Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

senate bill 2235 in ND legistrative


Recommended Posts

This bill basically changes the non-resident from two 7 days to three 4 days. I personnaly think this is more fair for non-residents even though you lose a couple days. Atleast I think we are moving in the right direction. Curious what some of you guys that travel from out of state think of this bill.

For the record I think its ridiculous having only two 7 days hunting season for non-residents.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 61
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • cbrooks

    13

  • brittman

    10

  • SledNeck

    5

  • walleye18

    3

In my states defense. I will say we are more non-resident friendly than some of the others states. I agree with what you say.

I would like to add that North Dakota had a bill like this a couple years ago I think that was 5 three day NR season. It was narrowly defeated so I could see this one going.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think they should leave it the way it is. If two seven day periods is not enough and killing duck is so important why not just move to ND? Legislators always have some kind of agenda. I’m guessing if you were to look into the bill sponsors they are from counties/regions with tons of NR’s. They see this bill as more money in their pocket. Maybe 1% of the local population would benefit from this. The rest would see nothing but additional pressure and competition for hunting areas. Trust me ND does not need NR hunting license money either, they have something called oil. NR should be happy they have the chance to come to ND. Instead many what to come for two weeks a year rape the resource go home tell everyone there is no pressure and complain about how bad NR have it. Why ruin such a pristine area with additional hunters/leases/pressure? Makes no sense to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think they should leave it the way it is. If two seven day periods is not enough and killing duck is so important why not just move to ND? Legislators always have some kind of agenda. I’m guessing if you were to look into the bill sponsors they are from counties/regions with tons of NR’s. They see this bill as more money in their pocket. Maybe 1% of the local population would benefit from this. The rest would see nothing but additional pressure and competition for hunting areas. Trust me ND does not need NR hunting license money either, they have something called oil. NR should be happy they have the chance to come to ND. Instead many what to come for two weeks a year rape the resource go home tell everyone there is no pressure and complain about how bad NR have it. Why ruin such a pristine area with additional hunters/leases/pressure? Makes no sense to me.

In reality, we are all americans.. why should stuff be closed off/limited to those who live over imaginary lines? Other states who allow NR hunting all season seem to be getting by just fine with all the added "pressure".

What would ND residents do if Minnesota limited their right to SHOP or stay in Minnesota? Kids in ND would grow up not knowing what civilization and people look like. Since Target field is payed for with Minnesota tax dollars should we limit ND residents to one game a year but only after the all-star break because they could be taking tickets that tax paying Minnesotans would buy?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like this bill, works for me. Buy another license if 14 or 12 days is not enough. I personally like the friendly people of ND and great hunting to boot!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What would ND residents do if Minnesota limited their right to SHOP or stay in Minnesota? Kids in ND would grow up not knowing what civilization and people look like. Since Target field is payed for with Minnesota tax dollars should we limit ND residents to one game a year but only after the all-star break because they could be taking tickets that tax paying Minnesotans would buy?

Awesome. Thanks for the slam. Much appreciated

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe if South Dakota was more liberal with their NR waterfowl regulations

it would take the pressure off of North Dakota. All I know is where I hunt in SE ND My business is greatly appreciated and I would be more than willing to spend additional time and money there in the fall. As for the oil money I don't see any of it being spread around in the eastern half of the state yet. And as for harvesting ducks isn't that a large part of what it's all about or am I confused. PS. I own a house out there pay taxes and vacation there at least 8 times a year and enjoy myself and my friendships

tremendously.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

one day ND will stop shooting themselves in the foot from a economic standpoint

Your comment is based on what facts?

There is no limit to the number of licenses sold in ND for either waterfowl or upland. They make you pay more to hunt waterfowl in the whole state vs picking a zone. A nonresident can buy additional upland game licenses.

The number of licenses they sell is right near the limit acceptable to resident hunters.

Most hotels, rental houses, and other business are near capacity anyways and additional NR would have some difficulty finding lodging.

In the windmill areas and oil field country these motels and homes are sold out year around now and no longer reliant on hunters.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well its the same principle behind the DNR in MN wanting to be cautious about raising fishing license fees. at some point you start pricing a lot of people out of the sport.

I sure as hell wouldn't buy a license to hunt in ND if I could only pick a 4 day period. I like having at least extremely limited flexibility. with 4 days you have none

what is the practical point of the bill? reducing non-resident hunters? that certainly seems to be the point of it from my perspective

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well its the same principle behind the DNR in MN wanting to be cautious about raising fishing license fees. at some point you start pricing a lot of people out of the sport.

I sure as hell wouldn't buy a license to hunt in ND if I could only pick a 4 day period. I like having at least extremely limited flexibility. with 4 days you have none

what is the practical point of the bill? reducing non-resident hunters? that certainly seems to be the point of it from my perspective

You would have the option of three 4 day hunts. Unlike SD it is easy to change the dates as long as you change the dates BEFORE the 1st day of your time period. This bill gives NRs the possibility of 3 weekend periods instead of 2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My only problem with is I base my vaction on 5-7 days and now I can only hunt there 4 days or could you possibly run 2 4 day hunts back to back if so No problem with me.

I do however like the fact that 4 weekends could be used

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I found another bill 1407 that will allow non-residents to hunt ND early goose season in Benson, Ramsey, and Towner counties(just north of Devils Lake). This would be early September and will not count against there 14 day NR hunting season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

brittman,

what I am saying is that i don't have flexibility WITHIN my hunting period. Bad weather? bummer. unforseen circumstances with my vehicle? bummer. just a poor day hunting? Now I can't stay an extra day on the end if I want, or go hunting with some of the landowners I've become friendly with

i know ND is great about changing the days of the hunting period beforehand, but with 4 days there is NO wiggle room.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think that I will have to become a resident in order to take full advantage of the hunting season but I will have to wait one more year till the wife is a RN then its Devils lake area here I come... at least thats what I'm praying for..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guys..I just have to reply to this.

I have 2 homes in ND. One a rental and the other a hunting house. For the last 6 years I have hunted waterfowl/pheasants etc...as a non resident.

The 14 day waterfowl season for non residents is a "one time license". Meaning, you cannot purchase another one for the year to continue to waterfowl hunt.

What I see in ND is this - most of the folks hunting waterfowl are non residents - fact!! Statistically, non residents far out weigh residents when it comes to waterfowl hunting. The $$ these people bring into the small towns in rural ND is huge. Cafe's, area businesses, etc, survive on the $$ hunting brings to the area - I know. One of the farmers that I hunt with is also the Mayor of this small town - he states that the $$ hunters bring to the community is important for the town survival.

Point being, changing the non resident season to 3 - 4 day periods is great. Not only will it bring more $$ to ND, but it lets the non resident hunters choose and use his times for waterfowl hunting is a "better way".

I do agree with the argument that having a non resident 14 day season for waterfowl is @#$%#@#$.

Should we have all non residents who come to MN and fish only get 14 days? This would make things fair - would'nt it?

Too bad the polititians who make the laws in ND are all from GF and Fargo.

I will never understand the 14 day argument for non resident waterfowl hunters in ND.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

walleye 18. I agree with you. I look at it the same way you mention with the fishing NR for Minnesota. I don't follow what you mean from politician are all from GF and Fargo. I feel most of the anti NR in North Dakota comes from the west but maybe I'm wrong.

If there is a politician iin the senate voting against this please let me know. I'm a voter here and I support extending the NR season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

brittman,

what I am saying is that i don't have flexibility WITHIN my hunting period. Bad weather? bummer. unforseen circumstances with my vehicle? bummer. just a poor day hunting? Now I can't stay an extra day on the end if I want, or go hunting with some of the landowners I've become friendly with

i know ND is great about changing the days of the hunting period beforehand, but with 4 days there is NO wiggle room.

Want to stay on, then use another one of your four day blocks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guys..I just have to reply to this.

I have 2 homes in ND. One a rental and the other a hunting house. For the last 6 years I have hunted waterfowl/pheasants etc...as a non resident.

The 14 day waterfowl season for non residents is a "one time license". Meaning, you cannot purchase another one for the year to continue to waterfowl hunt.

What I see in ND is this - most of the folks hunting waterfowl are non residents - fact!! Statistically, non residents far out weigh residents when it comes to waterfowl hunting.

Not true. There are around 35,000 resident licenses sold and 25,000 nonresident waterfowl licenses sold. A study about 8 - 10 years ago showed that ND residents spent more total $$ while hunting waterfowlin ND. I will give you the notion that nonresident dollar spend is higher in the hospitality sector (loding and dining).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I WOULD SAY THE RESIDENT DOES SPEND MORE BECAUSE THEY GO MORE OFTEN.HOWEVER THEY DON'T SPREAD THEIR MONEY AROUND LIKE THE N.R.

YOU CAN GAS UP IN FARGO OR BISMARK PACK A LUNCH AND NOT SPEND A DIME IN THE AREA YOU ACTUALLY HUNT IN.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Worthless study by the anti NR side. Figured in all the gear purchased by resident hunters. Apples to oranges.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I found some contacts in the state legistrature that arthured this bill.

Senate bill 2235-changing NR season from two 7 days to three four days.

Jerry Klein email [email protected]

John Andrist email [email protected]

Gerald Uglem email [email protected]

Michael Brandenburg email [email protected]

Duane Dekrey email [email protected]

Robin Weisz email [email protected]

Arthur for bill House bill 1407-open early goose season to NR for counties Ramsey, Benson and Towner W/o using there current 14 day season.

Dennis Johnson email [email protected]

Curt Hofstad email [email protected]

Robin Weisz email [email protected]

Ryan Taylor email [email protected]

Dave Oehlke email [email protected]

Don't be discourage not to send your input if you don't live in North Dakota. I've sent emails to Minnesota's rep and senators regarding fishing bills. I even got some replies back. Good luck

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Worthless study by the anti NR side. Figured in all the gear purchased by resident hunters. Apples to oranges.

You have read the report?

Apples and oranges are still sales. Like I said, NR do provide a strong flow of dollars into the hospitatlity industry (lodging, dining, etc). This is why small town chambers of commerce - if you can call them that - support these measures.

There are no limits to the number of hunters allowed into ND to chase ducks and geese. They do limit their total days in the state.

These small town hotels and rental houses are full and often becomes the limiting factor for more NRs to visit. Just no more room. People new to hunting in ND will not be purchasing houses.

The oil industry and the windmill industry continue to take up much of the available lodging in some areas of ND. Reliance on the sportsmans dollar is gone in these locales.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Brittman...not picking on you but for waterfowl hunting you are not correct. NR waterfowl hunters out number resident waterfowl hunters in ND - by a large number - Fact. These figures are published every year in the "North Dakota Outdoors Magazine" - published by the North Dakota Game and Fish Dept.

If you were comparing the small game license sales between NR and resident you might have something there. The numbers are close, but I think resident small game license sales do out number NR

Nonetheless, getting back on the topic, going from 2 14 day periods to 3 4 day periods is great IMO.

ND has so much to offer in waterfowl hunting. A person can do well/awesome given the migration and location in the State....14 days in ND is fine by me. Would I like to hunt more - you bet! Glad I have a wife from ND who "understands" that I need to go out and harvest what God has created for us. Now only if her and the kids left more birds for me to eat.

Finally, I do not have the facts to confidently comment regarding the $$ spent on waterfowl gear of the NR verses the $$ spent on waterfowl gear of the resident. Just by the shear number difference between the two, I would say NR waterfowl hunters spend more $$ verses resident waterfowl hunters

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The way I figure who spends more is irrelevent. Its revenue from out of state that matters. Brittman is right about the oil industry taking up lodging is the western part. In Devils lake all the hotels and some of the resorts have people in them from working on there dike. I know because I work out there last summer. Everything is book in that town from the dike project.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Like i've said in the past to avoid this non-resident bad-air, make both the Dakota's and Minnesota into one state and name it Minnkota! grin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • SkunkedAgain
      Hogs! Hogs!!!
    • MarkB
      My 2 cousins and myself just finished up a windy 4 day trip to our favorite lake. It was the last of the year and was eventful to say the least. When we arrived, water temperatures were 61 degrees and when we left yesterday morning the water temps had dropped to 54 degrees. The fishing was fantastic, once again, and we caught walleyes, bass, and northerns on minnows and crawlers(northerns only on minnows). We found the fish adjacent to shallow rock piles(14') in 20'-28' of water. Our best fishing hours of the day were ~5:30 -twilight in the evenings and until ~ 10:30 in the mornings. Although those two time periods were prime time, fish bit all day. For us, the bite was very light and we probably missed or lost as many fish as we caught. Some people think I'm nuts when I say bead color can make a difference and it certainly did this trip. My cousin's "go to" green/white bead combo did zilch on this trip. It was one translucent red bead and a plain size #2 gamakatsu hook with a 3' leader that produced the fish. We ended up with 137 walleyes and 19 bass for the 4 day outing. We caught far more 17"-19.999" walleyes on this trip than on our previous trips and our numerous slot fish measured from 21"-25". My younger cousin caught 4 slot fish in ~20 minutes one evening. We fish exclusively for walleyes and additional species are incidental. With that said, we caught some beautiful smallmouth bass on this trip and they were right down there with the walleyes, usually in the rocks. As usual, everything is catch and release except for the fish we eat while there and the 12 walleyes(3 individual limits) we take home to the wives. While cleaning some eaters we kept for supper, we always check the stomach contents. One of the walleyes had the jig that is pictured below loose in its stomach!  No attached line, no embedded hook, just the jig! It baffled us as to how in the world it could have gotten there . As you can see, the jig is in good shape so the fish must have swallowed it recently .   The boat traffic was minimal this trip and we had a couple days where it looked as if we had the lake to ourselves. Sunday was a brutal day with wind gusts to 50MPH!. We stayed in and ventured out finally at ~5:00. It turned out to be the best 2 hours of the entire trip. This time, the baby loons were around, the eagles were abundant, the changing leaves made the entire lake area look like a painting. If I could make only one short trip a year to the lake, now would be the time. What capped off the trip was the magnificent display of the Northern Lights. We can't wait for next spring to return, God willing, and, in the meantime, good fishing.  MarkB🙂 The jig found in the stomach of a walleye we ate.   My young cousin with his best of the trip.   a chunky 17" smallmouth   19.5" smallmouth
    • leech~~
      Well, since they both say Propane on them.  Not propane QT++ their probably both the same gender!  🤭
    • Wanderer
    • Brianf.
      What an amazing extended weekend. The fish were happy and cooperated nicely.   We also had the unique experience of fishing under Northern Lights each of the last three nights in pristine weather conditions.  I wish everyone could have that experience, even if just once.  The pics below don't do it justice, though you get the idea.  The walleyes are putting on the feedbag and some are getting rather plump.  We caught mostly slot fish with several 'overs' in our bag.  Our two biggest weighed 8lbs 5oz and 8lb 3oz.     The crappies were active at dusk and beyond.  Almost all of the ones we caught were 14" or bigger.  The biggest we caught was a bit over 15".  We lost two muskies at the boat and caught a 38" pike after dark - quite surprising.   Every fish we caught was immediately released btw.  Water temp 54/55 when we left.  All-in-all, another great fishing experience on Lake Vermilion - for which I'm so incredibly appreciative.        
    • JerkinLips
    • leech~~
      The price and the label.  It's that same exact gas.  
    • Finns
      I don't use gas anymore, what's the difference between them?
    • Fish Head
      Great to hear from you again Mark! I've always liked your posts over the years. 
    • leech~~
      Yep, it's just you know and I know every dad who takes his kids or family camping for the first time.  Is buying the camping gas no matter the cost, cuz it says "Camping" on it! 🤭🤭
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.