Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

Would you rather rent or own recreational land?


Bill Oelrich

Recommended Posts

I am curious about how the outdoor crowd feels about recreational land. I used to think ownership was the only way to go for a cabin on the lake, hunting land, etc, but I have changed my tune over the years. We sold the lake cabin and now prefer to hit resorts when we head north.

Which situation would you rather have prefer: 1) own 120 acres of land 2) own a cabin on a lake next close to whatever public land you like to hunt/explore 3) rent 10 to 15 acres on a logging/forest road inside of one our state forests? 4) rent a cabin on a lake close to whatever public land you like to hunt/explore 5) rent a small piece on lake where you could camp close to whatever public land you like to hunt/explore or 6) rent 160 acres you have all to your hunting party?

The kind of rentals I am talking about are long-term (1 year) so it seems a little more like ownership for comparison reasons. How often would you go to the property?

What is you choice? Just curious how people feel.

Thanks, Bill

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did the potlatch thing for a few years, been awhile though. I lease, but would like to buy if i can find the right piece of land.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks to the farmers non of us normal people will ever own 120 acrs of land, but to me thats the ultimate. Hard to do what tou want with food plots and shooting lanes or what ever on leased land.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...1) own 120 acres of land 2) own a cabin on a lake next close to whatever public land you like to hunt/explore 3) rent 10 to 15 acres on a logging/forest road inside of one our state forests? 4) rent a cabin on a lake close to whatever public land you like to hunt/explore 5) rent a small piece on lake where you could camp close to whatever public land you like to hunt/explore or 6) rent 160 acres you have all to your hunting party?...

I want to own land, option 1. Sure there are expenses and headaches involved, but if I want to cut some trees or put in a garden I need to own the land.

That being said, I am very thankful to have public land to hunt. It ain't all that bad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would prefer to own land.

Rent/lease is less expensive but not a sure thing in the long term. I don't like change, so hunting the same parcel for years is what I would prefer. Probably why i have been hunting the same parcel of public land since '92.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Depends totally on what is important to you/your family. Personally, My family used to own 5 acres on a beautiful lake in Itasca County. We did a lot of hunting and fishing around there, and growing up I had the time of my life there. Hunting is very important to us, and then, 1) neighbors started to die, land chunked up and sold 2) public land timber harvested heavily, 3) neighbors started to harvest timber heavily 4) private access spots dried up. Lot of public land still around, but you get the point. Now my brother and I relocated and along with some friends purchased 160 acres of woods/ag a couple hours further south. We have always wanted to get into land/deer management, and are now actively planting trees, food plots, ag, etc, and establishing harvest rules. Fun to be more interactive and involved. For us that's important and not possible renting a cabin or leasing land. So for me, the answer is own larger tract. But again, totally dependent on the needs of you and your family.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have done both when it comes to hunting property and I will say this nothing beats owning your own plot of property and the reason I say this in my situation we leased a real nice chunk of land for deer hunting and it was taken away with the stroke of a pen and nothing we could do about it. The land owner went through a messy divorce and lost the land we leased and the we were stuck holding the empty bag.

I also had owned a cabin just off of Mille Lacs and I think that was the way to go also but it was a lot of work, But worth every ounce of sweat we poured into it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks to the farmers non of us normal people will ever own 120 acrs of land, but to me thats the ultimate. Hard to do what tou want with food plots and shooting lanes or what ever on leased land.

Not true I bought 126 last April for $1,000 per acre, and that included 90 tillable. If you are serious enough to buy you just have to keep looking everyday almost because the great deals will get sold really quick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the input so far. I posted this reply on another forum:

For me the cost of entry now days is too great. I wish, like we all do, that I could turn the clock to when you could buy a piece for a price you can justify with that cost/benefit equation. My grandfather bought 96 acres in 1965 for $2000. The land next to us just sold for 1500/acre. That puts hers at roughly 150,000 to buy now. Decent appreciation over 50 years. But my grandmother has been paying taxes to the tune of at least $1000 for that last 20 years, plus the first thirty years. That doesn't count the interest paid if you finance and then subtracting capital gains. Interest of course is the big drain and I don't trust that the government will keep that mortgage interest deduction in place. So do you really make money? I can't convince myself of that anymore. We sold our cabin because once you added all the holding cost and maintenance and then divided it by the number of times we went up there, it is less to go to resorts and not do any work.

I recently read Warren Buffets letter to his shareholders (don't ask why, I am not a financial mind) and this line was on the first page: "Over the last 48 years (that is, since present management took over), book value has grown from $19 to $114,214, a rate of 19.7% compounded annually." That is if you owned one of his Class A stocks, just one.

Made me go Hummmm. Thanks for the input.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Out of those options I'd prefer to own a little cabin on a lake near lots of public land. Even if I could afford (and I can't) to buy private hunting land, I don't think I would. I could never limit myself to only being able to hunt an 80 or 120 acre chunk of land. I like being able to roam the huge expanses of public land up north and not need to worry about boundaries. Right now I have over 1,000 acres of public land that nobody else hunts, surrounded by endless country that is just lightly hunted, so it's just like owning my own private land with the exception that I can't plant food plots or cut shooting lanes, and the entire state shares the taxes with me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is like asking what type of car should I buy. Like many said it is based on your families uses of recreational land. There are pros and cons to both.

Me personally I like to rent via going to a resort to fish, or camp out on public land close to a lake I am fishing. I would not be interested in owning a lake cabin or lot.

I lean more towards owning hunting land for many of the reasons already listed. I owned a 20 acre parcel that bordered 240 acres of tax forfeit land. I really liked that, until a few neighboring pieces sold and other hunters moved in and hunted the same tax forfeited land. I ended up selling my 20 with a deer shack on it for a nice profit (plus to owning).

I now own a 40 acre parcel, but I am limited to that 40 as it does not border public land (although there is public land close by). The 40 is larger than the 20 obviously, but it gets real small by Monday morning on opening deer weekend with a small hunting party on it. (my 20 bordering public land hunted much larger). Also the taxes could probably cover a lease or close to it. I do like playing on it though - selective harvest timber gave me some $, I put in a small pond, a clearing to camp on, an outhouse, trails, permanent deer stands, and this year I hope to put in food plots. I do enjoy being able to get away to the 40 and "play in the woods". I guess my perfect piece (realistically) would be a 40 - 80 bordering some public land.

If $ were not an issue then a large tract all to myself for hunting on a great fishing lake.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyone who buys a cabin or hunting land as an investment is foolish. You will never get back all the hard work and $ you put into it. I bought 80 acres and built a cabin because I love to do it. I love building trails, stands and food plots. I enjoy harvesting firewood off my land to heat my home and my cabin and managing the forest. I take alot of pride in "MY" land and nobody can hunt in my spot or take it away. I too like to roam and my property butts up to over 15000 acres of public land with very little use on it, I would not buy property without it adjoining public land. I hunted potlatch land for years and lost my spots when it all sold in Pine & Carlton county, broke my heart. That won't happen again! grin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not always foolish, maybe nowaday it is for sure, but back in the day like my uncle who got bought out by an airport, he cashed in heavily, sure capital gains took a huge chunk, but he turned a monster profit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

From a hunting land standpoint, I'll vouch that there's nothing like owning your own parcel of land. Did the lease thing for many years and besides not being able to do exactly what you'd like, on all occasions it was just a matter of time before it had to end for one reason or the other. Now own our own chunk of land and it's an absolute breath of fresh air. I don't have the thoughts of "what did the landowner change now" when I drive up. I have 100% control and that's a big plus for me personally.

Now...a cabin on a lake is somewhat different for me and breaks down like this. I have A LOT of things going on at home. Work, my own maintenance and so on and so forth in the summer. If I had to choose, I'd pick the option to rent a cabin so that I can get up there, dump in the boat and fish, lay back and not have to worry about anything.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I had to pick just one, of course I would pick owning a decent tract of land that butted up to a lake. Best of both worlds!!! I would love to have a piece of hunting land of my own. We currently hunt public and I don't have huge complaints, but the dangers of not knowing who you are huting by and not knowing who is where and vice versa, makes me NOT want to bring my kids into that kind of scenario. My oldest is a few years away from being able to hunt and I have no interest in taking him out on public ground, basically for safety purposes. I have taken him with on my Father-in-laws farm and we have shot a few deer, but hunting the fields isn't the same for me as hunting the woods. I would love to have a 120 acre chunk, with a basic 30 x 40 cabin, in a lakes area. A great deer camp. A great spot to recreate and spend time with family and friends and all close to great lakes for fishing. If I could pick, it would be the Perham area or Cass Lake area. I've done the weekend thing, the full week thing, etc at resorts. Great to just show up and enjoy, but nothing like the feeling of owning a place. My parents bought a small cabin a few years ago and no matter what happens in the future, my kids will never forget it. All the times spent up there have been what they talk about most.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Land may not be the highest yielding investments you can make, but it is one of the safest investments you can make. Plus there are very few investments you can gain so much enjoyment from. The only problem with using it a an investment is that you won't want to sell it when you retire, so it should just be part of your investment portfolio. So far the farm land I've purchased has performed better than the money I've stuck into the stock market for the last 20 years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My wife and I love to camp. We always went to campgrounds on lake so we could fish. It got harder and harder to find resorts or campgrounds, even tougher if we decided at the last minute. We bought 40 acres close to many lakes. The taxes are cheaper than on a lake. I can hunt the 40 or go to public land close by. A win-win for us.

Rockin' Randy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • SkunkedAgain
      It doesn't look like the lake level has gone up at all. I was up a week ago and struggled to get my boat in and out of the public landing on the west end of Head O Lakes. I used my paddle to push the boat further out to deeper water. I could hear the hull moving over the sandy/muddy bottom near the launch.
    • JerkinLips
      Pretty tough.  Was catching about 2 walleyes per hour and the biggest was only 13".  Back up Thursday so I hope I have better success.
    • smurfy
      the kid and I always check our stands prior.......i'll go back to check the conditions of said stands before he gets there to see what we need. while i'm at it if i can i shoot at grouse with shells that appear to not have bb,s in them!!!!🙄
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      On the South Shore...  With unseasonably warm weather, there are still some anglers hitting the water and most have been rewarded.  Limits of walleyes and saugers being caught, and the forecast looking ahead is favorable. The best bite on the south end of LOW has been in 22-28 feet of water. Water temperatures are dropping and as the temps cool further, the bite has been excellent.     Vertical jigging with frozen emerald shiners has been the program for most anglers.  Bring plenty of bait, as you’ll need to sort through some smaller fish and short biters.  Plenty of eater fish to be had, just have to do a bit of sorting.  Anglers are also reporting very good numbers of jumbo perch and occasional pike mixed in with the walleyes.     For those fishing structure, if you slide up on top of a rock pile, don't be surprised to catch a big smallmouth bass, there are plenty around.   This week’s hot colors have been gold, gold/glow white, gold/chartreuse, gold/orange, and gold/glow white/pink.     One tip, a stinger hook on your jig will catch you more fish if you start missing too many fish. On the Rainy River...  Bait dealers are reporting good numbers of shiners in the river this past week.  Interesting, each night is different.  Some areas have the small shiners called pinheads.  Other areas have the larger minnows.     The river is producing some nice walleyes in various spots from Four Mile Bay to Wheeler's Point, to Baudette all the way to Birchdale.  There are 42 miles of navigable Rainy River from the mouth to Birchdale with plenty of public boat ramps along the way.     Walleyes are being caught in various depths, but 15-25 feet of water has been good.   Jigging with live or frozen emerald shiners has been highly effective. Some anglers are also trolling crankbaits to cover more ground and find fish. Both methods are producing solid results. Sturgeon fishing has been strong.  The catch-and-release sturgeon fishing is open into the spring when it changes to the "keep season" on April 24th. Up at the NW Angle...  Fall fishing continues to be excellent. Points, neck-down areas with current, shoreline breaks, and transition zones from rock to mud are all productive locations for walleye right now.   It is traditionally a mixed bag up around the many islands in this part of the lake and this fall is no different.  In addition to walleyes, pike, jumbo perch, and crappies are in the mix.  A jig and minnow has been the most effective presentation. Good muskie fishing is the norm during the fall of the year and area reports have been good.  In addition to casting, trolling shorelines, points and neckdown areas has been effective.  Muskies are often targeting schooling tullibees this time of year. The weather forecast for the next couple of weeks is conducive for fall fishing.  If you don't deer hunt, or if you have harvested your deer, consider some bonus walleye action before the ice forms.  The bite continues to be excellent.    
    • leech~~
    • gimruis
      I'm not one to leave that to chance the day I need it.  I always check on my stands prior to the season.  Just like I always shoot my rifle before the season and I always run my outboard motor before fishing opener.  Too many things to go wrong without confirming it ahead of time.   I guess it could have been beavers but the house itself didn't appear nearly big enough along one ditch.  It was about the size of chair.  I've seen beavers houses many times before and they appear much bigger than that.
    • leech~~
      Good thing you made a check run.  That would have really suked walking into opening day.  Why do you think muskrats and not beavers?  
    • gimruis
      Well I checked on stands over the weekend.  Kind of a disaster.   All the ditches are plum full and twice as wide becauase muskrats have clogged an area.  I spent an hour unclogging it and the water is slowly moving again, but our bridges and planks were underwater.  The back portion of the land where the best stand is was inaccessible.  Hopefully that changes by Saturday.  I have a feeling the muskrats are just going to clog it back up again.   Tons of standing corn still too.  They've started on it, but being so wet now with more rain coming, whatever's there will remain there for the foreseeable future.   All the grassland is completely flattened like a pancake due to 3-4 inches of heavy wet snow.  That eliminates about 75% of the pheasant habitat in this spot.  Total buzz kill.  And this specific spot was one of my better producers last season because the grass was intact and lush through December last year.
    • BWpineisland
      Jerkin, how was the fishing?
    • JerkinLips
      45.6°F Saturday afternoon.  Lake Vermilion was quite empty.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.