• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • Join In - We Share Fishing Reports & Outdoor Information Here

     
      You know what we all love...

      The same things you do!!!! Share what you love & enjoy in the outdoors as well as thank those whose posts you 'appreciate.'

      Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
troller89

Loon Lake kill off

Recommended Posts

troller89

Anybody here of the DNR wanting to turn the aereators off on loon and pearl lakes in jackson county to kill them off?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
walleyeaddict

They better not...wouldn't surprise me though...they need an overhaul...elected officials..something!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hotspot

It is not really up to the DNR local Cons club takes care of them.Its a tough deal to decide weather or not to leave them go or shut them off.Double edge sword.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
walleyeaddict

Not jumpin on ya hot spot but what do you mean "tough deal to leave them on or go shut them off" ?? Consevation clubs can only do things with the permission of the DNR i.e. permits etc. Why would you shut them off?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LOTWSvirgin

Cause the DNR wants to try to have a good kill. The DNR is also saying Clear lake is in bad shape to. I dont believe they are from talking to differant people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hotspot

I think aerators have ther place if somebody will net the rough fish out more often but sometimes having a good winterkill and let mothernature run its course may be the best.I also know that the rough fish are alot tougher and may not be killed off .Double edge sword

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
walleyeaddict

DOUBLE EDGE SWORD!!!

Note from admin, please read frum policy before posting again. Thank you.

Do you have any idea how many walleyes, crappies, and countless other worthy fish live in this lake?? I see where ur from do you fish it?? With the amount of flow through this lake and creek connections you would never kill the rough fish. Just a total waste of time and catastrophic failure of a better then average fishery for this area. I fish it regularily and last year had exceptional days....WASTE OF TIME! Gettin warm in here enough said!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LOTWSvirgin

DOUBLE EDGE SWORD!!! I am sure this will attract a moderator but how stupid!! Do you have any idea how many walleyes, crappies, and countless other worthy fish live in this lake?? I see where ur from do you fish it?? With the amount of flow through this lake and creek connections you would never kill the rough fish. Just a total waste of time and catastrophic failure of a better then average fishery for this area. I fish it regularily and last year had exceptional days....WASTE OF TIME! Gettin warm in here enough said!

I totally agree I have had many exceptional days just fishing the shore. It is or was a good spot to go. The pressure has been of thet lake for a few years since round has been so hot. What a shame. If the guy who has the permit to seine it would do it instead of waiting to make it worth his time that would get rid of some of the rough fish it would be a start.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
riverrat56

Netting rough fish is a band-aid at best, there is no possible way to get them all out and then they will spawn again and have better survival rates and there will be an explosion of small rough fish.

I don't know much about Loon lake other than it is shallow and is prone to winter kill. Both sides of the argument have made valid points for leaving it on or turning it off. Each case is differnt and I don't know enough about this one to comment.

All I know is the recent warm weather and rain will help to bring up the levels of dissolved O2 in the lakes and help to prevent any winterkills from occuring.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kosterguide

has anyone actully talked with the co or the sportsmens club or is this all rumor, i did talk to a couple people in that area and they said they have not hard anything about this, one works for the DNR,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LOTWSvirgin

Theres alot of rumors going around about this. Like the DNR testing on the south east side of the lake by the dock where it is shallow instead of out by the areators and the conservation club is testing out by the areators in which you will get two differant results. I did talk to a lake owner out there who says he has some thing to do with the lake some board or something like that and he says all is good. Just what I have heard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
heating guy

killing it off won't do anything for it carp, bullheads and sheapheads will still survive. What needs to happen is state needs to get off their buts and actually spend some money down here instead of all up in the metro and dredge the lakes go from 6 feet deep to teens to twenties run off is the problem lack of structure. Ya this is a sore spot I guess my home town in iowa did a dredge program with no help from dnr and it helped the water quality greatly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
walleyeaddict

I talked too a bunch of people about this. It appears it is just a bunch of hoo haa...no ones even heard about it. One guy almost had a heart attack and he lives there!! He is looking into it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
reddog

Rumor..

Not gonna happen.

Shutting off the aerators this late in the game, especially after yesterday, wont have any affect. While it may kill some game fish, the carp, catfish, and buffalo will just enjoy the extra space.

Keep all catfish you catch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ifishsd

Actually the carp are the first to die in low Oxygen. Perch and northerns can survive the longest in low oxygen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MN Shutterbug

Actually the carp are the first to die in low Oxygen. Perch and northerns can survive the longest in low oxygen.

I've heard the same thing. Unfortunately, I don't think bullheads need any oxygen to survive. wink I remember as a kid, (a long time ago), catching a stringer of bullheads, and not wanting to clean them right away, I'd hang them from the overhead garage door handle, in the sun, for a few hours. That didn't even seem to make them sad. They were still flopping around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
123fish

" That didn't even seem to make them sad." Hilarious!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SapperACE

Dredging a lake in this part of the state is pointless. Farm field run off would fill it back in as fast as you could take it out. It sounds great, but it would never work. Farming is the center of our local economy, and farmers are who our local legislators aim to please.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
heating guy

look at emmetsburg ia they dredge the lake with no help from the dnr and they improved the run off and 80% of that lake is farmed around and its still doing good for 20 years since dredging started. Five island went from max depth of 6 feet to over 20 after dredge farms just need to be less greedy and not farm up to lakes makes me mad when farmers destroy 100 year old tree fence lines and keep taking more of the ditch just so they can get one or two more rows in same with farming right up to the lakes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kosterguide

dont blame farmers you dont see them coming to you and telling you how to make your money, remeber farmers are dealing with high cost, everything has tripled in price for them so dont blame them for anything

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
heating guy

its not all the farmers but should the government regulate them cutting down trees along fence lines that are over 100 years old that can never be replaced in my job the government does tell me what I can do a lot of regulations refrigerant and chemicals but oh well i wish i could get government subsidies

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thump'n em big

you dont think there are regulations and rules that the government imposes on farmers??? there are thousands more than you could imagine and if farmers are cutting down trees by a lake... A. its illegal and you can not wrap up all farmers as being bad or B. its the farmers land that he bought years ago and its his to do what he wants with it... if it was sold as farm land he bought it to farm it... FINALLY.. this is a fishing forum... lets talk fishin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
riverrat56

There is far less sediment run of from farms than one thinks, at least that ends up in lakes. If there were lots most lakes would completly fill in, dredged or not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LOTWSvirgin

None you all have ever Been to Heron Lake huh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
heating guy

right lotwsvirgin heron lake decades ago use to be deeper but because of run off its super shallow. I even remember from conservation class in school that farm run off is the leading cause for lakes silting up from drain tiles dumping into cricks that trees and vegetation where removed from that dump into lakes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • arctic_scrap1
      I picked up a used 2013 Forest River True North 20x8 ice house. I got a decent deal on it but the front jack is having problems. When I try to raise up the tongue I get some loud clicking sounds from the jack and it's not raising. I'm prepared to just buy a whole new jack for it since I assume the internals are stripped but has anyone else a similar problem? This jack is rated for 3500lbs and the tongue weight is well under 1000lbs so I'm pretty disappointed with it. For right now I'm just using my car jack. Maybe I'll need it for the rear jacks.....
    • leech~~
      Winni or Leech.
    • Bryan P
      Been a slow start to my season but finally found few decent crappies.They were in 23ft off structure. Tungsten jig tipped with white plastic did the trick to bring them topside. Can't beat plastics, caught tons of fish on just one. You know its on and doesn't fall off. Got some cool footage of the flasher in this video too.     
    • pikeandchester
      Got a pickup, wheel house, ATV and portable. Been to (not all this year) Lake of the Woods, Upper Red, and Mill Lacs. Any recommendations for something new? Otherwise may try to get to know the lakes near Garrison.
    • pikeandchester
      5 sauger Saturday, 4 sauger and 3 pout Sunday out of Adrian’s. Started in deeper water, east of the crowd on Saturday. Sunday I moved around a bit, even drove the atv west of the crowd, 34 fow, with no luck. Spent the afternoon and evening in 25 fow near pine Island which was the only place I caught fish Sunday. Resort houses where mostly in 34 fow. Back home now.
    • Sunset Lodge
      Hello from the NW Angle! Fishing remains consistently strong on the Minnesota side this week. Many species are quick to bite leaving anglers with a very mixed bag at the end of the day. We saw multiple 40+ inch Northern, many Perch, even a Lake Trout among an already strong Walleye bite. 22-24 ft on gravel bottom surrounded by mud has been our best spots. Be sure to charge up any Glow tackle in use, with the increasing snow cover, glow or lighted lures have been hot. Pink/white and gold are also very effective on sunny days. The Canadian bite just keeps getting better! Crappies can be found in 30 foot holes while 22-26 ft flats on break lines have been hot for a Sauger/Walleye mix. Remember to stick to well-traveled trails as most have not been staked/marked as of yet. Until next week!
      Sunset Lodge
    • Parmer
      Not sure about the resort... But I know Adrians road is like 11 miles out past pine Island and they were plowing farther. Guy from my work was 9 miles out last weekend and did good on 14 inch sauger with some walleye mixed in.  He said there is 24 inches of ice.   I would say to try and get away from the groups.  Good luck fishing. 
    • Parmer
      Am heading up this weekend... Not sure where we going out of... But like to be away from the groups also. I usually go out of hunters but they are having road issues again. I am sure it will be resolved by Friday. 
    • Matt Johnson
      Some good news and some bad news over the last week...  good news is that we made more ice!!  Bad news is that the fish keep moving (STAY PUT FISHY'S!!! LOL)!!    I'm finding 12-16" of ice on most lakes, but still practice caution.  I've been driving out on many area lakes with my Suburban but you still need to pay attention to the ice conditions and don't take any risks.  Some of the shoreline ice is a little weird and areas around islands, channels, neck-downs, etc, will continue to have bad ice... something you can expect all winter in some spots.  So, always use caution and don't go venturing "off the beaten path" if you don't know the lake or know where you're going.     Ok, onto the the fishing stuff!  A lot of fish still holding in the shallows, but they are constantly moving.  The additional pressure that the lakes are seeing has the fish more active--and not necessarily active as-in feeding, but more-so just roaming and moving around more.  The vehicle traffic will push fish around, same with the increase amount of holes being cut and just the increase in general fishing pressure.  So, preaching mobility is no longer an option... you have to PRACTICE mobility as well.  You know, the whole "practice what you preach" phenomenon.  Get those augers going and chase down the fish.  The shallow bite can require a lot of holes to find the consistent pattern, but once you figure them out you can hone-in on a more specific area and hammer-home.  Yesterday morning from 8am-11am I went through 4 batteries on my Milwaukee ripping holes, just be thankful the ice isn't 2-feet thick yet so it's a good time to get after 'em!   One thing I've noticed lately is that the fish are really relating to the bends on the shoreline structure.  Seems to hold them a bit longer than traditional flats and break lines.  The bends that have weeds are even better--assuming those weeds are alive and flourishing.  Not much snow on the ice so it makes for easy travel, too... but don't forget the cleats, or you'll know why real-quick!  Punch out those bends both on the edge and up on the shallow portion if there are weeds present.  The pattern has held true on a handful of lakes... Chisago area, Minnetonka, Forest Lake, Clearwater and many others.  Might be onto something... let me know if others find the same thing...   And for presentations, I've been absolutely crushing them on the Pinhead Mino with NO BAIT at all.  The 1/16oz has been deadly on crappies and gills.  An easy bait to fish when staying mobile and no messing with bait or even plastics.  I've had to slow down and finesse some fish with tungsten and plastics too, so don't get me wrong, but it's amazing what that Pinhead will catch! See pics below...   Otherwise I just keep glued to my Lowrance and Navionics chip, or else the Navionics App for my phone and continue to scout out new spots.  Never get complacent and keep searching out new spots.  I'm seeing the spots dry-up faster and faster after you find a "honey hole," so keep looking for that next one!   Some cool temps heading our way... might actually feel like winter in MN for a while! Lol.  I'll be back on the ice Friday-Sunday and I'll check a few more lakes and report back.  Good luck out there and be safe!
    • LUCIFER
      Basswood motor permits are hard to come by. Be ready and get it the first day that permits are offered. JIM P.