• GUESTS

    If You  want access  to member only forums on FM, You will need to Sign-in or  Sign-Up now .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member.

  • WE CREATE LONG TERM, MEANINGFUL RELATIONSHIPS IN HERE ... PLEASE JOIN US.

    You know what we all love...

    RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE
    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
bak2MN

vexilar or marcum??

Recommended Posts

bak2MN

new to the area never used a flasher but thinking of getting one> I have heard mixed reviews of both not sure which one to get. where can a guy get the best deal? would like to fish with someone who had either to get a feel for them. any info would be great.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

That is the old Ford vs Chevy question --

I like the Vex over the Marcum. My Bro-in-law had problems with his Marcum and returned it three times. He now has a vex.

Also they used to interfere with vexs but I understand that is better now.

I have seen both in action -- I have been very satisfied with my Vex. In fact I have upgraded to my third one and they all have been good.

Just my $1.25.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cliffy

Hitman hit it on the head. Its a personal preference thingy

I happen to own both. I have a Vex FL-18 Pro pack and a Marcum LX-3tc. The Vex was a gift from my wife and I bought the Marcum after seeing a friend use one. I probably will be selling both next season and getting the Marcum LX-5.

Here is my reviews. Both units work great and will help you catch more fish. I went with the Marcum unit for a few reasons. First, I found it to be much easier to read in direct sun light, a crisper and more solid display. Also, It does not make any noise compared to the Vex. Not a big deal, just the something that got on my nerves after awhile. Both units have a zoom feature that is very nice. The vex will only zoom on the bottom 6 feet while the Marcum zoom is adjustable and can cover anywhere in the water column. To be honest, I only really zoom in on the bottom 6 feet.....so there is no difference to me on this feature.

The things that I dont like about the Marcum unit are.....its shape. I like the Vex unit much more in this area as I could just slide into a five gallon pail and it was protected when I threw it into my sled and pulled it across the lake. The Marcum unit is shaped differently...and now I just put it into a backpack and haul it on my person. I guess I am sort paranoid that I am going to damage these units....a lot of money to just have bouncing around the sled.

I also dont care for the transducer arm on the Marcum. I removed it and replaced it with a Vex float. I also wish the Marcum's transducer cord was a little longer. I have found that my Marcum and Vex will interfer with one another, but both have several channels of interference reduction and I am able to clean the display with little effort.

So, you can see there is no clear answer to which is the best. It comes down to what you like the best. In my case, I went with the Marcum for the reasons above...but I still use my Vex from time to time....so there is nothing wrong with either unit. Check out the "Equipment or Ice Fishing Forums" for a ton of posts on this topic.

The prices on these units are pretty stable. Its not too often that you see any kind of Big Sale but I am sure once in awhile, if you shop around, you can save a few bucks. My advise is to check out the "For Sale" forums on this site next fall. Lots of people seem to sell theirs in order to up grade....that is what I am going to do. You probably could get a real good deal on a one or two year old unit. Good luck

Cliffy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

Wow -- That is a heck of a post.

Cliff did a great job explaining it -- Get the one you like the best.

BTW -- Did you research that during a do-go-nut break?

;\)

Just kidding My Brother.

At least I said it before the Perch did.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bak2MN

Sounds to me there are more cons then pros to your post on the marcum vs the vex. Like I said I never have fished with either so I have limited experiance with the use of either one. Also can either of the units be put on a boat. And would it be useful on a boat? Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bak2MN

Is there anywhere around the detroit lakes or Lake of the woods area that rents them so a guy could try them?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Esox_Magnum

Yes both can be used on a boat, when I ran Vexilars they were on my bow, now that I use a Marcum it to will be on my bow. Advantage is you get real time and accurate reading. Flashers don't lie if it shows something then somethings there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bassbozo

I just got a Lowrance x67c and this thing is great. It has a flasher dipslay as well as a graph with hyperscroll. I am really impressed with it and I would suggest checking that out. It is great to have the graph to get the history instead what is only instantly happening. The other great thing is that it can be used on my boat this summer all I have to do is get a different transducer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bak2MN

Esox, what other special accesories do you need to adapt it to a boat? If any..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bak2MN

Esox, also why the change from vex to marcum?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cliffy

I am not sure about the DL area...but a lot of the resorts in the LOTW area rent them. I just stayed at Sportsmens Resort on LOTW last week and they rent them. I think Ballards, next door to Sportsman, also rents them. I am pretty sure they both rent the Vex units...not sure of the model. As already stated, you can mount the units on your boat for real time view of the water column....I think you just need a different transducer..etc. If you check out Vexilar's website, they have several free videos that explain their units....sorta gives you an idea of what we are talking about.

Good luck

CLiffy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bak2MN

thanks for the info maybe it will help make a decision

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CSP88

If you plan on using your flasher during the winter and on a boat I would strongly suggest going with Vexilar FL-18. The bottom lock feature on the FL-18 seperates itself from all other flashers. Like Cliffy mentioned, go to Vexilar's website and watch the videos for some great information on all of the their units.

Chad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cliffy

 Originally Posted By: Dahitman44

BTW -- Did you research that during a do-go-nut break?

;\)

Just kidding My Brother.

At least I said it before the Perch did.

Just remember Hitman...I am sure you have to drive thru my city sometime..... Just Kidding.

I have not heard much from Perch lately on the boards....both of us have gone to the Midnight shift......so we dont see much day light anymore......... \:\(\:\(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

Very good Cliffy --

One of my boys was wondering why I was laughing so hard and he saw your "picture" bouncing around -- he thought it was funny. He wondered why you are moving so much and that you are "heavy set."

"But he sure seems funny."

Kids -- gotta love them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cliffy

LOL!! Lets me make this pefectly clear...that pic is not of me!!!....although at times I feel like he looks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SalmonGuy

What kind of boat? My Dad siliconed a plunger (no handle) to the bottom of an aluminum fishing boat. Anywhere the boat makes solid contact with the water will work. Cut a circle out of the top of the plunger large enough for your ice transducer. Place some water in the plunger, put in the ducer; and you're set. It will shoot thru the hull. Works great, and your ducer is somewhat protected - plus you're able to make use of the ice ducer instead of purchasing another. Cone angle may be a factor.. I have all vexilars, but a buddy of mine swears by his Marcum.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Esox_Magnum

 Originally Posted By: CSP88
If you plan on using your flasher during the winter and on a boat I would strongly suggest going with Vexilar FL-18. The bottom lock feature on the FL-18 seperates itself from all other flashers. Like Cliffy mentioned, go to Vexilar's website and watch the videos for some great information on all of the their units.

Chad

I tried that with my 18 last year and didn't see much of an improvement over my 8. We'll see how the LX5 does in a month or so when we get open water

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fisherdog19

I like the Marcum; the biggest reasons being the adjustable zoom for suspended crappies, bright display, no noise making, and the stillness of the the screen and the marks shown on the screen. There are some things that Vex's have that may be better, but they are minor to me compared to the four above.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Icefisher23

I own a vexilar and like it. never used a marcum..just seen them on tv but they look nice too

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

Announcements



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • DLD24
      Do you have any tips for fishing Fish Lake this time of year? I'm gonna try it out in the next few days... Is it typically an early morning, late evening bite or can you get them all day long? Thanks for any info.
    • PRO-V
      Calling them would be your best bet. Maybe you can reserve some on a card.
    • delcecchi
      starft you off.... https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/lakefind/lake.html?id=69066000 http://files.dnr.state.mn.us/lakefind/data/lakemaps/b0537011.pdf Status of the Fishery Ely Lake is located approximately 2 miles SE of the city of Eveleth. This popular lake is highly developed with homes and cabins. There is a small seaplane base and two public swimming beaches also located there. Water clarity is good and large amounts of aquatic vegetation can be found throughout the lake. 

      There is a concrete planked boat ramp and dock located near the NE end of the lake off Cedar Island Drive (CR629) for public access. The parking space is somewhat limited near the ramp. Several private accesses are also present. 

      Thirteen species of fish were sampled during the 2017 survey on Ely Lake. Gill nets, trap nets and night electrofishing were all used to sample the fish community. Small bluegill were common in the gill net catch (34%) and abundant in the trap net catch (57%). Other panfish species including hybrid sunfish, pumpkinseed, green sunfish and black crappie were also sampled in good numbers. Largemouth bass outnumbered smallmouth bass in the 2017 sample. Walleye (16%) contributed to the gill net catch and several were sampled in the trap nets. Yellow perch are present in average amounts and some good sized pike were again sampled during the 2017 survey. 

      Bluegill numbers in 2017 (72.1/trap net) were much higher than the long term average (31.6/trap net) on Ely Lake and greatly above average (7.9/trap net) compared to other similar lakes in the area. The average bluegill sampled was 5.6 inches long and about 6 years old. Approximately 66% of the bluegill sampled with the trap nets were under 6 inches with a maximum size recorded of 8.0 inches. Bluegill sampled with the gill nets had a similar size structure. Approximately 7% of the hybrid sunfish sampled in the trap nets were 8 inches or larger. Several pumpkinseeds were also in this size range. 

      Largemouth bass (92%) and smallmouth bass (8%) were sampled during the night electrofishing effort. The average largemouth sampled was 10.9 inches which is similar to the historic average of 10.6 inches. The biggest largemouth sampled was 18.5 inches. Approximately 33% of the largemouth sampled were 12 inches or larger. The average smallmouth sampled was 9.8 inches which is slightly larger than the historic average (8.4 inches). The largest smallmouth sampled was 16.8 inches long. Approximately 32% of the smallmouth sampled were 12 inches or larger. Largemouth bass were also sampled from the gill nets and trap nets in numbers above average. 

      Walleye numbers in 2017 (6.2/gill net) were similar to the historic average (6.1/gill net) on Ely Lake and slightly above average (5.0/gill net) when compared to other similar area lakes with walleye. The average walleye sampled was 15.5 inches and about 4 years old. Approximately 34% of the walleye sampled were 15 inches or larger up to a maximum of nearly 29 inches. Walleye fingerlings are currently being stocked during even-numbered years and in 2017 approximately 62% of the walleye aged came from years where stocking occurred. 

      Northern pike numbers in 2017 (1.1/gill net) were similar to the historic average (1.3/gill net) and below average (3.2/gill net) compared to other similar area lakes with pike. The average pike sampled was 26.8 inches which is similar to the historic average length of 26.3 inches. The largest pike sampled in 2017 was 35.2 inches long and sampled with a trap net. 
    • gizmoguy
      Yes they do. Many resorts are set up for summer usage. Understand you can't use your FH in the storage lots. Only in a summer use lot. You have to pay for it. The cost is in addition to your winter fees. Usually more $ but the season is longer. The county requires the resorts to have bathroom facilities within a certain distance. Mac's Twin Bay has summer lots as do many others. Hunter's Point is another. Doubt Brandt's is set up for summer.
    • DRAGFOOT
      Sweet! Heading back up tonight through the weekend. Bringing the wife and little one this time instead of my buddies, hopefully the weather cooperates.
    • Neutz68
      Heading up Sat morning and will be looking for Shiners. Anyone know if the Gateway and/or Kab Outdoors have them in stock??    Thanks for the input.
    • crappieslapper
      Hi Guys & Gals, My brother in law recently purchased a property on Ely Lake. All the boys are invited up this year on Memorial. Unfortunately nobody in the family has been on the lake before. I thought I would reach out to the pros here on the forum to see if anyone would be willing to give us a few tips on fishing this lake. Thanks in advance, Dan
    • crappieslapper
      Hey Forum, My brother in law just purchased on Ely Lake. Memorial weekend will be the first time on lake. Wondering if anyone has some experience/tips they would be willing to offer the Ely lake rookies. Thanks so much. Dan
    • huntnfish
      I made it out last Sunday and did some searching for walleye. The search didn't produce any walleyes, just northerns and smallies. The water temp on the main lake was 58-59 with the bays being about 5 degrees warmer. The people I have talked to have had similar issues finding the eyes. We missed some fish that left the shiner all chewed up. Most of the fish marked were out in that 18-21 foot range which seemed pretty deep for this early. It could have been Saturday's cold front that pushed them a little deeper though. 
    • Hoey
      SRJ - Thanks for the report.  I heard the bite was very-good to excellent, off the rocks/reefs, in the mud/sand.  I will be at the lake fishing this weekend.