Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • 0

comparison between older 60HP and new 50HP questions


tjwierz2

Question

I have a 17'6" Crestliner with a '90 or '91 60HP Johnson. I am thinking about buying a new Merc or Yamaha, and I am curious if I would get the same performance from a new 50HP motor.

Will there be much difference between and older 60HP and a new 50HP. Should I stick with the same HP on the new motor? Thanks for the help.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 answer to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

good question, first of all, all outboards after 1990 are rated propshaft horsepower, so a 50 horse regardless of 2 or 4 stroke, or manufacturer is supposed to be the same ponies. What can be different is the final drive rpm and the amount of torque the motor produces at the propshaft. this gets very tricky.

Before 1990 manufacturers could measure horsepower at the propshaft or the crankshaft. The prop is a true reading, some manufacturers would rate propshaft so you could put the largest possible motor on a given boat and claimed thier motors were faster and more powerfull. Other manufacturers would rate thiers at the crankshaft, so they would claim you get more horses for your money and their motors had a better power to weight ratio and claim the competitions motors were too expensive and heavy. I have seen private lab expieriments where the crank could measure 22 Horses powerhead alone, attach lower unit and at the crankshaft it was now 18horses (what the motor was rated at) but at the propshaft it was only 14 horses. The next manufacturer was 24 horses at the crank but 19 horses at the prop (which it was rated 18HP) So which one will be faster? of course the higher prop horsepower. In the late 1980s a great debate over the USCG hp ratings resulted in that all outboard manufacturers must rate thier motors at the prop to ba fair and safe.

Its like in the 1960's when all the sudden a car that had a 330 horse v-8 all the sudden next year they said it was a 260 horse model, same displacement engine, same tranny and same car, even the same carbueretor. The NTSA said all automobiles must be rated at the drive whhels and not at the engines crankshaft.

Also there is motor weight to consider, a 60 horse 2 stroke 60 weighs about 200 pounds where a 4 stroke 50 might weigh upto 300 pounds (depending by manufacturer) so your overall power to weight ratio is affected.

To make it short, stick with a 60, if the motor is propped correctly and planes good. If you goto a 50 you take an 16.7 percent loss in the prop hp that you may be dissatisfied with. If you were comparing a 160 to a 150 i would say dont worry about it because it would only be a 6% loss in horsepower.

Good Luck I hope this helps.

------------------
The Warrior is back, and he's packin a new grill.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • ADAS
      don't know what roulette is? Hi. Roulette as I think is a very cool game. Roulette has been played since the nineteenth century and every self-respecting casino, including online casinos, be sure to have it in their assortment https://aolbroadband.in/ .Games for free, which the guys provide on this site, of course, include the most popular varieties of roulette: American, European and French. The online version of roulette is no different from the well-known one from land-based casinos: it features a green table with marked numbers and betting fields, as well as a wheel with numbered cells on which the ball rotates. On this site you can learn more and even play it 
    • andrew2
      In addition to to Feichao, you can also consider the DJI Mini SE. This is also an excellent piece. However, always try to read articles and thorough reviews before buying.
    • andrew2
      Mini drones like Feichao Mini Drone Quadcopter M9 are good to take footage.  
    • FrankOcean
      My grandmother is a very old person, and she has had a real estate company for 20 years now, she has dedicated her whole life to it, so she does not understand much about technology and is looking to modernize her business, she is one of the few real estate companies that They don't have their own application, so I see myself in charge of finding a good software developer for real estate and that type of business. Do you know any professional or company that is dedicated to it?
    • BobT
      Don't forget about IP Lures just west of town about 2 miles on the south side of Co. 82.    I was out on Osakis last week for a couple hours. Picked up two walleyes, one about 13" and the other a fat 14-1/2". Also a couple northerns and a handful of perch.
    • Andre.y
      Of course, you shouldn’t even ask about this, because this is the responsibility of the executor of the order, that is, the employee who will create such an application. I think it will be stated in the contract of employment if there is one and then you don't have to ask for anything.
    • smurfy
      👍 awesome sauce!!!
    • CigarGuy
      Shallow. Got skunked tonight. Just got chased off by the weather. Last evening was the only time the last 4 times out I caught fish. Last even was light drizzle and calm water. Water warmed up about 3-1/2 degrees since the first time out.
    • Kettle
      Got into the cranes, 5 a piece this morning for two of us  
    • Fasterok
      It is very important not only to identify mushrooms by their appearance but also to understand whether it is useful or not, because now there are many poisonous mushrooms, and it is extremely important that no mistakes were made in the selection of such mushrooms. That's why I here https://www.mushrooms.online/mushroom-poisoning/ read a lot of interesting information about poisonous mushrooms and was able to understand more about it. I hope that I was able to help you and was really helpful to learn. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.