Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

What's your total arrow weight?


sticknstring

Recommended Posts

Just curious to see what everyone shoots? Click on the calulator if you need to... The total weight of my arrows are 442 grains right now. I've shot a lot of different arrows and am always experimenting with new vanes so it flucuates from time-to-time but generally stays on the heavy side. This year, I'm thinking of lightening up a bit and maybe trying out a 400 grain setup. What's yours?

Arrow Weight Calculator

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For a pure deer bow, 400 would be plenty (and just about right for me). For a bow that I'd use for bigger boned critters like elk, bear, or caribou, a bare minimum for me is around 400, but I prefer more. I've shot 425 the last few years. I consider this a little on the light side for elk, but not too bad. It's a reasonable compromise and seems to blow through deer with no problem.

Much like I believe most hunters would be better off with longer bows, most deer hunters would be better off with a heavier arrow then they currently use. SNS, obviously your 440+ arrow doesn't qualify for this generality...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I beleive that I am around 425.... pulling 65 lbs and 30" and no prob punching through deer. I too like to err on the heavy side.. I could drop that weight down some but just to gain a few fps for me isn't worth the loss of KE. Especially considering I rarely shoot more than 30 yards... Probably 90% of my deer have been within 15 yards. And all but one of those that I can remember wasn't a complete passs-thru... Just rigged up my new D340 and I have to believe that she'll be a bone crusher with that arrow set up as well!

September yet?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Funny, We were just discussing this at work the other day and my hunting arrow with Broadhead and Lumenock weigh in at stout 350 grams.

Most everybody else was closer to the 400's.

I also have the shortest draw and went back to a 60 pound bow last year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My hunting arrows are just under 430 and this year I'm trying some target arrows and those are about 340. Its amazing how much more flat the 340's shoot. My pins out to 40 were all about the same but when I shot my 50 and 60 yard pins there was some adjustment needed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

im about 380 really like the gold tip arrows nice stiff arrow with low weight and the price isnt as bad as the carbon express arrows

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I cant remember to tell you the truth but I think mine are at 470 or somewhere in that ballpark I to believe heavy is better. For a few reasons one is the wind factor also a heavy arrow helps with vibration and noise and last but not least bone shattering power.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I stated 425 above as I thought that is what they were. After checking, it's more like approx 385 grain. That's ahooting 60#.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

SNS, you're a pot stirrin' trouble maker!!! winksmilegrin

That's what I was thinkin' too. Nothin' but trouble. I should have added that when I switch to broadheads in the fall I do shoot a heavier arrow, somewhere near 400 grains. Though I must admit, more than anything else I shoot the heavier arrow mostly because it's so much quieter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don, let's take him out back for a serious whoopin'!

I totally agree- one of the really big benefits of a heavier arrow is the impact it has on the noise of a bow. I shot a 425 arrow out of a center pivot Bowtech (a Commander- a very quiet bow by itself) a few years ago and you could hardly hear the thing from ten feet away. Besides being able to put an arrow where it's supposed to, noise is the 2nd most important spec in my set up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh c'mon Scoot - you started this whole mess! grin

Crediting Don for a 400 gr hunting arrow (that's what I was most interested in), the average for the 10 guys so far is a 408 grain arrow. I figured it to be right around 400 but with such a small sample size and bottom-bouncer shooting 470!... you shooting 125gr heads or telephone poles? laugh

I've never been a speed guy and have always shot heavy arrows in the 9-10.5 gpi range + wraps. This year I ordered a non-speed bow and was maybe looking to shoot some lighter arrows so I could practice at some longer distances more effectively. Just need to decided if the 15 fps I'd gain outweighs the minimal decrease in KE. For turkeys & deer, I think it would?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If stating my opinion, listening to people disagree with me, point out why they are wrong, and sticking to my guns was starting it, then yes... I started it. smile

I'm impressed with how many guys are shooting pretty heavy arrows! A lot of guys I know hunt with 300-350 grains arrows, saying they like the speed and the flat trajectory. In the end this is usually not ideal, IMO and works against the fact that the vast majority of deer are shot inside of 20 yards anyway. It also isn't consistent with the KE lost, particularly at longer range, on Western game too.

A few fps or a little KE- pick your poison! I like to get a relatively fast bow (I'm no speed freak), then choose the heavier arrow- gives lots of KE, is quiet, but still fairly fast.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

WOW!!!! Mark this down. I TOTALLY agree with Scoot. shocked Guess it was just a matter of time... laugh

LOL! It's a first!!! We better watch out or we'll start agreeing too often!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I knew I could get the two of you back on track - just a matter of time! Agreeing with one another isn't nearly as exciting as arguing back and forth though. smile

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK so I went back to look on an old thread to see what my arrow weight is cuz I couldnt remember I am at 419gr my bad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i shoot a 353 grain arrow at 285fps with my short 27 inch draw and have never had problems with penetration. I've always gotten pass throughs (be it fixed or mechanical) besides tonight on a doe that was 50 yards away. Shot her hard quartering away in the back left ham and exited slightly behind the front right shoulder with about 3 inches of arrow sticking out the exit side. So total i got about 26 inches of penetration through the deer and she was down in 60 yards. So for me a lighter faster arrow has performed great on deer.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i shoot a 353 grain arrow at 285fps with my short 27 inch draw and have never had problems with penetration. I've always gotten pass throughs (be it fixed or mechanical) besides tonight on a doe that was 50 yards away. Shot her hard quartering away in the back left ham and exited slightly behind the front right shoulder with about 3 inches of arrow sticking out the exit side. So total i got about 26 inches of penetration through the deer and she was down in 60 yards. So for me a lighter faster arrow has performed great on deer.

So you got a doe tonight you have any pictures and what area are you hunting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

just so happens i do have a picture for proof incase you have a hard time believing, and i hunt SD season dont end tell the 31st.

Entry

165175_1831820916784_1278210065_2191124_

exit

167734_1831821156790_1278210065_2191126_

Result

168576_1831820796781_1278210065_2191123_

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

I remember those...they were like 11-12 gpi weren't they? You win the heaviest arrow I think. Those have to be 5-6 years old plus. That's pretty good keeping your arrows around that long. I go through a close to a dozen a year.

Those CX Piledriver Hunters are really heavy - anybody shoot those? I could get KE in the mid 90's with those bad boys.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • SkunkedAgain
      Hogs! Hogs!!!
    • MarkB
      My 2 cousins and myself just finished up a windy 4 day trip to our favorite lake. It was the last of the year and was eventful to say the least. When we arrived, water temperatures were 61 degrees and when we left yesterday morning the water temps had dropped to 54 degrees. The fishing was fantastic, once again, and we caught walleyes, bass, and northerns on minnows and crawlers(northerns only on minnows). We found the fish adjacent to shallow rock piles(14') in 20'-28' of water. Our best fishing hours of the day were ~5:30 -twilight in the evenings and until ~ 10:30 in the mornings. Although those two time periods were prime time, fish bit all day. For us, the bite was very light and we probably missed or lost as many fish as we caught. Some people think I'm nuts when I say bead color can make a difference and it certainly did this trip. My cousin's "go to" green/white bead combo did zilch on this trip. It was one translucent red bead and a plain size #2 gamakatsu hook with a 3' leader that produced the fish. We ended up with 137 walleyes and 19 bass for the 4 day outing. We caught far more 17"-19.999" walleyes on this trip than on our previous trips and our numerous slot fish measured from 21"-25". My younger cousin caught 4 slot fish in ~20 minutes one evening. We fish exclusively for walleyes and additional species are incidental. With that said, we caught some beautiful smallmouth bass on this trip and they were right down there with the walleyes, usually in the rocks. As usual, everything is catch and release except for the fish we eat while there and the 12 walleyes(3 individual limits) we take home to the wives. While cleaning some eaters we kept for supper, we always check the stomach contents. One of the walleyes had the jig that is pictured below loose in its stomach!  No attached line, no embedded hook, just the jig! It baffled us as to how in the world it could have gotten there . As you can see, the jig is in good shape so the fish must have swallowed it recently .   The boat traffic was minimal this trip and we had a couple days where it looked as if we had the lake to ourselves. Sunday was a brutal day with wind gusts to 50MPH!. We stayed in and ventured out finally at ~5:00. It turned out to be the best 2 hours of the entire trip. This time, the baby loons were around, the eagles were abundant, the changing leaves made the entire lake area look like a painting. If I could make only one short trip a year to the lake, now would be the time. What capped off the trip was the magnificent display of the Northern Lights. We can't wait for next spring to return, God willing, and, in the meantime, good fishing.  MarkB🙂 The jig found in the stomach of a walleye we ate.   My young cousin with his best of the trip.   a chunky 17" smallmouth   19.5" smallmouth
    • leech~~
      Well, since they both say Propane on them.  Not propane QT++ their probably both the same gender!  🤭
    • Wanderer
    • Brianf.
      What an amazing extended weekend. The fish were happy and cooperated nicely.   We also had the unique experience of fishing under Northern Lights each of the last three nights in pristine weather conditions.  I wish everyone could have that experience, even if just once.  The pics below don't do it justice, though you get the idea.  The walleyes are putting on the feedbag and some are getting rather plump.  We caught mostly slot fish with several 'overs' in our bag.  Our two biggest weighed 8lbs 5oz and 8lb 3oz.     The crappies were active at dusk and beyond.  Almost all of the ones we caught were 14" or bigger.  The biggest we caught was a bit over 15".  We lost two muskies at the boat and caught a 38" pike after dark - quite surprising.   Every fish we caught was immediately released btw.  Water temp 54/55 when we left.  All-in-all, another great fishing experience on Lake Vermilion - for which I'm so incredibly appreciative.        
    • JerkinLips
    • leech~~
      The price and the label.  It's that same exact gas.  
    • Finns
      I don't use gas anymore, what's the difference between them?
    • Fish Head
      Great to hear from you again Mark! I've always liked your posts over the years. 
    • leech~~
      Yep, it's just you know and I know every dad who takes his kids or family camping for the first time.  Is buying the camping gas no matter the cost, cuz it says "Camping" on it! 🤭🤭
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.