• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • WE CREATE LONG TERM, MEANINGFUL RELATIONSHIPS IN HERE ... PLEASE JOIN US.

    You know what we all love...

    RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE
    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
catfreak

Cattin' the Chain

Recommended Posts

catfreak

Just seeing if anybody did any catfishing on the horseshoe chain in the past few days. I'm heading to Horseshoe tomorrow night with my girlfriend. She's never been ice fishin for cats before, so I'm hoping the bite will be on. If anybody has had any luck out there in the last week I'd be interested to here about it. Especially if you've got any tips on presentations that have been working.

Chris

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Borch

Was out the end of last week. A 1/16 or 1/8 oz spoon tipped with cut bait jigged subtle manner paired with a deadstick with a small spoon and cut bait. Sometimes they hit the jigging spoon and sometimes the deadstick. Look for the breaks on a hole and not so much setting up right in the hole.

Good Luck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Shack

Was out yesterday afternoon and well into the evening. Drilled holes, until I marked fish. Started out very slow and about the start of the fourth quarter of the Vikes game, the LX-5 lit up from top to bottom. Cats on the bottom and crappies 5-8 under the ice. The bite was very steady until about 9:30-10:00 when I packed up and went home. The fish pretty much went away or would not bite anymore.

1/8 Lindy Rattlin Flyer spoon and crappie minnow body (no head or tail) was what they wanted last night. Threw cut (fresh) sucker small chunks, cut frozen bull head, cut shiner, cut shad and all they wanted was cut crappie minnow crazygrin. I tried all kinds of spoons and jigs, from big to small, but the LRF was all they wanted.

I was jigging about 2-4 feet off the bottom, when bottom chatter would start on the LX-5. After a couple seconds of slight to moderate jigging, I would stop and hold still, then you could see the red bar come pretty quickly off the bottom and boom, the rod tip would bend. Set the hook and make sure your drag is set or in my case last night on a new reel (SC), make sure the drag evens works wink. Back reel'in was my only friend last night.

For the crappies I would just drop down a glow jig (Ratzo) about 5-8' under the ice and dead stick with spring bobber, tipped with a crappie minow for some action. @25' of water, with over a 30' hole to my back and 4' not to far away to my front. Like Borch said grin

Good luck and have fun!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rick G

Congrats on a good evening of fishing Shack.Glad to hear someone did well last night Looks like I should have stayed for a while longer as I didnt do so hot. I could find em but only managed to turn a few. Oh well tomorow is another day and I will be serching for mr wiskers again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
catfreak

I went down to Horseshoe today and didn't have much luck. Fished from about 4 till 7. Only marked a few fish. I was out with my girl and didn't want to hole hop too much cuz I knew if she got too cold being outta the house the night would be over soon.

I did get to use my brand new fishtv though. Saw a nice little crappie checkin me out right away. So that made the trip worth it. Does anybody know why I was having such a problem finding my lure on the camera though? I've got a marcum lid cover thing for holding the camera, I just couldn't get my lure on the screen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
50inchpig

I caught my first few cats last night on my first trip on Horseshoe, what a blast. Thanks for the sound advice on this thread, now I just need to ditch my 2 wheel drive for a 4 x 4!

Most of my bites were at dark but there were still fish hanging around with an occasional bite when I left about 7:30. It was all about the spoons and minnow heads, only a few light nibbles on the cutbait.

Sure seems like there's alot of space out there that a guy could pitch his house, catch some fish, and never get close to anybody else all day long.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rick G

Yep gota love the chain. Well I guess its time for me to go feed the cats. I will post how I do today.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DTro

Amongst other things, I really like how this chain of lakes has multiple bays, river channels, and main lake basins. I only have 2 or 3 “go to” spots that never seem to fail when it comes to the cats, but I would LOVE to spend some more time exploring up there. Unfortunately the 1.75 hr drive puts a damper on the fishing time.

Eventually, I’m sure I’ll need to find some new water, just like any other fish, the cats react negatively to excess pressure. The spots I fish are more and more becoming community spots, which is fine I’m part of that same community, but I know there is a lot of untapped water that would no doubt be lights out.

I’m just grateful that a few individuals were kind enough to take me to a couple of these spots. They sure have provided me the opportunity to make some great memories.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MinnesotaMuskie

How is the road access on Horseshoe. I am getting a little(actually alot) help on my first catfish trip.

I am pulling my perm off Sullivan and gong to try for Cats on Sunday...or if wour Wrestling commitments in Buffalo wrap up early enough...I may go out Saturday evening.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
catfreak

Is there any way to get to that southwest bay on horseshoe without driving out there? It looks pretty promising for the cats, but I dont think a mustang is going to be real fun on the lake...especially try to leave on that steep access.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
50inchpig

You should be able to get your perm out there if you don't mind fishing with the community, not sure about access to the southwest bay. Walking it would be really tough with the snow and I didn't see any roads going back that way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rick G

Well fishing was fair to good for the most part today. I found the kittys by drilling lots of holes and moveing around until I located them on the vex. Most of the fish were in 22-28 ft. I like to fish the iregular shoreline breaks that drop into at least 30ft as most of the deep holes get hit rather hard by people targeting the cats as well as crappies. The bite was very light today as I had to break out the spring bobber setup and had to down size my spoon. There are so many places to fish on the chain that you almost never have to fish close to other fisherman if thats your thing. I only saw one other person all day and that was co. Mike Martin. He sure is a nice guy and told me of a couple other areas that I may check out here in the next week. There is a road that goes back to the southwest bay and I have seen a few cars use it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fins&feathers

as mnmuskie asks how is the ice?... is there a plowed road on horseshoe or a well trvaved path? i never did fish for cats through the ice , would like to give it a try this weekend..if the roads are good for driving up from chisago..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rick G

16-17 inches of ice on the shoe , cedar island and a bit less on becker.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
catfreak

Riverfishingmiss, do you ever fish the southeast bay of horseshoe? I've been fishing there quite a bit lately. I've been hittin that 30 foot hole just north of the access without much luck. I've been trying to work the slope of the hole in about 20 to 25 fow. Only having a hand auger might be part the poor luck. I get a little too sweaty after about 8 holes. If you do fish that area at all I'd like to get together and see if I can improve my luck, or skill, at all. Let me know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
50inchpig

There is a road and tracks from 22 up to the big point by the meth hole. It's slightly worse at the point but there are still tracks to follow, then there is a plowed road running North/South along the west basin. In short, things are pretty accessible, even if you have to park and walk a short distance.

Catfreak, there's a decent chance I'll be out tonight by myself. If you'd like to come or meet me out there you're welcome to. I'm off work at 3:30.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rick G

Unfortunatly for me I have to work till fri night but will be over in krones bay this weekend with a few buddies if you would like to stop in and chat. I will be in one of the wheelhouses either the silver one w the black roof or the tan one w the big windows

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
89Bronco
I've been thinking about trying for some cats this year and the Chain would be new water for me. Is there anyplace that you can't drive? Like a place on the lakes that always has strong current or 99% of the time it is thin ice that the locals, or you cat-pros, would know about? I've been reading all the tips and info for a long time...thanks to all of you who share your knowledge. I've caught some in the Mississippi during the summer and I can't imagine what it's like through the ice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DTro

Yes, there are plenty of spots on the chain of lakes that you don’t want to drive a vehicle on. In areas where the river runs through, there are spots with minimal ice. If you are unfamiliar with these areas, I would be very careful wherever you see narrows or neckdowns. The current from the river can keep the ice fairly thin in certain spots.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Shack

Yep, always keep that back in the back of your head "River". You will find plenty of ice on main lake spots, but you get off the beaten path, you can find almost half the thickness or thinner eek.

If you get that feeling, stop and do an ice check. Most times you might be shocked at how thin the ice is.

Also, the Meth Hole on Horseshoe is a no-no. I do not even know if it is covered at all yet this year, but most times it is open. That is right in the main basin of the chain (horseshoe).

I would not be blazing a new trail with a truck or sled with out checking the ice first wink. It may take some time and effort, but think of the time and effort you would have to put into pulling your sled or truck out of the lake eek

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MinnesotaMuskie

We are heading out on Sunday...are cats an evening bite? I am taking my 6th grader and would need to leave by about 6:00PM.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DTro

I’ve caught them sun up to sun down and after sun down. There seems to be extra activity during the early morning and dusk. Not much different than any other fish.

Good Luck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
catfreak

Anybody have any luck with the cats this week? I'm guessing quite a few of you guys will be going out this weekend so I figured I'd see if anybody can give some reports. I'm gonna head to Horseshoe today and I'll let everybody know how I did when I get back.

p.s. Cross your fingers for me. I haven't been having too much luck lately. lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rick G

I will be out there sometime today.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
soft

I would like to make it to the chain tomorrow for the first time of the season, but i don't have a truck, i have a sedan front wheel drive , do you guys think i can get on and off the access between Cedar island and Horseshoe?

thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Rick
      With the all-terrain vehicle riding season in Minnesota in full swing – and the number of registered all-terrain vehicles continuing to rise – DNR conservation officers and safety officials remind people to be aware of the regulations and safety training opportunities before they head for the trails or allow youngsters to ride.  While youth riders are required to complete ATV safety courses (those between the ages of 12 and 15 must take an online course and a hands-on riding performance class, while those 16 and older born after July 1, 1987 must complete an online course), officials encourage anyone who operates an ATV to complete safety training. In about 92 percent of the 143 ATV-related fatalities in Minnesota since 2010, the operator didn’t have an ATV safety certificate. “We’ve seen the same trends in our other safety education programs – people who complete them are less likely to be involved in fatal or life-threatening accidents,” said Capt. Jon Paurus, Enforcement Education Program coordinator. “Learning about safe operation of these vehicles is one of the best ways to reduce the chances of being involved in a tragic accident.” Once they’re in the field, one of the simplest but most effective safety steps riders can take is to wear a helmet. While it’s recommended all riders wear one, it’s required of those under the age of 18. Whether they’re riding a Class 1 or a larger Class 2 vehicle, they must wear a DOT-approved helmet. It’s also vital that youth riders fit the vehicle they’re riding. They must be able to reach and control the handlebars or steering wheel and comfortably reach the foot pegs or brake/gas pedal while sitting upright on the ATV. While regulations are designed to keep riders safe, they can only do so much. It’s up to parents and guardians to make the call whether kids are ready to operate ATVs on their own. “We highly recommend active supervision of young riders,” Paurus said. “While they may have sufficient skills to start and stop an ATV – and to travel in a straight line – kids lack the experience necessary to respond to something unexpected.” See ww.mndnr.gov/safety/vehicle/atv/index.html for more information on ATV safety training. Off-highway vehicle regulations are at www.mndnr.gov/regulations/ohv/index.html Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Minnesota Department of Natural Resources conservation officers and hundreds of other public safety officers will ramp up patrols for intoxicated boaters this weekend, June 29 to July 1.  The enhanced efforts to curb alcohol- and drug-related boating accidents and deaths are part of Operation Dry Water, a nationwide campaign now in its tenth year of highlighting the dangers of boating under the influence of drugs and alcohol and the strict penalties for boating while intoxicated (BWI). In Minnesota and across the nation, BWI is the leading contributing factor in boating accidents and fatalities. Of the 12 fatal boating accidents that occurred last year in Minnesota, six involved alcohol. Over the past five years, alcohol has been a factor in about 44 percent of boating fatalities. “People who operate a boat under the influence of alcohol or drugs are a danger to themselves and other boaters,” said Lt. Adam Block, DNR Enforcement boating law administrator. “We have zero tolerance for anyone found operating a boat while under the influence. While failure to wear life jackets is the reason the majority of fatal boating accidents turn deadly, being intoxicated often is what causes people to end up in the water in the first place. The legal blood alcohol limit for boaters is .08, but public safety officials encourage boaters to leave alcohol on shore and boat sober on “dry water. The Operation Dry Water enhanced enforcement weekend takes place each year just before the Fourth of July, a holiday when BWI-related accidents and deaths tend to spike. Last year in Minnesota, conservation officers arrested five boaters for boating under the influence during the three-day Operation Dry Water. Minnesota has some of the strongest BWI laws in the country, which should send a message to boaters about the seriousness with which officers take intoxicated boating, Block said. Boaters convicted of BWI face fines up to $1,000 for a first offense, possible jail time, impoundment of their boat and trailer, and the loss of boat-operating privileges for the first 90 days during the boating season. Intoxicated boaters with prior BWI convictions, who have a child under 16 years old on board, or who have a blood alcohol content of 0.16 may be charged with a gross misdemeanor or felony crime and subjected to higher monetary fines, mandatory jail time, loss of driver’s license, loss of vehicle plates, and forfeiture of their boat and trailer. For more information on Operation Dry Water and boating safety, visit www.operationdrywater.org and www.mndnr.gov/boatingsafety Operation Dry Water activities are sponsored by the National Association of Boating Law Administrators in partnership with the U.S. Coast Guard. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • BartmanMN
      Has anyone been to Lake Martha recently to see if the parking lot has been re-graded?  It was extremely rutted the last time I was there.    
    • BrianF
      Snagger, nice report.  Wondering...Did you happen to get a measurement on that ski?? The length seems to go on forever. 
    • roony
      That is great, thanks for sharing the pics. I miss the days when my three boys were young and in the boat with me. I hope to have the same good times when my grandchildren get a bit older.  
    • snagger
      I was up at Vermilion with my family last Saturday - Friday. We stayed at Everett's Bay Lodge and also Glenmore. We had an absolute blast. Because I had my two young boys with me the walleye fishing was basically limited to the evening bite. It didn't disappoint and we caught lots of little ones with plenty of eaters mixed in. We mostly used slip bobbers with leeches in 2'-6'. We had a surprise catch while bobber fishing. A BIG musky clamped on to one of the walleyes that my son was reeling in and we actually got her in the net! My boys were thrilled. After a quick photo she was released. I also spent a fair amount of time chasing smallies and did very well once I figured out the cover that was holding the most and biggest fish. Great trip.....wish I was there right now.
    • roony
      I agree that the larger bass should be released, same with nearly any species it is good to have a balanced size population. However, hassling someone because they keep some fish for a meal is akin to hunter harassment. Sometimes I think those who preach "catch and release" are actually killing more fish than those who keep a few for a meal and go home to fry them rather than catch all the fish they can. I am of the belief that if you are going to release a fish you shouldn't even bring it into the boat, just unhook it and let it swim. After the photo opportunity the fish might swim away but that doesn't mean it won't suffer the long term effects of removal of the protective "slime" it is coated with. I guess it comes down to using good judgement and I see less of that all the time.
    • jwilli7122
      My "home" lake is about 300 acres with 15-20 ft water clarity.  It's also absolutely loaded with largemouth bass and they taste great - just like crappies.   I've eaten bass out of other lakes and have found some to taste pretty muddy, so I'm guessing it's a water quality thing. I'm big on selective harvest, and I take A LOT of 10-12 inch bass out of that lake, as I have for the last 25 years.  My cutoff for throwing them back is about 12.5 inches.  I also keep as many 20 inch pike as I can but always throw back 23.5 or bigger. Everything is relative, but on my lake, it's much better to take a meal of small largemouths than a meal of big sunnies, crappies, or walleyes, in my opinion.  Bass are a prolific fish in this lake and they can take it. And they taste great. On the other hand, I agree with you about not keeping 15+ inchers.  The worst thing you can do is keep the 15 incher and throw back the 11 incher (actually, keeping both would be less bad). To me, largemouth bass in general need less protecting than just about any other species in the state.  1. because they tend to be prolific and 2. because most people don't choose to eat them anyway.   Now if you want to tell people not to keep big crappies or bluegills, I could probably get behind that.    
    • Hookmaster
      In the late 70s or early 80s, Outdoor News had a recipe for grilled largemouth bass. The first ingredient was "1 five pound bass". I still laugh at that.
    • DonkeyHodey
      I eat bass.  I also release bass and typically only keep them to eat when they are by-catch targeting other eaters and I'm in the filleting mood...  (I personally don’t want to keep a bass >~14inches for eating anymore; they don't taste as good (especially in the summer), they have more toxins and I buy the argument that bass help control/balance the bluegill population...) Catch and Release isn’t perhaps the end-all-be-all  for a healthy lake/fishery… Story #1:  My wife caught a nice ~15 incher in mid-May that was missing an eye...--We couldn't keep him then due to season, but it would've been a bit of a dilemma if he’d been caught a week later after full opener.   Do I eat a bigger fish that might be limited to grow big (?mercy killing) or let the survivor continue to survive?   (It did seem likely his lost eye was a result of having been previously caught (?foul hook with a treble hook or removed roughly/carelessly/mishandled?   I could tell stories, and I suppose that could be an interested thread to start:  fish removal techniques you’ve witnessed that horrify you...  This, perhaps, highlights what Del was getting at in terms of harvest vs. annoying the fish…) Agree with Don.  Wasting of ANY fish is awful.  Story #2:  I was fishing this spring in the river and caught a big ol’ beauty of a white sucker (personal best!); when I released it, I was mocked by fellow shore-fishermen for throwing back a "carp" and they advised me the "right thing to do" is pitch it up on the shore...   (there's still alot of fisherman that believe the DNR actually encourages destruction of "rough fish")  I politely reminded them this big treasure is likely providing (through its baby suckers) future countless meals for their precious walleyes…  This argument was laughed at…  But back to bass…--Rodbender—I think you'll find very few anglers interested in a stranger telling them which fish they can or cannot keep...  It comes across as “stop eating MY future big bass!”  A lake is very much designed to thrive with harvest, and I would point out, releasing everything doesn’t always cleanly equal “more big fish.” There's comments here about the northern pike that perhaps highlight this paradox;  numerous lakes in MN had a ridiculous slot limit (release all norts <40 inches) that effectively made nort fishing catch and release (since the central and southern lakes effectively can’t produce a 40 incher and even if it could, eating one would be, well, interesting…).  The goal was to produce more big fish—the end result was lakes infested with <20 inch snakes that no one seems to want (and end up a nuisance by-catch when targeting anything else.)  Furthermore, those numerous small norts grow very slowly (and die of “old age” at 27 inches…)  (…thus, now the DNR is expending resources to try and encourage harvest and hence the (in my opinion) move in the right direction with the 2018 nort regulation changes…)  Yes, I know bass and norts are 2 VERY different species and react differently to lake/season/climate conditions, but lakes/fish/nature doesn’t always behave as we intuitively “know” it will.  A fellow fisher (that is eating “your bass”) might be reducing competition for remaining bass and potentially increasing their growth velocity in the lake.  (I will again repeat:  A lake is very much designed to thrive with harvest--be it humans, eagles, loons, cormorants, bears, snapping turtles, other fish, etc…  I know, we humans tend to be greediest, and take our harvest to unsustainable damaging extremes, but, that’s why we have rules/DNR/etc…  Just my thoughts…) Rodbender—If you want more big bass, there’s a good argument that you should harvest and eat (do not waste!) more small northern pike; they are outcompeting the bass for forage.    (It’ll likely get you farther than trying to guilt/change/bully what is otherwise legal behavior in others…)