as well. All say the same thing smallmouth eat mostly crustaceans, mayfly larvae then small small fish of which are mostly not walleye. The study does show that the pike do eat anything including walleye. But apparently walleye are very cannibalistic.

Mwal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Search Function

Hopefully the DNR can now reconsider reversing or relaxing their recent knee jerk Small Mouth regulation change. Coincidentally it would have been nice if they would have used this scientific data to begin with. Kind of proves they are just throwing Shart at the walls in St Paul!

I'm a bass fisherman and I think the one's having the "knee jerk" on this issue is people who think like this. What is "knee jerk" about having the limits being the same in the rest of the state? And that's not even true as their is a slot on Mille Lacs for smallmouth.

The big problem is the DNR giving walleye fishermen the perception that smallmouth are a major contributor to the down fall of the walleye population. Hey walleye fishermen, it IS NOT the bass causing your walleye to not be there. Please, don't go blaming someone else's prize gamefish for something that it didn't have anything to do with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
leech~~

So, Smallmouth don't eat Walleye but Largemouth do? Seems odd to me that you can throw any old shiny lure out in a lake and either one will hit it but they are selective on which live fish they eat? whistle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Search Function

So, Smallmouth don't eat Walleye but Largemouth do? Seems odd to me that you can throw any old shiny lure out in a lake and either one will hit it but they are selective on which live fish they eat? whistle

Largemouth and walleyes tending to not get along has nothing to do with them eating each other. It relates to what is typically what habitat that makes for a great walleye lake, doesn't typically make for a very good largemouth lake and vise versa. There are exceptions, such as Leech which is a great lake for both.

It may be true that Mille Lacs smallmouth are eating machines, but your typical small walleye isn't doing things that put it on a smallmouth basses radar screen as far as being smallmouth forage, so walleye's don't typically show up in a smallies stomach. Is that really all that hard for walleye fisherman to understand?

Also what makes a bass hit "any old shiny lure" as you call it, may have nothing at all to do with a fish feeding. Ever hear of triggering the strike? Your typical walleye probably moves in such a way it is unlikely to trigger a smallmouth to try and hit it, let alone eat it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
willyfahey

Clearly, there's is no way anyone can make any determination from any information found in this article. Samples taken over a one year period can hardly be seen as a good foundation for anything. I think there needs to be a lot more work done by the DNR before something happens. I think the article is written in poor context due the lack of key data such as actual number of fish sampled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wormdunker

My apologies Search You apparently know all and see all. I will bow down to you.

Fact: Small mouth regulation changed drastically for 2014 season.

Fact: Previous regulation turned the lake into a world class Muskie and Small mouth fishery.

Fact: Previously the DNR altered the SM regs only slightly each year but always protecting the fishery.

Fact: Resorts, Walleye Fishermen Guides alike (not all in each instance I admit) blame the Small mouth for the Walleye Population collapse.

Fact: The Small mouth regulation change on Mille Lacs was a KNEE JERK Reaction to public outcries from said groups mentioned above.

Fact: This Predator/Prey research was not completed prior to the rule change so one can only summarize that indeed the small mouth were being blamed.

Now I ask you this, does the walleye regulation on ML match the reg in the rest of the state? NO. So after years of special regs, the creation of a world class fishery on several fronts Why would they take extreme measures and alter the regulation in such a way that you almost promote a catch and kill mentality?

I am not against people catching fish to eat them but when you manage a lake, create a world class reputation then create regs like the current, you are almost begging people to come and clean it out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bassin

totally agree with everything you said worm. Whether the DNR did it on purpose or not the way they came out and changed the smallie regs made it seem like they were putting the blame on the smallies. And whether it was their intension or not people took it that way. It totally created a kill a smallie save a walleye mentality. They need to reverse this or its going to go down hill in a hurry. I get that pretty much every other lake in the state you can keep bass and for the most part it doesnt harm the lake. But this lake is different. Everybody is walley crazy and if there is even a hint another fish is causing the walley issues then kill them, kill them all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ANYFISH2

Whoa... take a deep breath guys.

I love smallmouth as much as any of you, take a step back, lets look at this in a bigger scope.

1. Like it or not Mille Lacs will and is viewed as a/the premier WALLEYE lake. Not going to change soon, if ever.

2. "Knee jerk" or not there is little reason for tight restrictions on bass on Mille Lacs. Release ethic is too strong in regards to bass.

3. The kill the smallmouth sentiment will pass when walleye pop. Begins to recover, the community learns how beneficial/lucrative smallmouth could be, and more proof is given that thier effects are minimal.

I also believe that smallmouth may play a roll in this yet. I doubt they prey on walleye enough to have a impact overall. But they are added biomass, and maybe thier young are competing with the young walleye (I doubt 5" bass are eating primarily cayfish) causing they walleye to go into winter in a lesser condition, resulting in poor recruitment.

These studies are steps to recovery as are the relaxation of the regulations. If they (DNR) would have done these studies and or any to come, first, before doing anything tangible. People would have cied foul them saying they did nothing to stop the crash.

If the situation on Mille Lacs was simple or they (DNR and thier biologists) knew exactly how to fix it, it would be done already.

I guess whether your a walleye angler, smallmouth angler, northern pike angler, muskie angler, or a perch angler when it comes to Mille Lacs, we are all going to have to except some sacrifice.

If we are not working/looking for a solution we're just adding to the problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
leech~~

I don't think they are cleaning out any lake of Walleye, but Bass Large and Small mouth are opportunist gulpers. I don't think they would turn down a meal if it came by! wink

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wormdunker

Whoa... take a deep breath guys.

I love smallmouth as much as any of you, take a step back, lets look at this in a bigger scope.

1. Like it or not Mille Lacs will and is viewed as a/the premier WALLEYE lake. Not going to change soon, if ever.

2. "Knee jerk" or not there is little reason for tight restrictions on bass on Mille Lacs. Release ethic is too strong in regards to bass.

3. The kill the smallmouth sentiment will pass when walleye pop. Begins to recover, the community learns how beneficial/lucrative smallmouth could be, and more proof is given that thier effects are minimal.

I also believe that smallmouth may play a roll in this yet. I doubt they prey on walleye enough to have a impact overall. But they are added biomass, and maybe thier young are competing with the young walleye (I doubt 5" bass are eating primarily cayfish) causing they walleye to go into winter in a lesser condition, resulting in poor recruitment.

These studies are steps to recovery as are the relaxation of the regulations. If they (DNR) would have done these studies and or any to come, first, before doing anything tangible. People would have cied foul them saying they did nothing to stop the crash.

If the situation on Mille Lacs was simple or they (DNR and thier biologists) knew exactly how to fix it, it would be done already.

I guess whether your a walleye angler, smallmouth angler, northern pike angler, muskie angler, or a perch angler when it comes to Mille Lacs, we are all going to have to except some sacrifice.

If we are not working/looking for a solution we're just adding to the problem.

Waiting to Exhale............ The end game on this will likely be the impact that Zebra Muscles play on the entire Mille Lacs Food chain and the continuous harvest of a narrow band of sizes of walleyes being caught in gill nets. I never said that Mille Lacs will ever be known that anything other than a walleye fishery.

Little reason for tight restrictions? Perhaps tighter restrictions needed to be in place on Walleyes? So put a regulation in place that could potentially have a tremendous impact on a species?

Ahh crayfish have babies too......but I get your point and the article said nothing about the diet being exclusive to Crayfish. it did say they eat insects and some minnows as well.

You do know there are groupons and living social deals from Launches and resorters luring people to not only come and catch smallmouth but also provide cleaning instruction after their trip. Here is a tip, CLEANING IS NO DIFFERENT THAN A WALLEYE.

I was solo happy I could slit the throat of a 19 7/8" walleye last Sunday. I caught it in 4' of water windy shore on a brown tube......Who is eating who's food?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wormdunker

I don't think they are cleaning out any lake of Walleye, but Bass Large and Small mouth are opportunist gulpers. I don't think they would turn down a meal if it came by! wink

"I don't think" similar scientific research behind this statement as the DNR's current Smallmouth reg.....

Winter 2014 DNR Mille Lacs Regulation Think tank results " AHH ERR I think them there smallmouth are eating them there Walleyes"

Summer 2014 DNR actual Testing results: "Ahh Errr I think we was wrong"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
delcecchi

I follow this with interest since much the same situation exists on the west end of Vermilion, only with no nets and no zeebs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
leech~~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ANYFISH2

Wormdunker I hate the "kill the smallmouth " sentiment as well, including the marketing of such. I have heard plenty of remarks at resorts this year. Although talking to the same guys later, NONE of them kept a single bass, all were released. It is hard to break habits good or bad, I think the institution that is C&R will prevail, and smallmouth will continue to flourish. Plus, they are one of the few fish known to eat zebra mussels.

Also, I couldn't agree more, that zeebs probably are having the largest impact lake and species wide.

In my mind I think spiny water flees may be a quiet problem with young of the year fish as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jigginjim

I would bite on to what anyfish2, has posted. Not only could the spiny water flea pose an issue, but also so can the muskies. We all hear about the guys fishing walleyes just to have a large skie, come eat your walleye. I idea that fish (A) doesn't eat that fish (B) is just dumb. Put a small enough fish in front of any other fish, it's going to be lunch or a snack. Sooner or later the larger fish will eat the small fish. Do you really believe a smallmouth bass will not eat, small walleye but will eat perch. Now lets look at other fishing eating and killing machines, Pelicans and cormorants. It doesn't take long of these fish eating monsters to clean house.

There can be so many sides to this puzzle-pie that no one thing can be blamed other than. WE HOSED UP THE FOOD CHAIN. Think of this "you can only shoot does for deer hunting" what happens? DUH!!! I DON'T KNOW? please!!!!!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wormdunker

I would bite on to what anyfish2, has posted. Not only could the spiny water flea pose an issue, but also so can the muskies. We all hear about the guys fishing walleyes just to have a large skie, come eat your walleye. I idea that fish (A) doesn't eat that fish (B) is just dumb. Put a small enough fish in front of any other fish, it's going to be lunch or a snack. Sooner or later the larger fish will eat the small fish. Do you really believe a smallmouth bass will not eat, small walleye but will eat perch. Now lets look at other fishing eating and killing machines, Pelicans and cormorants. It doesn't take long of these fish eating monsters to clean house.

There can be so many sides to this puzzle-pie that no one thing can be blamed other than. WE HOSED UP THE FOOD CHAIN. Think of this "you can only shoot does for deer hunting" what happens? DUH!!! I DON'T KNOW? please!!!!!!!!

Of course the Muskie/Pike will eat anything. Heck I have had numerous submarines inhale 4+lb smallies on Mille Lacs while flossing its teeth with my Power Pro. The Pike family is not the problem. It is the forage base for everything that should be the concern of the DNR. Zeeebs filter the water so much water it is likely having a major negative impact on he micro level food source that feeds the young of the year. Not sure how mucu the spiny flea has to do with it, I am sure some. The combination of both is a major problem.

Birds eat fish in every lake, I have not witnessed too many cormorants on ML however. At least not hundreds and thousands as we used to see on Leech.

Regarding what Smallies eat, I have never seen a smallie puke up a bait fish after being caught except on rivers where I see shad puke......Crayfish puke is always prevalent on lakes. Heck that is why they follow each other, they love crawdads so much they prey on the regurgitated remains they puke out during the fight.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Search Function

I would bite on to what anyfish2, has posted. Not only could the spiny water flea pose an issue, but also so can the muskies. We all hear about the guys fishing walleyes just to have a large skie, come eat your walleye. I idea that fish (A) doesn't eat that fish (B) is just dumb. Put a small enough fish in front of any other fish, it's going to be lunch or a snack. Sooner or later the larger fish will eat the small fish. Do you really believe a smallmouth bass will not eat, small walleye but will eat perch. Now lets look at other fishing eating and killing machines, Pelicans and cormorants. It doesn't take long of these fish eating monsters to clean house.

There can be so many sides to this puzzle-pie that no one thing can be blamed other than. WE HOSED UP THE FOOD CHAIN. Think of this "you can only shoot does for deer hunting" what happens? DUH!!! I DON'T KNOW? please!!!!!!!!

A walleye that is hooked on somebodies line isn't exhibiting normal walleye behavior. It is saying to the Muskie, there is something wrong with me come eat me. Normal walleye behavior doesn't scream for a muskie or a smallmouth to come an eat it.

As far as the results of this forage study, they pretty much match what forage studies in other bodies of water have shown that smallmouth don't typically feed on walleye, same goes for muskie. People may not want to believe it, but different fish have preferred forage. If a fish is able to get it's preferred forage, it will eat that almost exclusively. So long as there are abundant crawfish, perch, and shiners in Mille Lacs the smallies simply won't eat very many walleyes. So long as there are abundant tullibees, perch, suckers, and shiners in Mille Lacs the Muskie simply won't eat very many walleyes. But oh, isn't it so much more fun to disbelieve the science and speculate wildly about how this fish and that fish are eating your walleyes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MuskieFever

We all know what the real cause of the Mille Lacs walleye demise. If you don't think so, I want whatever you're smoking cuz it must be good!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
river rat316

We all know what the real cause of the Mille Lacs walleye demise. If you don't think so, I want whatever you're smoking cuz it must be good!

Yes walleye guys not releasing anything in the slot for years, and having twice the take as the nets..... got any other bright ideas?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TurnUpTheFishing

I never said they are cleaning out any lake of Walleye, but Bass Large and Small mouth are opportunist gulpers. I know dam well they would not turn down a meal if it came by! wink

No, you don't. Trying to make yourself seem so knowledgeable is actually doing the exact opposite for yourself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
leech~~

No, you don't. Trying to make yourself seem so knowledgeable is actually doing the exact opposite for yourself.

Dude, you can throw a door hinge out in a lake and a Bass large or small will hit it! Your telling me that if young eye's move into a rock pile in the evening to feed that a Small mouth wouldn't take it if it could! crazy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
southender

My apologies Search You apparently know all and see all. I will bow down to you.

Fact: Small mouth regulation changed drastically for 2014 season.

Fact: Previous regulation turned the lake into a world class Muskie and Small mouth fishery.

Fact: Previously the DNR altered the SM regs only slightly each year but always protecting the fishery.

Fact: Resorts, Walleye Fishermen Guides alike (not all in each instance I admit) blame the Small mouth for the Walleye Population collapse.

Fact: The Small mouth regulation change on Mille Lacs was a KNEE JERK Reaction to public outcries from said groups mentioned above.

Fact: This Predator/Prey research was not completed prior to the rule change so one can only summarize that indeed the small mouth were being blamed.

Now I ask you this, does the walleye regulation on ML match the reg in the rest of the state? NO. So after years of special regs, the creation of a world class fishery on several fronts Why would they take extreme measures and alter the regulation in such a way that you almost promote a catch and kill mentality?

I am not against people catching fish to eat them but when you manage a lake, create a world class reputation then create regs like the current, you are almost begging people to come and clean it out.

FACT: mille lace is managed as a WALLEYE lake first and foremost, musky and smallmouth are secondary.

FACT: most musky and smallmouth fishermen come here for the day from the cities. They don't buy bait, they buy their gas in the cities, and don't spend the night at a resort or motel. Some will spend $10 to launch at a resort.

FACT: musky and smallmouth fishermen bring no economic impact to the mille lacs area.

FACT: with the small amount of people that actually keep smallmouth, there will be NO impact on the smallmouth fishery.

FACT: you should have been fishing musky and smallmouth here 20 years ago, the musky were not as big, but 5 in a day was not uncommon. The smallmouth on the other hand were just as big and nobody fished for them except for a few that figured it out.

FACT: I could go on and on just like you, but the real fact is, you musky and smallmouth guys whine just as bad as the walleye guys, there just isn't as many of you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Huskie
      My 115 merc 4 stroke (2006) is acting up.  At about 2/3 throttle, 30 mph, 4000 rpm's the motor seems to cavitate or rev up and the tach pops way up, but we didn't speed up.  I quickly backed off and ran at a lower speed.  I have it trimmed up on plane but not overly so.  It did it once at a lower speed as well.  Most of the time at lower speeds it riund fine. Brought it in and they looked at it and pulled the prop and everything looked fine there etc.  The motors lower plate seems to be located correctly, right at the bottom of the boat.  Going on one last trip, and don't really have much time to bring it in for an extensive diagnosis, might need to baby it and stay close to the landing.  Any ideas?
    • MJ1657
      Not a lot of ducks flying this morning.   
    • tarpon6
      Samsung Note 10+.  It does have a great camera.  Had to use the digital zoom on that shot.  Wish I had my wildlife camera with me.  
    • delcecchi
      Works for me using chrome.
    • Bearfan1963
      Barbelboy, We have taken our 4 year old grandson camping on Namakan the last 2 years.  He loves it, its never too early !!!
    • Wanderer
      Ah, a couple walleyes just made it all better. 😁
    • Bigfatbert
    • Borch
      Try Darren Troseth at 3 rivers fishing adventures.  Fall is sturgeon  time.   He also specializes in catfish with a shot at a trophy.
    • Wanderer
      No doubt @papadarv!  They’re really good at it too.  The small family flocks have joined together where I’ve been seeing geese and now number 50+ typically.   We saw some geese and a few ducks today but didn’t shoot any.  We didn’t find anything worth setting up on.  Pretty amazing how slim the duck population is up here.  The biggest flock I’ve seen, including the drive up, numbered 5 birds.  It’s been mostly random singles and pairs.   The flooding up here has been amazing too.  Something like 10 inches in 25 hours.  Roads are flooded and the ditches are raging rivers.  The downstream sides of the bigger culverts look like power plant discharges.   We’re considering other options for tomorrow.
    • james1014
      $ 7800 $  O.B.O aluminum. 2008 20’ DreamShak Ice House/Camper, Model Namikan 202, very clean and in excellent condition. Bearings just repacked along with electric brake system inspection. Asking $7,800. Purchased new for $24,000. Camper style look with horizontal v-front. 4 Burner Cooktop range with full sized RV Oven – handles pizzas well. Sink, drain, and removable drain tank. AM/FM/CD/External Jack, 4 Speaker Stereo System. 12/120V TV with Power Boost Rooftop RV style HD Antenna. Easily sleeps 5 (King, XLong-Twin, Std-Twin) on fold out beds that are convertible to couches. Toy Hauler Backdoor 78” height, 61” width, folds down, w/ ATV type tie downs in floor. Easily holds 2 ATVs. Two 30lb propane tanks with auto switching regulator. Spare auto switching regulator and hose set. Floor mounted forced air Suburban heater. All windows with curtains. Carpeted floor. 8 Catch Covered Fish Holes. Double (parallel wired) deep cycle battery system with 12V charger in RV style power panel 12V/120V capable. Tandem axle, with remote control hydraulic up and down, torsion axles with removable wheel well covers. Makes fishing setup banking go quickly. RV Roof Vent. Numerous coat hooks, built in rod racks and holders. Lots of cabinets and storage. Brand new Tires and aluminum rins ¾” Treated Plywood Floor. Aluminum Tubing Walls & Roof Truss System. Aluminum Diamond Plate Stone Guards. 3 Thermal Pain Tinted Radius RV Windows with slide screens. 1 1/2" Foam Insulated Walls Natural cedar paneling and rough sawn cedar cabinet faces. 3 Interior Overhead & 2 Exterior 12 Volt Lights Aluminum siding. One piece rubber roof. Standard RV type entrance side door with removable bug screen for summer use. I HAVE PICTURES WHY this is SALVAGE TITLE. Please call or text 8013580144 or pictures